Should I Build It Should I Build It
19 Mar 2025
Dating

A dating app that matches users based on their shared values and ...

...ethical beliefs, rather than superficial preferences, fostering more meaningful connections.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

Your idea for a dating app focused on shared values and ethics aims to foster deeper connections, placing it squarely in the 'Freemium' category. This means while the concept resonates with users seeking meaningful relationships (similar products show medium engagement), converting this interest into paying customers is the primary hurdle. We found 10 similar product launches, giving us high confidence in this assessment but also highlighting significant competition in this niche. The data from these launches shows neutral signals regarding user intent to actively use or pay, reinforcing the Freemium challenge. Success hinges on clearly differentiating your app from the crowd and designing a compelling monetization strategy from the outset, proving value beyond free alternatives.

Recommendations

  1. Deeply analyze your early free users: Identify patterns among those who genuinely engage with the values assessment and initiate meaningful conversations. Who finds the most value? These insights are crucial for pinpointing potential paying customers, unlike apps where superficial interaction dominates.
  2. Develop premium features laser-focused on enhanced value-matching: Don't add generic dating perks. Consider offering advanced filters for specific ethical stances, compatibility reports based on nuanced values, or visibility boosts for users with highly completed/verified value profiles. Address the critique of 'limited criteria' seen in competitors like SoulMatcher by going deeper.
  3. Clearly articulate your unique value proposition vs. competitors AND generic AI: You have 10 competitors in this specific niche. Learn from feedback on similar AI-driven apps; explicitly state why your matching algorithm and community provide better results than someone trying prompts in ChatGPT. Highlight what makes your approach to 'values' unique and more effective.
  4. Address safety and authenticity proactively: Competitor discussions (like Happie's) highlight user concerns about safety in online dating. Integrating robust profile verification, potentially linked to confirming stated values or ethical commitments, could be a key differentiator and build trust, potentially justifying a premium.
  5. Design and test monetization experiments early: Given the 'Freemium' nature and lack of strong 'buy' signals for similar launches, don't delay monetization planning. Test modest pricing tiers for specific, high-value features with small user groups. Determine quickly what specific added value users might pay for, even if it's a small segment initially.
  6. Focus initial marketing on differentiation: With high competition, your launch messaging needs to cut through the noise. Emphasize the depth of your value matching and the potential for genuinely meaningful connections, contrasting it with superficial swiping or less focused competitors.

Questions

  1. Specifically, how will your values/ethics assessment methodology differ from existing apps (like SoulMatcher) to ensure it captures genuine depth and avoids simplistic categorization, thus creating truly defensible, meaningful matches?
  2. Considering the Freemium model challenge and high competition (10 similar launches), what single premium feature, directly tied to your core values-matching premise, do you hypothesize will convince a specific user segment to pay consistently, and how will you validate this early?
  3. How will you build and nurture a community around shared values within the app that enhances the user experience beyond just matching, potentially creating network effects and justifying premium tiers (learning from Happie's positive reception to community aspects)?

Your are here

Your idea for a dating app focused on shared values and ethics aims to foster deeper connections, placing it squarely in the 'Freemium' category. This means while the concept resonates with users seeking meaningful relationships (similar products show medium engagement), converting this interest into paying customers is the primary hurdle. We found 10 similar product launches, giving us high confidence in this assessment but also highlighting significant competition in this niche. The data from these launches shows neutral signals regarding user intent to actively use or pay, reinforcing the Freemium challenge. Success hinges on clearly differentiating your app from the crowd and designing a compelling monetization strategy from the outset, proving value beyond free alternatives.

Recommendations

  1. Deeply analyze your early free users: Identify patterns among those who genuinely engage with the values assessment and initiate meaningful conversations. Who finds the most value? These insights are crucial for pinpointing potential paying customers, unlike apps where superficial interaction dominates.
  2. Develop premium features laser-focused on enhanced value-matching: Don't add generic dating perks. Consider offering advanced filters for specific ethical stances, compatibility reports based on nuanced values, or visibility boosts for users with highly completed/verified value profiles. Address the critique of 'limited criteria' seen in competitors like SoulMatcher by going deeper.
  3. Clearly articulate your unique value proposition vs. competitors AND generic AI: You have 10 competitors in this specific niche. Learn from feedback on similar AI-driven apps; explicitly state why your matching algorithm and community provide better results than someone trying prompts in ChatGPT. Highlight what makes your approach to 'values' unique and more effective.
  4. Address safety and authenticity proactively: Competitor discussions (like Happie's) highlight user concerns about safety in online dating. Integrating robust profile verification, potentially linked to confirming stated values or ethical commitments, could be a key differentiator and build trust, potentially justifying a premium.
  5. Design and test monetization experiments early: Given the 'Freemium' nature and lack of strong 'buy' signals for similar launches, don't delay monetization planning. Test modest pricing tiers for specific, high-value features with small user groups. Determine quickly what specific added value users might pay for, even if it's a small segment initially.
  6. Focus initial marketing on differentiation: With high competition, your launch messaging needs to cut through the noise. Emphasize the depth of your value matching and the potential for genuinely meaningful connections, contrasting it with superficial swiping or less focused competitors.

