26 May 2025
GitHub

Making web-based game to serve children. The web will contains a few ...

...small simple games.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

You're entering the freemium space with your web-based game for children. The good news is, there are several similar products out there (n_matches = 21), indicating a viable market, and many even have high engagement (avg n_comments = 14). However, the freemium model suggests that users enjoy such games but are hesitant to pay. This means you'll need a solid strategy to differentiate your game and identify which users would be willing to pay for premium features or additional value. Focus on building something unique that kids love to play and their parents are willing to spend on!

Recommendations

  1. Begin by identifying the core features that will make your game engaging and fun for children. Since several similar products show high engagement, understanding what works is vital. Consider incorporating elements from successful web games, such as visually appealing graphics, simple mechanics, and educational content, but also look at the criticisms from similar products, like confusing controls or unclear instructions.
  2. Determine which users derive the most value from the free version of your game. Is it the educational aspect? The entertainment value? The ability to play with friends? This understanding will inform your strategy for creating premium features that cater to these users.
  3. Develop premium features that offer enhanced value to those users. Think about features like ad-free gameplay, exclusive levels, character customization, or progress tracking. Ensure these features directly address the needs and desires of your target audience.
  4. Explore alternative monetization strategies. Instead of charging individual users, consider team or classroom licenses for schools or educational organizations. Alternatively, offer personalized help or consulting services to parents or educators who want to use the game for learning purposes.
  5. Implement a robust testing strategy. Before fully launching premium features, test different pricing approaches with small groups of users to gauge their willingness to pay. Gather feedback on the perceived value of each feature and adjust your pricing accordingly. Be very mindful about the 'sign-in' requirement as that was flagged as negative in competing products.
  6. Focus on creating a user-friendly and accessible experience. Address criticisms from similar products, such as display issues across devices or confusing instructions. Ensure your game is compatible with various browsers and devices, and provide clear, concise instructions for gameplay.
  7. Actively gather feedback from your users and iterate on your game based on their suggestions. Pay attention to comments and reviews, and address any issues or concerns promptly. Regularly update your game with new content and features to keep users engaged and coming back for more.
  8. Consider that in 'I gamified learnpython.org and made a version for kids', users suggested more descriptive method names. Think through the user experience of your game and carefully chose names and commands. The right term helps kids learn and makes your game more playable.

Questions

  1. Given that many similar games have high engagement but operate on a freemium model, what specific, unique mechanics or content can you introduce to justify a premium purchase, especially considering the negative feedback some competitors received regarding unclear value propositions?
  2. Considering the criticisms of display issues and compatibility problems in similar web games, how will you ensure a seamless and consistent user experience across different devices and browsers, particularly for your target audience of children?
  3. With the freemium model's inherent challenge of converting free users to paying customers, what innovative and non-intrusive monetization strategies can you implement that align with the educational or entertainment value your game provides, while avoiding the pitfalls of credit card requirements or auto-subscription models that have drawn criticism in the past?

Your are here

You're entering the freemium space with your web-based game for children. The good news is, there are several similar products out there (n_matches = 21), indicating a viable market, and many even have high engagement (avg n_comments = 14). However, the freemium model suggests that users enjoy such games but are hesitant to pay. This means you'll need a solid strategy to differentiate your game and identify which users would be willing to pay for premium features or additional value. Focus on building something unique that kids love to play and their parents are willing to spend on!

