Should I Build It Should I Build It
02 Jul 2025
Personal Finance Fintech Money

Financial management for managing both household and individual ...

...finances separating concerns

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Your idea for a financial management tool that separates household and individual finances enters a very competitive space. We found 27 similar products, indicating a high level of competition. This isn't necessarily bad; it validates the demand for such tools. However, to succeed, you'll need a clear differentiator. The average engagement for similar products is medium (5 comments), suggesting users are interested but not overly enthusiastic. Since we do not have any use/buy signals, it's hard to assess demand, but the sheer number of competitors indicates that there's certainly demand for these kinds of products. Your challenge now is to cut through the noise and offer something truly unique and valuable.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with extensive market research, deeply analyzing existing solutions. Focus on identifying pain points that your competitors aren’t adequately addressing. The criticisms from similar products highlight a common need for automation and easier maintenance, so explore how you might address that. Many users desired bank integration and automatic calculation of metrics.
  2. Define your unique selling proposition (USP). Given the crowded market, what specific problem will your application solve better than anyone else? Perhaps it's superior visualization, AI-powered insights, or seamless integration with specific financial institutions. Ensure this USP is clear and compelling.
  3. Consider niche targeting. Instead of competing broadly, focus on a specific segment, such as freelancers, small business owners, or couples managing shared finances. Tailor your features and marketing to meet their specific needs. A smaller target audience allows for more focused development and marketing efforts.
  4. Prioritize user experience (UX). The discussion summaries of similar products reveal that user-friendliness and design are crucial. Invest in creating an intuitive interface and a seamless user journey. A clean and aesthetically pleasing design can significantly improve user satisfaction.
  5. Develop a strong brand and marketing message. Highlight your USP and resonate with your target audience's values and aspirations. Emphasize ease of use, security, and tangible benefits, like saving time and money. Consider content marketing (blog posts, tutorials) to showcase your expertise and attract potential users.
  6. Implement a feedback loop with early users. Actively solicit feedback and iterate based on their needs and pain points. This continuous improvement will help you refine your product and build a loyal user base. Focus on building a community where users can share their experiences and provide valuable insights.
  7. Explore potential integrations with other financial tools and services. Consider partnerships with banks, investment platforms, or accounting software to offer a more comprehensive solution. Integrations can provide added value and convenience for your users.
  8. Incorporate robust data security measures. Financial data is sensitive, so ensure your application meets the highest security standards. Transparency about your security practices can build trust with your users.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition, what is the one killer feature or benefit that will make users switch from their current financial management solution to yours?
  2. What specific niche are you targeting, and how will you tailor your marketing and product development to meet their unique needs?
  3. How will you ensure data security and user privacy, and how will you communicate these measures to build trust with your users?

Your are here

Your idea for a financial management tool that separates household and individual finances enters a very competitive space. We found 27 similar products, indicating a high level of competition. This isn't necessarily bad; it validates the demand for such tools. However, to succeed, you'll need a clear differentiator. The average engagement for similar products is medium (5 comments), suggesting users are interested but not overly enthusiastic. Since we do not have any use/buy signals, it's hard to assess demand, but the sheer number of competitors indicates that there's certainly demand for these kinds of products. Your challenge now is to cut through the noise and offer something truly unique and valuable.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with extensive market research, deeply analyzing existing solutions. Focus on identifying pain points that your competitors aren’t adequately addressing. The criticisms from similar products highlight a common need for automation and easier maintenance, so explore how you might address that. Many users desired bank integration and automatic calculation of metrics.
  2. Define your unique selling proposition (USP). Given the crowded market, what specific problem will your application solve better than anyone else? Perhaps it's superior visualization, AI-powered insights, or seamless integration with specific financial institutions. Ensure this USP is clear and compelling.
  3. Consider niche targeting. Instead of competing broadly, focus on a specific segment, such as freelancers, small business owners, or couples managing shared finances. Tailor your features and marketing to meet their specific needs. A smaller target audience allows for more focused development and marketing efforts.
  4. Prioritize user experience (UX). The discussion summaries of similar products reveal that user-friendliness and design are crucial. Invest in creating an intuitive interface and a seamless user journey. A clean and aesthetically pleasing design can significantly improve user satisfaction.
  5. Develop a strong brand and marketing message. Highlight your USP and resonate with your target audience's values and aspirations. Emphasize ease of use, security, and tangible benefits, like saving time and money. Consider content marketing (blog posts, tutorials) to showcase your expertise and attract potential users.
  6. Implement a feedback loop with early users. Actively solicit feedback and iterate based on their needs and pain points. This continuous improvement will help you refine your product and build a loyal user base. Focus on building a community where users can share their experiences and provide valuable insights.
  7. Explore potential integrations with other financial tools and services. Consider partnerships with banks, investment platforms, or accounting software to offer a more comprehensive solution. Integrations can provide added value and convenience for your users.
  8. Incorporate robust data security measures. Financial data is sensitive, so ensure your application meets the highest security standards. Transparency about your security practices can build trust with your users.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition, what is the one killer feature or benefit that will make users switch from their current financial management solution to yours?
  2. What specific niche are you targeting, and how will you tailor your marketing and product development to meet their unique needs?
  3. How will you ensure data security and user privacy, and how will you communicate these measures to build trust with your users?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 27
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 5
  • Net use signal: 18.7%
    • Positive use signal: 18.7%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 2.9%
    • Positive buy signal: 2.9%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Money Management - The easy way to take control of your finances

