Should I Build It Should I Build It
03 Jun 2025
Productivity

A tool that automatically extracts information from emails/documents ...

...in the same format, and stores them in another format as specified by the user, e.g. Taking emails/PDFs and reforming them into a spreadsheet based on similar features. Automation for non-coders.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Your idea for a tool that automates information extraction from emails and documents and converts them into a user-specified format, like spreadsheets, falls into a competitive area. There are already many similar products in the market. This isn't necessarily bad news, as it confirms there's a demand for this type of solution. The relatively high engagement (average of 7 comments) suggests that these tools address a real need for users. However, with 18 similar products already identified, you'll need to think hard about how your product will stand out. The user feedback highlights that data privacy, security, and clear pricing are critical factors for users. To succeed, you'll need to focus on differentiation and building trust with your target audience.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with in-depth market research to identify gaps in existing solutions. Focus on the complaints and feature requests users have about the existing solutions. Prioritize those gaps that your expertise or unique access can address to create a truly differentiated product.
  2. Focus on a specific niche within the broader market. For example, you could specialize in processing legal documents, financial reports, or medical records. Tailoring your tool to a particular industry will allow you to offer more relevant features and a better user experience. This will provide a more focused approach than trying to cater to everyone and differentiating yourself more easily.
  3. Since data privacy and security are major concerns, prioritize building robust security features into your product. Consider features such as end-to-end encryption, data anonymization, and multi-factor authentication. Clearly communicate your security measures to users to build trust and alleviate their concerns. User feedback from competitors indicates that this is a crucial factor.
  4. Simplify your pricing structure and make it transparent. Clearly outline what features are included in each pricing tier and how credit usage is calculated. Avoid hidden fees or complicated formulas that could confuse or frustrate users. Address pricing concerns upfront, as confusing pricing is a common criticism of similar tools.
  5. Consider offering a free trial or a freemium version of your product. This will allow potential users to test out the tool and see if it meets their needs before committing to a paid subscription. Make sure the value is evident quickly to capture their interest and convert them into paying customers.
  6. Develop compelling marketing materials that highlight the unique benefits of your product. Focus on how your tool solves specific pain points for your target audience and how it compares to competing solutions. User feedback indicates that a well-designed website and video tutorials are essential for demonstrating the value of your product.
  7. Actively solicit feedback from your early users and use their input to improve your product. Create a feedback loop that allows you to continuously refine your tool and ensure that it meets the evolving needs of your customers. Address user concerns promptly and transparently to build a loyal customer base. This is crucial for long-term success in a competitive market.

Questions

  1. Given the existing concerns about data privacy, how can you ensure that your tool complies with relevant regulations (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA) and protects user data from unauthorized access or misuse?
  2. Considering the number of competitors, what specific performance metrics (e.g., extraction accuracy, processing speed, scalability) will you track to demonstrate the superiority of your solution?
  3. What innovative features or integrations can you incorporate into your tool to differentiate it from existing solutions and provide a truly unique value proposition for your target audience?

Your are here

Your idea for a tool that automates information extraction from emails and documents and converts them into a user-specified format, like spreadsheets, falls into a competitive area. There are already many similar products in the market. This isn't necessarily bad news, as it confirms there's a demand for this type of solution. The relatively high engagement (average of 7 comments) suggests that these tools address a real need for users. However, with 18 similar products already identified, you'll need to think hard about how your product will stand out. The user feedback highlights that data privacy, security, and clear pricing are critical factors for users. To succeed, you'll need to focus on differentiation and building trust with your target audience.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with in-depth market research to identify gaps in existing solutions. Focus on the complaints and feature requests users have about the existing solutions. Prioritize those gaps that your expertise or unique access can address to create a truly differentiated product.
  2. Focus on a specific niche within the broader market. For example, you could specialize in processing legal documents, financial reports, or medical records. Tailoring your tool to a particular industry will allow you to offer more relevant features and a better user experience. This will provide a more focused approach than trying to cater to everyone and differentiating yourself more easily.
  3. Since data privacy and security are major concerns, prioritize building robust security features into your product. Consider features such as end-to-end encryption, data anonymization, and multi-factor authentication. Clearly communicate your security measures to users to build trust and alleviate their concerns. User feedback from competitors indicates that this is a crucial factor.
  4. Simplify your pricing structure and make it transparent. Clearly outline what features are included in each pricing tier and how credit usage is calculated. Avoid hidden fees or complicated formulas that could confuse or frustrate users. Address pricing concerns upfront, as confusing pricing is a common criticism of similar tools.
  5. Consider offering a free trial or a freemium version of your product. This will allow potential users to test out the tool and see if it meets their needs before committing to a paid subscription. Make sure the value is evident quickly to capture their interest and convert them into paying customers.
  6. Develop compelling marketing materials that highlight the unique benefits of your product. Focus on how your tool solves specific pain points for your target audience and how it compares to competing solutions. User feedback indicates that a well-designed website and video tutorials are essential for demonstrating the value of your product.
  7. Actively solicit feedback from your early users and use their input to improve your product. Create a feedback loop that allows you to continuously refine your tool and ensure that it meets the evolving needs of your customers. Address user concerns promptly and transparently to build a loyal customer base. This is crucial for long-term success in a competitive market.

