Should I Build It Should I Build It
07 May 2025
Privacy

Privacy/PII Code Scanner: A static analysis service that scans source ...

...code for personal data patterns and compliance issues. Its AI-driven engine identifies hidden PII/PHI flows and flags GDPR/HIPAA risks early drummondgroup.com . Sell this as a DevOps plugin or API: development teams subscribe to avoid costly data breaches and ensure legal compliance throughout the build process

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

Your idea for a Privacy/PII code scanner falls into the 'Freemium' category, meaning there's likely to be strong interest in using the service, but converting users to paying customers can be challenging. We found 11 similar products, indicating high confidence in this categorization and a competitive market. You're entering a space where people appreciate the value of the service, but aren't necessarily willing to pay for it upfront. The similar products have medium engagement. Focus on clearly articulating the value proposition and demonstrating how your service goes above and beyond what free alternatives offer. Given the context that your scanner identifies GDPR/HIPAA risks, it would be prudent to highlight how your solution directly addresses the costly repercussions of non-compliance.

Recommendations

  1. Since you're targeting developers (DevOps plugin or API), prioritize seamless integration with CI/CD pipelines. HoundDog.ai's launch showed that users specifically inquire about CI/CD integration. Make the process as frictionless as possible, so developers can easily incorporate your scanner into their existing workflows.
  2. Address the potential for false positives head-on. Based on feedback from Magnify.dev, LLMs sometimes 'hallucinate' vulnerabilities. Implement robust mechanisms for minimizing false positives and providing clear, actionable guidance on addressing identified issues. Offer customization for data privacy policies, as suggested by HoundDog.ai users, to increase usefulness.
  3. Offer a free tier that provides significant value, such as scanning a limited number of repositories or a subset of rules. This allows users to experience the benefits of your service firsthand and encourages adoption. Identify which users get the most value from your free version. Understanding the key metrics tied to the free version's value and utility for specific users will help guide product strategy.
  4. Develop premium features that cater to the needs of larger teams or organizations, such as enhanced reporting, role-based access control, or priority support. Create premium features that help them even more and consider charging teams rather than individuals.
  5. Explore offering personalized help or consulting services to customers who require assistance with remediation or compliance. This can be a valuable revenue stream and a way to build stronger relationships with your users. Offer personalized help or consulting to generate revenue by assisting with remediation and compliance.
  6. Consider a tiered pricing model that scales with the number of repositories, users, or scans. Test different pricing approaches with small groups and see what sticks.
  7. Given some users found the use case for similar tools unclear, focus on crystal-clear communication. Avoid jargon and acronyms (like PII) without immediate explanation, as noted in the HoundDog.ai criticism. Make sure the value proposition is easily understood by both technical and non-technical audiences.
  8. Address potential security concerns proactively. Users of similar tools have raised concerns about leaking secrets or doxxing (as seen in feedback for 'I built a tool that helps people scan and clean any repo for secrets'). Clearly articulate your security measures and data handling practices to build trust.
  9. Because there are already a few companies that do something similar, develop a unique value proposition that makes your service stand out from the competition. Focus on specializing in a specific niche, regulatory framework, or programming language.

Questions

  1. Considering the competitive landscape, what specific programming languages, regulatory frameworks (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA, CCPA), or compliance standards will your scanner prioritize to differentiate itself and cater to a specific niche within the DevOps security space?
  2. Given the potential for false positives with AI-driven code scanning, how will your service strike a balance between thoroughness and accuracy to minimize developer frustration and ensure that identified issues are genuinely actionable and not 'hallucinated' vulnerabilities?
  3. How will you address the security concerns related to potential secrets leakage or doxxing, as raised by users of similar tools, and what specific security measures and data handling practices will you implement to build trust and ensure the confidentiality of scanned code?

Your are here

Your idea for a Privacy/PII code scanner falls into the 'Freemium' category, meaning there's likely to be strong interest in using the service, but converting users to paying customers can be challenging. We found 11 similar products, indicating high confidence in this categorization and a competitive market. You're entering a space where people appreciate the value of the service, but aren't necessarily willing to pay for it upfront. The similar products have medium engagement. Focus on clearly articulating the value proposition and demonstrating how your service goes above and beyond what free alternatives offer. Given the context that your scanner identifies GDPR/HIPAA risks, it would be prudent to highlight how your solution directly addresses the costly repercussions of non-compliance.

