09 May 2025
Community

A Skool or circle platforms community management tool powered by ai to ...

...improve productivity of admins, increase engagement and revenue opportunities for community owner,

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.


Your are here

You're entering a competitive space with your AI-powered community management tool for platforms like Skool and Circle. There are already a good number of similar products in the market (n_matches = 12), so standing out will be key. On the bright side, these types of tools tend to have high engagement (avg n_comments = 36), suggesting people are interested in solutions that improve community management. It's also great news that there is already a very strong buy signal, which means people express a willingness to pay for a product like yours! Given the competitive landscape, you should definitely focus on differentiation early.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by conducting thorough competitive research. Analyze existing AI community management tools, paying close attention to their features, pricing, and user reviews. For example, user reviews of similar products highlight desired features like integrations with Slack/Discord, payment gateways, and mobile apps (Odd Circles). Figure out where these tools fall short and identify opportunities for differentiation.
  2. Based on your competitive research, pinpoint 2-3 key areas where your tool can offer a unique advantage. This could be a specific AI-powered feature, a more intuitive user interface, or a focus on a niche community type (e.g., Web3, education). One identified weakness with similar products is the lack of self-service capabilities. (Concurrence AI), this might be a great thing to focus on.
  3. Consider focusing on specific platforms like Skool and Circle, which can give you a narrower target. You can also consider focusing on the job to be done, for example, 'increase engagement and revenue opportunities for community owner' and deliver something that solves that specific problem.
  4. Develop a clear and compelling brand message that highlights your tool's unique value proposition. Focus on how your AI-powered features directly address the pain points of community admins and owners. Instead of highlighting the AI, highlight how it will help the community manager save time, increase revenue and/or drive more engagement.
  5. Prioritize early user feedback. Launch an MVP (minimum viable product) to a small group of community admins and actively solicit their input. Use this feedback to iterate quickly and refine your product based on real-world usage. Address any issues raised in similar products, such as confusing interfaces or a lack of clear task instructions (Community Hub, Albus for Community).
  6. Implement robust data privacy and user consent practices. Several similar products have faced scrutiny regarding data privacy, especially in global contexts (Odd Circles). Be transparent about how you collect, use, and protect user data to build trust with your community.
  7. While a positive buy signal is great, be mindful of pricing strategies. Offer a free tier or trial period to allow potential users to experience the value of your tool before committing to a paid plan.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions, what specific AI functionalities will your tool offer that genuinely improve community admin productivity and engagement beyond what's currently available?
  2. How will you ensure your AI algorithms are unbiased and promote inclusivity within the communities they manage, avoiding potential pitfalls of AI-driven moderation?
  3. What metrics will you use to measure the success of your AI-powered community management tool in terms of increased engagement and revenue generation for community owners, and how do these metrics compare to industry benchmarks?

Your are here

You're entering a competitive space with your AI-powered community management tool for platforms like Skool and Circle. There are already a good number of similar products in the market (n_matches = 12), so standing out will be key. On the bright side, these types of tools tend to have high engagement (avg n_comments = 36), suggesting people are interested in solutions that improve community management. It's also great news that there is already a very strong buy signal, which means people express a willingness to pay for a product like yours! Given the competitive landscape, you should definitely focus on differentiation early.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by conducting thorough competitive research. Analyze existing AI community management tools, paying close attention to their features, pricing, and user reviews. For example, user reviews of similar products highlight desired features like integrations with Slack/Discord, payment gateways, and mobile apps (Odd Circles). Figure out where these tools fall short and identify opportunities for differentiation.
  2. Based on your competitive research, pinpoint 2-3 key areas where your tool can offer a unique advantage. This could be a specific AI-powered feature, a more intuitive user interface, or a focus on a niche community type (e.g., Web3, education). One identified weakness with similar products is the lack of self-service capabilities. (Concurrence AI), this might be a great thing to focus on.
  3. Consider focusing on specific platforms like Skool and Circle, which can give you a narrower target. You can also consider focusing on the job to be done, for example, 'increase engagement and revenue opportunities for community owner' and deliver something that solves that specific problem.
  4. Develop a clear and compelling brand message that highlights your tool's unique value proposition. Focus on how your AI-powered features directly address the pain points of community admins and owners. Instead of highlighting the AI, highlight how it will help the community manager save time, increase revenue and/or drive more engagement.
  5. Prioritize early user feedback. Launch an MVP (minimum viable product) to a small group of community admins and actively solicit their input. Use this feedback to iterate quickly and refine your product based on real-world usage. Address any issues raised in similar products, such as confusing interfaces or a lack of clear task instructions (Community Hub, Albus for Community).
  6. Implement robust data privacy and user consent practices. Several similar products have faced scrutiny regarding data privacy, especially in global contexts (Odd Circles). Be transparent about how you collect, use, and protect user data to build trust with your community.
  7. While a positive buy signal is great, be mindful of pricing strategies. Offer a free tier or trial period to allow potential users to experience the value of your tool before committing to a paid plan.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions, what specific AI functionalities will your tool offer that genuinely improve community admin productivity and engagement beyond what's currently available?
  2. How will you ensure your AI algorithms are unbiased and promote inclusivity within the communities they manage, avoiding potential pitfalls of AI-driven moderation?
  3. What metrics will you use to measure the success of your AI-powered community management tool in terms of increased engagement and revenue generation for community owners, and how do these metrics compare to industry benchmarks?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 12
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 36
  • Net use signal: 15.7%
    • Positive use signal: 16.0%
    • Negative use signal: 0.3%
  • Net buy signal: 0.5%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.5%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

