an AI-driven healthcare platform that empowers general practitioners ...

...to streamline primary care workflows and deliver evidence-based assessments. By integrating an advanced AI health assessment engine, DiceWill generates structured differential diagnoses, suggests appropriate investigations, and provides management pathways. A secure, collaborative medical forum fosters knowledge sharing among physicians and patients, while built-in telemedicine capabilities enable seamless virtual consultations. The platform features a suite of digital medical calculators, wellness tracking, and a women’s health module. Designed for compliance and scalability, DiceWill reduces unnecessary specialist referrals, optimizes resource allocation, and enhances clinical decision support—improving efficiency and patient outcomes across primary care.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

DiceWill, an AI-driven healthcare platform for general practitioners, enters a competitive market. Our analysis reveals that you are in the 'Freemium' category, where users appreciate such tools but hesitate to pay. With 26 similar products already out there, you'll need a strong strategy to differentiate and monetize. While the engagement for such products is medium (avg 4 comments), the lack of positive 'use' or 'buy' signals from our data suggests that you should think carefully about whether or not users want to use your idea or buy it. The good news is that there is also no negative feedback. The numerous comparable offerings indicate that while the need is validated, user acquisition and retention will depend on how effectively you address specific pain points, build trust, and create compelling value.

Recommendations

  1. Given the 'Freemium' category, focus initially on providing immense value for free. Identify the core features that solve the most pressing problems for general practitioners, and make those readily available. This will encourage adoption and build a user base. Based on the summary of discussions from similar products, lack of information, unclear sign-up processes and lack of trustworthiness will lead to almost certain failure. Therefore, put special attention to these details.
  2. Concentrate on building trust and addressing concerns around AI in healthcare. Transparency is key. Clearly articulate how DiceWill's AI works, what data it uses, and how it ensures patient privacy and data security. Address HIPAA compliance and other regulatory concerns upfront, demonstrating a commitment to ethical and responsible AI implementation. Consider including short demo videos and testimonials from physicians who have successfully used the platform.
  3. Identify the users who derive the most value from the free version of DiceWill. Analyze their usage patterns to determine which features are most popular and beneficial. Use this information to refine the platform and tailor premium features that cater to their specific needs. For example, if the women's health module is popular, create a premium version with personalized treatment plans and one-on-one support.
  4. Develop premium features that offer significant advantages over the free version. These could include advanced analytics, personalized consulting with specialists, priority support, or team collaboration tools. Focus on features that demonstrably improve efficiency, reduce workload, and enhance patient outcomes. Given the criticism of similar products lacking actionable insights, ensure your premium features offer clear and direct benefits that justify the upgrade.
  5. Explore team-based pricing models, as charging entire practices may be more effective than individual subscriptions. Pitch DiceWill as a solution that benefits the entire team, streamlining workflows and improving communication. This can make the platform more attractive to larger organizations and increase revenue potential. Instead of charging individual doctors, try charging whole practices in a tiered fashion.
  6. Gather user feedback continuously and iterate on the platform. Based on the criticism of similar products, ask for ongoing feedback about slow feedback, incorrect information or readability issues (e.g. contrast issues with font colors). Actively solicit feedback from users on their experiences, pain points, and feature requests. Use this feedback to improve the platform, address concerns, and ensure that DiceWill remains relevant and valuable to its users.
  7. Given the feedback in similar products, it's crucial to clearly differentiate DiceWill from existing solutions. The AI needs to provide insights and actionable insights, not just be a chatbot. Explain explicitly how DiceWill surpasses current apps, such as iOS Health, MyFitnessPal, or Fitbit, by offering more tailored and intelligent health insights. Offer practical benefits that integrate easily into doctor workflows.

Questions

  1. Given the sensitivity around healthcare data and AI, what specific steps will DiceWill take to ensure data privacy and security, and how will you communicate these measures to build trust with both physicians and patients?
  2. Considering the competitive landscape and the challenge of monetizing freemium healthcare tools, what is your strategy for identifying the ideal customer segment who will be willing to pay for premium features, and how will you tailor your marketing efforts to reach them effectively?
  3. How will DiceWill continuously validate and update its AI models to ensure they are providing accurate, evidence-based recommendations, and what mechanisms will be in place to address potential biases or errors in the AI's analysis?