22 Jul 2023 Personal Finance Notion

Take control of your finances with this Notion template! Track your income, expenses, and budget in one place. See where your money is going and make changes to reach your financial goals. Easy to use and customizable. Get started today!

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising the template's usefulness for finance tracking, money management, and budgeting. Many users congratulated Min on the launch and complimented the template's design and user-friendliness. Some users requested additional features like graph capabilities and external service/bank syncing. One user shared their experience of recovering lost funds with the help of a recovery agent.

The main criticism is that the product requires too much manual effort to keep the information updated. This suggests a need for more automation or easier maintenance features.

Avatar
142
21
4.8%
21
142
4.8%
Relevance

Notion Finance Tracker & Goal Planner - Streamline your finances, streamline your life

30 Sep 2023 Productivity Notion Money

This template is your all-in-one solution for effective financial management. It covers income, expenses, accounts, transfers, subscriptions, and goals, giving you a clear overview of your finances and empowering you to make informed financial decisions.

The product launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its clean, functional, and aesthetically pleasing design. The Subscriptions Tracker feature and the comprehensive finance tracker template were specifically highlighted as valuable. Users found the app effective for tracking expenses, incomes, and subscriptions, and appreciated its ease of use. Several commenters congratulated the team on the launch, with one suggesting a potential integration with a data management product. The product effectively meets users' financial tracking needs.

The primary criticism revolves around the automatic calculation of metrics within templates. Users are inquiring about the possibility of Morph assisting with this functionality, indicating a desire for automated metric calculation capabilities.

Avatar
111
11
36.4%
11
111
36.4%
Relevance

Pallo - All-in-one personal & business financial management

07 Sep 2023 Fintech Freelance Career

Manage your personal & business budgets, income, expenses, receipts, mileage, products, services, clients, projects, time and invoices & receive financial insights, credit score, reports & tax prep.

Pallo's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising its financial insights, comprehensiveness, and usefulness for both personal and business finances. The credit score feature is particularly appreciated. Many users congratulated the team on the launch and wished them luck. Some users inquired about Pallo's unique features compared to other platforms. One user highlighted Pallo 2's impact on virtual meetings, referring to it as revolutionary.

Avatar
134
11
18.2%
9.1%
11
134
18.2%
9.1%
Relevance

Notion Ultimate Finance Dashboard - Take Control Of Your Finances With Notion

30 Aug 2024 Personal Finance Finance Notion

Take control of your finances with the Ultimate Finance Dashboard. Plan, track, budget, save, and manage everything in one place. This all-in-one dashboard combines top finance templates into a powerful, integrated tool for organizing your financial life.

Users are excited about the all-in-one finance tool, particularly its budget control features. There's a request for investment/debt tracking functionality. Commenters congratulated Dave on the launch and lauded the marketing. Positive feedback was given on the template's appearance.

