21 Apr 2025
SaaS

Subscription management system. Do we already have one or how is the ...

...competition. Can we monetize

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Run Away

Multiple attempts have failed with clear negative feedback. Continuing down this path would likely waste your time and resources when better opportunities exist elsewhere.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.


Your are here

The idea of a subscription management system has been explored by many others, with 27 similar products already launched. This indicates a crowded market, requiring a strong differentiator to stand out. While some users appreciate the convenience of such systems, there are recurring criticisms around cost, the desire for one-time purchase options instead of subscriptions, and the need for seamless automation. The average number of comments across these similar products is 4, signaling medium engagement, so there isn't a huge amount of feedback available, and there are no buy or use signals that we can leverage from other products. Given this landscape and the expressed negative signals of other products in the space, it's important to take a step back and re-evaluate before committing significant resources.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly analyze the negative feedback from existing subscription management tools, focusing on pricing concerns, the preference for one-time purchases, and the need for more automation. Several products were criticized for unclear pricing or being too expensive. Use this to identify potential unmet needs and design a system that addresses these specific pain points.
  2. Instead of directly competing with existing subscription management systems, explore adjacent opportunities. Can you focus on a specific niche (e.g., managing subscriptions for SaaS tools, content creators, or a particular industry)? Specialization can help you differentiate and attract a more targeted user base.
  3. Consider alternative monetization strategies beyond a subscription model. Could you offer a one-time purchase option with limited features or usage? Or could you partner with existing subscription services to offer a bundled solution? Explore revenue streams that align better with user preferences and address the cost concerns highlighted in the competitive analysis.
  4. If you've already started building, assess if the underlying technology can be repurposed for a different problem. Perhaps it could be adapted for managing licenses, tracking usage-based billing, or automating other types of recurring transactions. Focus on leveraging your existing work in a more viable market.
  5. Before proceeding further, interview at least three individuals who have tried similar subscription management products and understand their needs, pain points, and desired features. Get to the bottom of what features are missing for them, and why they are missing, i.e. what were the trade-offs in the original implementation?
  6. Based on the feedback and competitive analysis, identify a critical area for improvement or innovation. Focus on building a minimal viable product (MVP) that addresses this specific need and test it with a small group of users. Iterate based on their feedback before investing in a full-scale launch.

Questions

  1. Given the expressed user preference for one-time purchase options, how can you design a pricing model that balances user expectations with the need for sustainable revenue?
  2. Many users reported a desire for more automation. What specific processes can be automated to significantly improve the user experience and reduce manual input?
  3. Considering the crowded market, what unique value proposition can you offer that differentiates your system from existing solutions and addresses the criticisms raised in the competitive analysis?

Your are here

The idea of a subscription management system has been explored by many others, with 27 similar products already launched. This indicates a crowded market, requiring a strong differentiator to stand out. While some users appreciate the convenience of such systems, there are recurring criticisms around cost, the desire for one-time purchase options instead of subscriptions, and the need for seamless automation. The average number of comments across these similar products is 4, signaling medium engagement, so there isn't a huge amount of feedback available, and there are no buy or use signals that we can leverage from other products. Given this landscape and the expressed negative signals of other products in the space, it's important to take a step back and re-evaluate before committing significant resources.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly analyze the negative feedback from existing subscription management tools, focusing on pricing concerns, the preference for one-time purchases, and the need for more automation. Several products were criticized for unclear pricing or being too expensive. Use this to identify potential unmet needs and design a system that addresses these specific pain points.
  2. Instead of directly competing with existing subscription management systems, explore adjacent opportunities. Can you focus on a specific niche (e.g., managing subscriptions for SaaS tools, content creators, or a particular industry)? Specialization can help you differentiate and attract a more targeted user base.
  3. Consider alternative monetization strategies beyond a subscription model. Could you offer a one-time purchase option with limited features or usage? Or could you partner with existing subscription services to offer a bundled solution? Explore revenue streams that align better with user preferences and address the cost concerns highlighted in the competitive analysis.
  4. If you've already started building, assess if the underlying technology can be repurposed for a different problem. Perhaps it could be adapted for managing licenses, tracking usage-based billing, or automating other types of recurring transactions. Focus on leveraging your existing work in a more viable market.
  5. Before proceeding further, interview at least three individuals who have tried similar subscription management products and understand their needs, pain points, and desired features. Get to the bottom of what features are missing for them, and why they are missing, i.e. what were the trade-offs in the original implementation?
  6. Based on the feedback and competitive analysis, identify a critical area for improvement or innovation. Focus on building a minimal viable product (MVP) that addresses this specific need and test it with a small group of users. Iterate based on their feedback before investing in a full-scale launch.

