Should I Build It Should I Build It
03 Jun 2025
Developer Tools

Data enrichment service for directory builders, where users can get ...

...websites scraped for enriching their directory website

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

You're entering a moderately competitive market for data enrichment services for directory builders. With around 25 similar products already out there, it's a space with established solutions. The good news is that there seems to be a good buy signal, which suggests people are willing to pay for such services. However, the presence of numerous competitors means you'll need a clear strategy to differentiate your offering and capture market share. The general consensus is that your idea is very promising, but you should think about differentiating your idea with a specific target niche and compelling marketing.

Recommendations

  1. Given the competitive landscape, conduct thorough market research to pinpoint underserved niches within directory building. For example, focus on a specific industry or type of directory that has unique data enrichment needs.
  2. Based on the discussion of similar products, make sure your pricing is transparent and justified. Offer different tiers or usage-based pricing to accommodate various customer needs and budgets. Consider a free tier to gain initial traction.
  3. Prioritize ease of use and seamless integration with popular directory platforms. A well-designed, intuitive interface can be a significant differentiator, especially if competitors are perceived as complex or cumbersome, and use no-code solutions for a faster launch.
  4. Since users of similar products have requested LLM/AI features, consider adding features like AI-powered data extraction and categorization. However, be mindful of costs and hallucination frequency; focus on delivering accurate and reliable results.
  5. Implement robust anti-scraping measures to ensure data quality and reliability. Address challenges such as antibot measures and captchas to provide a seamless data enrichment experience.
  6. Develop comprehensive documentation and tutorials to guide users on how to effectively use your service. Address common issues such as JavaScript rendering and dynamic content handling.
  7. Establish a feedback loop with your early users to gather insights and iterate quickly. Prioritize feature requests and bug fixes based on user feedback to continuously improve the product.
  8. Clearly define your brand and marketing message to communicate your unique value proposition. Emphasize the benefits of your service, such as time savings, accuracy, and scalability.
  9. Consider offering specialized features such as image scripting, especially if building local directories. This can be a unique selling point that attracts users seeking specific directory solutions.

Questions

  1. What specific anti-scraping measures will you implement to ensure data quality and reliability, especially given the challenges of scraping real-world sites with anti-scraping technologies?
  2. How will you balance the desire for AI-powered features with the need for cost-effectiveness and accuracy, especially in light of concerns about hallucination frequency and the costs associated with calling LLMs each time?
  3. Given the emphasis on SEO and content quality in the discussions of similar products, how will you ensure that your data enrichment service supports ethical SEO practices and delivers accurate, high-quality content?

Your are here

You're entering a moderately competitive market for data enrichment services for directory builders. With around 25 similar products already out there, it's a space with established solutions. The good news is that there seems to be a good buy signal, which suggests people are willing to pay for such services. However, the presence of numerous competitors means you'll need a clear strategy to differentiate your offering and capture market share. The general consensus is that your idea is very promising, but you should think about differentiating your idea with a specific target niche and compelling marketing.

Recommendations

  1. Given the competitive landscape, conduct thorough market research to pinpoint underserved niches within directory building. For example, focus on a specific industry or type of directory that has unique data enrichment needs.
  2. Based on the discussion of similar products, make sure your pricing is transparent and justified. Offer different tiers or usage-based pricing to accommodate various customer needs and budgets. Consider a free tier to gain initial traction.
  3. Prioritize ease of use and seamless integration with popular directory platforms. A well-designed, intuitive interface can be a significant differentiator, especially if competitors are perceived as complex or cumbersome, and use no-code solutions for a faster launch.
  4. Since users of similar products have requested LLM/AI features, consider adding features like AI-powered data extraction and categorization. However, be mindful of costs and hallucination frequency; focus on delivering accurate and reliable results.
  5. Implement robust anti-scraping measures to ensure data quality and reliability. Address challenges such as antibot measures and captchas to provide a seamless data enrichment experience.
  6. Develop comprehensive documentation and tutorials to guide users on how to effectively use your service. Address common issues such as JavaScript rendering and dynamic content handling.
  7. Establish a feedback loop with your early users to gather insights and iterate quickly. Prioritize feature requests and bug fixes based on user feedback to continuously improve the product.
  8. Clearly define your brand and marketing message to communicate your unique value proposition. Emphasize the benefits of your service, such as time savings, accuracy, and scalability.
  9. Consider offering specialized features such as image scripting, especially if building local directories. This can be a unique selling point that attracts users seeking specific directory solutions.

