05 May 2025
Video

Video editing for full and short format videos for all platforms

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

You're entering the video editing space, which is competitive, as evidenced by the 30 similar products we found. This places you in a 'Freemium' category, meaning users appreciate these tools but are hesitant to pay. The average number of comments on similar products is 11, suggesting high engagement, which is good news. However, the absence of net use and net buy signals indicates users aren't explicitly expressing a desire to use or buy these tools, which highlights the challenge of monetization. The positive feedback on similar launches emphasizes ease of use and rich feature sets, especially for beginners. To succeed, you'll need to differentiate and strategically monetize, likely by offering immense value or targeting specific user segments willing to pay.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by deeply understanding which users derive the most value from the free version of your video editing tool. Analyze their usage patterns and identify their specific pain points to determine which features are most beneficial to them. This will allow you to tailor premium offerings more effectively.
  2. Develop premium features that significantly enhance the experience for your most active free users. These could include advanced editing capabilities, access to exclusive templates and effects, higher resolution exports, or priority support. Focus on features that solve tangible problems and provide considerable time savings.
  3. Consider structuring your pricing around team or business use rather than individual users. Many video editing tools are used collaboratively, so offering team-based plans with features like shared workspaces, user roles, and centralized billing can be attractive to organizations. This can tap into a higher willingness to pay.
  4. Offer personalized help, training, or consulting services to users who need additional support. This could involve providing onboarding sessions, custom template creation, or one-on-one editing assistance. Position these services as a way to unlock the full potential of your tool and achieve professional-quality results.
  5. Experiment with different pricing models and approaches on small user groups before implementing them widely. A/B test various price points, subscription tiers, and feature bundles to see what resonates best with your audience. Gather feedback through surveys and user interviews to refine your pricing strategy.
  6. Based on criticisms of similar products, such as the 'Turn clips into masterpieces' tagline being perceived as exaggerated, ensure your marketing claims are realistic and demonstrate genuine value. Focus on clear and concise messaging that accurately reflects the capabilities of your video editing tool.
  7. Address technical issues promptly and maintain high website performance. Some similar products faced criticism for slow upload times and choppy landing pages. Prioritize optimizing your platform for speed and reliability to avoid frustrating users.
  8. Given the need for short video creators, consider focusing on AI-powered features that automate repetitive tasks, but be mindful that users expect AI-driven responses and may be disappointed by manual intervention. Develop features that automatically summarize, create engaging short videos quickly.

Questions

  1. Considering the competitive landscape and the freemium nature of video editing tools, what unique value proposition will differentiate your product from competitors and justify a paid subscription?
  2. How will you identify and target specific user segments (e.g., businesses, marketers, educators) who are more likely to pay for premium video editing features or team-based plans?
  3. What strategies will you employ to convert free users into paying customers, such as targeted promotions, limited-time offers, or exclusive content?

Your are here

You're entering the video editing space, which is competitive, as evidenced by the 30 similar products we found. This places you in a 'Freemium' category, meaning users appreciate these tools but are hesitant to pay. The average number of comments on similar products is 11, suggesting high engagement, which is good news. However, the absence of net use and net buy signals indicates users aren't explicitly expressing a desire to use or buy these tools, which highlights the challenge of monetization. The positive feedback on similar launches emphasizes ease of use and rich feature sets, especially for beginners. To succeed, you'll need to differentiate and strategically monetize, likely by offering immense value or targeting specific user segments willing to pay.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by deeply understanding which users derive the most value from the free version of your video editing tool. Analyze their usage patterns and identify their specific pain points to determine which features are most beneficial to them. This will allow you to tailor premium offerings more effectively.
  2. Develop premium features that significantly enhance the experience for your most active free users. These could include advanced editing capabilities, access to exclusive templates and effects, higher resolution exports, or priority support. Focus on features that solve tangible problems and provide considerable time savings.
  3. Consider structuring your pricing around team or business use rather than individual users. Many video editing tools are used collaboratively, so offering team-based plans with features like shared workspaces, user roles, and centralized billing can be attractive to organizations. This can tap into a higher willingness to pay.
  4. Offer personalized help, training, or consulting services to users who need additional support. This could involve providing onboarding sessions, custom template creation, or one-on-one editing assistance. Position these services as a way to unlock the full potential of your tool and achieve professional-quality results.
  5. Experiment with different pricing models and approaches on small user groups before implementing them widely. A/B test various price points, subscription tiers, and feature bundles to see what resonates best with your audience. Gather feedback through surveys and user interviews to refine your pricing strategy.
  6. Based on criticisms of similar products, such as the 'Turn clips into masterpieces' tagline being perceived as exaggerated, ensure your marketing claims are realistic and demonstrate genuine value. Focus on clear and concise messaging that accurately reflects the capabilities of your video editing tool.
  7. Address technical issues promptly and maintain high website performance. Some similar products faced criticism for slow upload times and choppy landing pages. Prioritize optimizing your platform for speed and reliability to avoid frustrating users.
  8. Given the need for short video creators, consider focusing on AI-powered features that automate repetitive tasks, but be mindful that users expect AI-driven responses and may be disappointed by manual intervention. Develop features that automatically summarize, create engaging short videos quickly.