Recommendations

  1. Begin by identifying the core features that will make your game engaging and fun for children. Since several similar products show high engagement, understanding what works is vital. Consider incorporating elements from successful web games, such as visually appealing graphics, simple mechanics, and educational content, but also look at the criticisms from similar products, like confusing controls or unclear instructions.
  2. Determine which users derive the most value from the free version of your game. Is it the educational aspect? The entertainment value? The ability to play with friends? This understanding will inform your strategy for creating premium features that cater to these users.
  3. Develop premium features that offer enhanced value to those users. Think about features like ad-free gameplay, exclusive levels, character customization, or progress tracking. Ensure these features directly address the needs and desires of your target audience.
  4. Explore alternative monetization strategies. Instead of charging individual users, consider team or classroom licenses for schools or educational organizations. Alternatively, offer personalized help or consulting services to parents or educators who want to use the game for learning purposes.
  5. Implement a robust testing strategy. Before fully launching premium features, test different pricing approaches with small groups of users to gauge their willingness to pay. Gather feedback on the perceived value of each feature and adjust your pricing accordingly. Be very mindful about the 'sign-in' requirement as that was flagged as negative in competing products.
  6. Focus on creating a user-friendly and accessible experience. Address criticisms from similar products, such as display issues across devices or confusing instructions. Ensure your game is compatible with various browsers and devices, and provide clear, concise instructions for gameplay.
  7. Actively gather feedback from your users and iterate on your game based on their suggestions. Pay attention to comments and reviews, and address any issues or concerns promptly. Regularly update your game with new content and features to keep users engaged and coming back for more.
  8. Consider that in 'I gamified learnpython.org and made a version for kids', users suggested more descriptive method names. Think through the user experience of your game and carefully chose names and commands. The right term helps kids learn and makes your game more playable.

Questions

  1. Given that many similar games have high engagement but operate on a freemium model, what specific, unique mechanics or content can you introduce to justify a premium purchase, especially considering the negative feedback some competitors received regarding unclear value propositions?
  2. Considering the criticisms of display issues and compatibility problems in similar web games, how will you ensure a seamless and consistent user experience across different devices and browsers, particularly for your target audience of children?
  3. With the freemium model's inherent challenge of converting free users to paying customers, what innovative and non-intrusive monetization strategies can you implement that align with the educational or entertainment value your game provides, while avoiding the pitfalls of credit card requirements or auto-subscription models that have drawn criticism in the past?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 21
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 14
  • Net use signal: 1.2%
    • Positive use signal: 6.8%
    • Negative use signal: 5.6%
  • Net buy signal: -2.3%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 2.3%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

PlayCodeAI – A tool I created to let my kid create their own videogames

Hi hn,Its been a while since my kid has been dreaming to make videogames, as you know, the entry bar is high, too many technical details are involved.A few months ago, we started making games, we have tried many different ways, from dragging blocks to write code with a high-level library to make it simple, it is still too much work.Getting into the AI boat, I decided to give it a try for making games, turns out that it works super nicely, still, you still have many technical concepts involved, what language should the game be written in? where do you store the file/assets? how do you run it?I decided creating a simple playground where most of the tech details are already defined, html/javascript due to the portability they provide, we can get the code and see the result right away, same way, we can easily export it and upload it to a server.So far, the results are amazing, my kid has managed to create 10 simple games in a few hours with no help at all (the landing page includes screenshots from these).I strongly believe that this can help many other people to bring their ideas to life.As of now, the tool is simple, it runs on the client side, requiring an OpenAI API Key to interact with the models, it has the problem that only paid users can access this and I hope to remove that barrier soon but this was the simplest/fastest way to get things done.A big limitation relates to image loading, many images have CORS limitations that chatgpt can't detect, games without images aren't fun and I hope to solve this soon (suggestions accepted).I'd also love making it simple to share the results with others.Anyway, if your kid is willing to make a videogame, I encourage you to try this out, any feedback should help me to polish this to be usable for others.Thanks.


Avatar
7
7
Relevance

A list of the card games/puzzles I made to teach kids programming

22 Mar 2024 Education Games

In the process of teaching my kid I made some card games, which I think are useful tools for other parents/teachers.If you have ideas about new games, or teaching tools, please contact me, I think the space of non condescending tools for teaching kids is very unexplored.e.g. now I am working on a car/cdr card game, and an ARP who-has/is-at board game

Created educational card games, seeking new ideas.

Non condescending tools for teaching kids unexplored.


Avatar
4
1
1
4
Relevance

I gamified learnpython.org and made a version for kids

05 Jun 2024 Education

Users commented on a Show HN product with inquiries about graphics and command naming, suggestions for more descriptive method names like 'move_forward', and positive feedback on the concept of learning Python through a game, especially for kids. The implementation and user experience were praised as 'cool', and the approach to learning programming was described as easy and playful. However, one user noted the lack of content.

Users criticized the product for having a command name that is too long, which requires additional typing. However, some users argue that the extra typing effort is justified by the increased readability it provides.


Avatar
9
6
16.7%
6
9
16.7%
Relevance

2d web paddle game

05 Jun 2024 Games

Simple retro paddle arcade game written in Javascript, using good ol' Canvas.