Questions

  1. What specific anti-scraping measures will you implement to ensure data quality and reliability, especially given the challenges of scraping real-world sites with anti-scraping technologies?
  2. How will you balance the desire for AI-powered features with the need for cost-effectiveness and accuracy, especially in light of concerns about hallucination frequency and the costs associated with calling LLMs each time?
  3. Given the emphasis on SEO and content quality in the discussions of similar products, how will you ensure that your data enrichment service supports ethical SEO practices and delivers accurate, high-quality content?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 25
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 7
  • Net use signal: 6.0%
    • Positive use signal: 11.1%
    • Negative use signal: 5.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.7%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.1%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.5%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Scraping Pros - Web Scraping Services

18 Jul 2024 Data SaaS Web App

Leverage our web scraping services at Scraping Pros to easily extract data from any website for informed decision-making. Transform web data into a business advantage with our tailored strategies and reliable, fresh data delivered in your preferred format.

The web scraping service is praised for providing seamless, efficient, and accurate data extraction for businesses. Users highlight its reliability and overall fantastic performance.

Avatar
9
2
50.0%
50.0%
2
9
50.0%
50.0%
Relevance

Scrapejoy - Unlimited web scraping for startups and enterprises

16 Jun 2023 Social media marketing Sales Marketing

Get unlimited number of website scrapes + custom built automations at fixed monthly price:1. Identify the website(s) to scrape2. Our dedicated team of engineers build custom solution for you3. Use this to scale lead generation/marketing/GTM discovery

The Product Hunt launch received numerous congratulations. Users expressed excitement and acknowledged the product's potential usefulness and amazing look. However, the pricing was a significant concern for some, who requested justification. There were inquiries about future expansions and the inclusion of Twitter data. One user pointed out grammar and spacing errors and another mentioned the difficulty of scaling without understanding data extraction. Overall, the launch was well-received with excitement and minor concerns.

The primary criticisms revolve around pricing, which is perceived as too high without sufficient market justification. Users also pointed out issues with the product's grammar, inconsistent spacing, and unclear pricing details. Additionally, there's a need for improved guidance, particularly for businesses uncertain about their specific data requirements.

Avatar
173
16
12.5%
16
173
12.5%
Relevance

We're building an open data warehouse inspired by Git scraping

11 Jan 2024 Data & Analytics GitHub

Hey everyone, this is Jason and Nathan from https://subsets.io, a new open data warehouse. Our goal is to make finding and accessing public data easier for human analysis, in apps, or as a source of up-to-date data for retrieval-augmented-generation.Inspired by git scraping [1], the core idea is to build something where people don’t upload a snapshot of their dataset directly, like you might do on Kaggle or Huggingface. Instead, anyone can contribute code (connectors) which we then continuously run and make the fetched data available for everyone in our shared, public data warehouse. We currently have connectors for 120+ datasets including an index of YC companies, U.S. house prices, and Wikipedia search volumes.Separately, open data portals, such as from NGOs, can be hard to use due to their use of semantic web principles - i.e., representing data as a graph and adding structured metadata. We’re taking a less structured approach: each dataset is just a table that you can download or query using SQL, and we’re building a machine learning engine for ranking, pre-processing, and to generate relevant subsets/views from the data warehouse.BigQuery is used as the data warehouse. We use dagster for the data pipelines, running it on top of Kubernetes. Frontend is NextJS. The data pipelines are currently centralised in our repo, but we’re building our own engine where you can just upload simple scripts. Search is currently basic semantic search, with one big index that stores unique strings across tables, columns, and rows. Before we used better search using LLM’s, but the cost, latency, and rate limits mean we’re still investigating the right way to go.The project is in its very beginning stages, but we’d like to get some early feedback and find people who either want to help us build connectors or use the data to build something cool. The connectors are available at https://github.com/subsetsio/subsets-connectors, and you can visually explore the datasets and get your own free API key at https://www.subsets.io.[1] - https://simonwillison.net/2020/Oct/9/git-scraping/

