Should I Build It Should I Build It
03 Jun 2025
SaaS

core web vital monitoring for saas businesses. notifications when ...

...something bad happens

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

The idea of core web vital monitoring for SaaS businesses is entering a highly competitive space, as indicated by the 14 similar products already available. This falls under the "Competitive Terrain" category, where the primary challenge isn't proving demand, but differentiating yourself. To succeed, your core web vital monitoring solution needs to offer a unique value proposition that competitors aren't already providing. While the average engagement (6 comments) on similar products suggests interest, breaking through the noise requires a compelling offering. Given the crowded market, standing out with your unique features and marketing will be a necessity. Even if there isn't a signal for 'buy' or 'use' here, this doesn't mean that people won't use or buy your product; it means that these metrics aren't applicable to this idea. Many of the competitors do get criticism though, so there's some potential opportunity there. You should proceed cautiously and prioritize differentiation.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with a thorough analysis of existing core web vital monitoring tools, paying close attention to their strengths and weaknesses. The high number of similar products means you'll need to deeply understand the competitive landscape. Speetals, for example, was praised for its RUM data but also criticized for data accuracy compared to Google Lighthouse. Identify what competitors are missing or doing poorly.
  2. Based on your competitive analysis, focus on 2-3 key areas where you can significantly improve upon existing solutions. This could be through more accurate data, a more user-friendly interface (addressing a common pain point), deeper integration with specific SaaS platforms, or unique alerting features. Consider mobile notifications, since Notifyz received criticism for lacking quick integration with them.
  3. Consider specializing in a niche within the SaaS market. For example, you could focus on monitoring web vitals for e-commerce SaaS platforms, marketing SaaS, or developer tools. This allows you to tailor your features and marketing to a specific audience and potentially gain traction more quickly.
  4. Develop a strong brand and marketing message that clearly communicates your unique value proposition. Given the competition, your messaging needs to be compelling and resonate with your target users. Highlight the specific benefits of your solution and why it's better than the alternatives. Don't make the same mistake as Uptime System, which received criticism for a launch description that lacked detail.
  5. Prioritize early user feedback and iterate quickly. Engage with your first users to understand their needs and pain points. Use their feedback to improve your product and add new features. The goal is to create a loyal base of early adopters who will advocate for your product. Look into the suggestions and feature requests that were expressed in the comments of similar products.
  6. Explore integrations with popular SaaS platforms and tools. This will make your solution more valuable to your target users and increase its stickiness. Consider integrating with Slack and similar products, as this was an expressed wish of several users.
  7. Carefully consider your pricing strategy. The products launched by Notifyz and Monitor were criticized for their high price. Offer a free plan or trial to attract new users, and then provide paid plans with more advanced features. Make sure your pricing is competitive and reflects the value you're providing.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions for core web vital monitoring, what is the truly unique and compelling advantage that your product will offer to SaaS businesses? How will you measure and demonstrate this advantage to potential customers?
  2. Many competing products face criticism related to data accuracy, beginner friendliness, lack of support, or lack of clarity of pricing and value. Which of these potential pitfalls are you most concerned about and how will you mitigate these?
  3. Considering the high number of competitors, how will you prioritize your initial marketing efforts to effectively reach your target audience and stand out from the crowd?