Questions

  1. Given the expressed user preference for one-time purchase options, how can you design a pricing model that balances user expectations with the need for sustainable revenue?
  2. Many users reported a desire for more automation. What specific processes can be automated to significantly improve the user experience and reduce manual input?
  3. Considering the crowded market, what unique value proposition can you offer that differentiates your system from existing solutions and addresses the criticisms raised in the competitive analysis?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 27
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 4
  • Net use signal: -0.1%
    • Positive use signal: 11.1%
    • Negative use signal: 11.2%
  • Net buy signal: -10.2%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 10.2%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Submate - Subscription management

16 Dec 2024 Finance Money Payments

- Keep track of your recurring subscriptions and payments, ensuring you never miss a due date. - Submate is hosted on a 100% Australian Server to ensure security, reliability, and speed. - Multi-Currency Support - Mobile View - Free to use


Avatar
5
5
Relevance

subs - Put a stop to the subscription chaos

Drowning in subscriptions? Meet Subs! Your all-in-one tool for managing subscriptions. Get push notifications about due dates, keep track of spending, and never be surprised by payments. Subs makes managing your subscriptions as easy as breathing.

Subs is receiving overwhelmingly positive feedback for simplifying subscription management. Users appreciate its ability to track subscriptions and prevent unexpected expenses. Many congratulate Anthony and the team on the launch, calling it a lifesaver and a great project. Suggestions include push notifications, cost-effective alternatives, tracking credits/gift cards, and compiling forgotten subscriptions automatically. One user reported a buggy Android UI leading to uninstall, also requesting common subscriptions. The landing page receives positive feedback for clarity.

Users criticize the lack of cost-effective subscription options and report a buggy, unfinished-feeling Android UI. The current system's reliance on manual input is seen as tedious and inefficient, indicating a need for improved automation and a smoother user experience across platforms.


Avatar
149
17
23.5%
17
149
23.5%
Relevance

subs - Put a stop to the subscription chaos

26 Jun 2023 Fintech Cell Phone Tech

Drowning in subscriptions? Meet Subs! Your all-in-one tool for managing subscriptions. Get push notifications about due dates, keep track of spending, and never be surprised by payments. Subs makes managing your subscriptions as easy as breathing.

The Product Hunt launch received mixed reactions. Some users are excited to try the product and find it helpful, congratulating the makers. However, a recurring concern is the subscription model, with some users preferring a one-time purchase and finding the $10/month price too expensive, even comparing it to Netflix. A one click unsubscribe and warning notification for free trials were requested. Users appreciated the inclusion of expiration dates.

Users expressed disappointment with the subscription model, preferring a one-time purchase option. The cost was perceived as too high, especially when compared to services like Netflix. Managing subscriptions and the lack of clear free trial warnings were also raised as concerns.


Avatar
104
8
25.0%
-25.0%
8
104
37.5%
Relevance

BillaBear – Self-Hosted SaaS Subscription Management and Billing

27 Jun 2023 SaaS

Users criticized the product for not being open-source and having unclear licensing, with the AGPL seen as a 'bait-and-switch.' There's confusion over whether it's standalone or a Stripe front-end, and the documentation has errors. Pricing is unclear, and the subscription model is considered too complex. The lack of webhooks for billing events is a significant omission, and there are concerns about the reliability of 3D Secure payments. The design, including the logo, received negative feedback, and there's a perception of no clear differentiation from competitors.


Avatar
107
40
-17.5%
-15.0%
40
107
2.5%
Relevance

imSubs - Subscriptions, Accounts, Days Manager

24 Jun 2024 Windows Android iOS

imSubs is a powerful all-in-one solution designed to simplify the management of your subscriptions, accounts, days and finances. With its comprehensive set of features, you'll stay organized and in control of your digital life like never before.