EigentBot - Build an AI community manager in seconds

EigentBot deploys an AI-powered community manager in seconds! - Seamlessly integrate with web links, files, Notion, GitHub, LinkedIn, and more. - Prioritizing privacy, we support local model deployment. - With one-click, get your bot running in just 3 seconds!

Eigenbot is being praised for its personalized knowledge capabilities, easy deployment, and user control features. The Product Hunt launch is receiving congratulations, with users excited about the product. Many are impressed with Eigenbot's community and intend to try it out, particularly noting its integration with Discord.


Avatar
60
3
100.0%
3
60
100.0%
Relevance

Community Hub - Boost community activity, crush marketing KPIs

Community Hub uses AI to automate your community marketing with gamification. Reward community members for their activity on Social, YouTube, Discord, and more to crush your marketing KPIs, boost community activity, and save tons of time.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising the product's innovative approach to community engagement, especially its use of AI and gamification. Many are excited about the product's potential for Web3 projects, Discord communities, and NFT initiatives. Users appreciate its ease of use, supportive community, and the potential for rewards and growth. Several users specifically highlighted Sesame Labs' role in making community management more efficient and enjoyable. There was an accusation of vote buying. A few comments mentioned needing better verification and task instructions.

Users criticized the product launch, accusing the team of buying upvotes and abusing the Maker's community. Several users mentioned the lack of responsiveness from the team regarding product testing and expressed concerns about the tedious screenshot verification process. Some users found the task verification unclear and requested more guidance. Additionally, the web3 community tools were deemed lacking. Accusations of abuse were made, with calls for improvement in this area.


Avatar
451
226
15.9%
0.9%
226
451
15.9%
0.9%
Relevance

Concurrence AI - Manage your communities using AI

Revolutionize community management with AI-powered filters, 24/7 uptime, multi-language support, and unlimited message handling! Enjoy flexible, low-cost plans starting at $5/month.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with numerous users congratulating Ayush and the team on the launch. Many highlighted the product's potential to solve problems, especially for community management and large group admins. Several users specifically mentioned the tool's usefulness and expressed excitement for its future success. There's also encouragement for continued development. One user noted the product isn't self-served.

The primary criticism is that the product lacks self-service capabilities. Users are finding the lack of autonomy frustrating.


Avatar
273
20
20
273
Relevance

Thrive is an open-source concierge bot for public projects

18 Jun 2024 SaaS

Hey HN! I'm excited to share our latest project called Thrive, an open-source bot designed to handle community requests, reports, and answer frequent questions. Think of it as your community concierge aid.Managing community requests can be overwhelming when the same issues and questions routinely need handling. Thrive simplifies this by tracking bugs, to-do lists, feature requests, release info, event coordination, and more. It's a smart companion that requires no configuration and is programmable by moderators.Thrive is written in TypeScript, runs on Bun, and integrates with Discord and Telegram. It uses PostgreSQL via Supabase and Fly.io for hosting. <3Our small Midwest team built Thrive to make social coordination fun and effortless. Initially for internal use, we realized its broader potential and decided to open-source it. We’re excited to share it and see how it can help your community thrive!Check out Thrive and let us know your thoughts on how we can make it more useful for day to day help. Test out the latest version by visiting us on Discord at: https://discord.gg/mWMsPshP :)


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Thrive Bot – automatically file and respond to user requests