Your are here

The idea of core web vital monitoring for SaaS businesses is entering a highly competitive space, as indicated by the 14 similar products already available. This falls under the "Competitive Terrain" category, where the primary challenge isn't proving demand, but differentiating yourself. To succeed, your core web vital monitoring solution needs to offer a unique value proposition that competitors aren't already providing. While the average engagement (6 comments) on similar products suggests interest, breaking through the noise requires a compelling offering. Given the crowded market, standing out with your unique features and marketing will be a necessity. Even if there isn't a signal for 'buy' or 'use' here, this doesn't mean that people won't use or buy your product; it means that these metrics aren't applicable to this idea. Many of the competitors do get criticism though, so there's some potential opportunity there. You should proceed cautiously and prioritize differentiation.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with a thorough analysis of existing core web vital monitoring tools, paying close attention to their strengths and weaknesses. The high number of similar products means you'll need to deeply understand the competitive landscape. Speetals, for example, was praised for its RUM data but also criticized for data accuracy compared to Google Lighthouse. Identify what competitors are missing or doing poorly.
  2. Based on your competitive analysis, focus on 2-3 key areas where you can significantly improve upon existing solutions. This could be through more accurate data, a more user-friendly interface (addressing a common pain point), deeper integration with specific SaaS platforms, or unique alerting features. Consider mobile notifications, since Notifyz received criticism for lacking quick integration with them.
  3. Consider specializing in a niche within the SaaS market. For example, you could focus on monitoring web vitals for e-commerce SaaS platforms, marketing SaaS, or developer tools. This allows you to tailor your features and marketing to a specific audience and potentially gain traction more quickly.
  4. Develop a strong brand and marketing message that clearly communicates your unique value proposition. Given the competition, your messaging needs to be compelling and resonate with your target users. Highlight the specific benefits of your solution and why it's better than the alternatives. Don't make the same mistake as Uptime System, which received criticism for a launch description that lacked detail.
  5. Prioritize early user feedback and iterate quickly. Engage with your first users to understand their needs and pain points. Use their feedback to improve your product and add new features. The goal is to create a loyal base of early adopters who will advocate for your product. Look into the suggestions and feature requests that were expressed in the comments of similar products.
  6. Explore integrations with popular SaaS platforms and tools. This will make your solution more valuable to your target users and increase its stickiness. Consider integrating with Slack and similar products, as this was an expressed wish of several users.
  7. Carefully consider your pricing strategy. The products launched by Notifyz and Monitor were criticized for their high price. Offer a free plan or trial to attract new users, and then provide paid plans with more advanced features. Make sure your pricing is competitive and reflects the value you're providing.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions for core web vital monitoring, what is the truly unique and compelling advantage that your product will offer to SaaS businesses? How will you measure and demonstrate this advantage to potential customers?
  2. Many competing products face criticism related to data accuracy, beginner friendliness, lack of support, or lack of clarity of pricing and value. Which of these potential pitfalls are you most concerned about and how will you mitigate these?
  3. Considering the high number of competitors, how will you prioritize your initial marketing efforts to effectively reach your target audience and stand out from the crowd?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 14
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 6
  • Net use signal: 13.9%
    • Positive use signal: 14.7%
    • Negative use signal: 0.8%
  • Net buy signal: 1.1%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.9%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.8%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Speetals - Website Speed and Web Vitals monitoring

20 Dec 2024 User Experience SEO Analytics

Speetals is a Web Vitals and website speed Monitoring tool focused on real user metrics to help you improve what matters and save money. It helps measure, prioritize, validate optimizations, and prevent regressions of user experience.

Speetals' Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its RUM data, web performance capabilities, and usefulness for e-commerce SEO. Many users congratulated Aymen, the founder, highlighting his dedication and the tool's value for performance engineers and website owners. Speetals is noted for monitoring website speed, providing actionable insights, and saving time. Questions were raised about the tool's data collection methods and its differentiation from Lighthouse. Overall, users expressed enthusiasm for Speetals and wished Aymen continued success.

Users criticize the product's interface, stating it needs to be more beginner-friendly for those new to performance monitoring. Data accuracy is also questioned, with some users comparing the product unfavorably to Google Lighthouse in terms of reliability.