Usage-based pricing model, open source connectors available.

Unclear pricing details.

Avatar
5
1
1
5
Relevance

AIScraper - AI-Powered Web Scraping Tool

13 Sep 2024 Productivity API Chrome Extensions

AIScraper Extension lets you scrape structured data from any website with just a few clicks, featuring AI-powered modifications and analysis on the fly

AIScraper is praised as a handy, simple, and extremely useful web scraping tool, lauded for its ease of use, intuitive interface, and time-saving AI-powered data collection. Users report success in extracting and categorizing data from websites like Amazon, creating lists in CSV/JSON, and automating tasks. Many congratulate Natalia and the team on the launch, highlighting the product's convenience and effectiveness. Some users experienced issues with Google login. Overall, the tool is considered promising, with users excited to try it and recommending it to friends.

Users reported issues with Google login, suggesting a need for manual entry as a workaround. There's concern about the product becoming overly complex and data-heavy, implying a desire for simplicity and focus. A suggestion was made to enable headless environment support.

Avatar
74
32
43.8%
3.1%
32
74
43.8%
3.1%
Relevance

I built a no-code scraper for Lists and Page Details (Chrome Extension)

26 Sep 2024 Chrome Extensions

Hey everyone, just wanted to share a tool I’ve been working on.It’s a chrome plugin to extract Lists & Page Details from any website. Here’s a preview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZyFFhilcGBoBackstory:A few months ago I was toying with the idea of building a no-code scraper. I shared a prototype on twitter and it blew up, so I continued working on it.This is how PandaExtract was born.Originally I was aiming to build a full web scraper but slowly realized that trying to cover every scraping need is just too complex. So I niched it down to a very specific use case: List + Page Details.What it can do now: * Extract Lists instantly * Extract Page Details using AI models (best for small data that can fit into a spreadsheet)Who is it meant for? This is not meant to replace more traditional scraping operations but rather allow people to quickly grab some structured data from websites.Most common use cases are reviews extraction, phone numbers, local business lists, product lists…Pricing:Most of the plugin is Free but there are some PRO features.Chrome WebStore URL: * https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/web-scraper-data-ex...Let me know what you think!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Ship Local - Scrap and build local directories in minutes.

04 Sep 2024 Website Builder Community Developer Tools

Build local directories in minutes with ShipLocal. This powerful boilerplate lets you quickly create a fully-functional directory, scraping data from Google and displaying it on your site with just a few lines of code. Fast, easy, and efficient.

Users are recommending the tool for quick local directory setup, highlighting its practicality and ability to address common challenges. The image scripting feature is also praised. Users building with ShipFast express enjoyment. There are words of encouragement and congratulations for the launch.

Avatar
35
7
14.3%
7
35
14.3%
Relevance

Databoutique.com, a Marketplace for Web Data

24 Mar 2023 Data

Hi all! We’re building a marketplace for web data (https://www.databoutique.com).If you need web data for training models or app development, you can ask the community for it. The goal is to save time and cut down on scraping costs.The basic idea is that most of the times, you’ll need data that someone is already scraping, so it’s faster and easier to ask for it, instead of doing again the scrape yourself.We’re in early phase, any feedback is welcome. We hope this helps lower the barriers to data.

