Should I Build It Should I Build It
09 Apr 2025
Investing Finance API

Financial data API, which provides stock market data, companies data, ...

...fundamentals data, and various toher financial data

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your idea for a financial data API enters a crowded space, categorized as a 'Swamp' due to the presence of numerous, often mediocre, existing solutions. The high number of similar products (n_matches = 28) confirms significant competition. While engagement is low across these similar products (average of 1 comment), there is a surprisingly strong net buy signal, placing it in the top 5% of products we've analyzed, suggesting that people are interested in this type of product. However, the existence of many competitors suggests that the market may be saturated with subpar solutions and that standing out might be difficult without substantial differentiation and innovation. To succeed, you need to either find a niche group being underserved, offer a radically superior solution, or address an adjacent, more promising problem.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly investigate why existing financial data APIs haven't fully succeeded. Understand their shortcomings in terms of data quality, accessibility, pricing, or specific use cases. This research will inform your strategy for differentiation.
  2. Instead of directly competing with established players, explore serving a niche segment of users with specific data needs. This could be focusing on a particular industry (e.g., renewable energy, ESG investing), a certain type of data (e.g., alternative data, sentiment analysis), or a specific geographic region. The similar product discussions mentioned a need for deeper analytics for market trends which you could focus on.
  3. Before building your own API, consider creating tools or plugins that enhance the functionality of existing financial data providers. This approach lets you test the market and gather user feedback without significant upfront investment. Some users of similar products mentioned the need for integrations.
  4. Given the strong buy signal, prioritize building a freemium version or a free trial that provides substantial value to users. Remove any barriers to entry like requiring credit card details for the free trial as this has been a pain point for similar products. This will help you attract users and demonstrate the value of your API.
  5. Focus on data accuracy and real-time updates. Several competing products face criticisms about data accuracy and handling real-time fluctuations. Emphasize data validation and transparency in your API to build trust with users.
  6. Ensure that your pricing is clear and transparent, with no hidden fees or unclear plugin costs. Users have criticized similar products for unclear pricing models. Offer flexible pricing plans that cater to different user needs and budgets.
  7. Develop a robust marketing and content strategy to highlight the unique value proposition of your API. Showcase your API's capabilities through tutorials, case studies, and sample code. Consider listing your app on relevant AI directories as suggested by users of similar products.
  8. Actively solicit and incorporate user feedback into your API's development. Pay attention to the discussion and criticism on similar products and address those pain points in your solution.
  9. Explore adjacent problems in the financial data space that may be more promising. This could involve developing tools for data visualization, analysis, or integration with other financial applications.

Questions

  1. What specific data accuracy validation processes will you implement to differentiate your API from competitors and address the common concerns about data quality?
  2. How will you ensure your API addresses the specific needs of underserved niche markets within the financial industry, such as ESG investing or alternative data analysis?
  3. Given the strong buy signal but low engagement, how can you leverage a free trial or freemium model to drive more active usage and solidify your value proposition?

Your are here

Your idea for a financial data API enters a crowded space, categorized as a 'Swamp' due to the presence of numerous, often mediocre, existing solutions. The high number of similar products (n_matches = 28) confirms significant competition. While engagement is low across these similar products (average of 1 comment), there is a surprisingly strong net buy signal, placing it in the top 5% of products we've analyzed, suggesting that people are interested in this type of product. However, the existence of many competitors suggests that the market may be saturated with subpar solutions and that standing out might be difficult without substantial differentiation and innovation. To succeed, you need to either find a niche group being underserved, offer a radically superior solution, or address an adjacent, more promising problem.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly investigate why existing financial data APIs haven't fully succeeded. Understand their shortcomings in terms of data quality, accessibility, pricing, or specific use cases. This research will inform your strategy for differentiation.
  2. Instead of directly competing with established players, explore serving a niche segment of users with specific data needs. This could be focusing on a particular industry (e.g., renewable energy, ESG investing), a certain type of data (e.g., alternative data, sentiment analysis), or a specific geographic region. The similar product discussions mentioned a need for deeper analytics for market trends which you could focus on.
  3. Before building your own API, consider creating tools or plugins that enhance the functionality of existing financial data providers. This approach lets you test the market and gather user feedback without significant upfront investment. Some users of similar products mentioned the need for integrations.
  4. Given the strong buy signal, prioritize building a freemium version or a free trial that provides substantial value to users. Remove any barriers to entry like requiring credit card details for the free trial as this has been a pain point for similar products. This will help you attract users and demonstrate the value of your API.
  5. Focus on data accuracy and real-time updates. Several competing products face criticisms about data accuracy and handling real-time fluctuations. Emphasize data validation and transparency in your API to build trust with users.
  6. Ensure that your pricing is clear and transparent, with no hidden fees or unclear plugin costs. Users have criticized similar products for unclear pricing models. Offer flexible pricing plans that cater to different user needs and budgets.
  7. Develop a robust marketing and content strategy to highlight the unique value proposition of your API. Showcase your API's capabilities through tutorials, case studies, and sample code. Consider listing your app on relevant AI directories as suggested by users of similar products.
  8. Actively solicit and incorporate user feedback into your API's development. Pay attention to the discussion and criticism on similar products and address those pain points in your solution.
  9. Explore adjacent problems in the financial data space that may be more promising. This could involve developing tools for data visualization, analysis, or integration with other financial applications.

