Should I Build It Should I Build It
30 May 2025
Marketing

PixPost: Last-Mile Out Of Home Delivery network in Canada Core ...

...Mission: “Deliver better, faster, and cheaper — by obsessing over customers, slashing costs, and treating carriers, merchants, and locker partners like family.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

The last-mile delivery space is crowded, with numerous companies attempting to optimize delivery networks and reduce costs. Your idea, PixPost, aims to achieve this in Canada through customer obsession, cost reduction, and a focus on carrier/partner relationships. However, the 'Swamp' category suggests that many similar solutions have struggled to differentiate themselves, and with 19 similar products already out there, the competition is significant. While there isn't explicit negative feedback on similar products (net use and buy signals are neutral), this could also imply a lack of strong positive sentiment or engagement. The average number of comments for similar products is also low, indicating that standing out and attracting users will be challenging. You'll need a significantly differentiated value proposition to thrive in this competitive landscape.

Recommendations

  1. Deeply analyze the failures of existing last-mile delivery solutions in Canada. Understand why they haven't resonated with users or achieved sustainable profitability. Focus on identifying specific pain points that PixPost can uniquely address. For instance, many users in similar "Uber clone for deliveries" solutions are turned off by perceived astroturfing, suggesting a lack of authenticity in the product's promotion, so you should think about how to create an authentic brand voice from day one.
  2. Instead of targeting the entire Canadian market, identify a niche or underserved segment. This could be a specific type of product (e.g., perishable goods, oversized items), a geographic area with limited delivery options, or a demographic group with unique needs. Specializing can help you build a strong reputation and avoid direct competition with larger players.
  3. Before building your own delivery network, explore partnering with existing logistics providers or couriers. Offer them tools or services that enhance their operations, such as route optimization software, real-time tracking systems, or a centralized platform for managing deliveries. This approach could be more capital-efficient and allow you to validate your core assumptions before investing in infrastructure.
  4. Given the challenges in last-mile delivery, consider whether there are adjacent problems that might be more promising. For example, could you focus on developing technology for warehouse management, inventory optimization, or supply chain visibility? These areas may offer greater opportunities for innovation and differentiation.
  5. Carefully assess the market dynamics and competitive landscape before committing significant resources to PixPost. The 'Swamp' category suggests that the odds are stacked against you, and it may be wise to explore alternative opportunities with greater potential for success. Maybe focus on building tools for existing providers, as recommended by the idea category description.
  6. Develop a laser focus on cost reduction. Given that the Ireland post service does package pick up for free, ask yourself, what innovations can you create to reduce the costs of last mile delivery? And create a competitive advantage that will allow you to compete with the incumbents?

Questions

  1. What specific, unmet needs of Canadian merchants, carriers, and consumers will PixPost address that existing last-mile delivery solutions are failing to meet?
  2. What are the key assumptions underlying PixPost's business model, and how will you validate these assumptions quickly and cost-effectively before investing in a full-scale launch?
  3. How will PixPost differentiate itself from competitors in terms of service quality, pricing, and technology, and how will you measure and track these differentiators over time?

Your are here

The last-mile delivery space is crowded, with numerous companies attempting to optimize delivery networks and reduce costs. Your idea, PixPost, aims to achieve this in Canada through customer obsession, cost reduction, and a focus on carrier/partner relationships. However, the 'Swamp' category suggests that many similar solutions have struggled to differentiate themselves, and with 19 similar products already out there, the competition is significant. While there isn't explicit negative feedback on similar products (net use and buy signals are neutral), this could also imply a lack of strong positive sentiment or engagement. The average number of comments for similar products is also low, indicating that standing out and attracting users will be challenging. You'll need a significantly differentiated value proposition to thrive in this competitive landscape.