Avatar
21
5
40.0%
5
21
40.0%
Relevance

Notion Ultimate Finance Manager - Take control of your finances with Notion finance manager

11 Jun 2023 Personal Finance Notion Money

Managing your finances can be overwhelming, but it doesn't have to be. With our Notion Finance Manager template, you can easily keep track of your income, expenses, accounts,subscriptions, and budget all in one place.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising the usefulness of the template and describing it as 'awesome'. One user enthusiastically said 'Fire bro!' indicating strong approval.

Avatar
71
3
3
71
Relevance

Financial - Manager & Tracker - A better way to manage your income, expenses & debts.

30 Jul 2024 iOS Productivity Finance

Discover Financial, the all-in-one app for managing your finances! With Financial, you can manage all your accounts in one place, set up recurring payments with SmartPay, organize contracts and wish lists, and keep track of your liabilities.

App launch congratulations; feedback given, but difficult to provide initially.

Hard to find on ProductHunt; feedback submission not intuitive.

Avatar
63
1
100.0%
1
63
100.0%
Relevance

FinWise – The modern way to manage your personal finances

30 Oct 2023 Fintech Personal Finance

Hi everyone, I'd like to share FinWise (https://finwiseapp.io) with you, which my wife and I have been building over the last few months.FinWise is an all-in-one personal finance management tool, including budgeting, net-worth tracking, financial planning & forecasting and a couple of other things which we're still busy working on like couples/family budgeting and being able to set and track goals.It's designed to make managing all your personal finances as simple, easy and painless as possible, and we've put a lot of effort into making the website as simple and intuitive, whilst still being powerful and offering a comprehensive set of personal finance tools.A non-exhaustive list of things you can do with FinWise:- Connect your bank & investments accounts with Plaid & Yodlee (Or manual imports). - Currently US, CA and ZA. EU, NZ, AU and others coming soon!- Track and visualize your net-worth.- Budget and save money.- AI transaction categorization (You almost never have to manually categorize your transactions).- Transaction splitting, tags, notes and attachments.- Import transactions with CSV files from Mint/Empower etc.- Export account, transaction and insights data to CSV.- Plan, project and forecast your future finances (In beta).- Spending, saving and net-worth insights and analytics.- Multi-currency support.- Goals and goal-tracking (Coming soon).- Developer API access (Coming soon).- iOS/Android app (Coming soon).- Privacy-focused. No ads, selling data or anything like that.- Just about SOC2 and ISO compliant (No certificates yet, but I've done a few SOC2 certifications in the past.)We made FinWise because we were not able to find a personal finance tool out there which offered all the features we wanted, and which was simple, intuitive and easy to use. There are lots of personal finances apps around, but we felt most were either too basic, over-complicated or too expensive, or limiting in some way.We're now on a mission to build the best personal finance app out there, and to help as many people as possible to better save, grow and manage their money.If you'd like to learn more and try it out, head over to our website: https://finwiseapp.ioIf you have any feedback or questions, please let me know :)Find us on X/Twitter: Me: https://twitter.com/jasrusable Nicol: https://twitter.com/NicolNvojacek FinWise: https://twitter.com/FinwiseappPS: There are some interesting technical aspects of the project that we are particularly proud of which I am planning to do more in-depth posts on soon, namely:- How we implemented our AI transaction categorization system.- How we built the entire website to use optimistic loading, so no loading states.- How we kept the codebases extremely simple and intuitive, allowing us to move quickly.- Going open source once we hit critical mass.

Avatar
9
9
Relevance

Maybe - Modern financial planning & wealth management

24 Jan 2023 Fintech Personal Finance Money

Your financial future, in your control! Track all of your accounts in one place, simulate scenarios, get advice from qualified financial advisors and much more. All for a transparent, flat monthly price. No percentages or hidden fees!

Many users congratulated the team on the launch of Maybe, expressing excitement for its potential in financial control and organization, with some highlighting its superior features compared to Mint or Quicken. The user interface and design received considerable praise, including specific appreciation for the dark theme. There were requests for international access, particularly for the UK, Australia, and Canada, as well as support for more financial institutions (beyond IBKR). Users also inquired about features like net worth tracking with real estate assets and the ability to manually create and include assets.