Questions

  1. What specific data accuracy validation processes will you implement to differentiate your API from competitors and address the common concerns about data quality?
  2. How will you ensure your API addresses the specific needs of underserved niche markets within the financial industry, such as ESG investing or alternative data analysis?
  3. Given the strong buy signal but low engagement, how can you leverage a free trial or freemium model to drive more active usage and solidify your value proposition?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 28
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 1
  • Net use signal: 5.7%
    • Positive use signal: 7.9%
    • Negative use signal: 2.1%
  • Net buy signal: 0.4%
    • Positive buy signal: 2.5%
    • Negative buy signal: 2.1%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

API for Stock Prices, News and Company Financials

03 Jun 2024 Investing

Hi, co-founder of markets.sh here.While building our financial research and company database, we have gathered quite a bit of information on public and private companies.Right now, it has basic data like descriptions, recent prices, financials, news (with summaries and sentiment), and some financial ratios.We have limited the free points for now, but you can write in the support chat or via the contact form, and I'll credit some more.I would appreciate any feedback or feature requests

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

AI Trading Stock Fundamentals Dataset - Free algorithmic trading dataset directly from SEC filings

28 Jun 2023 Fintech Investing API

We needed a clean dataset of historic US company fundamentals data. This is available from SEC filings, parsing them took months of sweat/tears. We've made the parsed data available to anyone interested in exploring algorithmic trading through this simple API.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback regarding the effort invested in data cleaning, which is acknowledged as a challenging task. A suggestion was made to increase visibility by listing the app on AI directories, specifically mentioning wikigpt3.com.

Avatar
71
2
2
71
Relevance

Free Investment Research for Everyone • No Financial Data Paywalls

26 Dec 2023 Fintech Investing

Hey,A toolbox for retail investors. Free forever, 25+ years of financial data on global securities (currently 12k). No need to pay for data access, as others define with.Our toolbox contains fundamental dashboards, portfolios, watchlists, simultanous equity research, corporate focus, macro insights, news articles, earnings, sentiments and many more components. Merged into an all-in-one dashboard.Next year we will bring portfolios, watchlists and up-to-date financial data together into a generative AI, that is exclusively trained on, financial/investing & expert knowledge. What do you think about it?

Looks neat, asks about integration and differentiation.

Questions differentiation from current solutions.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

Finagg – free and nearly unlimited financial data

22 Jan 2024 Data & Analytics Fintech

finagg is a Python package and CLI that enables you to aggregate and update free financial data from a handful of high quality data sources all within your own SQL database.Here're some quick facts about it:- Implements nearly all of the BEA API, FRED API, and SEC EDGAR APIs (all of which have free and nearly unlimited data access)- Only focused on macrodata (no intraday data support)- Provides methods for transforming data from these APIs into normalized features that're readily useable for analysis, strategy development, and AI/ML- The most popular methods include getting historical price earnings ratios, getting historical price earnings ratios normalized across industries, and sorting companies by their industry-normalized price earnings ratios- Python >= 3.10 only (you should upgrade anyways if you haven't ;)I'm looking for feedback on the overall package and CLI designs. Also, I'd appreciate any recommendations for implementing other financial data sources that're free with no daily API limits.Cheers!

