Should I Build It Should I Build It
20 Apr 2025
Artificial Intelligence Notes Productivity

app where users come in and speak their thought to do task management, ...

...get notes from ai

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Your idea for an AI-powered voice-to-task management app enters a competitive market. There are already many similar products, evidenced by the 28 matches we found. This indicates strong interest in the space, but also a high barrier to entry. Engagement for similar products is high, averaging 14 comments per launch, suggesting people are actively seeking and discussing these types of tools. However, note that although we have no explicit use signal (neither positive or negative), we have a very strong buy signal. This means people are willing to pay for a product like this but it doesn't mean that you automatically will get them to pay for YOUR specific product. To succeed, you'll need a clear differentiator and a compelling value proposition.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, your first step should be a thorough competitive analysis. Dig into the offerings of tools like TalkNotes, Voicenotes, and Minutes AI, paying close attention to user reviews and identified shortcomings. Focus on identifying gaps in the market or unmet needs that your app can uniquely address. From the user reviews, potential gaps are things like: lack of clear cloud security details, file processing and server location concerns, lack of offline capabilities, lack of integrations with existing tools like Obsidian and Notion, and finally, lack of customizability regarding accents and background noise.
  2. Instead of trying to be everything to everyone, consider nicheing down. Focus on a specific user group (e.g., students, creatives, project managers) or a particular use case (e.g., meeting note-taking, brainstorming, language learning). Tailor your app's features and marketing to resonate with this specific audience. This will not only make marketing easier but also organically give you a differentiation point that your competitors may not have.
  3. Differentiate not only on features, but also on the AI capabilities. Given the number of similar products, you MUST BE able to clearly articulate how your AI will be superior. Will it be able to better understand different accents? Will it have better memory to retain important details? Will it be faster, more accurate or more customizable? Make sure you address this on your landing page.
  4. Prioritize a seamless user experience. Many users of similar apps complain about clunky interfaces, slow performance, and lack of integration with other tools. Invest in a clean, intuitive design and robust integrations to minimize friction and maximize user satisfaction. A lot of users really loved the 'clean UX' of competing products like Voicenotes and MinutesAI, so you should try to emulate this.
  5. Develop a strong brand and marketing message that highlights your app's unique value proposition. Clearly communicate how it solves a specific problem for your target audience and why it's better than the alternatives. A clear and succinct landing page explaining everything should be your first priority. Consider creating explainer videos to demonstrate your unique features and benefits.
  6. Actively engage with your early users and solicit feedback. Use their input to iterate and improve your app. Build a community around your product to foster loyalty and advocacy. Pay close attention to the feature requests and pain points expressed by users of similar apps. Don't be afraid to copy features that users love (such as Obsidian / Readwise integration), but be sure to implement your own unique spin.
  7. Consider a freemium model or offer a free trial to allow users to experience the value of your app before committing to a paid subscription. Given the positive buy signal for this idea, this makes sense. But make sure that the free tier still delivers meaningful value, otherwise you risk losing potential customers.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition, what are the 2-3 key features that will make your app stand out and attract users away from established players?
  2. How will you ensure the accuracy and reliability of your AI transcription and summarization, especially when dealing with different accents, background noise, and technical jargon?
  3. What is your plan to build a community around your app and foster user engagement, and how will you leverage this community to drive product development and marketing?