Your are here

DiceWill, an AI-driven healthcare platform for general practitioners, enters a competitive market. Our analysis reveals that you are in the 'Freemium' category, where users appreciate such tools but hesitate to pay. With 26 similar products already out there, you'll need a strong strategy to differentiate and monetize. While the engagement for such products is medium (avg 4 comments), the lack of positive 'use' or 'buy' signals from our data suggests that you should think carefully about whether or not users want to use your idea or buy it. The good news is that there is also no negative feedback. The numerous comparable offerings indicate that while the need is validated, user acquisition and retention will depend on how effectively you address specific pain points, build trust, and create compelling value.

Recommendations

  1. Given the 'Freemium' category, focus initially on providing immense value for free. Identify the core features that solve the most pressing problems for general practitioners, and make those readily available. This will encourage adoption and build a user base. Based on the summary of discussions from similar products, lack of information, unclear sign-up processes and lack of trustworthiness will lead to almost certain failure. Therefore, put special attention to these details.
  2. Concentrate on building trust and addressing concerns around AI in healthcare. Transparency is key. Clearly articulate how DiceWill's AI works, what data it uses, and how it ensures patient privacy and data security. Address HIPAA compliance and other regulatory concerns upfront, demonstrating a commitment to ethical and responsible AI implementation. Consider including short demo videos and testimonials from physicians who have successfully used the platform.
  3. Identify the users who derive the most value from the free version of DiceWill. Analyze their usage patterns to determine which features are most popular and beneficial. Use this information to refine the platform and tailor premium features that cater to their specific needs. For example, if the women's health module is popular, create a premium version with personalized treatment plans and one-on-one support.
  4. Develop premium features that offer significant advantages over the free version. These could include advanced analytics, personalized consulting with specialists, priority support, or team collaboration tools. Focus on features that demonstrably improve efficiency, reduce workload, and enhance patient outcomes. Given the criticism of similar products lacking actionable insights, ensure your premium features offer clear and direct benefits that justify the upgrade.
  5. Explore team-based pricing models, as charging entire practices may be more effective than individual subscriptions. Pitch DiceWill as a solution that benefits the entire team, streamlining workflows and improving communication. This can make the platform more attractive to larger organizations and increase revenue potential. Instead of charging individual doctors, try charging whole practices in a tiered fashion.
  6. Gather user feedback continuously and iterate on the platform. Based on the criticism of similar products, ask for ongoing feedback about slow feedback, incorrect information or readability issues (e.g. contrast issues with font colors). Actively solicit feedback from users on their experiences, pain points, and feature requests. Use this feedback to improve the platform, address concerns, and ensure that DiceWill remains relevant and valuable to its users.
  7. Given the feedback in similar products, it's crucial to clearly differentiate DiceWill from existing solutions. The AI needs to provide insights and actionable insights, not just be a chatbot. Explain explicitly how DiceWill surpasses current apps, such as iOS Health, MyFitnessPal, or Fitbit, by offering more tailored and intelligent health insights. Offer practical benefits that integrate easily into doctor workflows.

Questions

  1. Given the sensitivity around healthcare data and AI, what specific steps will DiceWill take to ensure data privacy and security, and how will you communicate these measures to build trust with both physicians and patients?
  2. Considering the competitive landscape and the challenge of monetizing freemium healthcare tools, what is your strategy for identifying the ideal customer segment who will be willing to pay for premium features, and how will you tailor your marketing efforts to reach them effectively?
  3. How will DiceWill continuously validate and update its AI models to ensure they are providing accurate, evidence-based recommendations, and what mechanisms will be in place to address potential biases or errors in the AI's analysis?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 26
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 4
  • Net use signal: 8.6%
    • Positive use signal: 13.9%
    • Negative use signal: 5.4%
  • Net buy signal: -5.4%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 5.4%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

ChatMedical.ai - AI specialized medical agents & professional tools

Integration of Global Search and Local Care. AI Specialized Medical Agents and Professional Tools. Seamless medical consultations and professional collaborations. Real-time AI assistance tailored to various medical specialties.

ChatMedical.ai's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users praising its potential to revolutionize healthcare through global search, local care, and AI assistance. The AI integration was highlighted for promising seamless medical consultations, improved efficiency, and enhanced accuracy. There's interest in its application in developing countries, and the team's commitment to addressing this issue was noted. One user, however, suggested a potential future lawsuit. Many congratulated the team on the launch and wished them success.