Avatar
68
18
5.6%
5.6%
18
68
5.6%
5.6%
Relevance

I built a tool to monitor third-party cloud and SaaS services

03 May 2024 SaaS Developer Tools

Hi,I built this tool to monitor third-party cloud and SaaS services and send notifications, primarily meant for techops/SRE folks. I built this based on my past work experience where I felt a need for such a tool and had to be satisfied with patched together scripts.E.g. Getting alerted when my public cloud has incidents, my monitoring SaaS is unable to send alerts, GitHub has intermittent issues, Slack has trouble delivering messages, Stripe has payment failures for an edge case, and so on.It was important to catch these issues before they impacted my apps. For paging services, I wanted to avoid potential disasters because my on-call teams were not receiving alerts (true story - AWS had an outage and PagerDuty was not sending alerts). For non-infra services like Slack, I wanted to know if there were message drops or delays.There are RSS feeds for these services but I wanted a single place to monitor the ones I am using and be notified, rather than manually check 10-15 or more RSS feeds.I'm the solo dev on this project. I've been in backend development/ops most of my career, so my frontend skills are not great yet, which is evident in the UI :) All feedback is highly appreciated.Thank you.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Uptime System - Eliminate SaaS Downtime

02 Aug 2024 SaaS Developer Tools Tech

Uptime Monitoring Solution with advanced monitoring tools to eliminate SaaS downtime

A user expressed concern about the Product Hunt description being too minimal, suggesting it implies incompleteness. One other comment was deleted.

The Product Hunt launch description was criticized for lacking detail, which made the product appear incomplete to potential users.

Avatar
9
2
2
9
Relevance

Notifyz - Create, Subscribe, Notify All in One Place

21 Oct 2024 Developer Tools

Instant web push alerts 🔔 for indie hackers and developers. Stay on top of server errors, new sign-ups, and critical events with minimal setup. Simplify your project monitoring and never miss important insights again. Built by devs, for devs.

The product launch is generating excitement, particularly for its easy setup, real-time notifications, and potential for simplifying monitoring through instant alerts. Users, especially solo developers and small teams, appreciate its user-friendliness. A key feature request is mobile notification integration, especially concerning an upcoming open-source gateway release. Concerns were raised regarding the pricing, which was perceived as too high.

The Product Hunt launch received criticism for several reasons. Users noted the absence of quick integration with mobile notifications, similar to Notifyz. Additionally, some users felt that the product lacked sufficient resources for absolute beginners without any coding experience. Finally, there were concerns raised that the product's pricing was too high, which could deter potential customers.

Avatar
119
7
42.9%
-14.3%
7
119
57.1%
Relevance

Simple Uptime - Monitor the health of your websites and servers inside Slack

08 Jun 2024 SaaS

Simple website & API monitoring fully inside Slack. Monitor the health of websites, APIs and servers in Slack and get up/downtime alerts delivered to your team's channel. No registration needed. Setup for free in <1 minute.

Users express positive feedback regarding Simple Uptime, praising its ease of use for website and API health monitoring, particularly the Slack integration. Several users inquired about alert customization, compatibility with other platforms besides Slack, and pricing for advanced or paid features. Some asked about functionality, such as whether it works like a cron tool. Users congratulate the team on the launch and milestone, highlighting the importance of website health monitoring.

Users expressed concerns about the platform's limited support and requested broader compatibility. Questions were raised regarding the pricing model and how the tool would be monetized, especially since only a free version is currently available. One comment was incomprehensible and could not be assessed for criticism.

Avatar
219
14
14.3%
14
219
14.3%
Relevance

Wards – IT Infrastructure Monitoring

07 Oct 2023 SaaS

Hello everyone,I'm thrilled to introduce you to Wards, a groundbreaking IT infrastructure and server monitoring tool designed to keep a vigilant eye on your systems 24/7. I'm Amjad, the CEO and founder of Wards (https://wards.app).In today's fast-paced digital world, the stability and reliability of your IT infrastructure are paramount. That's why we've developed Wards - to provide companies with a comprehensive monitoring solution that ensures the smooth operation of their IT systems at all times. With Wards, you can rest easy knowing that your servers and infrastructure are under constant surveillance.Our mission is to empower businesses like yours to proactively manage their IT assets and respond swiftly in case of any issues. We understand the importance of early detection, which is why Wards is designed to alert you the moment something goes awry.The feedback we've received so far has been overwhelmingly positive, and we couldn't be more excited to share this innovative solution with you. But our journey is just beginning, and we're committed to continuous improvement and innovation.At Wards, we believe that the future of IT infrastructure management lies in advanced monitoring tools like ours. Stay tuned for more updates and features as we work tirelessly to make your IT operations more efficient and worry-free.Thank you for joining us on this exciting journey. Together, we can ensure that your IT infrastructure remains secure, reliable, and always at its best.