Questions

  1. Given the existing concerns about data privacy, how can you ensure that your tool complies with relevant regulations (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA) and protects user data from unauthorized access or misuse?
  2. Considering the number of competitors, what specific performance metrics (e.g., extraction accuracy, processing speed, scalability) will you track to demonstrate the superiority of your solution?
  3. What innovative features or integrations can you incorporate into your tool to differentiate it from existing solutions and provide a truly unique value proposition for your target audience?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 18
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 7
  • Net use signal: 25.3%
    • Positive use signal: 26.0%
    • Negative use signal: 0.7%
  • Net buy signal: 3.5%
    • Positive buy signal: 3.5%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

AI bot that automatically processes unstructured documents

23 Nov 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity

Hi HN!We’re excited to share what we’ve been working on—a bot that automates the tedious task of processing unstructured documents from emails and entering them into ERPs. After many iterations, we’ve achieved 99.8% accuracy in extracting and mapping data from invoices, POs, and other documents.One surprising takeaway from this journey: building the AI was only 10% of the challenge! The real work came from handling edge cases, integrating seamlessly with various ERPs, and creating a reliable pipeline for real-world documents with messy formats.We’d love your feedback, thoughts, or questions about how we built this, the challenges we faced, or anything else. Let us know what you think!Thanks for checking it out!

Request for code sharing

Avatar
4
1
1
4
Relevance

AI Bookkeeping Assistant

14 Sep 2024 Artificial Intelligence Fintech Productivity

Hi HN, I've built a SaaS to solve a data entry task that I have often had as a business owner - to be able to extract key invoice data from batches of invoice files for financial record keeping.From my experience GPT-4o now outperforms traditional OCR for extracting text from documents, plus the LLM's reasoning ability means that specific data can be extracted and formats can be converted as desired. Traditional OCR services generally extract all text in the document and of course they extract it as-is without the ability to convert dates etc. Accounting software usually expects imported data to be in a specific format.The tool can extract data from batches of mixed invoice types (PDF, Word, JPG, PNG) which is particularly useful for 'bricks and mortar' businesses who often have mixed format invoices such as scanned documents or photos of receipts. The data is extracted to a spreadsheet with columns that the user defines ready for the user's workflow or for importing into their accounting software.The tool optimizes the document contents for best LLM understanding - which isn't necessarily what happens when you upload the documents to ChatGPT for example.I've tried to make the software as easy to use as possible, so hopefully there isn't a learning curve involved - it is just completing our template by using natural language to describe the data you need extracting. Again, with traditional (non LLM) OCR tools there is usually a learning curve involved in using the software, a long set-up process, and a rigid invoice format expected.If there are any business owners, bookkeepers or accountants who think the tool might be useful for them then I'm extremely open to working with you as an early user to onboard you with additional free credits so you can test out the software.I've tried to keep this brief - it would be great to hear feedback or hear from anyone who thinks this might be useful for them!Best regards, David.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Parseflow – Automate data extraction from documents