Avatar
75
9
9
75
Relevance

Health AI - Empower Your Health Journey With AI-Driven Insights.

An AI-powered health app that helps users manage medical concerns and overall wellness. It offers personalized insights, health monitoring, self-diagnosis tools, and preventive care recommendations, providing real-time assistance for users' well-being

The launch is congratulated as Health AI products are considered rare and promising. There are questions regarding legal and medical issues, as well as availability in other countries.


Avatar
13
2
50.0%
2
13
50.0%
Relevance

Empirical Health - Proactive primary care that scales using AI

Empirical Health is proactive primary care that scales. Using AI, we triage healthcare resources to efficiently manage chronic illness and succeed in value-based care payment models. Anybody with an Apple Watch can use our app.

Empirical Health's launch on Product Hunt garnered excitement and congratulations from many users. A recurring theme was inquiries about the AI's functionality, proactive issue detection, data handling (especially EMR and transmission to doctors), and integration with devices like Fitbit and Apple Watch. Questions were raised about feature differences compared to other apps, the unique selling proposition, and plans for state expansion and program focus. The quick setup was appreciated. Support was expressed for the team and the initiative.

Users criticize the product for lacking actionable insights for general users, questioning its target audience (specific health conditions). Concerns arise regarding the AI's role, doctor interaction, and whether the app replaces primary care physicians or accepts insurance. Users inquire about Fitbit support, suggesting a missing feature. Questions are also raised about the app's 17+ rating on the app store, and some perceive the launch as self-promotional.


Avatar
97
19
5.3%
19
97
5.3%
Relevance

Doc AI - Your AI-Powered Doctor - Anytime, Anywhere.

DocAI is an AI-powered health assistant providing personalized, reliable medical advice 24/7. Get instant recommendations based on thousands of medical cases. Secure, private, and always available.

DocAI is seen as a helpful AI assistant, providing medical assistance and generally aiding in daily life. Users are optimistic about its potential as a future AI tool.


Avatar
9
2
100.0%
2
9
100.0%
Relevance

Azyri - AI co-pilot for healthcare

AI Co-pilot for Healthcare

The Product Hunt launch received congratulations from multiple users. Feedback on the health app included concerns about slow feedback and incorrect age calculation. Suggestions were made regarding the contrast of the font color on the agree/disagree buttons. Users expressed excitement for the launch and hoped for smoother healthcare experiences. Appreciation was expressed for the use of AI and product execution.

Users reported slow feedback times and inaccurate age calculations. Readability issues were also noted, specifically regarding the agree/disagree buttons needing a more contrasting font color.


Avatar
106
6
16.7%
6
106
16.7%
Relevance

ThincHealth - Transforming the healthcare experience

04 Aug 2023 Health & Fitness

ThincHealth is revolutionising healthcare in Southeast Asia and the Pacific by leveraging technology and AI. Our solutions, including our Telemedicine platform and AI system, provide accessible, personalised, and affordable healthcare for all.

The launch of ThincHealth has been met with congratulations from multiple users. The project is considered promising, particularly for its use of AI in telemedicine. One user suggested improvements, including the addition of a demo video and testimonials to further enhance the platform.

The primary criticism is that the website content is too generic. Users suggest improving the site by adding video content and testimonials to enhance credibility and engagement.


Avatar
80
4
4
80
Relevance

Introducing an AI Health Guidance App for Managing Chronic Conditions.

I’m excited to share that I’m building an AI health guidance app aimed at helping individuals manage chronic conditions and take control of their health. Our goal is to simplify complex medical reports, provide personalized health advice, and offer expert AI tips to help users avoid unnecessary doctor visits.I would love to get your feedback! If you’re interested in exploring how this app can support you or someone you know, please take a moment to check it out. Your insights will be invaluable as we work to make this tool better for everyone facing similar challenges.

Building AI health app for chronic condition management.


Avatar
5
1
1
5
Relevance

Dr. GPT - Your personal AI Doctor & health assistant

Dr. GPT is a specialized AI assistant designed to help users understand and interpret their health concerns and medical reports. It simplifies complex medical language into easily understandable terms, catering to those who need straightforward explanations.