Your are here

Your idea for an AI-powered voice-to-task management app enters a competitive market. There are already many similar products, evidenced by the 28 matches we found. This indicates strong interest in the space, but also a high barrier to entry. Engagement for similar products is high, averaging 14 comments per launch, suggesting people are actively seeking and discussing these types of tools. However, note that although we have no explicit use signal (neither positive or negative), we have a very strong buy signal. This means people are willing to pay for a product like this but it doesn't mean that you automatically will get them to pay for YOUR specific product. To succeed, you'll need a clear differentiator and a compelling value proposition.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, your first step should be a thorough competitive analysis. Dig into the offerings of tools like TalkNotes, Voicenotes, and Minutes AI, paying close attention to user reviews and identified shortcomings. Focus on identifying gaps in the market or unmet needs that your app can uniquely address. From the user reviews, potential gaps are things like: lack of clear cloud security details, file processing and server location concerns, lack of offline capabilities, lack of integrations with existing tools like Obsidian and Notion, and finally, lack of customizability regarding accents and background noise.
  2. Instead of trying to be everything to everyone, consider nicheing down. Focus on a specific user group (e.g., students, creatives, project managers) or a particular use case (e.g., meeting note-taking, brainstorming, language learning). Tailor your app's features and marketing to resonate with this specific audience. This will not only make marketing easier but also organically give you a differentiation point that your competitors may not have.
  3. Differentiate not only on features, but also on the AI capabilities. Given the number of similar products, you MUST BE able to clearly articulate how your AI will be superior. Will it be able to better understand different accents? Will it have better memory to retain important details? Will it be faster, more accurate or more customizable? Make sure you address this on your landing page.
  4. Prioritize a seamless user experience. Many users of similar apps complain about clunky interfaces, slow performance, and lack of integration with other tools. Invest in a clean, intuitive design and robust integrations to minimize friction and maximize user satisfaction. A lot of users really loved the 'clean UX' of competing products like Voicenotes and MinutesAI, so you should try to emulate this.
  5. Develop a strong brand and marketing message that highlights your app's unique value proposition. Clearly communicate how it solves a specific problem for your target audience and why it's better than the alternatives. A clear and succinct landing page explaining everything should be your first priority. Consider creating explainer videos to demonstrate your unique features and benefits.
  6. Actively engage with your early users and solicit feedback. Use their input to iterate and improve your app. Build a community around your product to foster loyalty and advocacy. Pay close attention to the feature requests and pain points expressed by users of similar apps. Don't be afraid to copy features that users love (such as Obsidian / Readwise integration), but be sure to implement your own unique spin.
  7. Consider a freemium model or offer a free trial to allow users to experience the value of your app before committing to a paid subscription. Given the positive buy signal for this idea, this makes sense. But make sure that the free tier still delivers meaningful value, otherwise you risk losing potential customers.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition, what are the 2-3 key features that will make your app stand out and attract users away from established players?
  2. How will you ensure the accuracy and reliability of your AI transcription and summarization, especially when dealing with different accents, background noise, and technical jargon?
  3. What is your plan to build a community around your app and foster user engagement, and how will you leverage this community to drive product development and marketing?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 28
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 14
  • Net use signal: 28.1%
    • Positive use signal: 28.5%
    • Negative use signal: 0.4%
  • Net buy signal: 4.4%
    • Positive buy signal: 4.6%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.2%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Todo AI - Convert Idea to Tasks, Transcriber Powered by AI

17 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Product Hunt Task Management

Todo AI transforms your spoken ideas into actionable tasks with AI. Capture, organize, and get smart suggestions for completing tasks—quickly and effortlessly. Simplify your planning with a lightweight tool that enhances productivity without adding complexity.

Users are excited about Todo AI's productivity-boosting features, especially the smart suggestions and voice-to-task functionality. There's interest in its ability to capture ideas effectively. A question was raised about potential non-verbal input compatibility.

Avatar
9
5
60.0%
5
9
60.0%
Relevance

TalkNotes - Turn your thoughts into actionable notes, fast

08 Oct 2023 Artificial Intelligence Writing Productivity

Just speak, and let the AI transcribe, clean up and structure your voice. Create clean transcripts, summaries, emails, video scripts and many more. And it works in 50+ languages! Try it for free today!

TalkNotes is receiving overwhelmingly positive feedback for its innovative approach to voice-to-text transcription. Users praise its ease of use, time-saving capabilities, and impressive transcription quality across different languages. Many are excited about the potential iOS app and integration with platforms like Notion and Google Calendar. Users appreciate its ability to declutter thoughts, streamline creative processes, and replace manual note-taking. There are inquiries about the AI technology used, pricing models, and comparisons to competitors. Nico is receiving numerous congratulations and support for the launch.

Users criticize the lack of clarity regarding TalkNotes' advantages over Google Recorder and question AI accuracy with diverse accents. There are requests for a mobile app and the return of a lifetime deal. Users also expressed concerns about file processing, server location, and the discoverability of supported languages on the website. Additionally, there's a complaint about a missing feature requiring manual selection.

Avatar
742
125
25.6%
3.2%
125
742
25.6%
3.2%
Relevance

BrainNote - Your AI voice notetaker. Speak and go

21 Dec 2024 Artificial Intelligence Audio Productivity

Bring CLARITY to your ideas - Faster. Struggling to organize your thoughts? BrainNote.ai transforms rambling ideas into actionable notes. Just speak, and let our AI-powered notetaker handle the rest. Effortless clarity in seconds!

BrainNote is praised for its ability to transform scattered thoughts into clear notes effortlessly, particularly while multitasking like driving and listening to podcasts. Users highlight its utility for chaotic brainstorming sessions and suggest topic separation features. A key concern revolves around how BrainNote differentiates itself from existing speech-to-text technologies and platforms like OpenAI.