Users generally find the pong game enjoyable, praising its fun mechanics, satisfying design, and interesting power-ups. There's a strong interest in multiplayer features and local two-player modes. Some users suggest improvements like parabolic paddles for intuitive angle computation and light-theme modes. The game's challenge and complexity, particularly with angle mechanics, are appreciated, though some find it too addictive or time-consuming. Technical feedback includes issues with code, naming, and bugs. High scores and experiences against AI opponents are frequently shared, with some users reminiscing about classic games like Arkanoid and Shufflepuck Cafe.

Users criticized the game's physics as random and unintuitive, particularly the angle mechanics. The lack of a clear win state, outdated base game, and absence of an end goal were also noted. Gameplay elements like reflecting and powerups were seen as unenjoyable, and the game was said to waste too much time. Confusion about GPT involvement, inconsistent naming, and a desire for features like light-theme mode, mouse control, and multiplayer were mentioned. The AI's performance and the need for an iPhone paddle input device were also criticized.


Avatar
309
74
12.2%
74
309
14.9%
Relevance

I Built a Free AI Platform to Instantly Create Games with Your Voice

14 Aug 2024 Games

Hey HN,I'm Damiano Rodriguez, and I've been working solo on a project called Caisual Games. It's a free platform where anyone can create web games just by describing them with their voice.Here's how it works: You simply describe your game idea ("Make a cookie clicker game with 5 upgrades"), and the platform generates a playable web game in seconds using HTML and JavaScript.There's no coding required and no downloads needed—you can create and play directly in your browser.What's more, anyone can improve a published game, fostering a collaborative environment for game creation.The ultimate goal is to make game creation accessible to everyone by removing the coding barrier. Currently, it's possible to create only simple games, but soon maybe we might be able to create increasingly complex games.To my knowledge, this is a novel approach to game creation. Your feedback will be extremely valuable in refining and enhancing the platform, especially in this initial phase.Thank you.P.S.: You can create multiplayer games too :-)P.P.S: One of the early users made a game about a water drop floating in the air trying to avoid dust particles and trying to merge with other water molecules. I'm very proud of it: https://caisual.com/g/buo4vwbjveg926vt

Users find the product interesting and somewhat unsettling. There is curiosity about its capability to handle complex games. Overall, the feedback is positive.


Avatar
5
2
2
5
Relevance

A simple world flags game, my first web dev project as a beginner

25 Jan 2023 Developer Tools

Users praised the project's execution and design, highlighting its usefulness for visual learning and flag recognition. However, many comments pointed out display issues across various devices and resolutions, with suggestions to show flags and answers more prominently, especially after incorrect guesses. Users also recommended improvements such as resizing options, clearer feedback messages, and the inclusion of a leaderboard. Some noted outdated flags and suggested updates. The interactive globe feature was well-received, but there were requests for better performance on certain devices. Overall, the project was considered fun and educational, with potential for enhancements.

Users criticized the product for display issues, including lack of responsiveness to different resolutions and cropping of options. Feedback clarity was a common complaint, with calls for more prominent correct answers and flags, especially after incorrect guesses. The game's difficulty, including too many choices and similar flags, was noted. Users also mentioned high CPU usage, lack of a leaderboard, and the desire for more game modes and better learning tools, such as a review page for wrong answers and optimized flag selection.


Avatar
238
97
6.2%
97
238
10.3%
Relevance

I made a little fun mini game with JavaScript

Hello online friends, devs and hackers, I have created some little game using Z js, a framework I made a while ago, nothing much just for fun... what do you think, cause I made this using my own js framework which I made a while a go, here was just exploring what's possible as of now using the framework!https://z-mini-game.netlify.app/ and source code: https://github.com/Hussseinkizz/mini-game


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Juggling Game

02 Nov 2024 Games

I made this small juggling game. It’s for desktop browsers now. Started as something ChatGPT created for me, but it looked fun to play with, so I decided to invest some more time in ot. Turned out to be a good project for the weekend.


Avatar
2
2
Relevance

I made a simple web app to help kids learn a new language

11 Oct 2024 Education

Hey there!Out of the necessity to teach my son a new language, I developed an app just for him. After months of use and realizing how effective it was, I decided to make it available to the public. Now, I’m looking for your support, feedback, and possibly help in reaching potential customers.Take a look and let me know your thoughts!Thank you!