No content available

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

LLM Scraper – turn any webpage into structured data

20 Apr 2024 Data

Users appreciate the tool, highlighting its usefulness in transforming webpages into structured data and suggesting improvements like handling JavaScript-heavy sites and adding Markdown output. Concerns about cost and efficiency are noted, with suggestions for reusable scripts and compatibility with OpenAI's API. Some users report specific use cases like CSS selector generation and structured data extraction with LLMs. Challenges such as antibot measures and captchas are mentioned, as well as a curiosity about the tool's prompt and capabilities like instruction following and screenshot parsing.

Users criticized the Show HN product for lacking a reusable script for LLM, high costs associated with calling LLM each time and scaling content size, and concerns about cost and hallucination frequency. Other issues include difficulty with information hidden in text, the need for handling JavaScript sites, lack of Markdown output, and latency issues with web LLMs. Users also suggested solving underlying problems such as antibots and captchas.

Avatar
88
18
5.6%
-5.6%
18
88
5.6%
Relevance

flyscrape – An expressive and elegant web scraper

13 Oct 2023 Productivity

Users are interested in the product, with one asking about async handling similar to waitFor in puppeteer. Another user compares it to colly, expressing satisfaction but openness to improvements. A third user appreciates the neat approach but initially missed that it's written in JavaScript.

The main criticism is the lack of information on asynchronous handling in the readme. Additionally, there is a general openness to improvements.

Avatar
14
3
3
14
Relevance

Page Replica – Tool for Web Scraping, Prerendering, and SEO Boost

01 Jan 2024 SEO

Comments reflect mixed opinions on SEO's relevance in the AI era, with some arguing it's becoming obsolete while others believe it's necessary due to commercial dynamics. AI's content quality and accuracy are questioned, with suggestions for using RAG over ChatGPT. There's a debate on the history and current state of SEO, with some claiming it's been dead since the 90s, while others credit PageRank and note ongoing SEO efforts. Technical discussions include the SEO impact of JavaScript, dynamic content, and static site generation. Some comments are skeptical about the need for certain tools and question the user experience delivered by JS-heavy UIs.

Users criticized the product for being outdated and unnecessary due to AI advancements, with concerns about AI-generated content quality and SEO tactics potentially misleading AI. There were doubts about the product's effectiveness, relevance for onpage SEO only, and its lack of local service information. Technical issues raised include potential problems with JavaScript rendering affecting free SEO traffic, search engines parsing JavaScript apps, and the ethical use of scraping. The product was also seen as inefficient, possibly a hack, and not addressing the logged-in experience. Some users questioned the need for the tool, its value, maintenance, and the benefits of caching over static sites. The user experience was criticized for being degraded by JS-heavy UIs and excessive sliders, with a sentiment against JavaScript among HN users.

Avatar
135
41
-17.1%
41
135
Relevance

Flyscrape – A standalone and scriptable web scraper in Go

11 Nov 2023 Developer Tools

Users have expressed concerns about Flyscrape's effectiveness in scraping real-world sites, particularly those with anti-scraping measures like Cloudflare. There's a demand for more features, dynamic settings, and examples of advanced web-scraping. Comparisons with other tools like Colly and Playwright are requested, and there's interest in handling dynamic content and site changes. Some users find the tool potentially useful and plan to test it, while others have moved to different technologies. There are also technical questions about specific functions and suggestions for improvements, including opening the core for feedback.

Users criticized the product for its inability to handle real-world scraping challenges such as dynamic content, JavaScript rendering, and anti-scraping measures. The lack of examples, broken documentation links, and the need for clearer methods were also mentioned. Some noted the inefficiency of Python compared to UNIX utilities and the necessity to spoof user agents. The product's inability to handle iframes, shadow elements, and the absence of programmatic extensibility for custom browser control were highlighted. Users also pointed out the risk posed by gatekeeping technologies like Cloudflare and Akamai.

Avatar
208
42
-7.1%
42
208
4.8%
Top