Should I Build It Should I Build It
26 Apr 2025
Advertising Marketing

Software to automate Facebook and Instagram ads. It saves time and is ...

...more user friendly to create and manage your ads.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

You're entering a competitive space with your software to automate Facebook and Instagram ads; there are at least 18 similar products in the market, so there's definitely interest in this area. The good news is that the engagement for similar products is medium, with an average of 5 comments per product launch. This indicates people are interested and sharing feedback. Your idea falls into the "Freemium" category, which means users are likely to appreciate the functionality but may resist paying for it. The challenge will be to identify the core features that users value enough to upgrade to a paid version, while also dealing with the competition from existing tools and the constant changes in the advertising landscape.

Recommendations

  1. Start by deeply understanding your target audience and their specific pain points with Facebook and Instagram ads. Don't make any assumptions. Conduct user interviews, analyze existing solutions, and identify gaps in the market. Many users struggle with Facebook ads, and automation is a valuable solution, so make sure you understand exactly which parts of the ad creation and management workflow they would like to automate.
  2. Since users are resistant to pay for these tools, focus on delivering exceptional value with the free version to attract a large user base. Given feedback from similar products, focus on features like streamlined campaign creation, easy management, and potentially a calendar view for ad scheduling. Then, offer a compelling reason to upgrade, such as advanced analytics, A/B testing, personalized support, or integrations with other marketing tools.
  3. Based on the idea category, identify which users get the most value from the free versions. Focus on those users and collect as much feedback as possible. Then, create premium features that help those users even more. For instance, if small businesses with limited marketing expertise benefit from the free version, a premium feature could include AI-powered ad copy generation or automated budget optimization. This also solves the user need that Facebook ads are challenging.
  4. Consider charging teams rather than individual users. This aligns with the business value proposition of saving time and improving efficiency. Explore features like team collaboration, user roles and permissions, and shared ad libraries to make your product appealing to larger organizations with more complex advertising needs. Also, remember the user that was uncertain about creating Facebook ads and questioned how to identify the target audience. That might be a good signal that there is potential to charge teams if personalized help and consulting is part of your offer.
  5. Offer personalized help or consulting as part of a premium plan. Many users struggle with the complexities of Facebook and Instagram advertising, and they might be willing to pay for expert guidance to improve their ROI. This also addresses the criticism that existing tools are unpolished and rough, so ensure you are always delivering a polished and professional experience.
  6. Test different pricing approaches with small groups of users. Experiment with freemium models, tiered pricing, usage-based pricing, and value-based pricing. Don't be afraid to iterate and adjust your pricing strategy based on user feedback and market trends.
  7. Address the common criticisms found in similar product launches. For example, users often request integration with other social media platforms, A/B testing capabilities, and more comprehensive information about the product. By actively addressing these concerns, you can differentiate your product and gain a competitive edge.
  8. Actively monitor user feedback and engage with your community. Respond to comments, address concerns, and incorporate user suggestions into your product roadmap. This will help you build a loyal user base and ensure that your product continues to meet their evolving needs. This can be achieved by ChatGPT integration that other users are requesting.

Questions

  1. Given the competitive landscape, what specific niche or target audience will you focus on to differentiate your product and avoid becoming just another 'me-too' solution?
  2. How will you balance the need to provide valuable features in the free version with the need to incentivize users to upgrade to a paid plan, especially considering the "Freemium" category's tendency for users to resist paying?
  3. Considering the criticisms of similar products (lack of polish, integration issues, insufficient information), what specific steps will you take to ensure your product is user-friendly, well-integrated, and provides clear value to its users?

Your are here

You're entering a competitive space with your software to automate Facebook and Instagram ads; there are at least 18 similar products in the market, so there's definitely interest in this area. The good news is that the engagement for similar products is medium, with an average of 5 comments per product launch. This indicates people are interested and sharing feedback. Your idea falls into the "Freemium" category, which means users are likely to appreciate the functionality but may resist paying for it. The challenge will be to identify the core features that users value enough to upgrade to a paid version, while also dealing with the competition from existing tools and the constant changes in the advertising landscape.