Recommendations

  1. Since you're targeting developers (DevOps plugin or API), prioritize seamless integration with CI/CD pipelines. HoundDog.ai's launch showed that users specifically inquire about CI/CD integration. Make the process as frictionless as possible, so developers can easily incorporate your scanner into their existing workflows.
  2. Address the potential for false positives head-on. Based on feedback from Magnify.dev, LLMs sometimes 'hallucinate' vulnerabilities. Implement robust mechanisms for minimizing false positives and providing clear, actionable guidance on addressing identified issues. Offer customization for data privacy policies, as suggested by HoundDog.ai users, to increase usefulness.
  3. Offer a free tier that provides significant value, such as scanning a limited number of repositories or a subset of rules. This allows users to experience the benefits of your service firsthand and encourages adoption. Identify which users get the most value from your free version. Understanding the key metrics tied to the free version's value and utility for specific users will help guide product strategy.
  4. Develop premium features that cater to the needs of larger teams or organizations, such as enhanced reporting, role-based access control, or priority support. Create premium features that help them even more and consider charging teams rather than individuals.
  5. Explore offering personalized help or consulting services to customers who require assistance with remediation or compliance. This can be a valuable revenue stream and a way to build stronger relationships with your users. Offer personalized help or consulting to generate revenue by assisting with remediation and compliance.
  6. Consider a tiered pricing model that scales with the number of repositories, users, or scans. Test different pricing approaches with small groups and see what sticks.
  7. Given some users found the use case for similar tools unclear, focus on crystal-clear communication. Avoid jargon and acronyms (like PII) without immediate explanation, as noted in the HoundDog.ai criticism. Make sure the value proposition is easily understood by both technical and non-technical audiences.
  8. Address potential security concerns proactively. Users of similar tools have raised concerns about leaking secrets or doxxing (as seen in feedback for 'I built a tool that helps people scan and clean any repo for secrets'). Clearly articulate your security measures and data handling practices to build trust.
  9. Because there are already a few companies that do something similar, develop a unique value proposition that makes your service stand out from the competition. Focus on specializing in a specific niche, regulatory framework, or programming language.

Questions

  1. Considering the competitive landscape, what specific programming languages, regulatory frameworks (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA, CCPA), or compliance standards will your scanner prioritize to differentiate itself and cater to a specific niche within the DevOps security space?
  2. Given the potential for false positives with AI-driven code scanning, how will your service strike a balance between thoroughness and accuracy to minimize developer frustration and ensure that identified issues are genuinely actionable and not 'hallucinated' vulnerabilities?
  3. How will you address the security concerns related to potential secrets leakage or doxxing, as raised by users of similar tools, and what specific security measures and data handling practices will you implement to build trust and ensure the confidentiality of scanned code?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 11
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 4
  • Net use signal: 2.5%
    • Positive use signal: 6.0%
    • Negative use signal: 3.5%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

HoundDog.ai Static Code Scanner - Catch PII leaks in code & keep your PII inventory current

03 Oct 2024 Privacy Tech Security

HoundDog.ai static code scanner not only flags PII leaks in plaintext within logs, files, cookies, and tokens but also tracks data flows to third-party integrations, highlighting data processing agreement violations before they become production issues.

HoundDog.ai's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users highlighting its ability to track PII and prevent data leaks, crucial for compliance. The tool is seen as a game-changer for proactive security and data flow monitoring. Users inquired about CI/CD integration, false positives, customizability for data privacy policies, and whether the platform offers solutions for fixing identified PII leaks. Some users found the use case unclear for non-technical audiences. There were also questions about the motivation and problem identification behind the product.

The Product Hunt launch received criticism for not explaining the acronym PII. Users were confused about the tool's functionality, specifically if it recommends fixes or only highlights issues. Furthermore, the primary use case was unclear, particularly for non-technical users.

Avatar
310
18
5.6%
18
310
5.6%
Relevance

Scan your code to see where user data is going

28 Feb 2023 Developer Tools Security

Hey everyone! We’ve been working on a static code analysis tool to map out where user data is flowing at the code level and catch potential privacy violations; you can check it out here: https://github.com/monoid-privacy/monoid/tree/master/monoid-...To run it via CLI, use the Docker command in the README with a local directory, and the tool will scan the directory and print detected user data sources, sinks, and paths.In short, the tool converts code to a code property graph (CPG), extracts the sources and sinks from the CPG, and uses the variable/function names to determine whether the sources could contain user data & the sinks could be sensitive outputs (e.g. logs, DB, analytics/marketing tools, etc.). The output is a list of potential user data variables (the scanning is fairly robust, so it detects everything from standalone variables to class attributes) and the outputs they eventually flow to (e.g. a "first_name" variable that makes its way to Segment).The goal here is to “shift privacy left” and make it easier to find potential privacy headaches, like user data leaking into logs, earlier in the software lifecycle. The tool slots easily into CI/CD for privacy checks on every commit, and can also be run ad-hoc via the CLI.This was also a pretty exciting build from a technical perspective; OSS tooling around code graph generation and static analysis is pretty sparse (though https://github.com/Fraunhofer-AISEC/cpg offers a great foundation), so we built out a lot of code property graph generation + manipulation logic from the ground up.Feedback would be much appreciated!