Users criticized the product for its limited availability, specifically being restricted to the US without clear upfront notification. There's frustration with the lack of international account support, including the UK and Romania. Some users expressed difficulty in finding an advisor, and the reliance on Personal Capital was not universally appealing. The 12-month return policy received mixed reactions. The limited connectivity to only Interactive Brokers was also a drawback.

julia_markus

This is so exciting! I absolutely NEED it. Is it only for the US, or is Canada included?

zackkatz

I’ve been using Maybe during the beta and I’m impressed. It’s a modern and clean way to see all my finances in one place. Plus, since it’s a paid service, it doesn’t feel like a gross scam like Mint. I’m not happy to see my 12 month returns for this year, but I’m happy that I CAN see them, easily, with Maybe.

consolamentor

Can’t wait for you to launch in Australia 🤗

paolo_degiglio

Congrats on the launch of Maybe! 🎉I'm so excited to see the amazing tools and resources you've created to give us the confidence to take control of our finances. 🤑 Let's get our money right! 💰

sebastienb

I've been following this for a while now and it was great seeing all the updates on Twitter from @shpigford and even better to be able to test the beta version. Congrats to the team, you have an awesome product!

joshtoasts

I've been following Maybe since Josh announced it so long ago. I'm always impressed by the products he's released and I'm excited for the launch of his and his team's hard work so we can finally see it all come together!

alexcuuper

Wow, I really like your useful app. Actually I work in the financial area, so it would be close friend for me. P.S. I would happy to see such amazing people in our community!

ezahnlecker

Just started using Maybe and I'm enjoying it so far. Have linked a few accounts and am already finding a few cool features that are missing from Wealthfront - which is the best version of this sort of tool that I currently have. For example, it shows how much I'm spending monthly and annually which is a trivial feature but not trivial to calculate myself. Great work Josh and team, excited to keep using it and watch it get even better :)

xmcgraw

Congratulations Team Maybe! I've been following since you all started the adventure, and I look forward to diving in tonight. I'm ready for a solution that really helps with keeping an eye on net worth, asset value, investments, and more. I'm looking forward to the advisor component. There's been plenty of moments where I should ping one, but don't (pain finding one leading to overconfidence that I can figure it out myself). Good luck, team!

britt_joiner

I've been testing Maybe out in Beta, and I'm really excited for more folks to get to try it out! Great way to keep track of your money in one place and organize your assets at a higher level rather than combining everything in a spreadsheet. Congrats on the launch, I'm excited for y'all!

usamaejaz

Congratulations on the launch of Maybe! I'm excited to see the possibilities this product offers for taking control of our financial future. Let's start the discussion on how to make the most of it!

colinloretz

I've been using the beta for a few months and I use a lot of other net worth apps like Mint, Personal Capital, etc. Maybe has done the best job at pulling together all of my accounts across so many different types of accounts/assets/debts and keep them up to date so I have a good sense of my financial situation. The planning feature was pretty enlightening to help me figure out how my goals line up with possible future realities - or big "maybes." Nice work Maybe team!

chocksy

I love the product and i only can connect my Interactive Brokers account for now as it’s not available in Romania but the design is great and the ease of use is perfect. Nice work and i’ll be keeping close :) Nice work @shpigford

weirdowizard

Been eagerly waiting to get my hands on this tool. Will have to wait some more time for international accounts. Anyway, congrats @shpigford & team!

Avatar
357
30
46.7%
3.3%
30
357
46.7%
3.3%
Relevance

Notion x Finance - Automate your financial management to take smart decisions

13 Jan 2023 No-Code Productivity Notion

Simplify and automate the way you track your finances. Have a clear view of your cash flow to find where to save and finally pay off your debts to achieve financial goals.

The Notion x Finance launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising the clean design and usefulness of the finance tracking template. Many congratulated Dave on the launch and highlighted its potential for improving finance skills. Questions arose regarding automation capabilities, specifically with various banks and credit card invoice generation. Several users expressed intent to purchase, believing the template would be valuable for managing finances, and one user shared a personal success story of improved credit score management.