The comments indicate that there is a clickable link to wards.app, but no content is available on the site.

Avatar
5
2
2
5
Relevance

Monitor your webapp with minimal setup

21 Nov 2023 SaaS Analytics Developer Tools

Hey HN,I'm building a service that monitors your webapp and gives you a definitive signal when something is broken, all with minimal setup.You can check it out at: https://www.catalystmonitor.com/, read the docs at: https://docs.catalystmonitor.com/, or see the dashboard at: https://app.catalystmonitor.com/You can also see a (very quickly made) demo at: https://www.loom.com/share/5b38a328ded94f93a980f1ba28081329?sid=5afe55d1-0e0a-42a1-b748-1c230eacd430I've seen how having robust internal monitoring infra maintained by dedicated teams helped developers at large companies. This was something I missed when I later moved to a startup. I was disappointed by how much setup and maintenance was required by existing monitoring products: I constantly fiddled with Splunk queries, pruned Sentry errors, and created New Relic dashbords, all to get weak signals to the only thing I cared about: is my product currently broken or not for users? So I decided to build the tool that I would've wanted.Most people building a product want to maximize effort on actually building their product and minimize effort monitoring it, so I built this service to be easy to set up: you can sign up, integrate it, and get useful signals within a day without worrying about configuration or monitoring new code-paths.The downside to being easy to set up is that it's opinionated, less configurable, and won't be 100% effective for certain use-cases. If you throw errors and use HTTP error codes instead of swallowing errors, you'll get useful monitoring with minimal effort right out of the box.There are currently client libraries for the browser, Node.JS, Express, and React Router, but integration with other JS/TS frameworks shouldn't be hard while integration with other languages is definitely possible. Please let me know if you'd be interested in support for another language or framework.Also, I know it's ironic, but it's still under development, and thus may have bugs. I'd love to know what you think. Either way, may your queries flow and your pagers stay silent.

Users are interested in the product, requesting a loom or sample dashboard for a clearer view before signing up, as images on the site are blurry. They find the dashboard clean and are inquiring about pricing information, with a particular interest in affordability for indie developers. Questions about support for Next.js, setup, traffic handling, and pricing differences are also raised. One user suggests trying Monibot for app metrics and server usage.

Users criticized the product for its unclear market position, blurry images on the website, inaccessible pricing for independent developers, inability to import metrics from other tools, and lack of comparability to established products like Catalyst.

Avatar
5
6
16.7%
16.7%
6
5
16.7%
16.7%
Relevance

Free Monitoring Suite by WebGazer - Monitoring for websites, APIs, and cron jobs

11 Jul 2024 Web App Analytics Developer Tools

Monitor websites, APIs, cron jobs, and more with ease. Get real-time alerts for downtime, performance issues, and SSL problems. Enjoy a customizable status page. Try WebGazer: Your free, comprehensive monitoring solution.

WebGazer's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its real-time alerts, easy setup, comprehensive monitoring capabilities, customizable status pages, and generous free plan. Many users found it a simple, effective, and crucial tool for monitoring websites, cron jobs, and APIs. Several users highlighted WebGazer's uptime monitoring and prompt email notifications. Questions were raised about alert customization, self-hosting options, GDPR compliance, handling simultaneous issues, sign-in monitoring, competitive advantages and market saturation. Long-time users appreciate the product's affordability and effectiveness.

Users expressed concerns regarding potential alert overwhelm and the need for customization options. There's a sense of hoping the product lives up to its promises, suggesting possible skepticism or concerns about unmet expectations. Differentiation in a competitive market was also highlighted as a crucial aspect for the product's success.

Avatar
317
35
28.6%
35
317
28.6%
Top