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

We’ve Built an All-in-One Subscription Management Toolkit

05 Mar 2023 E-Commerce

Good day HN! This is Ali, the co-founder and CEO of Hengam (https://www.hengam.io). With 3 different apps up and running, Hengam is a Shopify app studio.About one year ago, we launched Subify, a Shopify subscription management app (https://apps.shopify.com/subify-subscriptions). It was a delicate decision from the start, but we took the risk and got into the competition with big companies that already had a reputation in the field.My team started with reviewing the competitors and analyzing the users’ needs and pain points. Since last year, we've come up with new releases every fortnight with features that are custom-tailored to the business' needs and user requests (gathered through Canny). My goal was to make Subify an app that is easy to use, personalized and caring, and inclusively functional. Shopify store owners turn to subscriptions in search for recurring revenue, predictive MRR, and an increased LTV. Each of them has their own exact interpretation of how a subscription system should work, including specific billing plans. My intention was to make Subify the go-to solution for all these scenarios, and ever since, my team and I have been working towards that end.In the past few months, my team has worked really hard on making our dunning/billing management as easy as it can get.(1) We started with adding the prepay option to the app’s settings. Subscription customers are not normally looking for a prepay button, but this can change a lot if you offer a discount, only for the prepay plan. So I had my team work on the combination of the tools that could make this scenario work, plus the UX design that could make it easy to understand.(2) Next, was the discount itself. My experience with studying the subscription brands has taught me that succeeding in the subscription industry is mainly bound to keeping the customers interested in making repeated purchases with your brands. Discounts make that possible. So in addition to a discount percentage that could be applied to a set of products, assigned to a certain rule, my team has added the manual discount feature which will allow customers to insert the exact amount of money they’d like to decrease from the original price.(3) Our next project was to create a dashboard that would be able to cover multiple aspects of a brand's relationship with its customers. Cancellation is an always present risk of launching a subscription business, and it was my job to give my merchants some control over that. So through the app panel, we added the option to choose about the cancellation limits. Now, whether subscribers could cancel their subscription after one successful payment, after 100, or at any time, remains up to the store owner.(4) The other feature’s idea came from our own users. For many reasons (inventory, restock, or even marketing), brands may be open to receiving subscription orders– up to a limit. After a few weeks, the developers at Subify were able to add the expiration date feature to the panel to be changed according to the user’s preferences. I wanted to cut out all the trouble and make the customers design come true, so as simple as it sounds, this turned out to be exactly how it works: Merchants create a subscription rule, add the subscription products, set an expiration date (e.g. after 10 successful payments), and then, it’s all automatically handled.What I love about the subscription industry? It never fails to surprise. As the days go by, Shopify brands are discovering more ways to benefit from subscriptions. I’d like myself to join this flow as well. As you can see, working on new features and tools will be our never-ending job. This was just a small sample and I hope you’ve enjoyed reading about it. We're eager to receive comments and advice about our process or anything you'd suggest for the future; don't be afraid to voice your opinion!


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Subscription Vault - It's application to monitor and manage your subscriptions.

There are two great options here: to make it as easy as possible to add subscriptions and find them in the app store. It supports over a hundred different currencies, extensive customization options and no annoying notifications.

Subscription Vault aims to help users manage subscriptions, payments, and spending. The product has received positive feedback, with users congratulating the team on the launch and praising the product. Support was requested from the community, and the launch was upvoted.


Avatar
24
5
5
24
Relevance

Subscription & Invoices Management - Easily manage your subscriptions and invoices in Notion.

Keep your finances organized with the Subscription & Invoices Management template for Notion. Track all your subscriptions and invoices in one simple, customizable space.

Users are excited about the Subscription & Invoices Management template. They find it clean, customizable, and useful for budget and subscription management.


Avatar
6
2
100.0%
2
6
100.0%
Relevance

Patreon and Stan.store Alternative

11 Aug 2024 Marketing

Subscription tiers, donations, digital products etc; an all-in-one suite of features with many integrations.I am building https://subjoin.me and working towards an affordable blend of those two platforms.Soon to come: email marketing flows, analytics.What kind of platforms have you used before? Any features you'd like to see in current mainstream content monetization platforms?

Offers help and requests feedback.


Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

I built a membership page builder in 9 days – new personal best

03 Jun 2024 Website Builder

Do you want to monetize a private group/ channel/ community?Use Subjoin to create a personal membership page in minutes.It's easy to use and free to try out. No need to integrate Stripe if membership is free.- - - -I have never built something this fast, what a thrill!I saw there was no easy way to create a simple subscription page. Big platforms are confusing and expensive for simple needs.- - - -What are you building?Would love to connect with like-minded people on X: @tjmakingof

Simple setup, uses Stripe, one-click install on Digital Ocean.


Avatar
5
1
1
5
Relevance

CreateHQ - Monetize your content by creating your HQ today

CreateHQ is a social subscription platform operated by CreateHQ L.L.C. This platform serves as both a social and networking environment for content creators to run a subscription based service by monetizing their creative content.

The launch of CreateHQ 3.0 is receiving positive feedback, with congratulations to Brian. Users find the product helpful for content creators and are looking forward to its growth and its empowering features for content creation.