Questions

  1. Considering the competitive landscape and the freemium nature of video editing tools, what unique value proposition will differentiate your product from competitors and justify a paid subscription?
  2. How will you identify and target specific user segments (e.g., businesses, marketers, educators) who are more likely to pay for premium video editing features or team-based plans?
  3. What strategies will you employ to convert free users into paying customers, such as targeted promotions, limited-time offers, or exclusive content?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 30
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 11
  • Net use signal: 23.1%
    • Positive use signal: 26.4%
    • Negative use signal: 3.4%
  • Net buy signal: -2.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.8%
    • Negative buy signal: 2.9%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Edit Videos Online - Effortless video editing - turn clips into masterpieces

08 Apr 2023 Design Tools Video

Our free online video editor empowers creators with intuitive tools for seamless editing & storytelling. Effortlessly merge, trim, add effects & text to videos, with no watermarks.

The video editing tool launch received positive feedback, with users praising its accessibility, convenience, impressive features, and ease of use. Many congratulated the creator and expressed intentions to try the tool, appreciating the hard work behind it. One user found the marketing claim "Turn clips into masterpieces" to be exaggerated. Overall, the sentiment is encouraging and positive.

The primary criticism revolves around the tagline "Turn clips into masterpieces," which was perceived as exaggerated or ridiculous.


Avatar
109
8
50.0%
8
109
50.0%
Relevance

Free Video editing tools - Compress, cut, join, resize and add subs

04 Jun 2024 GitHub Video

Compress, cut, join, resize and add subs

Ankur's free video editing tool launch on Product Hunt received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users praised its ease of use, effectiveness, and rich feature set, particularly highlighting its value for beginners. Many congratulated the team on the launch and the tool's usefulness in simplifying video creation. Several users are planning to test the tool with their editing teams, and free access was a repeatedly emphasized benefit.


Avatar
66
14
35.7%
14
66
35.7%
Relevance

Simple Video Tools - Free video editing, no registration, no watermarks

Simplify video editing with 16 completely free, user-friendly tools by Videobolt. Seconds to complete tasks like compressing, cutting, cropping, and more. No registration. No watermarks.

Videobolt's Simple Video Tools launch on Product Hunt received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its user-friendly interface, simplicity, speed, and lack of watermarks or registration requirements. Many are excited to switch from alternatives like Canva and are eager to try the free tools for quick and easy video editing. Several users highlighted its potential for marketers and beginners, with some expressing intent to use it for various purposes, including content creation, job ad promotion, and business development. A few users offered suggestions for improvement, such as adding specific features or optimizing the website domain and icon.

Users express concerns about Veed's tool discoverability and lack of advanced features compared to professional video editors. Several users suggest improvements, including screen recording, horizontal-to-vertical video conversion, integrations, tutorials, and interactive onboarding. There are questions about Veed's monetization strategy if it remains completely free, and suggestions for alternative domain names and paywall expectations. Some users also report technical issues, such as a potential bug with the speed-up feature and login problems.


Avatar
601
122
34.4%
2.5%
122
601
34.4%
2.5%
Relevance

VideoFast - Super easy online video editor

VideoFast is the easiest way to create and edit high-quality videos. It works by allowing you to choose from a list of beautifully crafted text, media, and shape animations and customizing them into how you want your video to be.

VideoFast is lauded for its ease of use, especially for beginners and busy creators, with many praising its simple interface and time-saving premade animations. Users appreciate the tool's functionality for quick edits, social media content creation, and the ability to add text, audio, and customize animations. Several users congratulated Rexan on the launch, expressing excitement about VideoFast's potential and offering support. Suggestions for improvement include website performance enhancements, more templates, and future support for features like 4K video export and more customization options.

Users criticized the product launch for lacking sufficient examples and templates. Website performance issues, specifically object-fit and navigation problems, were noted, alongside concerns about slow upload times for large video files. Several users reported choppy landing page experiences, stretched images, and incomplete account pages. There were questions regarding its capabilities compared to competitors and requests for advanced features. Some users expressed doubt about VideoFast's power for complex projects.