Users criticized the product launch for lacking clear instructions on usage. The inefficiency of the current financial tracking system was also pointed out as a significant drawback.

Avatar
193
30
13.3%
10.0%
30
193
13.3%
10.0%
Relevance

Financial Control - Keep your finances under control

09 Jul 2023 Personal Finance Notion

Keep your Personal Finances under control, have all your Expenses registered by Category, with a Performance Chart versus your Budget, in addition to having an Annual Balance.

The launch received congratulations and positive feedback, with users praising the UI as simple and useful. The tool is seen as needed and helpful for managing finances, with suggestions for expense visualization. Users look forward to features like performance charts and annual balance for better budgeting. A key request is for automatic bank integration to improve the tool's functionality.

The primary criticism is the lack of bank integration for automatic expense tracking. Users must manually enter expenses, which is seen as a significant drawback. This absence limits the product's convenience and efficiency for users seeking effortless financial management.

Avatar
100
7
42.9%
7
100
42.9%
Relevance

Budget Buddy - Simple Budgeting for Busy People

11 Apr 2023 Budgeting Personal Finance Notion

Wake up each morning feeling financially secure and in control. With this notion template, you can easily track your spending, set budget limits, and achieve money goals. Say goodbye to debt, overspending, and hello to financial freedom and peace of mind.

Users find the Budget Buddy app user-friendly, simple, and helpful for financial tracking and budgeting. The tagline and overall idea are considered impressive and brilliant. One user inquired about the use of Chat-GPT for content creation. Several users congratulated the team on the launch and its potential, with one requesting inclusion in a directory.

Avatar
80
7
7
80
Relevance

My side project is helping me manage my finances

27 Dec 2023 Fintech Personal Finance Artificial Intelligence

For years, I have struggled to understand my cash flow and save for the future. In addition to that, my wife has many credit cards and accounts that complicate matters. I am building a tool that connects all our accounts, helps us create a budget, and tracks and adjusts expenses on the fly. I am also sprinkling some AI magic on it for financial suggestions. I am looking for feedback on the implementation. More importantly, I am looking for more beta testers to improve the product.

The Show HN product, FML, is recognized for simplifying financial planning and review. Users have concerns about the association with a well-known initialism potentially being detrimental. There is curiosity about the AI's functionality and questions regarding integration with financial institutions. The product has received positive remarks on its appearance. Some comments are no longer active.

Users suggest rethinking the use of the initialism 'FML' due to its commonly known negative connotation, which contrasts with the intended message.

Avatar
9
7
7
9
Relevance

Manage your Budget - Master your money: every expense, every detail

14 Oct 2023 Budgeting Personal Finance Money

Dive into your finances with Manage Your Budget! Get monthly insights, effortless categorizing, and crystal-clear budgeting. Seamlessly track and master your spending in one touch, bringing clarity and control to your financial journey.

A user hopes the product replaces Mint, indicating dissatisfaction with Mint. Another user highlights the importance of money management as a critical skill for founders. One comment was deleted.

The user expressed a dislike for Mint. Since this is the only criticism provided, the summary focuses solely on this negative feedback.

Avatar
72
3
33.3%
3
72
33.3%
Relevance

Expense Ease - Manage your expenses & incomes effortlessly

02 Apr 2024 Android Productivity Tech

Track daily expenses and incomes, create money sources, and customize income and expense categories. Automate your routine with daily, weekly, and monthly recurring transactions. Visualize your financial story with intuitive graphs for specific time periods

The app launch received congratulations and positive feedback. A user inquired about the app's differentiation from competitors. The launch team is seeking collaboration and feedback on Product Hunt.

Avatar
92
3
3
92
Relevance

Finance Management Tool - Finance manager

24 Feb 2025 Personal Finance Money

Manage your finances effortlessly with the my Finance App. Track expenses and incomes. Select a specific date range to see monthly breakdowns. Visualize your data in tables and charts. View summaries of monthly totals and differences.

Avatar
5
5
Top