Your are here

Your idea for a dangerous areas app for travelers falls into a crowded space, as indicated by the existence of 4 similar products. This puts you in the 'Swamp' category, meaning the market has seen similar solutions that haven't really taken off. With low engagement around these existing apps (average of 3 comments), it suggests that users aren't finding them particularly compelling or that they haven't reached wide adoption. While there's clearly a need for safety information while traveling, the key will be to offer something significantly different from what's already available to avoid the same fate as those before you. Be cautious moving forward with this idea.

Recommendations

1. Begin by deeply researching why existing safety apps haven't resonated with travelers. Analyze user reviews, identify gaps in their offerings, and understand why users might be hesitant to rely on them. For example, LocationChecker's users asked for more objective location scoring using crime data, this could be a good start. This research will be pivotal in shaping your app's unique value proposition.
2. Instead of targeting all travelers, focus on a specific niche. Consider solo female travelers, adventure travelers going off the beaten path, or families with young children. Tailoring the app's features and content to a specific group will make it more relevant and appealing to them. This focus allows you to create a more targeted GTM strategy and messaging, something that the existing apps don't seem to have.
3. Explore the possibility of partnering with existing travel providers, such as tour operators, hotels, or travel insurance companies. Offer them a white-labeled version of your app or integrate your safety data into their existing platforms. The Scene app launch received a question about potential partnerships with colleges/universities. This approach allows you to leverage their existing customer base and distribution channels.
4. Instead of focusing solely on dangerous areas, broaden your scope to include other aspects of travel safety, such as health advisories, local scams, or emergency contact information. Position your app as a comprehensive travel safety companion rather than just a crime map. Make sure to be transparent regarding data sources, coverage areas, and data visualization methods as this was brought up as a criticism of LocationChecker.
5. Given the challenges in this specific area, step back and analyze if there are adjacent problems that might be more promising. Could you, for example, build an app to help travelers prepare for trips in risky environments with safety guidelines and checklists? Or perhaps something focused on emergency communication and evacuation plans? Sometimes, pivoting slightly can make all the difference.
6. Carefully analyze similar apps like LocationChecker, Scene, and Tourist Guards. Note their strengths and weaknesses, especially based on user feedback. LocationChecker's users asked for more objective location scoring using crime data. Can you incorporate this or similar feedback into your app to give it a competitive edge?
7. Explore alternative business models beyond direct sales to consumers. Consider partnerships with travel insurance companies, tourism boards, or even providing data to security firms. A B2B approach might find more success initially than trying to convince individual travelers to pay for safety information.

Questions

1. How can you objectively quantify 'danger' in a given area, and how will you ensure the data is up-to-date and reliable across different cities and countries, while avoiding biases?
2. Given that several similar apps exist, what unique and compelling features will your app offer that will make it stand out and attract a dedicated user base in a low engagement market?
3. How will you balance providing safety information with avoiding fear-mongering or negatively impacting local tourism in the areas your app covers?