The Show HN product received mixed feedback. Users criticized unclear value propositions, complicated demos, and mistrusted content due to fake podcasts and poor translations. Some opposed requiring credit cards for free trials, while others suggested it to prevent multiple accounts. Technical issues were noted, and there were comparisons to Duolingo, with questions about its effectiveness for both kids and adults. Positive remarks included a polished tool and suggestions for educational use. Users also advised on pricing strategies and requested website title edits.

Users criticized the product for an unclear value proposition, complex and wordy presentation, and disliked the credit card requirement for free trials. Multiple mentions of fake podcasts and poor translations led to distrust in content. There were issues with Chrome, audio imbalance, and a lack of user control. Comparisons with Duolingo and LingQ questioned its effectiveness in language acquisition, and users were offended by the auto-subscription model. The title was also noted as incorrect for Show HN standards.


Avatar
47
25
-24.0%
-28.0%
25
47
4.0%
Relevance

I'm making one web game per month, here's game #1

14 Jun 2023 Puzzle Games Games

Hey!A while ago I discovered three.js, a JavaScript library to manipulate 3D objects. It looked really interesting, but I had no real need for it... until now!In order to learn three.js, I'm challenging myself to make one 3D web game per month. And you can play the first game here: https://www.thomasfriday.com/clockwise/Please let me know if you have any questions or feedback. Thanks!

Simple and fun


Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

Balancing game for the mobile browser with increasing difficulty

23 Apr 2024 Games

I made this 10 level Game. Excited for people to try it. :) Stay Balanced :)

Users appreciate the nostalgia and challenge of the game, reminiscent of Marble Madness and Monkey Ball, but criticize the harsh penalty of restarting after three falls and suggest improvements like a lives system, better camera angles, and technical fixes for various browsers. Some users find the tilt controls intuitive, while others struggle with orientation and suggest a zeroing button. There are mixed reports on compatibility across devices and browsers, with some experiencing bugs or unresponsiveness. The community is engaged, sharing tips and requesting features like leaderboards and daily challenges.

-Camera angle, lighting, level timing, harsh punishment. - Harsh punishment - UI suggests incorrect number of balls. - Low pay and frustration - Ruins metaphor, mentally map tilting to arrow keys. - Tilt dampening needs improvement - Universal 3-life max is very harsh. - Restarting after 3 drops kills fun. - Limited level retries. - Replaying levels is boring. - Needs more difficulty after 10 levels. - Extends the non-fun bits. - 3 lives per level better for starters. - Horizontal plane zero issue. - Neutral position tilting away - Zero point being horizontal is easier. - Requires specific orientation to play. - Game too easy to complete. - Didn't learn about Knot Theory. - Ball falls up when phone is upside down - Assumption of phone position already made. - Avoid redoing completed levels. - Skill issue. - Improve skills. - Win should count as death - Not fun re-doing all levels - None - Stop playing not meaningful metric. - Current game frustrates players without such modes. - Artificial difficulty deters players. - End detection area too high. - Didn't work on Brave on Android - Unresponsive interface on Chrome Android. - You have to tilt your phone. - Unclear instructions, start button not visible in landscape. - Unresponsive to input on next screen. - Inner dread from falling off path in maze. - It's just ThreeJS. - No automatic reset like other levels. - Frustrated at level 9. - Difficult to use without arrow keys - 2D game didn't work well - No installable version - No visual feedback, heavy ball, wrong perspective. - Ball falls forever without triggering next life. - No permission option for motion sensors; privacy concerns. - No comparison feature after level completion - No criticism. - No GitHub repo. - React games are a slideshow. - Doesn't work on Chrome for Android. - Controls are too reactive. - Dislikes the 'lives' feature. - Ball falls off and endlessly through space - Arrow keys not working. - No criticism - No accelerometer. - Add autofocus on next button. - stupid random idea - Needs better camera angles. - Needs level editor. - Not compatible with Firefox for Android - Clicks ineffective on initial game screen. - Interaction method not clear. - Tilt feature not working. - Froze occasionally.


Avatar
338
106
-6.6%
-4.7%
106
338
6.6%
Top