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Secretsnitch, a fast, modular secret scanner in Golang

01 Nov 2024 Developer Tools

this is a tool i wrote in golang that combines a set of practices i learned over the years in finding secrets that developers commit all the time. it has easy-to-use features like modules and caching that can generate a continuous stream of data to be used for security analysis purposes (such as attack surface monitoring).part of my work involves finding exposed secrets for organizations. this tool helps you find several exposed production urls, tokens etc. on services like github and on websites. the craziest one was a leaked github personal access token from a renowned car company, and the latest one was a leaked payment gateway key from an insurance company.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Magnify.dev – AI Code Security Scanner

07 Aug 2024 Developer Tools

Hi all! I'm looking for some wisdom on a side project I started out of interest. Magnify (magnify.dev) is an AI powered code vulnerability scanner that aims to be simple, affordable, and automated. You can just upload a .zip file with your code and it'll return a PDF report containing potential security issues in your code. I'm looking for some opinions:Would you use a code security scanning service? Do you value code security or am I talking to a wall here?What would be a fair price? Currently I've priced it at 5 CAD (~3.6 freedom dollars) for 1k lines of code, but willing to go quite a bit lower. What would you be willing to pay to have 1k lines of code scanned by AI?What other features would you be interested in? Like an API, CI, etc.I'm hoping I can get some valuable opinions! And also, for the next 72 hours, I'll do scans for free so you can all get a demo! Just select the paid option and upload your code as a .zip file, but when you get to the payment page, just close it. Contact support with the the email you used and I'll approve the task manually and send you the link to the analysis after (might take a few hours, I'm pretty busy during the day).I genuinely believe that the affordability of my project can bring usefulness -- professional code security audits are often ~1k USD for 1k lines of code, so Magnify, although not as effective (yet), is literally hundreds of times cheaper. Thank you all!

Tool identifies vulnerabilities but has false positives.

LLMs hallucinate vulnerabilities, ranking issues.

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

Amplify Security – LLM-powered code fixes for your PRs within minutes

09 Sep 2024 Developer Tools

Hey HN,We recently launched a public beta for our Security code fix generation service that we've been working on for a while now here at Amplify Security, and we'd like to hear your thoughts and experience using it!Our main goal is to make developers and application security teams lives better by fixing vulnerable code /before/ it enters a code base, but if its already there we can still help you out with that. Our service lets users use battle-tested, open-source static analysis tools like Semgrep OSS or paid solutions (coming soon) to identify vulnerabilities, and then leverages AI Agents to provide actionable code fixes directly within a pull request. We also have a little knowledge base at https://docs.amplify.security/ that goes a bit more into detail about how it all works.We support repositories hosted on GitHub and GitLab Hosted, via their respective CI infrastructure, so feel free to try it out on one of your repos by signing up at https://app.amplify.security!

Avatar
4
4
Relevance

Open-source tool to find PII across data silos

03 Feb 2023 Developer Tools

Hey everyone! I’ve been working on a tool to scan for and map PII across DBs/warehouses/SaaS’s, as well as to automate user data deletion/export in these silos; right now it integrates with ~10 different data silos.It’s locally deployable, so you can spin it up privately and make a map of where sensitive data is fairly quickly. It’s also extensible; you can add new connectors easily (following our connector development guide at https://docs.monoid.co), though we’re also adding new connectors weekly. If you'd like to play with the tool without having to deploy, you can check out a read-only demo at https://demo.monoid.coWe’re hoping that this provides a solid foundation for teams that build internal maps of user data for CCPA/GDPR compliance, and who aren’t fans of using cloud solutions (e.g. OneTrust) to integrate with sensitive data silos.Feedback would be much appreciated!

Avatar
3
3
Relevance

BugDazz - Shift API Security Left

17 Oct 2024 API Developer Tools Security

Avoid security headaches by integrating an API security scanner in your CI/CD or uploading your OpenAPI spec early. Our scan engine helps dev & security teams find BOLA issues, benchmarked with open-source tools. You're covered for OWASP, NIST, HIPAA, & PCI.

BugDazz API Scanner is introduced as an on-premise solution for developers and DevSecOps, praised as a top API scanning platform delivering excellent performance and results. Users highlight its importance for API security, emphasizing its capabilities in CI/CD, SSO, and compliance. It's considered a crucial tool for API protection, ensuring top-tier security and filling a significant gap in the market.

Avatar
12
6
6
12
Relevance

AI-CodeWise – Transforming Code Reviews with AI-Powered Analysis

10 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence Developer Tools

Say goodbye to slow code reviews! Introducing AI-CodeWise, an AI-powered code reviewer transforming code quality & security. Harness the power of OpenAI API for comprehensive reviews & suggested fixes.We have compared its results with those of existing Static Application Security Testing (SAST) and Infrastructure as Code (IaC) scanner tools. AI-CodeWise differentiates itself from these tools by offering the following advantages: 1. All-in-One Review: Detects code smells, best practice violations, & security issues across languages for versatile code review. 2. Unforeseen Issue Detection: AI-powered for discovering issues that rule-based systems might miss, ensuring thorough code analysis. 3. Fix Suggestions: Offers code change suggestions directly in PR comments, empowering developers to resolve issues efficiently, boosting code quality & securityWould love to hear your feedback!

Avatar
2
2
Top