Avatar
491
60
38.3%
60
491
38.3%
Relevance

I built a super easy to use online video editor in high school

08 Jul 2024 Education

Hey HN,I'm a 16-year-old in high school from Hong Kong. Often, I find myself having to edit videos, whether it may be for school assignments or creating content for the stuff I'm building.However, I've come to the realization that video editing and creating high-quality videos is really difficult and tedious.For beginners, it takes hours to learn how to use traditional editing software to edit great videos. There's a huge learning curve. For pros, implementing those high-quality animations for your videos requires a lot of time to create and customize.Personally, for school homework and social media video preparation, I need a tailor-made, powerful enough, but not too overkilled video editor to create videos quickly with high quality. Existing tools such as iMovie, DaVinci Resolve, and Adobe Premiere Pro are great but too heavy-duty.That's why I built VideoFast, an easier alternative to creating and editing videos.1. Pick a beautifully premade animation 2. Customize that animation fully to your needs 3. Repeat - you then have an epic video 4. Export, and voila.I designed and developed this video editor based on my needs, other KOLs', and the needs of professionals that I connected with via social media while building VideoFast in the last couple of months while being a full-time high school student taking AP exams - hope you like VideoFast.Please feel free to give me any feedback - I'm a high schooler and first time building a startup and launching a product, so I still have a lot to learn. Thanks.Rexan


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

I built a simple tool for making short form videos

Hello HN,I recently found myself stuck in a loop, spending hours editing the same type of short-form videos over and over again.Frustrated by the repetition, I decided to take matters into my own hands and automate the process.With ShortScripter, I can now generate captivating short story videos without any effort, saving myself valuable time and frustration.I hope you like it!

Users are reporting an issue with homepage thumbnails appearing as black rectangles. Additionally, there is an inquiry about the type of AI being used in the product.

Users have criticized the product for having unappealing thumbnails, with some specifically mentioning an issue with black thumbnails.


Avatar
4
3
3
4
Relevance

Video Editor AI

Hey HN! These last months I have been working with some LLMs and I was encouraged to launch a video editor. Today I want to introduce you to VideoEditorAI.com, a web tool that allows you to edit and create videos using Text2Video-zero and Django.

Complains about high pricing for individuals and teams.

Pricing is too high.


Avatar
3
1
-100.0%
-100.0%
1
3
Relevance

I have built a tool to automatically Edit Videos

11 May 2024 Video YouTube

Hi, I built a tool in which you upload a raw video it will automatically edit it.It will do things like removing silences, adding zoom at certain portion of the content, automatically adding the titles on the top and adding sound effects.I hate when people without sufficient knowledge gain lots of influence on social platforms because they put lot of content out. While people with knowledge are not able to put content.One of the reason is friction in generating content so I want to tackle the editing part of content generation.Do try it and let me know how you feel. Here is the youtube demo https://www.youtube.com/shorts/hU6fbimeiMs


Avatar
2
2
Relevance

I Made an AI Video Editor

Hi, I made an online video editor with some AI features. For example you can make pretty realistic sounding AI voiceovers or create subtitles automatically. Also you can remove the background of a video without having to use a greenscreen. Let me know what you think about it. I'm always improving it and looking for new feature ideas:)

Couldn't upload videos, unsure of issue.

Couldn't upload videos.


Avatar
3
1
-100.0%
1
3
Relevance

Turn long videos into short videos

26 Oct 2023 Video Social Media

Hey! I've been working with some friends on Bolt Foundry, a tool to help people upload long videos and download short clips to share on social platforms.It's free to use for transcription, and you can preview the clips it generates.

Users find the tool neat and useful for creating YouTube shorts. There are questions about WASM and encoding speed, and some users expected AI to summarize videos automatically. There is also a mention of Opus doing something similar.

Users expected AI-driven responses but were disappointed to find human intervention instead.


Avatar
5
4
4
5
Relevance

Minvo 2.0 - All-in-one AI video shorts platform for podcasts & more

The #1 video shorts editing tool for extracting viral shorts from long videos. Minvo's powerful online video editor and social media integrations make creating video content at scale easy.

Minvo's launch, particularly version 2.0, is widely congratulated as a game-changing tool for short-form video creators. Users praise its ease of use, time-saving capabilities, and professional editing features, especially for creating shorts from long-form content like podcasts. The platform's constant updates, new features, and multilingual support are appreciated. Users highlight its value for microlearning and its convenience for centralized content creation. Some users request features like real-time collaboration, scheduling/analytics, and custom branding options. Many consider it the best product in its category.