Users appreciate the app's clear, single responses for health queries, finding it better than WebMD and more accurate than Google searches, which often yield alarming results. The tool's ability to provide clear and confident health information is valued, and users are impressed with Dr. GPT's accuracy. AI integrations in healthcare are seen as a welcome and cool development, with users expressing hope for further improvement.

Users expressed a desire for improved accuracy in future responses, highlighting concerns about the unreliability and potentially alarming nature of health-related search results from Google. The need for more dependable information was emphasized.


Avatar
77
6
66.7%
6
77
66.7%
Relevance

Miko – an alternative to googling healthcare queries

This is a personal experiment that uses AI to respond to healthcare queries. I was fed up of googling symptoms which provided no concrete advice. The only alternative was to fork out for a doctor's appointment that would last a few minutes.So I built a little tool that will hopefully augment people's interactions with their health. I have no interest in replacing the hospital or the need for a doctor.Miko is not flawless but it is a free, instant alternative to expensive healthcare. My hope is that users would try the advice Miko gives them but also visit their doctor if their symptoms persisted.Previously I built a one-stop shop for healthcare which sold services at discounted prices but it is just an interesting side project. I have investigated ways of incorporating GPT and other models into healthcare since last year. I used bubble.io for the web app because of its convenience.

Users expressed skepticism about the need for the product over existing solutions like chatGPT or search engines, and concerns about trust, including the lack of a demonstration of trustworthiness and questions about HIPAA compliance. The sign-up process was criticized for being unclear and requiring account creation before trying the service. There was also a call for expert help and caution when following the advice provided.

Users criticized the Show HN submission for an unclear sign-up process, lack of information, and the necessity of creating an account first. There were suggestions that it needs expert input to scale beyond a side project. Some users prefer using ChatGPT directly, questioning the product's necessity. Criticisms also included receiving contradictory advice, not fitting the 'Show HN' format, and a lack of demonstrated trustworthiness.


Avatar
14
9
-33.3%
-44.4%
9
14
11.1%
Relevance

miicube - conversational ai in healthcare

16 Oct 2024 Health & Fitness

he opposite side of this is conversational AI in healthcare, where a system that applies AI-driven natural language interactions can communicate with users. It answers users' health-related questions, reminds medication,

Conversational AI in healthcare provides support and companionship, especially for elders.


Avatar
4
1
1
4
Relevance

AI for researching personal health issues

I have some chronic medical conditions, and spend a lot of time asking about different drugs and supplements. Wanted to create a resource that others might get value from. It's trained to always provide citations, and to urge people to see their doctor before making major decisions. Open for feedback.

Users raised concerns about privacy policy gaps and extensive rights granted by terms. A simple prompt was found to bypass safeguards, exposing the API key. Suggestions included a preliminary check for medical requests and creating a custom GPT to avoid hacks. The service worked well but had issues with mixed languages. Questions were asked about the model, training, and weight availability. The service was praised for clear instructions and accuracy but faced demands for open-sourcing. It uses OpenAI models and APIs, with some modifications to ChatGPT.

Users criticized the Show HN product for inadequate privacy policies and data security, with specific concerns about the lack of safeguards and the risks of uploading medical information. The absence of a medical request filter and inability to respond to inappropriate queries were also noted. Additionally, users found the mixed languages on the landing page confusing and some advised open-sourcing the service. There was also a mention that people might not be forthcoming in admitting issues.


Avatar
38
12
-25.0%
-25.0%
12
38
Relevance

PMcardio - Revolutionizing cardiovascular care with AI

PMcardio is an AI-powered medical device empowering healthcare professionals to interpret ECGs accurately in seconds and confidently diagnose and treat 38 cardiovascular diseases. The app integrates human expertise with cutting-edge AI technology.

PMcardio is an AI-powered app designed to assist physicians and emergency responders in quickly and accurately diagnosing cardiovascular conditions via ECG analysis. Users are impressed with its ability to digitize ECGs, provide cardiologist-level interpretations, and offer treatment recommendations. The app is praised for its user-friendliness, potential for improving patient outcomes, and cost-effectiveness. Many see it as a game-changer for healthcare, particularly in ECG diagnosis and treatment, with some surprised such a solution didn't exist previously. The integration of AI with human expertise is viewed as a crucial innovation.


Avatar
119
20
25.0%
20
119
25.0%
Top