28 Oct 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity

Hi HN,I've been in software engineering for over 10 years and I'm excited to share my latest project, Parseflow (https://parseflow.io). It's a AI data automation platform designed to simplify data extraction from documents and integrate it effortlessly with your go-to applications.Parseflow can handle a variety of document types, including PDFs, images, and scanned documents. This means you can easily extract data from invoices, receipts, contracts, and more. Once you've extracted the data, you can integrate it with a variety of applications, including Google Sheets, QuickBooks, Slack and 3000+ more through Zapier. This makes it easy to automate tasks and workflows that would otherwise be manual.Parseflow is free to use with a limited number of credits, so you can try it out for yourself and see how it can help you automate your data extraction tasks.Feel free to reach out to me at dev@parseflow.io if you have any questions regarding your specific use case. We're happy to help you explore how Parseflow can help you!Looking for feedback on: • What do you think of the idea? • Do you do data extraction? If so, do you do it manually or via a similar service? • What is your use case?

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Parsio 2.0 - Automate data extraction with AI-powered document parser

03 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence Email API

Parsio extracts structured data from emails, PDFs, and files (Excel, HTML, CSV, XML) using AI-powered parsers. The parsed data can be exported to Sheets, webhooks, and 6000+ apps, saving you hours of work each week and increasing accuracy ✅.

Parsio 2.0's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising its ease of use, affordability, and ability to automate data extraction, saving time and increasing accuracy. Several users congratulated the launch and described the platform as a game-changer for organizing email data and streamlining workflows. A user shared a story of recovering $1.2M USDT using Parsio. Questions were raised regarding data handling, privacy (suggesting enhancements for version 3.0), OCR engine, parsing PDFs with images, and extracting data into CSVs.

The primary criticism revolves around user concerns regarding the security and privacy implications of sharing potentially sensitive email data with a third-party service. This apprehension about data handling and potential misuse is a key point of caution for prospective users.

Avatar
242
16
31.2%
6.2%
16
242
31.2%
6.2%
Relevance

FormX.ai - AutoML for extracting structured information from documents

29 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence Productivity Tech

Train your own no-code extractors powerd by ML and easily integrate FormX into your workflows via API. Eliminate manual data entry to automate data extraction from various documents like IDs, receipts, invoices, and more with 90%+ accuracy.

Users expressed positive feedback and congratulations on the Product Hunt launch. They were impressed with the idea and offered wishes for the team's success. One user is planning to provide an in-depth review, while another suggested listing the product on AI directories and requested more details about the app.

Avatar
45
4
25.0%
4
45
25.0%
Relevance

PDFMerse - Data Extractor - Any PDF to Any Format

22 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Data Data & Analytics

Extract data from any PDF to structured data format with AI. PDFMerse uses AI to handle complex documents, including handwritten text and multiple languages. Our newly released API enables you to integrate PDF extraction into your apps.

PDFMerse - Data Extractor is praised for its impressive AI capabilities, enabling effortless data extraction.

Avatar
19
2
50.0%
50.0%
2
19
50.0%
50.0%
Relevance

panda{·}etl - Automate your document workflows

27 Sep 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity Spreadsheets

Turn messy files into actionable data. Upload PDFs, images, audio and websites. Define data points for AI-powered extraction. See results in exportable spreadsheets with linked, highlighted sources. Ask questions, plot charts and draft reports on top.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team and praising the product's sleekness, user-friendliness, and potential to streamline data handling, especially with messy and unstructured data. Several users highlighted its capabilities in PDF extraction and workflow automation, with excitement around its AI-powered features. Questions arose about API availability, handling of different languages and file formats, pricing, and integration with other tools. Some users shared specific use cases and expressed intent to try or subscribe, while others offered encouragement and support.

Users expressed concerns regarding unclear pricing, especially credit usage. Several questioned the product's AI capabilities, seeking differentiation from competitors like Deepnote, and requesting improvements in data point definition and multilingual document handling. There were also concerns about performance with PDFs and large data volumes, emphasizing the need for real-world effectiveness. Users desired a more intuitive upload process (drag-and-drop), better collaboration features, mobile app support, and raised skepticism about the promise of "instant actionable data."