Recommendations

  1. Start by deeply understanding your target audience and their specific pain points with Facebook and Instagram ads. Don't make any assumptions. Conduct user interviews, analyze existing solutions, and identify gaps in the market. Many users struggle with Facebook ads, and automation is a valuable solution, so make sure you understand exactly which parts of the ad creation and management workflow they would like to automate.
  2. Since users are resistant to pay for these tools, focus on delivering exceptional value with the free version to attract a large user base. Given feedback from similar products, focus on features like streamlined campaign creation, easy management, and potentially a calendar view for ad scheduling. Then, offer a compelling reason to upgrade, such as advanced analytics, A/B testing, personalized support, or integrations with other marketing tools.
  3. Based on the idea category, identify which users get the most value from the free versions. Focus on those users and collect as much feedback as possible. Then, create premium features that help those users even more. For instance, if small businesses with limited marketing expertise benefit from the free version, a premium feature could include AI-powered ad copy generation or automated budget optimization. This also solves the user need that Facebook ads are challenging.
  4. Consider charging teams rather than individual users. This aligns with the business value proposition of saving time and improving efficiency. Explore features like team collaboration, user roles and permissions, and shared ad libraries to make your product appealing to larger organizations with more complex advertising needs. Also, remember the user that was uncertain about creating Facebook ads and questioned how to identify the target audience. That might be a good signal that there is potential to charge teams if personalized help and consulting is part of your offer.
  5. Offer personalized help or consulting as part of a premium plan. Many users struggle with the complexities of Facebook and Instagram advertising, and they might be willing to pay for expert guidance to improve their ROI. This also addresses the criticism that existing tools are unpolished and rough, so ensure you are always delivering a polished and professional experience.
  6. Test different pricing approaches with small groups of users. Experiment with freemium models, tiered pricing, usage-based pricing, and value-based pricing. Don't be afraid to iterate and adjust your pricing strategy based on user feedback and market trends.
  7. Address the common criticisms found in similar product launches. For example, users often request integration with other social media platforms, A/B testing capabilities, and more comprehensive information about the product. By actively addressing these concerns, you can differentiate your product and gain a competitive edge.
  8. Actively monitor user feedback and engage with your community. Respond to comments, address concerns, and incorporate user suggestions into your product roadmap. This will help you build a loyal user base and ensure that your product continues to meet their evolving needs. This can be achieved by ChatGPT integration that other users are requesting.

Questions

  1. Given the competitive landscape, what specific niche or target audience will you focus on to differentiate your product and avoid becoming just another 'me-too' solution?
  2. How will you balance the need to provide valuable features in the free version with the need to incentivize users to upgrade to a paid plan, especially considering the "Freemium" category's tendency for users to resist paying?
  3. Considering the criticisms of similar products (lack of polish, integration issues, insufficient information), what specific steps will you take to ensure your product is user-friendly, well-integrated, and provides clear value to its users?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 18
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 5
  • Net use signal: 16.5%
    • Positive use signal: 17.8%
    • Negative use signal: 1.3%
  • Net buy signal: -0.1%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.2%
    • Negative buy signal: 1.3%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

blanco.ai (YC S23) Ad Management. Automated

13 Mar 2023 Advertising Marketing

Hi I am Orlando founder of blanco (https://www.blanco-media.ai/). Were automate social media ad management for small businesses. We have taken the advertising agency model of managing ads and put it into a software product. We provide far greater performance as we can analyse data 24/7 have 98% lower costs than agencies (we start at just $49/month compared to agencies at $2.5-$12k/month) and you can get started in just 10 minutes with our streamlined onboarding.We have made and end to end solution from creating the ads to managing the ads. Ad copy is done by GPT-3 so you can just type in your first ideal version and then we will generate multiple others. We allow you to create graphic ads on our site using our ad generator, creating high quality, converting ads for your business.For managing ads dynamically A/B test all of your title, image and description combinations to see what preforms best with your target audience and then optimise the budget to the ads that preform well. We also look at metrics like cost-per-action to optimise ads which convert your desired goal (e.g. product sales) for the lowest price possible.So far we have over 100 small businesses effectively managing their ad campaigns with us. Providing greater performance for a fraction of the price. I saw that agencies were expensive and ineffective and so I created blanco.If you need to run ads for your website or business then we would love to hear feedback from you. The first month is free only for the next 5 days.https://www.blanco-media.ai/

The comments clarify the business count, YC status, and upcoming updates. Users reported issues with username, password, email, and website links. One user mentioned launching their product soon and expressed interest in trying and emailing the service.

The product is criticized for being unpolished and rough, leading users to feel it is a waste of time and money. Additionally, there is confusion about its YC status that needs clarification.

