Should I Build It Should I Build It
04 May 2025
Community

A social network for developers where you can share your work via ...

...posting, showcase your contribution streak, and ask questions to the community

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

You're venturing into a crowded space: a social network for developers. Our analysis indicates this falls into the 'Swamp' category, meaning there are already many similar solutions, and standing out will be a challenge. With 14 similar products identified, competition is high. The average engagement (comments) on these similar platforms is low, suggesting it's difficult to capture developer attention and foster a vibrant community. There's no clear positive signal for either 'use' or 'buy' which suggests people are, on average, not excited about these platforms. It is imperative to be aware of these drawbacks and pitfalls when progressing forward. You'll need a truly unique angle to succeed.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly research why existing developer social networks haven’t achieved widespread adoption. What are their shortcomings in terms of engagement, content quality, or community management? Knowing the failures of others is critical for differentiating your platform.
  2. If you're committed to this idea, identify a specific niche within the developer community that is currently underserved. Focus on a particular technology, skill level, or region to build a loyal user base before expanding.
  3. Instead of building a completely new social network, consider creating tools or integrations that enhance existing platforms like GitHub, Stack Overflow, or Discord. This approach could be a lower-risk way to enter the market and provide value to developers.
  4. Examine adjacent problems that developers face, which could be more promising avenues for innovation. For instance, focus on improving collaboration workflows, streamlining code review processes, or simplifying project management.
  5. Focus on a very niche initial launch (e.g., "Social network for Solidity developers using Foundry"). This helps to narrow your target audience and tailor features to a specific user group. Make sure to include tight moderation to increase the feeling of high signal to noise ratio in that specific niche, and prevent it from becoming a generic swamp.
  6. Learn from the criticism of similar product launches. As one example, the 'IndieHub' launch faced issues with registration. Ensure your sign-up process is seamless across all devices and browsers to avoid frustrating early adopters. Test rigorously!
  7. Study successful developer communities and note what works for them. Do they lean on tight moderation? Do they only allow questions? Are there strong gamification mechanics? Are people expected to be polite, or can they be brutally honest?
  8. Given that many similar tools suffer from low engagement, focus on content quality and community building. Seed the platform with high-quality content and actively engage with early users to foster a sense of community ownership.

Questions

  1. What fundamental problem are you solving for developers that isn't already adequately addressed by existing platforms? What is the '10x' improvement you can provide that justifies building a new platform?
  2. How will you incentivize developers to actively contribute and engage with your platform, given the existing low engagement levels in similar networks? What is your community building / moderation plan?
  3. What specific features will you implement to differentiate your platform from existing developer social networks, and how will these features create a defensible competitive advantage? Consider things like Stack Overflow's Q&A format or GitHub's code collaboration focus.

Your are here

You're venturing into a crowded space: a social network for developers. Our analysis indicates this falls into the 'Swamp' category, meaning there are already many similar solutions, and standing out will be a challenge. With 14 similar products identified, competition is high. The average engagement (comments) on these similar platforms is low, suggesting it's difficult to capture developer attention and foster a vibrant community. There's no clear positive signal for either 'use' or 'buy' which suggests people are, on average, not excited about these platforms. It is imperative to be aware of these drawbacks and pitfalls when progressing forward. You'll need a truly unique angle to succeed.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly research why existing developer social networks haven’t achieved widespread adoption. What are their shortcomings in terms of engagement, content quality, or community management? Knowing the failures of others is critical for differentiating your platform.
  2. If you're committed to this idea, identify a specific niche within the developer community that is currently underserved. Focus on a particular technology, skill level, or region to build a loyal user base before expanding.
  3. Instead of building a completely new social network, consider creating tools or integrations that enhance existing platforms like GitHub, Stack Overflow, or Discord. This approach could be a lower-risk way to enter the market and provide value to developers.
  4. Examine adjacent problems that developers face, which could be more promising avenues for innovation. For instance, focus on improving collaboration workflows, streamlining code review processes, or simplifying project management.
  5. Focus on a very niche initial launch (e.g., "Social network for Solidity developers using Foundry"). This helps to narrow your target audience and tailor features to a specific user group. Make sure to include tight moderation to increase the feeling of high signal to noise ratio in that specific niche, and prevent it from becoming a generic swamp.
  6. Learn from the criticism of similar product launches. As one example, the 'IndieHub' launch faced issues with registration. Ensure your sign-up process is seamless across all devices and browsers to avoid frustrating early adopters. Test rigorously!
  7. Study successful developer communities and note what works for them. Do they lean on tight moderation? Do they only allow questions? Are there strong gamification mechanics? Are people expected to be polite, or can they be brutally honest?
  8. Given that many similar tools suffer from low engagement, focus on content quality and community building. Seed the platform with high-quality content and actively engage with early users to foster a sense of community ownership.

Questions

  1. What fundamental problem are you solving for developers that isn't already adequately addressed by existing platforms? What is the '10x' improvement you can provide that justifies building a new platform?
  2. How will you incentivize developers to actively contribute and engage with your platform, given the existing low engagement levels in similar networks? What is your community building / moderation plan?
  3. What specific features will you implement to differentiate your platform from existing developer social networks, and how will these features create a defensible competitive advantage? Consider things like Stack Overflow's Q&A format or GitHub's code collaboration focus.