Users are requesting more organizational features, specifically the ability to separate and organize different topics. There are also concerns regarding differentiation from existing speech-to-text technologies, including feature parity with solutions like OpenAI's voice mode. A specific question was raised about the product's ability to distinguish between different voices.

Avatar
35
5
40.0%
5
35
40.0%
Relevance

VoiceTaking – Voice notes with AI-powered documents

22 Sep 2024 Meetings Productivity

Hello everyone, I made another voice note app with AI transcription. But, it has a Notion-like page structure with AI assistance on the editor. This makes it easy to keep your thoughts organized and find what you need quickly.The use cases:- Brainstorm ideas anytime, even without your hands - Create a meeting report document with the team - Conversation summary - It’s my personal case , sometimes when I talk importantly with someone I need to take a note to make me remember or get insights from the conversationIt comes with the Automation workflow with smart labels, which means you can tag a smart label in the document and generate everything you need eg, a daily scrum meeting report, auto elaborate the idea, and more. Here are the details: https://voicetaking.com/automation.Just it. Thank you and let me know your thoughts!

Avatar
4
4
Relevance

SpeakNotes - AI powered voice note transcriber & summarizer

15 Jun 2023 Android Notes Productivity

SpeakNotes: An AI-powered app that transcribes and summarizes voice notes. Perfect for students, professionals, and journalists. Available on iOS and Android. Elevate your note-taking efficiency.

Users express positive feedback regarding the product idea. SpeakNotes is highlighted for its accurate transcription and summarization capabilities, making it a must-have tool particularly for students and professionals.

Avatar
71
2
50.0%
2
71
50.0%
Relevance

Notable AI - AI-powered note-taking with smart summaries & voice commands

25 Sep 2024 Android Writing Productivity

Effortlessly capture notes, manage tasks, and generate AI summaries with voice commands. Enjoy seamless cross-platform sync without an account. Stay organized and boost productivity with Notable AI's intuitive interface and smart features.

Users express excitement about the app, highlighting its potential for improved organization and productivity. The innovative voice command tool, featuring AI summaries and synchronization, is a key feature that is seen as promising. Users are eager to try the app and integrate it into their workflow.

Avatar
8
3
100.0%
3
8
100.0%
Relevance

Voicenotes - AI note-taker that's truly intelligent

13 May 2024 Artificial Intelligence Notes Productivity

Voicenotes is an intelligent note-taking app. Record your thoughts freely, get them transcribed using state-of-the-art AI, and ask about every word you spoke.

Voicenotes is receiving overwhelmingly positive feedback for its design, simplicity, and effectiveness in capturing and transcribing voice notes. Users praise its clean UI/UX, accurate transcription (including bilingual sentences), and helpful AI features, particularly for journaling, note-taking, and productivity. Many users have already purchased lifetime deals and are actively using the app daily, some switching from alternatives like Google Keep. Requests include Apple Watch integration, iOS widgets, better cloud details, Obsidian integration, and options for text input and improved Android app performance. The team, especially Jijo, is congratulated repeatedly.

Users criticized the app for slowness, upload issues, and site unreachability. There are concerns about the AI's accuracy, especially regarding memory and context differentiation. Many requested features like better organization (tags/folders), text input, download/embed options, Obsidian/Readwise integration, and a quick iOS widget. The lack of cloud security details and clarity on the subscription model were also points of concern. Several users found voice notes impractical in certain situations and asked for text options, while some Android users reported issues with voice uploads and signup. Some users expressed reservations about the app's simplicity being compromised by future development.

Avatar
1478
161
44.1%
10.6%
161
1478
44.1%
10.6%
Relevance

Echo AI - AI chat note powered by GPT-4

26 Sep 2023 Artificial Intelligence Notes Productivity

An app created for hands-free note-taking.

Echo AI Chat Note's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and expressing interest in the voice note-taking functionality. Questions arose regarding AI memory retrieval, Apple rewards, the product roadmap, and web application availability. Users inquired about calendar integration with Google and Apple, and several wished the team luck. The app was promoted on AI directories, and some users expressed love for the app and asked about integrations with other apps.

Avatar
103
12
33.3%
12
103
33.3%
Relevance

ScriptMind - Elevate note-taking with AI assistants

22 Mar 2024 Notes Writing Developer Tools

Elevate note-taking with AI assistants like ChatGPT for seamless writing. Visualize your ideas with dynamic graphs based on folders or tags. Plus, experience your notes through speech with our TTS feature. Transform your notes into a second brain.

The product launch is receiving positive feedback with users congratulating the team. Many users express excitement about the potential of AI to enhance note-taking and improve tools like Obsidian. Users find the tool cool and promising.