Avatar
11
11
Relevance

Finboard – An Affordable Financial Database

08 Apr 2024 Fintech Finance

I've developed a web app that organizes financial statements from SEC.There are similar products on the Internet, but all of them I found just "abstracts" raw information into something.For example, typical website has "Revenue" as a top-line metrics. In reality, that can be "Total Revenue", "Net Sales", "Operating Revenue", and so on. Those website can't cover exceptional values in same reason.I believe serious investors need raw financial statements aggregated because each number reflect the companies' financial performance. Major platforms like Bloomberg does that but too expensive for individuals.That's why I've built "Finboard". You can see the aggregated financial statements like this: https://finboard.net/companies/TSLA/income-statementThe idea also came from "Notion". Notion is a great tool with infinite use cases. I thought it would be great if we can have financial data in a text editor. So I've decided to build Editor & Database platform.Currently the“Card view”is the most powerful feature. You can screen a company lists (such as all US listed companies), and the result can show financial performance and/or stock price chart like this: https://finboard.net/view/sec?view=a037684a58c448a590e3d3ec5...You may also find it useful that Japanese companies’ financial information is also available in English on Finboard.The tech stack is: Next.js with TypeScript on Vercel and MongoDB Atlas.Open to any questions or feedback. Hope you might find it interesting!

Users appreciate the removal of registration and the provided examples. Some suggest offering a free trial without requiring credit card details. The pricing is noted as $5/month with a 66% discount for a limited time.

Users criticized the product for lacking a free trial option without requiring credit card details and for having cheesy marketing.

Avatar
8
3
33.3%
3
8
33.3%
Relevance

Quanty - AI powered market analysis platform with GraphQL API

01 Jun 2024 Artificial Intelligence Fintech API

Quanty is an innovative platform that leverages AI to create a powerful Knowledge Graph for market insights. Track and analyze financial data, including cryptocurrencies and stocks, in real-time. With our GraphQL API, access structured data effortlessly.

Quanty's Product Hunt launch received congratulations from users. Feedback focused on the real-time data accuracy, which was of particular interest. The GraphQL API was highlighted as being super intuitive, with Dawid receiving specific praise for its design.

The primary criticism revolves around the handling of real-time data fluctuations and the accuracy of the data presented. Users are concerned about how the system manages rapidly changing information and ensures the reliability of the data displayed.

Avatar
102
3
3
102
Relevance

Data and Financial Analysis and Forecasting via Natural Language

28 Apr 2023 Artificial Intelligence Fintech Analytics

Hey, We just launched the MVP of OpenOS,a data & financial analysis tool! It tackles common challenges like needing technical skills for querying data, integrating open-source models, and scattered data. With OpenOS, you can:1. Query relational databases & financial info using natural language. 2. Generate reports like MIS & financial statements with a single command. 3. Forecast user growth, cashflow, etc. It's powered by GPT, Tapas, and Prophet. We built it as a project/tool & would love for any of you guys to try it out & provide feedback as we build the product for public launch.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Trove - Real-time AI intelligence for financial transactions

31 Oct 2024 Artificial Intelligence Fintech API

Harness the power of AI for financial transaction analysis with Trove. Our API provides real-time merchant intelligence, helping developers build smarter fintech solutions. Understand spending patterns across different merchants and categories effortlessly.

The launch is receiving positive feedback, with users praising the free API. Questions revolve around the target audience (developers vs. B2D consumers), usage throttling, and specific fintech API examples. One user shared how the API aided a fintech side project, noting issues with transaction descriptors. Best wishes and congratulations were also extended to the team.

Users criticized the product launch for using cryptic descriptors, which resulted in incorrect fraud reports. The ambiguity of the descriptors appears to be the central issue raised.

Avatar
153
6
16.7%
6
153
16.7%
Relevance

Stock Analysis Platform for Value Investors

01 Jul 2024 Fintech Investing

Hey, I've built this website to empower retail investors. In summary, at the moment there are:Worldwide stocks to research; Unlimited financial filings history and visualization (quarter and annual); Qualitative analysis (through AI); Stock quotes; Stock comparisons with integrated filing reader, industry comparison and valuation models; Stock lists (country, sector, city, industry); Stock news, calendars; Custom dashboards; Simple, fast watchlists; Stock screener where you can apply custom criteria through 240 listed key figures and decide wether to use the latest quarter or annual data.; Portfolios, calculating alpha, beta, volatility and the sharpe ratio on a regular base.My biggest goal is to satisfy retail investors with fundamental insights. What tools are you missing? Do you have any ideas or wishes? Thank you.

The comments on the Show HN submission highlight a comprehensive and nicely designed product with useful tools. However, there is a need for more openness. Some comments noted a lack of content or were not available.

Users want the ability to create custom screeners and watchlists without the need to sign up.

Avatar
6
3
3
6
Relevance

SecAnalytica - AI-Powered SEC Filing Analysis

02 Dec 2024 Finance Money Bots

AI-powered SEC filing analyzer that helps you extract insights instantly from financial documents, compare multiple filings, and generate custom reports with visualizations. Perfect for analysts who want to spend less time reading and more time understanding.

Avatar
4
4
Top