Avatar
80
3
33.3%
3
80
33.3%
Relevance

I built an easy straightfoward email monetization tool

I built MailShare to solve a problem I encountered while trying to monetize my own email list: existing solutions were either too complex or i had to setup my email sending provider completely from scratch again.What MailShare does:Provides a simple way to set up paid subscriptions for your email content Integrates with Stripe for secure payments Offers a free tier with a fee and a $89/month premium tier with only Stripe fees Automates welcome emails and subscriber managementKey features:One-click audience setup Customizable payment links Automated subscriber management Basic analytics dashboardI'm particularly interested in feedback on:The pricing model (free with 20% fee vs $89/month flat fee) Essential features for email monetization that I might be missing Potential integrations that would make MailShare more usefulAs a solo founder, I'm excited to share this with the HN community and eager to hear your thoughts, criticisms, and suggestions. I'm here to answer any questions and discuss the challenges of building a product in the email monetization space.


Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Title not found - Subtitle not found

18 Sep 2024 E-Commerce Payments Tech

Easy Subscriptions is a Shopify subscriptions app that simplifies recurring payments. It lets you offer flexible plans with seamless billing, boosting customer loyalty and sales. Perfect for food or beauty businesses looking to add subscriptions effortlessly!

Users find the Easy Subscription app user-friendly and effective for managing recurring payments. A key suggestion is to add custom trial periods, particularly beneficial for new subscription stores. The app is recognized as a solid subscription management solution, offering customizable plans and customer notifications.


Avatar
6
3
3
6
Relevance

I made a tool to ditch paying $20/month LLM subscriptions

13 Mar 2024 SaaS

Users appreciate the logical progression of composing models in node flow and find the idea of managing unused subscriptions cool. However, concerns are raised about the requirement of a Google account, limitation to American English, and lack of clarity on privacy and security of data. A prospective customer is seeking a more detailed explanation at the credit level, and there is dissatisfaction with the current UI interface layout.

Users criticized the UI for feeling raw and having an unsatisfactory layout, particularly noting inadequate zooming and panning features. There were complaints about the lack of value for the cost of ChatGPT Plus, leading to cancellations. Users also expressed a need for a standard/international English option and raised concerns over the absence of information on privacy and security. Additionally, there were mentions of unused subscriptions.


Avatar
7
6
6
7
Relevance

I built a SaaS to grow sales with "credits" instead of subs

23 May 2024 SaaS

Hi HN,While developing another app, I realized users really hate our beloved subscriptions. And one-time payments for micro-features? Super inefficient thanks to fixed costs.I thought, why not a 'credits' system instead? So, I created CreditCharge.Me, making it easy for other creators to solve this problems and set up the same model for their users.- No subscriptions - Less fixed fee pain on microtransactions - Free credits for content users actually want, not bulk trial - No user auth - No code - Lower churn rate.I use Stripe API for bulk credit recharges, GCP for cloud magic, and NextJS plus TailwindCSS for the UI.

Created credits-based payment alternative for apps.


Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

Subscription-based front end development

28 May 2023 SaaS

Seeing lots of design subscription services as well as webflow development but not much in custom software development.Come from a software agency business and building a subscription-based frontend development as it seemingly possible to productize as opposed to product or backend development.Here is the website: https://www.supergile.com/Would you use something like this for your startup/company? What do you think about the pricing?

Users are questioning the value of the service compared to traditional contract work or hiring. They note that contract work offers flexibility but emphasize the need for interviews to ensure quality.

Users criticize the high cost of the service and the lack of tests or quality assurance until the $12k plan. Additionally, there is a perceived lack of commitment from the service provider.


Avatar
1
2
-100.0%
-100.0%
2
1
Relevance

SaaS Development Team as Monthly Subscription

13 Nov 2023 SaaS

Users noted the absence of work samples, team information, and proper attribution on the showcased product or service. There were specific concerns about the lack of attribution links for illustrations and questions regarding attribution on non-Notion or Popsy sites. The product or service appears to be associated with an Indian development hub. Users suggested clearer language, particularly questioning the term 'active request' and suggesting 'Request' is too ambiguous. One comment found the spread of DesignJoy's philosophy interesting.

Users criticized the lack of work samples and detailed team information, with multiple mentions of missing team info. There's confusion about the attribution policy and unclear terminology, specifically the term 'Request'. Additionally, the product or service presents a new way to sell services, which may not be a criticism but a point of interest or concern.


Avatar
10
9
-11.1%
-11.1%
9
10
Top