Questions

  1. Specifically, how will your values/ethics assessment methodology differ from existing apps (like SoulMatcher) to ensure it captures genuine depth and avoids simplistic categorization, thus creating truly defensible, meaningful matches?
  2. Considering the Freemium model challenge and high competition (10 similar launches), what single premium feature, directly tied to your core values-matching premise, do you hypothesize will convince a specific user segment to pay consistently, and how will you validate this early?
  3. How will you build and nurture a community around shared values within the app that enhances the user experience beyond just matching, potentially creating network effects and justifying premium tiers (learning from Happie's positive reception to community aspects)?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 10
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 5
  • Net use signal: 4.5%
    • Positive use signal: 6.1%
    • Negative use signal: 1.6%
  • Net buy signal: -0.4%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.2%
    • Negative buy signal: 1.6%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.
Isabella
March 31, 2025, 10:25 p.m.

Values, eh? Sounds like a minefield of arguments waiting to happen. I'll stick to swiping based on looks... less drama that way.

Sarah
March 28, 2025, 10:22 a.m.

Matching on values? Seems tough to do right with AI. I'd be worried about it reinforcing biases or becoming some kind of echo chamber. But hey, if you can pull it off, it'd be way better than swiping based on looks. Good luck making it not creepy!

Similar products

Relevance

An AI-powered swingers dating app

25 Sep 2024 Dating

Hi HN community,I’m excited to share Venus (TakeMeToVenus.com), a project we’ve been working on to foster more meaningful connections within ethical non-monogamy.Why we're building Venus?Non-monogamy is a rich tapestry woven through human history. To put it simply, humans love sex.From the polyamorous practices of ancient indigenous societies to the consensual multi-partner relationships in historical religious sects, loving more than one has always been part of our story.The free love movement of the 1960s reignited this flame, challenging societal norms and celebrating love in all its forms.Fast forward to today, and digital platforms have thrust non-monogamy into the spotlight, making it more visible and accepted than ever before.Yet amid this surge of easy access to others, we’ve lost sight of something essential: meaning.When you’re on Venus, it’s not about more connections, it’s about better connections (and better sex).1. It's an evening social networkVenus operates within a unique framework: it is open only from 7 PM to 11 PM every night.By limiting access to these hours, Venus encourages users to engage more intentionally. Research suggests that time constraints lead to more meaningful engagement. In the complex world of non-monogamous relationships, this focused timeframe helps you prioritize and invest in the connections that matter most.When the clock strikes 7 PM, Venus unveils The Lounge — an open space where all users can connect freely. Share photos, texts, and links with the community in a vibrant, communal atmosphere.2. It's AI for meaningful conversationsAt the heart of successful non-monogamous relationships lies trust and understanding — not just between primary partners but among all connections. Venus leverages cutting-edge AI to enhance these crucial elements.Our AI assistant provides smart profile summaries, offering a sneak peek into the values and fantasies of couples or singles who catch your eye.Venus will even help you choose the best profile photo, ensuring you and your partner give the best first impressions.When you’re ready to send a message, Venus AI offers personalized conversation starters based on user profiles.Venus is world where everyone looks their best, shared desires are openly shared, and conversations are both intellectually stimulating and irresistibly sexy.3. How to join VenusQuality connections thrive in a quality community. Venus operates on an invite-only basis, with each new user receiving three invites.To get an invite code, ask around. Someone you know may already be on Venus. You’ll likely find Venus users on Instagram, Reddit, and at lifestyle events.If you can’t get access to an invite code, you may join our waitlist for future updates here: TakeMeToVenus.com

