Should I Build It Should I Build It
21 Mar 2025
Personal Finance Fintech Investing

A service providing personalized financial advice and investment ...

...strategies based on individual goals, risk tolerance, and life circumstances, for people just starting out.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your idea for personalized financial advice for beginners enters a challenging market space we classify as a 'Swamp'. We found 15 similar products, indicating high competition and confirming this is a well-trodden path. Generally, these similar products show low engagement, with an average of only 3 comments, suggesting many existing solutions haven't captured significant user enthusiasm or differentiation. However, there's a crucial bright spot: the metrics reveal an exceptionally strong 'Net buy signal' for ideas like yours, placing it in the top 5% of products analyzed. This means despite the crowded field and mediocre past attempts, a segment of users expresses a clear willingness to pay for a solution in this space if it truly meets their needs. Your challenge is significant: you must create something fundamentally better or different to avoid blending in, but the strong buy signal indicates a genuine, payable demand exists if you can successfully tap into it, particularly for beginners who often feel underserved by complex or generic tools.

Recommendations

  1. Deeply investigate why the 15+ similar products haven't achieved breakout success despite the potential demand. Analyze their shortcomings based on user feedback (e.g., complexity like Zactor, limited US-only scope like Maybe). What specific user needs are consistently unmet that create this 'buy' signal?
  2. Sharpen your niche beyond just 'beginners'. Identify a specific type of beginner (e.g., gig workers, recent grads with student debt, first-time investors in a specific region) and tailor the 'personalization' aspect to their unique financial context and challenges. Generic advice won't cut through the noise.
  3. Focus relentlessly on simplicity and user experience. Competitor feedback highlights criticism around complexity (Zactor) and praise for good UI (Maybe). For beginners, an intuitive, non-intimidating interface is paramount. How can you make financial planning feel accessible, not overwhelming?
  4. Address the 'personalization' promise concretely. How will your service deliver advice that is demonstrably more tailored and actionable than competitors or free resources? Define what data points are crucial for this personalization and how you'll translate them into clear, trustworthy strategies for someone starting out.
  5. Validate the specific value proposition tied to the strong 'buy signal'. What exact feature, outcome, or feeling of security are users willing to pay for? Is it the specific advice, the curated investment options, the feeling of control, or something else? Test this hypothesis early before building extensively.
  6. Develop a clear go-to-market strategy that acknowledges the high competition. How will you reach your specific beginner niche effectively and affordably? Content marketing focused on beginner financial literacy? Partnerships with relevant communities or platforms? Highlight your unique differentiator from the outset.
  7. Carefully consider geographic scope and regulatory hurdles. Financial advice is often region-specific (as seen in Maybe's feedback). Define your target market(s) clearly and ensure you can adequately support users and comply with regulations within those areas. Limited support was a key criticism for competitors.

Questions

  1. Given the high number of existing competitors and their low engagement, what specific, critical failure point in their offerings creates the powerful 'buy' signal you can capitalize on, making beginners choose (and pay for) your solution over established free or freemium tools?
  2. How will your 'personalization' for beginners go significantly beyond simple risk tolerance questionnaires or goal setting to address their likely low financial literacy and unique life circumstances in a way that builds immediate trust and justifies a paid service?
  3. Considering the 'Swamp' nature of this category and competitor issues like complexity (Zactor) and limited support (Maybe), what is your tangible plan to ensure your product is radically simpler, more trustworthy, and provides truly actionable guidance that avoids the pitfalls others have fallen into?

Your are here

Your idea for personalized financial advice for beginners enters a challenging market space we classify as a 'Swamp'. We found 15 similar products, indicating high competition and confirming this is a well-trodden path. Generally, these similar products show low engagement, with an average of only 3 comments, suggesting many existing solutions haven't captured significant user enthusiasm or differentiation. However, there's a crucial bright spot: the metrics reveal an exceptionally strong 'Net buy signal' for ideas like yours, placing it in the top 5% of products analyzed. This means despite the crowded field and mediocre past attempts, a segment of users expresses a clear willingness to pay for a solution in this space if it truly meets their needs. Your challenge is significant: you must create something fundamentally better or different to avoid blending in, but the strong buy signal indicates a genuine, payable demand exists if you can successfully tap into it, particularly for beginners who often feel underserved by complex or generic tools.