Users have expressed concerns and asked questions regarding the functionalities available in the free version, the specific features included in the paid subscription, and the availability of an Android application for the product.

Avatar
84
8
12.5%
8
84
12.5%
Relevance

Minutes: AI Meeting Notes & Transcripts - Simple, hassle-free AI note taking app for meeting minutes

31 Aug 2024 Notes Meetings Productivity

Automate your meeting audio notes with AI. Minutes AI instantly creates formatted notes and transcriptions from live audio, uploaded audio files, or imported YouTube links. You can chat with your audio to extract key insights, list action items, and more.

Minutes AI's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, praising its user-friendly design and time-saving AI-powered meeting note automation. Users appreciate its clean UX and seamless functionality, with some calling it a game-changer. Many congratulated the team and expressed excitement to try the app, while others inquired about integrations with tools like Notion, Asana, and Trello, as well as availability on Android/Desktop. Differentiation from competitors like Microsoft Teams, Otter.ai and Rev were also questioned. Some users love the idea and find it promising.

The Product Hunt launch received several criticisms. Users questioned its handling of various accents and audio quality and how it differs from Microsoft Teams' MOM. The iOS-only availability was a significant drawback, excluding Android users. Reviewers noted missing features compared to Otter.ai/Rev and Asana/Trello integration. There were concerns about the proliferation of AI tools and its utility and questions about the project's focus, specifically concerning JotBot.

Avatar
345
36
25.0%
36
345
25.0%
Relevance

Hearer AI - AI note-taker. Helps you focus in class.

29 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence SaaS Education

Your AI classroom assistant. This innovative app uses advanced speech recognition to take detailed notes during lectures, allowing you to focus on understanding the material. Review and edit your AI-generated notes later. Never miss important information again

The tool is considered perfect for lectures, effectively capturing all important details to ensure nothing is missed. One comment was deleted.

Avatar
9
2
50.0%
2
9
50.0%
Relevance

MindForger – Attention, LLM is all your note-taking app needs!

19 Feb 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity

The new MindForger release brings integration with OpenAI's large language models, which takes note-taking and knowledge management to a new level. MindForger now allows you to easily expand your notes and knowledge by leveraging the power of AI. Whether you need to prepare a plan, write an in-depth analysis, draft a blog post, or simply generate ideas. Large language model can fix grammar, translate, write, reformulate, summarize, suggest synonyms and antonyms, and much more. You can effortlessly create high-quality content and enhance the organization of your knowledge. Enjoy!

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

acta.ai - AI powered meeting notes

22 Nov 2024 Artificial Intelligence Marketing automation Productivity

ACTA is AI note taker, providing meeting summary, action points, key discussions, ACTA.AI allows teams to focus on decision-making and collaboration rather than administrative follow-ups. Acta can joins Google meet, MS Team and Zoom.

The Product Hunt launch of ACTA.AI is receiving positive feedback. Users highlight that ACTA.AI effectively automates and simplifies meetings. A key feature, the AI's ability to precisely capture and organize action points, is being praised.

Avatar
59
2
2
59
Relevance

Fellow + AI - AI powered features to skyrocket your meeting productivity

29 Jun 2023 SaaS Meetings Productivity

Get quick summaries of meetings with AI. ✨ Keep detailed transcripts. 🤩 Let advanced AI assist in creating productive agendas. 🚀 Receive smart talking point suggestions for engaging conversations. 🙌

Fellow's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users praising the AI integration and highlighting its importance as a productivity tool for alignment, updates, and centralized resources. Several users congratulated the team and expressed excitement about trying the product. One user inquired about the project's intended impact, while another offered to list the app in AI directories.

Avatar
153
10
40.0%
10
153
40.0%
Relevance

I built a live AI meeting copilot that asks better questions than me!

05 May 2024 Artificial Intelligence Meetings Productivity

Hey HN! I built a real-time AI tool that listens to your meeting and prompts you with great questions to help you participate. It also answers questions it picks up, fact-checks statements and takes insightful notes. I built it because I personally needed something like this as I'm not very confident in meetings, especially group meetings. Hope it helps some of you too! Cheers, Tom

Users expressed concerns about self-promotion on HN, noting that the platform is meant for curiosity-driven content. They also pointed out that the submission contained duplicate items and suggested that the title's joke should be self-referential rather than targeting the reader.

The main criticisms are that the repeated self-promotion violates guidelines, the content is largely duplicates, and the title may insult readers.

Avatar
4
3
-33.3%
-33.3%
3
4
Top