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 14
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 1
  • Net use signal: -7.3%
    • Positive use signal: 0.0%
    • Negative use signal: 7.3%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

A discussion platform for developers

26 Oct 2024 Developer Tools

We developers have always wanted a place to ask questions freely. While Stack Overflow has been the go-to platform for years, it’s clear that developers need a change. That’s why I was inspired to create Rapport, a free and community-driven platform designed for developers to discuss and share ideas.On Rapport, you can ask your questions, and discussions are capped to 15 minutes. This setup encourages active participation—when a discussion starts, a notification system alerts users who clicked the notification button. If a topic relates with many, they'll upvote it, drawing even more participants and leading to lots of answers.It’s really that simple, and I’d love to know what you all think!

Redirect to /login breaks back button on Firefox.

Redirect breaks back button on Firefox for Android.

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

IndieHub - Where your ideas take flight (and sometimes crash)

26 Oct 2024 SaaS Social Media Social Networking

IndieHub: A community for indie developers, creators, and entrepreneurs to connect, share projects, and grow together. Join us to get feedback, find resources, and collaborate on your journey!

The Product Hunt launch is receiving mixed feedback. Users appreciate the concept, but there are technical issues reported, specifically with the registration page. There's also interest in understanding the feedback mechanisms and incentive structures related to the IndieHub launch.

The primary criticism is that the registration page is not functioning correctly. This issue prevents users from signing up and fully utilizing the product.

Avatar
13
2
2
13
Relevance

I made a site for sharing 'work in progress' updates

01 May 2024 Social Media

I've always been fascinated by seeing other people work. Not just their end result, but the process that got them there.Over the years builders have become more willing to share their process. But those updates were scattered throughout the web on different blogs and social media accounts.So I made a social network, very similar to Twitter, focused solely on answering the question "What are you working on right now?"Throughout the day people share small updates of what they have completed. I find it both interesting and motivating to see people make progress on their projects.It's mostly bootstrapped startups, but there are also some authors writing books and people working on various hobby projects.https://wip.coIt's invite-only at the moment to protect the community from an influx of new users (sorry!), but curious to get HN's view on this and whether they'd consider joining such a platform.

Criticizes invite-only post on Show HN.

Invite-only post not suitable for Show HN.

Avatar
4
1
-100.0%
1
4
Relevance

I built an app that turns long-form articles into LinkedIn posts

02 Nov 2024 LinkedIn

Hey,Ever felt Linkedin was overwhelmed with marketing and corpo posts everywhere?That was me.So I decided to post educational content on Linkedin with some AI assistance.Problem: this takes a lot of time. Really.And the existing post generators suck in science and engineering communication. They are tailored for marketers and for telling life stories, etc.I needed something tailored for engineers and tech entrepreneurs.I needed an app where we can ingest research papers, generating good drafts for compelling linkedin posts.So...I built it.I have just a few users, and want to launch a public beta.So here it is. - 20 credits to try for everyone who joins.It's my first product as indie hacker - feedback would be amazing.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

I made a simple tool that writes your social media posts

25 Jun 2024 Social Media

i’m still building my personal brand. i’ve invested in coaching and courses, but they didn’t bring the success i wanted.i learned it’s key to build an active community, especially on linkedin. so i tried posting regularly, but no big wins, mostly because i wasn’t consistent. lack of time and creativity didn’t help either.to fix this, i made an ai tool that asks me daily questions based on my industry and role. i just answer, and it generates a linkedin post. this way, content creation is easier, and i can focus on other stuff.it is not perfect yet, but helps a lot i think.any questions or feedback? thanks

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

A Community for Indie Tech Blogs

01 Feb 2024 Writing

Hey HN! For a while I’ve been trying (unsuccessfully) to find a community for tech bloggers to get together and share what they’re working on, so here’s my attempt at making my own. It’s a completely free website and designed to be super straightforward to use.Functionality wise it’s pretty minimalist right now, with just the ability to register accounts, post drafts, and comment on other user’s posts. Support for more features like tagging post topics, user profiles and more are coming soon!Thanks for checking it out, and I’d love to hear any thoughts from the community.P.S. if you don’t write much yourself but still want to participate, feel free to join! You can give other people feedback without having to post anything of your own.

Cool idea, improve commenting UI like Google Docs.

Improve commenting UI.

Avatar
16
1
1
16
Relevance

Share private GitHub repos by auto-generated URL and paywall

29 Feb 2024 GitHub

Morning HN. I had an issue recently where I wanted to share some private Github repositories with a larger audience than usual (25k+) on Youtube and was simply considering making my code public. Came up with an idea to build a middleman service that handles user access/management, generate share links and even paywall individual repos.Thought I might as well share here in case there's another dev out there who might be interested in sharing a private repo. Keen to get any feedback as I'm currently building

Users commented on the Show HN product with concerns about a waitlist and off-topic content. There were doubts about the product's uniqueness, with some fearing that GitHub could easily replicate its features. Suggestions were made to expand the product's scope to include broader coding, repository monetization, and management tools. Questions were raised about the necessity of private repositories for shared code, and there was curiosity about how code monetization would work. Despite the concerns, there was also enthusiasm for the product's launch.

Users criticized the Show HN submission for including off-topic content and suggested that the product's functionality could potentially be replicated by a GitHub feature. There were suggestions to broaden the scope beyond just repository monetization. Additionally, there were concerns about the product's effectiveness in preventing cloning and the lack of clarity in the monetization process.

Avatar
8
6
6
8
Top