Recommendations

  1. Deeply investigate why the 15+ similar products haven't achieved breakout success despite the potential demand. Analyze their shortcomings based on user feedback (e.g., complexity like Zactor, limited US-only scope like Maybe). What specific user needs are consistently unmet that create this 'buy' signal?
  2. Sharpen your niche beyond just 'beginners'. Identify a specific type of beginner (e.g., gig workers, recent grads with student debt, first-time investors in a specific region) and tailor the 'personalization' aspect to their unique financial context and challenges. Generic advice won't cut through the noise.
  3. Focus relentlessly on simplicity and user experience. Competitor feedback highlights criticism around complexity (Zactor) and praise for good UI (Maybe). For beginners, an intuitive, non-intimidating interface is paramount. How can you make financial planning feel accessible, not overwhelming?
  4. Address the 'personalization' promise concretely. How will your service deliver advice that is demonstrably more tailored and actionable than competitors or free resources? Define what data points are crucial for this personalization and how you'll translate them into clear, trustworthy strategies for someone starting out.
  5. Validate the specific value proposition tied to the strong 'buy signal'. What exact feature, outcome, or feeling of security are users willing to pay for? Is it the specific advice, the curated investment options, the feeling of control, or something else? Test this hypothesis early before building extensively.
  6. Develop a clear go-to-market strategy that acknowledges the high competition. How will you reach your specific beginner niche effectively and affordably? Content marketing focused on beginner financial literacy? Partnerships with relevant communities or platforms? Highlight your unique differentiator from the outset.
  7. Carefully consider geographic scope and regulatory hurdles. Financial advice is often region-specific (as seen in Maybe's feedback). Define your target market(s) clearly and ensure you can adequately support users and comply with regulations within those areas. Limited support was a key criticism for competitors.

Questions

  1. Given the high number of existing competitors and their low engagement, what specific, critical failure point in their offerings creates the powerful 'buy' signal you can capitalize on, making beginners choose (and pay for) your solution over established free or freemium tools?
  2. How will your 'personalization' for beginners go significantly beyond simple risk tolerance questionnaires or goal setting to address their likely low financial literacy and unique life circumstances in a way that builds immediate trust and justifies a paid service?
  3. Considering the 'Swamp' nature of this category and competitor issues like complexity (Zactor) and limited support (Maybe), what is your tangible plan to ensure your product is radically simpler, more trustworthy, and provides truly actionable guidance that avoids the pitfalls others have fallen into?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 15
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: 30.2%
    • Positive use signal: 30.2%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 1.9%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.9%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

The AI Personal Financial Adviser – Your Investment Professional

14 Nov 2023 Artificial Intelligence

Hey Hacker News community!I'm excited to share a project that I've been working on, an AI-driven Personal Financial Adviser. It's designed to democratize access to personalized financial advice, leveraging advanced AI capabilities to cater to individual financial goals and risk tolerances.Key Features:Personalized Financial Advice: Whether you're planning investments, savings, or retirement, this AI adviser tailors its guidance to your unique financial situation.Interactive Financial Planning: Engages users with targeted questions, ensuring advice is aligned with their specific goals and risk profile.Advanced Financial Modelling: Utilizes the code interpreter for budgeting, forecasting, and market analysis, providing insights that are usually accessible only to professional advisers.Dynamic Risk Assessment: Understands and communicates risks, helping users make informed decisions and mitigate potential financial pitfalls.Downloadable Data Models: Offers the ability to download personalized financial plans in Excel format, enabling users to not only view but interact with their financial data.Continuous Learning and Adaptation: This AI adviser learns from user interactions, continuously improving its advice and recommendations.Why It Matters:In a world where financial advice is often gated behind high fees or generalized robo-advisors, this project aims to bridge the gap, offering nuanced, personalized advice at scale. It's not just about algorithms and numbers; it's about understanding individual user stories and financial journeys.Seeking Your Feedback:I'm looking for feedback from the HN community. Whether you're a financial expert, tech enthusiast, or someone interested in AI's role in personal finance, I'd love to hear your thoughts:How can this tool be more effective for your personal financial planning?What features would you like to see in the future? Any other feedback or ideas you have!Check out the demo https://chat.openai.com/g/g-9OxH4jCax-personal-financial-adv... and let's discuss how AI can revolutionize personal finance!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Maybe - Modern financial planning & wealth management

24 Jan 2023 Personal Finance Fintech Money

Your financial future, in your control! Track all of your accounts in one place, simulate scenarios, get advice from qualified financial advisors and much more. All for a transparent, flat monthly price. No percentages or hidden fees!

Many users congratulated the team on the launch of Maybe, expressing excitement for its potential in financial control and organization, with some highlighting its superior features compared to Mint or Quicken. The user interface and design received considerable praise, including specific appreciation for the dark theme. There were requests for international access, particularly for the UK, Australia, and Canada, as well as support for more financial institutions (beyond IBKR). Users also inquired about features like net worth tracking with real estate assets and the ability to manually create and include assets.

Users criticized the product for its limited availability, specifically being restricted to the US without clear upfront notification. There's frustration with the lack of international account support, including the UK and Romania. Some users expressed difficulty in finding an advisor, and the reliance on Personal Capital was not universally appealing. The 12-month return policy received mixed reactions. The limited connectivity to only Interactive Brokers was also a drawback.

Avatar
357
30
46.7%
3.3%
30
357
46.7%
3.3%
Relevance

Sound Advice App - Personalized Financial Advice

06 Oct 2023 Android Fintech Investing

Sound Advice is a mobile app designed to make building wealth accessible for today’s generation. We believe money is for everyone. Including you.

