The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback and congratulations. Users expressed excitement, offered well wishes, and complimented the branding. Questions arose about unique aspects, current user numbers, the inspiration behind the product, future plans, and Discord server usage/access, with one user suggesting alternatives to Discord. There was also a question on if bots are leaving comments on some product launches. Some users reported issues with joining, while others expressed support and excitement about the community.

Users criticized the Discord server for lacking clear instructions and guidance. Some suggested alternative platforms like Telegram or a forum for better communication. One user reported difficulty accepting the invite to the Discord server, though it's unclear if this was a widespread issue.

Users expressed strong positive anticipation and support, particularly highlighting Avery's leadership and business acumen as key drivers for Early Stage Founders' (ESF) growth. Avery is highly regarded for providing valuable entrepreneurial guidance through ESF. The Discord community is seen as actively engaging, with users expressing happiness in joining it.

Very useful website

The product is well-received with positive feedback. Users noted the title truncation issue due to overflow hidden, and inquired about monetization plans. It's described as a nice product, and was also mentioned on IndieMakers.io

The primary criticism is that the 'overflow: hidden' CSS property truncates titles, leading to a poor user experience by cutting off potentially important information.

Users appreciate the completion and release of the site. They find the concept interesting but note its similarity to uneed.best. There is a call for more variety in listings beyond indie hackers and an expanded definition of indiehackers.

Users criticized the product for having network effects that limit opportunities for new entrants. Additionally, they felt that the current definition of indiehackers is too narrow, excluding many potential users.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team and expressing excitement about the platform's concept and execution. Users find the platform useful for connecting with indie creators, escaping algorithms, and fostering collaboration. Some users inquired about future features like more categories and search functionality, while one user reported a sign-in issue. The quality of connections was also questioned. The platform is seen as a potential alternative to crowded platforms like IndieHackers.

Users expressed concerns regarding the quality assurance of connections made through the platform. There are also suggestions to enhance the platform by incorporating more categories and improved search functionality. A sign-in issue specifically affecting X accounts was also reported and needs to be resolved.

The Product Hunt launch received congratulations and well wishes for good luck from at least one user. A comment was deleted, which suggests potential moderation or removal of content.

The Indie Hacker Stacks launch is receiving widespread excitement and congratulations, with many users praising it as a game-changer and invaluable resource, particularly for indie hackers and makers. Users find it helpful for discovering projects, showcasing products, finding tech stacks, and saving time. Several users have added their stacks, and praise the platform's UI. Concerns include potential overcrowding, quality control, and the need for more detailed tech stack guides. Some users reported issues adding products and bugs, while others suggested UI improvements, such as removing an unnecessary "OK" button.

Users criticized the Product Hunt launch for several issues. The primary concern revolves around usability, with reports of a button redirecting to the homepage instead of the intended product showcase, an ambiguous "OK" button, and navigation challenges. There are worries about the platform becoming overcrowded, making it difficult to find useful information. Furthermore, users have pointed out missing logos and raised concerns regarding the overall quality control and lack of detailed guides for effective tool use.

The product launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating the creator Pere. Users highlighted the tool's value as a resource for lead generation, especially within the indie game market. Several users expressed excitement to try the product and anticipated using it for future startups. The launch was celebrated, with several comments explicitly congratulating Pere on their work and success.

The Product Hunt launch for Indie Dev Tools is receiving positive feedback. Users are congratulating the creator and highlighting the tool's usefulness for indie developers, particularly for obtaining SEO backlinks. Several users have bookmarked the tool, indicating its perceived value and potential for future use.

The primary concern raised is how to effectively grow the platform and expand its reach to attract a larger audience of indie developers. Addressing this growth strategy is crucial for the platform's success.

The Indie Hackers Wiki launch on Product Hunt received positive feedback, with users praising its open-source and collaborative nature. The curated list of resources, clean interface, and usefulness were also highlighted. Several users congratulated the team on the launch and acknowledged the project's value.

Congrats on launch, added product, ask about adding tools

No way to add tools

Users appreciate the concept of contrasting MVPs and employed engineering. However, there is frustration with the landing page as it does not lead to an actual platform.

Users criticized the product for over-engineering, which they believe stifles creativity. Additionally, they pointed out that there is no actual platform available, just a landing page.

Users express excitement and offer congratulations to Jaisal on the launch, anticipating its usefulness for startups. The website is praised for its helpful tools, curated resources, and great design. Several users specifically appreciate Jaisal's work and mention the potential for Readership.fyi following the success of startups.fyi. Suggestions include a collection of free startup tools and the addition of a tool comparison feature.

The sole criticism suggested is the addition of a tool comparison feature for the website. This enhancement would allow users to evaluate different tools side-by-side, improving the overall utility and user experience of the platform.

Users expressed gratitude for the helpful information, especially for online entrepreneurs. The product is considered a great resource for startup research. There were also congratulations to ThuNhap.online on launching on Product Hunt.

Thanks, help me so much!

Empty category links make app look broken.

App looks broken with empty category links.

Excited about IndieFindr's concept and future development.

The IndiePage launch on Product Hunt received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating Marc and praising the product's simplicity, ease of use, and value for indie makers and startups. Several users highlighted its potential for showcasing projects, validating ideas, and building in public. Some inquired about future plans, differentiation from competitors, and long-term maintenance. The video and design received positive attention. Users also shared their experiences, from securing usernames to building websites quickly. There were suggestions around integrations and improvements.

The Product Hunt launch received criticism regarding its target audience and how it differentiates from existing link-tree platforms. Users requested features like user browsing and social feeds, Paddle integration, and platform categories. There were concerns about the lifetime deal's long-term viability and why a related app wasn't mentioned. Some questioned the lack of a subscription model. Additionally, a bug report about a duplicate key error was submitted, and feedback suggested the original sentence was too vague.

Indie Affiliates launch garnered positive feedback, simplifying affiliate setups and enabling focus on product development. Users find it useful, especially in India, and appreciate its informative nature. Many congratulated the launch, wished success, and expressed interest, noting it solves a problem for programs seeking visibility. Some users suggested improvements like voiceovers for videos and inquired about influencer outreach. One user experienced difficulty finding their listed program after signing up.

Users criticized the launch promo video for being difficult to understand without voice-over narration. There are concerns about the platform's long-term financial sustainability while maintaining affordability. Additionally, users reported confusion regarding the free submission process, specifically the lack of a confirmation message after submission.

Confused about platform's purpose and customer matching.

Unclear platform purpose and customer matching.

Opportunity for paid submission upsell.

Users expressed a mix of positive feedback and constructive criticism. One user loved the product, while another showed interest in similar desktop applications. There were technical issues reported, such as the site being down and a lack of content. Suggestions included adding Domain Authority metrics for backlinks to enhance the product's value, which aligns with users' understanding of SEO importance. Additionally, a user mentioned maintaining a similar list, indicating a potential user base with existing interest in such tools.

Users reported that the site was down and suggested adding Domain Authority metrics for backlinks.

Users praised the site but questioned the incentives for upfront pricing and inquired about building a double-sided marketplace.

Users question the incentives for upfront pricing, suggesting it may not be beneficial or transparent.