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

GPT-3-based app for couples to build the relationship consciously

27 Feb 2023 Artificial Intelligence

I'm a developer and I wanted to improve my technical skills while gaining more product knowledge. It's been challenging to do this at work, so I've been exploring ideas for creating a useful app that will also allow me to use a cool tech-stack and recent AI progress. I have spoken to many couples and therapists, and a common theme that came up was communication problems. I dug a bit deeper and realized that these issues could be prevented, if people consciously get to know each other at the initial dating stage.So I have created an app that helps couples establish meaningful communication from the early stages of their relationship. The app gives you a question and an action for your date, then afterwards app sends you a self-reflection question and ask for your feedback on how it went. App also provides an entertaining way to keep a relationship diary. Here are the links to Apple Store (https://apps.apple.com/no/app/nemlys/id1662262055) and Google Play (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.nemlys.app)I've also heard that couples want more personalized questions that adapt to their relationship. So, I have introduced AI-generated questions based on the detailed feedback on how conversations went, their relationship diary within the app, previous questions, relationship goal, their milestones and level of intimacy. With all this context, GPT-3 can create a personalized question about the specific issue you're facing.I want to make the personalization even more precise and require less input from you (because let's be real, not everybody wants to write long diaries).What do you think are the best ways to achieve it? I am thinking about fine-tuning the model on our examples how to ask a personalised question with less context

Users suggest that ChatGPT can function as a date coach with rephrased prompts and recommend clearly explaining the app's benefits on the landing page.

Users question the app's performance compared to ChatGPT and are unclear on the benefits of downloading the app over using ChatGPT.

Avatar
3
2
-50.0%
-50.0%
2
3
Relevance

SoulMatcher: Find the Right People - Match & make the right friends

01 Nov 2023 Android Social Media Dating

SoulMatcher is the free psychological-based dating and social network app that connects users based on their most compatible partner.

SoulMatcher's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising its user-friendly interface, advanced matching capabilities, and focus on connecting souls rather than appearances. Multiple users congratulated the team on their launch. Some expressed curiosity about the matching algorithm. A spelling error ('Daiting' instead of 'Dating') was pointed out on the landing page. One user inquired about the potential addition of more criteria for matching.

The Product Hunt launch received criticism for a spelling error on the landing page ("Daiting" instead of "Dating"). Users also found the matching process limited due to the small number of characteristics used to find a perfect match, making it harder to get ideal results.

Avatar
83
11
9.1%
11
83
9.1%
Relevance

I made a dating app for max authenticity with GPT 4

21 Oct 2024 Dating

Hi HN!I built this one, Vibing: https://vibing.fun/ simply because I really don't like shallow profiles and convos. And I don't think it's people's fault. The current picture-sharing mechanism almost guarantees staged profiles since people only want to share their best part and keep swiping (wanting more).With Vibing, users are now prompted to take videos themselves, powered by GPT in the app to share their daily lives and unfiltered personalities. I feel in this way, people can go beyond the looks and start looking for something deeper and make authentic connections.Just a thought and I built the prototype. Here is a rough demo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1hIYB7BfH90&list=LLIf you are interested, we will have the beta testing in New York and you can join us together!Thanks for reading - would love to hear your feedback!

Users are inquiring about the advertising plans for the product and are also requesting a GitHub link. Additionally, there are compliments about the product.

Avatar
1
2
2
1
Relevance

Happie - A relationship platform for the best of us!

03 Feb 2024 Android Social Networking Tech

Discover Happie: Revolutionizing dating with authentic connections, dynamic interaction, deep bonds, and safety. A refreshing alternative to traditional apps. Join us for meaningful experiences and genuine connections.

Happie's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with numerous congratulations and excitement for its innovative approach to dating. Users lauded the app's concept and expressed hope for meaningful connections. Several comments inquired about safety measures and differentiation from existing dating apps like Tinder. There's enthusiasm for interactive features and the cohort experience for making friends. The app is perceived as a breath of fresh air in the dating world, with some users offering partnerships and expressing a desire to try it out. The launch was described as timely and well-received.

Avatar
250
36
11.1%
2.8%
36
250
11.1%
2.8%
Relevance

Check out our speed blindfold dating app

20 Feb 2023 Dating

Hey HN! We made a blindfold dating web app for fun as a side project, and are looking for some people to become our pilot users. Please visit to check it out:https://www.reveal-app.site/It's a mix of Omegle and Tinder where you go into a call simmilar to Omegle but without video at first, and then you guys can decide to reveal if you find that you like each other's vibes. Feel free to use it or not, some feedback would be much appreciated if you are interested, thanks!

Avatar
2
2
Top