Hey HN! I'm excited to share about Thrive, an open-source Discord and Telegram bot designed to handle community requests, reports, and answer frequent questions. Think of it as your community concierge aid. Managing community requests can be overwhelming when the same issues and questions routinely need handling. Thrive simplifies this by tracking bugs, to-do lists, feature requests, release info, event coordination, and more. It's a smart companion that requires no configuration and is programmable by moderators.Thrive is written in TypeScript, runs on Bun, and integrates with Discord and Telegram. It uses PostgreSQL via Supabase and Fly.io for hosting. <3Our small Midwest team built Thrive to make social coordination fun and effortless. Initially for internal use, we realized its broader potential and decided to open-source it. We’re excited to share it and see how it can help your community thrive!Check out Thrive and let us know your thoughts on how we can make it more useful for day to day help. Test out the latest version by visiting us on Discord: https://discord.gg/mWMsPshP


Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Albus for Community - AI-powered knowledge bot for Slack communities

A smart sidekick and buddy for all your community members in Slack. Albus learns from your Slack conversations (+ other sources) to give instant answers and handle repetitive questions. Transform your community into a knowledge hub for your members.

Albus AI's Product Hunt launch garnered overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its ability to transform Slack communities into organized knowledge hubs by efficiently answering repetitive questions and streamlining information access. Users appreciate Albus for saving time, enhancing productivity, and improving community engagement. Several users congratulated the team and expressed excitement about Albus's potential impact, with some specifically mentioning its benefits for large or confusing Slack communities. Some users inquired about integrations, knowledge base updates, and differentiation from existing Slack features, also providing feedback for future improvements.

Users find Albus confusing within Slack, citing lost messages and questioning its advantage over existing Slack tools. There are concerns about its evolution, accuracy, and relevance across different communities, plus its inability to summarize discussions. Functionality requests include linking answers to their source and implementing topic-based threads. Some users question the emphasis on Slack over Google Workspace and suggest improvements to Albus's robotic branding to create a more human feel.


Avatar
367
58
24.1%
58
367
24.1%
Relevance

Odd Circles - Community management platform

04 Sep 2024 Community

Odd Circles is a dynamic community management platform packed with features to help communities thrive. From powerful engagement tools to monetization options, we empower community managers to build, sustain, and grow vibrant, successful communities.

Odd Circles' Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users praising its comprehensive community management tools, user-friendly interface, and potential as a game-changer for community managers. Users appreciate its all-in-one nature, relieving them from tab juggling. Many are interested in monetization features, member engagement tracking, integrations (like Slack/Discord), payment gateways, and mobile app plans. Some are exploring it as a Meetup alternative. A critical issue reported is inaccessibility from India. Users inquire about onboarding, motivation behind the platform, and challenges in growth and sustainability.

Criticism includes the inaccessibility of the report service in India, suggesting potential geographical limitations. Users questioned the practicality of the tool for daily use, and proposed adding more functionality. Doubts were raised about the term 'dynamic' and its relevance to smaller communities. Finally, a user inquired about Odd Circles' data privacy and user consent practices.


Avatar
202
23
34.8%
23
202
34.8%
Relevance

Integral - Slack/Discord alternative for expert communities and orgs

New age desktop and mobile app for expert communities and organizations. Transfer specific knowledge and relationships 10x faster.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many congratulating the team, especially Sina, and expressing excitement about Integral's potential. Users praise its simplicity, intuitive UI, and focus on quality conversations, positioning it as a refreshing alternative to Slack and Discord. The Learning Loop community's move to Integral is highlighted as a success. Some users requested features like mobile apps and group chat summaries, and asked about integrations and comparisons to existing platforms. A few users reported issues such as unappealing light mode and client-side exceptions.

Users question the product's differentiation from existing platforms like Slack and Discord, with some suggesting Circle as an alternative. Key concerns include the lack of a mobile app, unclear adoption and go-to-market strategy, and doubts about suitability for small teams. The light mode appearance received criticism, and current integrations are perceived as lacking. Suggestions include a group chat summary feature. While some find Slack expensive and Discord chaotic, the video demonstration failed to highlight unique value and improvements.


Avatar
742
60
28.3%
60
742
31.7%
Relevance

Spreadify AI - Intelligent social media management hub

Streamline Your Social Media, Amplify Your Business with AI. Let us handle your online presence, so you can focus on what matters most - growing your business.

Spreadify is praised for its ease of use and effective brand promotion capabilities on social media. Users find its features useful and easy to navigate. There's excitement around Spreadify AI and its potential impact on online presence management. Users are eager to try the tool.


Avatar
42
3
100.0%
3
42
100.0%
Top