Recommendations

  1. Deeply analyze the failures of existing last-mile delivery solutions in Canada. Understand why they haven't resonated with users or achieved sustainable profitability. Focus on identifying specific pain points that PixPost can uniquely address. For instance, many users in similar "Uber clone for deliveries" solutions are turned off by perceived astroturfing, suggesting a lack of authenticity in the product's promotion, so you should think about how to create an authentic brand voice from day one.
  2. Instead of targeting the entire Canadian market, identify a niche or underserved segment. This could be a specific type of product (e.g., perishable goods, oversized items), a geographic area with limited delivery options, or a demographic group with unique needs. Specializing can help you build a strong reputation and avoid direct competition with larger players.
  3. Before building your own delivery network, explore partnering with existing logistics providers or couriers. Offer them tools or services that enhance their operations, such as route optimization software, real-time tracking systems, or a centralized platform for managing deliveries. This approach could be more capital-efficient and allow you to validate your core assumptions before investing in infrastructure.
  4. Given the challenges in last-mile delivery, consider whether there are adjacent problems that might be more promising. For example, could you focus on developing technology for warehouse management, inventory optimization, or supply chain visibility? These areas may offer greater opportunities for innovation and differentiation.
  5. Carefully assess the market dynamics and competitive landscape before committing significant resources to PixPost. The 'Swamp' category suggests that the odds are stacked against you, and it may be wise to explore alternative opportunities with greater potential for success. Maybe focus on building tools for existing providers, as recommended by the idea category description.
  6. Develop a laser focus on cost reduction. Given that the Ireland post service does package pick up for free, ask yourself, what innovations can you create to reduce the costs of last mile delivery? And create a competitive advantage that will allow you to compete with the incumbents?

Questions

  1. What specific, unmet needs of Canadian merchants, carriers, and consumers will PixPost address that existing last-mile delivery solutions are failing to meet?
  2. What are the key assumptions underlying PixPost's business model, and how will you validate these assumptions quickly and cost-effectively before investing in a full-scale launch?
  3. How will PixPost differentiate itself from competitors in terms of service quality, pricing, and technology, and how will you measure and track these differentiators over time?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 19
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: -3.4%
    • Positive use signal: 5.7%
    • Negative use signal: 9.2%
  • Net buy signal: -6.9%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.1%
    • Negative buy signal: 8.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Mailjour - Open and Fair Deliveries for Everyone

22 Aug 2024 SaaS Android Delivery

Mailjour provides an ecosystem where parcel and delivery service providers, from independent to business, can connect with their customers and manage their deliveries, with the freedom to decide their own terms and conditions from pick-up to delivery.

Users are interested in the claimed 45% reduction in delivery costs. Positive feedback highlights great tech support and suggests the service is trustworthy when delivery conditions are agreed upon.

Avatar
9
2
50.0%
2
9
50.0%
Relevance

Boxpend a Delivery Management Tool

19 Jun 2023 SaaS Delivery

Hi everyone,For a while now, we've been working on a product called Boxpend. It's a tool that allows agencies and delivery people to connect and track orders in real time. We created Boxpend in response to the pain that delivery people experience when managing and tracking orders.Boxpend solves this problem by providing a centralized platform where agencies and delivery people can collaborate on orders.We're excited to share Boxpend with the world and help make the delivery process easier for everyone involved. If you're interested in learning more, please visit our website or contact us.Thanks, The Boxpend team

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Cargoffer - Round Trip Bussiness - MarketPlace Ground Logistics

05 Jul 2024 Delivery Transportation Tech

Cargoffer, a groundbreaking online platform poised to redefine the way customers and transport companies engage in the negotiation, arrangement, and monitoring of deliveries. Often referred to as the "Uber for trucks," Cargoffer emerges as a game-changer

Cargoffer: comprehensive logistics solution with agility, fair prices, total control.

Avatar
5
1
100.0%
100.0%
1
5
100.0%
100.0%
Relevance

GoRoutes - carpool & delivery

19 Jul 2024 Android User Experience Ridesharing

GoRoutes is a platform that combines carpooling arrangements and courier services to streamline parcel delivery and promote shared commuting. Users can organize shared rides by creating or joining carpooling groups, post items for delivery.

Avatar
5
5
Relevance

I've updated my food delivery repo. Feedback Welcome

08 Jan 2024 Delivery Developer Tools

Hey everyone! Over the past few years, I've dedicated my time to crafting a customizable solution for food delivery management. Now, I'm excited to showcase the culmination of all my work. Throughout the development journey, I've successfully incorporated all the planned features and even expanded upon them based on valuable feedback from the community.My methodology has consistently involved seeking input from platforms like Reddit and forums, where I engage with like-minded individuals. Some of the recent enhancements stem directly from this collaborative feedback, and I'm eager to gather more insights on the latest update to the project.Designed with a focus on individuals or businesses looking to start their own food delivery services, this solution simplifies the process of adding vendors, managing food items, coordinating deliveries, and overseeing riders. Beyond these core functionalities, you'll find a bunch of other features, including order tracking, real-time notifications, and more.Since I don’t have a substantial team backing me, I truly appreciate any assistance you can offer. Every form of contribution is valued.Give it a star and share your thoughts in the comments section. Your support means the world to me!