Users noted that the shorts sometimes need adjustments to appear perfect. There is anticipation for an editing feature that allows modifications behind characters. Users are also looking forward to the addition of more features and the ability to animate backgrounds.


Avatar
232
31
58.1%
31
232
58.1%
Relevance

Video editor app that generates FFmpeg commands

21 Nov 2024 Photo & Video

Hello Friends, I have built a new video editor app that generates ffmpeg commands to get the edited video. This gives you flexibility to use it in scripts etc. for your video editing workflows and makes editing tasks smooth by letting you visually adjust video elements that are difficult to adjust in commandline.Demo is here- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KSvazNBEfTcLink is here- https://newbeelearn.com/tools/videoeditor/Features are- video, image, text editing- adjustable timeline and layers- adjust position, size , alignment, font size color, borders etc.- quick info of image, video files- preview player to get the idea of edited video with play, pause, seek.Limitations are- Audio files(mp3) are currently not supported though audio inside mp4 will work- player is not frame accurate it just gives u close enough approximation.- file paths are not supported due to browser's security limitations.- I have only tested happy path so there would be many bugs but it should work for simple tasksOthers- Completely free- No registration/login etc.- Works online does not requires any installation- Works offline after first load- Works locally does not requires serverBackground is i generally have one off video tasks and i don't mind using ffmpeg for it but recently i had to create a bunch of product videos and it was difficult to get text etc. right on commandline, i tried kdenlive and openshot as well but couldn't figure out how to something simple like adding a logo and text to it(i guess i am dumb) so i created this new app to suit my workflow

The Show HN product received positive feedback for its audio support, efficient gst pipelines, and powerful ffmpeg integration, with users expressing interest in open sourcing and self-hosting. There's curiosity about a gstreamer equivalent and a desire for a user-friendly GUI for ffmpeg. Some users reported issues with video upload and audio in previews, while others shared their use cases like security cameras, GPS, and VHS digitization. Suggestions include a scene detector for splitting files and optimizing chapter creation. The light mode UI was criticized as non-professional.

Users criticized the app for its increased size (350KB), awkward UX for connections, lack of self-hosting and open-source options, difficulty working with ffmpeg, playback issues post-upload, limited advanced features in Handbrake, audio issues in cut videos and previews, complex gst-launch usage, persistent file format problems, unsuitable scene detector for TV shows, unclear chapter naming process, and a light mode UI that appears unprofessional.


Avatar
147
24
20.8%
24
147
20.8%
Relevance

A video editing SDK that runs in the browser

30 Jul 2024 Developer Tools

Hello HN,Video content is more popular than ever, but the toolkit for creating such content is a bit behind. You usually have to rely on a server for rendering whenever you want to create a video editing project in the browser. This means uploading content to a server, coding complex filters and effects, and more.My friend and I spent a year developing an SDK that handles all these complexities and offers an easy-to-use interface for developers. The SDK works entirely in the browser, manages memory efficiently so it can run even on a 7-year-old Android device, supports GLSL effects and transitions, handles captions, and much more.We also created a custom video editor UI interface using the SDK to showcase its speed and flexibility. You can see the video editor embedded on our landing page: https://rendley.com.As for the tech stack, the SDK was built using TypeScript, Pixi.js, C++, FFmpeg WASM, and WebCodecs. The UI interface was created using Stencil.js and MobX.The SDK is called Rendley SDK and it is live on npm: https://www.npmjs.com/package/@rendley/sdkTo get started, follow this guide: https://docs.rendley.com/installationIf you want to embed the pre-made interface, follow this guide, it’s literally a few lines of code: https://docs.rendley.com/video-editorIf you have any questions about the product or any feedback, feel free to write them below, and I’ll be more than happy to answer them.

Users raised concerns about the product's open source claims, patent issues with mp4, and lack of visible pricing information. Comparisons with similar services like Revideo and Remotion were made, questioning differences in API, rendering, and licensing. Technical issues with ffmpeg wasm, codec support, and file loading were noted. The 'Get in touch' button leading to a 404 page and forced sign-up were criticized. Some users appreciated the service but were deterred by the sales approach and misleading information on the website. There were also requests for transparent pricing and questions about the use of Pixi.js.

Users criticized the product for not being truly open source, misleading claims, and lack of public repositories. Concerns over memory safety, codec errors, and patent issues were noted. The requirement for a license key, forced sign-up, and issues with file compatibility were disliked. Criticisms also focused on the lack of transparent pricing, with many mentioning hidden costs behind email requirements and no fixed pricing. The product's value proposition for non-technical users and small target market were questioned, along with the effectiveness of Show HN/Product Hunt for growth.


Avatar
129
42
-26.2%
-28.6%
42
129
4.8%
Top