Avatar
672
89
32.6%
3.4%
89
672
32.6%
3.4%
Relevance

GmailGenius – an open-source AI aided invoice management tool

03 Sep 2024 Artificial Intelligence

Hey HN,I am excited to share GmailGenius, a tool that automatically processes new emails, extracts data from attachments, and organizes everything in a spreadsheet!I made this because I was having difficulty managing all the invoices manually. It can easily be a time-sink.This is the tech stack I have used:1. Composio for Gmail and Google Sheets integration.2. Nanonets for data extraction from invoice PDFs3. CrewAI for agent orchestration4. React + Vite for a simple frontend.How it works:1. Add a few keywords to find potential emails with invoices. Also, specify the key attributes you want to extract from invoices using a simple front-end interface.2. Set up an event listener to poll new emails from Gmail.3. The AI agent uses Nanonet to extract pre-defined attributes from invoice PDFs.4. The agent automatically updates data in a Google Sheets spreadsheet.I would love your feedback!

Avatar
4
4
Relevance

Receiptor AI - Extract receipts and invoices from your emails with GPT-4

14 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence Accounting Productivity

An AI-powered tool that automates receipt extraction from Gmail/Outlook, analyses past emails, and provides detailed receipt info. It integrates with your expense management system and simplifies tax prep. Ideal for individuals, businesses, and accountants.

Receiptor AI's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users praising its simplicity and speed, expressing excitement and labeling it as super helpful. Congratulations were offered on the launch and the hard work behind it. One user raised a concern about email scraping. Another user, impressed with the concept, suggested including the app in a directory.

The primary criticism revolves around the lack of email scraping functionality, which raises concerns about privacy.

Avatar
94
6
0.0%
6
94
16.7%
Relevance

AutoDocument – Multi-Source Document Generation

09 Aug 2024 Productivity

Hi there, this post is introducing AutoDocument, a free and open-source document generating web app that connects spreadsheets, databases and user forms into documents such as Microsoft Word and PDFs. It's based on fantastic open sources libraries like https://github.com/elapouya/python-docx-template and headless LibreOffice.Mail Merge is a pain because it:- Only converts from Excel to Word- Uses special field objects in the Word document- Requires a Microsoft Office License- Has limited templating optionsAutoDocument is a free and easily installable web app that can setup reusable Workflows that convert data from a variety of sources including straight from databases and spreadsheets to several types of outputs, including Word and PDFs. It only uses text based fields such as "{{ myfield }}" instead of special objects. It can deal with logical blocks of text and loops to populate flexible templates including lists and tables.Features- Create (optional) user forms to kick off a workflow and link to your users- Load and save data, templates and output from windows and linux network mounts, as well as S3 and SharePoint libraries.- Powerful templating based on jinja2 and python-docx-template with logic blocks (like if, while etc) as well as standard field substitution.- Chain sources together like forms, spreadsheets and SQL queries to create clever workflowsEasily installed by running the container: docker.io/tommalkin/autodocument:latestRepo: https://github.com/TomMalkin/AutoDocumentDocumentation: https://tommalkin.github.io/AutoDocument/Landing Page: https://autodocument.app/Container: https://hub.docker.com/r/tommalkin/autodocument

Avatar
7
7
Relevance

Terabinder - Automated data entry & document management

14 Oct 2023 SaaS Productivity Storage

A system that knows exactly what you want from each document, can effortlessly sort through hundreds of files, automatically extract data, and present you with comprehensive reports. Ditch outdated folder mazes and embrace a new era of document management.

The Product Hunt launch is receiving positive feedback, with users wishing @jon_a_tron well. Users appreciate the software's automation of document sorting, data extraction, and report generation. One user confirmed the UI is good. A suggestion was made for a video tutorial in addition to the well-designed website and web application.

A key criticism revolves around the security of uploaded documents and user data. Users expressed concern about the safety and privacy of their information when using the product.

Avatar
71
5
5
71
Relevance

Hand Check - Extract Text from PDF

26 Sep 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity API

An easy to use document to text application, for extracting data from PDFs and other document images. Coverts table data and handwriting to text, or to JSON via our API.

The tool is useful for legal firms needing document conversion into searchable formats. Users are requesting OCR functionality, specifically for handwriting recognition, to aid students and professionals. One user reported a broken video link on the website.

Users have expressed concerns about the accuracy when processing handwritten documents. Additionally, one user reported that the video link on the website is not functioning.

Avatar
6
3
3
6
Top