The Show HN product, likely a delivery service platform, received mixed feedback. Users appreciated the open-source frontend but criticized the proprietary backend and API, questioning the viability of the business model against giants like Uber and Doordash. Technical issues such as broken images, slow website performance, and lack of testing were noted. Some see potential in smaller communities and non-food deliveries, while others doubt the willingness to pay for the codebase. There's interest in pivoting towards POS systems or white-label services, and concerns about the service's availability and adherence to local regulations.

Users criticized the product for broken images, slow website performance, and poor code quality, including a lack of testing. The proprietary nature of the API/backend was a concern, limiting self-hosting and interoperability. The business model and market competition were questioned, with doubts about profitability and benefits to consumers and small businesses. Criticisms also targeted the gig economy's impact on wages, limited availability, especially in rural areas, and the lack of global service. The open-source aspect was unclear, and there were issues with delivery methods and rider availability.

Avatar
43
30
-16.7%
-23.3%
30
43
6.7%
Relevance

Check out my food delivery management solution and provide feedback

29 Dec 2023 Delivery

Hey everyone! Over the past few years, I've dedicated my time to crafting a customizable solution for food delivery management. Now, I'm excited to showcase the culmination of all my work. Throughout the development journey, I've successfully incorporated all the planned features and even expanded upon them based on valuable feedback from the community.My methodology has consistently involved seeking input from platforms like Reddit and forums, where I engage with like-minded individuals. Some of the recent enhancements stem directly from this collaborative feedback, and I'm eager to gather more insights on the latest update to the project.Designed with a focus on individuals or businesses looking to start their own food delivery services, this solution simplifies the process of adding vendors, managing food items, coordinating deliveries, and overseeing riders. Beyond these core functionalities, you'll find a bunch of other features, including order tracking, real-time notifications, and more.Since I don’t have a substantial team backing me, I truly appreciate any assistance you can offer. Every form of contribution is valued.Give it a star and share your thoughts in the comments section. Your support means the world to me!

The Show HN product or service received mixed feedback. Users praised the food delivery solution and highlighted the company's dedication to user feedback. There was also support for abbas_NC's efforts and recognition of potential in the technical documentation. However, a significant number of comments were flagged, indicating possible issues or community guideline violations.

Users are turned off by perceived astroturfing, suggesting a lack of authenticity in the product's promotion.

Avatar
12
9
-11.1%
9
12
Relevance

I Created an Interactive Delivery Zone Geolocation Module

03 Apr 2024 Maps

Hey everyone! I've created an interactive delivery zone module capable of setting and saving boundaries for various use cases. This is part of the app that I am currently working on; which is a food delivery solution that allows anyone to set up a food delivery application like Foodpanda or Ubereats.In this module, you can create delivery bounds using different points on the map.You can also save the created zones or delete ones that have already been created. Geolocation is enabled so you can get your exact location and create zones within that area. There is also a live demo within the repo so please do check it out and provide your valuable feedback.Please visit and share your thoughts in the comments section. Any type of feedback will be appreciated! Cheers!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Borderless Delivery - Delivery operations management for logistics startup

20 Mar 2023 Delivery API Tech

SaaS solution to delivery operations management, driver management, customer management and pricing management problems faced by African courier service providers, thereby causing a ripple effect in unlocking the potential of the logistics sector in Africa.

The Product Hunt launch is perceived very positively. The subject is regarded as amazing. The launch is viewed as a game-changing logistics solution, specifically for addressing operational and pricing challenges in Africa. There is excitement surrounding the focus on Africa as a powerhouse of innovation.

Avatar
84
4
4
84
Relevance

FullStro - An end-to-end fulfilment inventory management system

12 Sep 2023 E-Commerce Sales Productivity

FullStro is an end-to-end fulfillment solution for sellers to manage inventory to their customers. FullStro's order fulfillment system seamlessly integrates with all your sales channels, streamlining the shipping and fulfillment processes.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback with congratulations on the launch and well wishes for success being a common theme. Users inquired about integration possibilities with sales channels and website builders, as well as differentiation strategies given the competitive landscape. There was also a question regarding the app's online/offline functionality. Overall, users expressed excitement and appreciation for the app, acknowledging the hard work behind it.

Avatar
115
8
8
115
Top