SoundAdvice's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and praising the app's potential to promote financial freedom. There's excitement about potential partnerships with non-profits for financial literacy programs. A user inquired about the target audience and potential integrations, indicating interest in the app's practical application and broader usability.

Avatar
96
5
5
96
Relevance

FinanceRants' Personalized AI Platform for Better Money Decisions

25 Jun 2024 Artificial Intelligence Personal Finance Fintech Money

FinanceRants helps individuals understand and improve their financial behaviors by using AI to provide personalized insights and strategies based on their unique financial personalities. By addressing the common issues of financial stress, poor money management, and lack of financial literacy, FinanceRants empowers users to make informed financial decisions, achieve financial stability, and enhance their overall well-being. Our platform offers tailored advice, budgeting tools, and investment strategies, making finance accessible and manageable for everyone .

FinanceRants uses AI for personalized financial insights and strategies.

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

FinWise – The modern way to manage your personal finances

30 Oct 2023 Personal Finance Fintech

Hi everyone, I'd like to share FinWise (https://finwiseapp.io) with you, which my wife and I have been building over the last few months.FinWise is an all-in-one personal finance management tool, including budgeting, net-worth tracking, financial planning & forecasting and a couple of other things which we're still busy working on like couples/family budgeting and being able to set and track goals.It's designed to make managing all your personal finances as simple, easy and painless as possible, and we've put a lot of effort into making the website as simple and intuitive, whilst still being powerful and offering a comprehensive set of personal finance tools.A non-exhaustive list of things you can do with FinWise:- Connect your bank & investments accounts with Plaid & Yodlee (Or manual imports). - Currently US, CA and ZA. EU, NZ, AU and others coming soon!- Track and visualize your net-worth.- Budget and save money.- AI transaction categorization (You almost never have to manually categorize your transactions).- Transaction splitting, tags, notes and attachments.- Import transactions with CSV files from Mint/Empower etc.- Export account, transaction and insights data to CSV.- Plan, project and forecast your future finances (In beta).- Spending, saving and net-worth insights and analytics.- Multi-currency support.- Goals and goal-tracking (Coming soon).- Developer API access (Coming soon).- iOS/Android app (Coming soon).- Privacy-focused. No ads, selling data or anything like that.- Just about SOC2 and ISO compliant (No certificates yet, but I've done a few SOC2 certifications in the past.)We made FinWise because we were not able to find a personal finance tool out there which offered all the features we wanted, and which was simple, intuitive and easy to use. There are lots of personal finances apps around, but we felt most were either too basic, over-complicated or too expensive, or limiting in some way.We're now on a mission to build the best personal finance app out there, and to help as many people as possible to better save, grow and manage their money.If you'd like to learn more and try it out, head over to our website: https://finwiseapp.ioIf you have any feedback or questions, please let me know :)Find us on X/Twitter: Me: https://twitter.com/jasrusable Nicol: https://twitter.com/NicolNvojacek FinWise: https://twitter.com/FinwiseappPS: There are some interesting technical aspects of the project that we are particularly proud of which I am planning to do more in-depth posts on soon, namely:- How we implemented our AI transaction categorization system.- How we built the entire website to use optimistic loading, so no loading states.- How we kept the codebases extremely simple and intuitive, allowing us to move quickly.- Going open source once we hit critical mass.

Avatar
9
9
Relevance

FinanceFit - Shape your wealth: Personal finance made for all

26 Feb 2024 Education Money Online Learning

Discover a revolutionary personal financial course that helps you achieve your financial goals and secure your future with ease within a very short time.

FinanceFit's Product Hunt launch is celebrated, with one user expressing happiness about the hunt. The tool is considered helpful for young adults managing their personal finances. Congratulations are extended to @efan13 on the launch.

Avatar
7
2
50.0%
2
7
50.0%
Relevance

Zactor - Comprehensive personal finance platform

13 Apr 2024 Android Fintech Investing

Looking to manage personal finance, plan for goals and retirement, make better investment decisions. We offer an all-in-one platform that provides personalised insights and actionable recommendations to improve your financial health.

The Product Hunt launch received congratulations and well wishes from users. One user suggested simplifying the tool, referencing the FIRE calculator in NomadList. Another user inquired about the tool's global or region-based functionality. Several users expressed interest in trying the app and wished the team luck with the launch and its mission of financial empowerment.

The main criticism is a need for simplification, with a user suggesting it should emulate the ease of use found in the FIRE calculator on NomadList by Levelsio.

Avatar
73
4
25.0%
4
73
25.0%
Relevance

Personal CFO - Your ultimate financial companion

09 Jun 2023 Personal Finance iOS Budgeting

Empower your financial journey with Personal CFO. Gain insights, make informed decisions, and achieve goals. Manage money effectively with intuitive features and a user-friendly interface.

Users are congratulating Adam on the launch of Personal CFO. One user specifically mentions that Personal CFO is an invaluable tool for getting finances in order. The comments are short and positive, expressing general support and appreciation for the launch.

Avatar
79
3
3
79
Top