Avatar
3
3
0.0%
-33.3%
3
3
33.3%
Relevance

ADXL - Set Your Marketing on Autopilot with AI Driven Automation

05 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence Marketing automation Marketing

ADXL unifies FB, IG, TikTok, Twitter & LinkedIn for effortless ads with peak results. Save time & cost. Now introducing Instant Lead Ads - one form syncs across FB, IG & LinkedIn. ADXL, your ultimate sales & leads engine since 2022.

Users express positive sentiments towards ADXL, recognizing it as a comprehensive digital marketing solution. One user congratulates the team on the launch and encourages continued effort. There is general agreement that the product is valuable and intuitive. A suggestion was made to list the product in a relevant directory category to increase visibility.

Avatar
83
4
4
83
Relevance

Colocio Ai - Create, evaluate and automate your ads, social media & PPC

22 Jul 2024 Artificial Intelligence Social media marketing Marketing

Your end-to-end copilot- Create high-converting ad copy and social media content instantly. Schedule posts effortlessly across platforms for maximum reach. Receive real-time guidance, and access valuable insights and analytics to optimize your campaigns

Colocio AI's Product Hunt launch is receiving positive feedback, with users praising its streamlined marketing efforts, easy campaign creation and management, and the calendar view for tracking ad schedules. The tool's ability to automate ad creation and content management using AI, including generating high-converting ad copy, is also appreciated. Some users inquire about social media platform support (specifically Facebook/Instagram) and API limitations. A suggestion was made to include A/B testing for ad optimization. Several users congratulated the team on the successful launch.

Users have expressed the need for A/B testing functionality, which is currently absent from the product. This feature request indicates a desire for more advanced testing and optimization capabilities.

Avatar
112
15
20.0%
15
112
20.0%
Relevance

M1-project - AI driven copy and targeting for your Facebook ads

27 Feb 2024 Artificial Intelligence Advertising Marketing

Unlock unique, ready-to-use Facebook Ads and targeting recommendations tailored to your brand and audience. Create your advertising assets without overspending time and money.

The M1-project launch on Product Hunt received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating Igor and the team. Users praised the tool's potential to revolutionize Facebook advertising, improve ad ROI, simplify campaign creation, and save time. Several users highlighted its effectiveness, usefulness for small businesses and its innovative approach. Some users inquired about AI adaptation, integration with other apps, and reel advertisement creation. There's a sentiment that Facebook ads are challenging, and the tool is a valuable solution, and a game-changer.

Users have criticized the platform's lack of integration with other social media platforms. Several users also mentioned difficulties and low ROI associated with advertising, particularly on Facebook (especially for premium products in Germany) and Google Ads, citing issues such as complexity and a lack of streamlining. There is a need for automated ad optimization, with a focus on attracting paying customers and the need to solve the challenge of creating effective Facebook campaigns.

Avatar
311
38
23.7%
2.6%
38
311
23.7%
2.6%
Relevance

SocialMate - Facebook and Instagram AI automation

01 Apr 2023 Instagram Facebook Messenger Bots

Automate & Combine Facebook Messenger, Instagram Direct, Email and SMS Marketing to Grow Your Business with the power of OpenAI.

Users are expressing interest in SocialMate, praising it as an amazing AI automation tool. One user requests more information about post planning and lead generation. Another user gives positive feedback and inquires about potential ChatGPT integration to further enhance the tool's capabilities.

The primary criticism is a lack of sufficient detail and information about the product. Users are requesting more comprehensive information to fully understand its features and benefits.

Avatar
65
3
3
65
Relevance

Adout.ai - Turn words into display ads

01 Apr 2023 Artificial Intelligence

Adout.ai is an AI-powered ad creation tool for small agencies and startups. Its features include user-friendly ad input, audience insights, engaging visuals and copy, and customization options.

Users congratulate the launch, expressing excitement about the tool's ability to find new creatives. Some users encountered errors. There are questions about using stock photos, modifying generated text, and the campaign creation time. Several users simply showed interest in the product and wanted to learn more.

Users experienced errors during the Product Hunt launch, potentially due to a surge in traffic. This was the primary criticism mentioned.

Avatar
108
8
25.0%
8
108
25.0%
Relevance

Ad Morph AI: Your Creative Companion for Crafting Ads

23 Sep 2023 Artificial Intelligence Advertising Marketing

Hello Hacker News!We're excited to introduce our latest project, Ad Morph AI, a groundbreaking tool designed to revolutionize the way people create advertisements. In a world where digital marketing is constantly evolving, crafting visually captivating ads that resonate with your target audience can be a daunting task. Ad Morph AI is here to make this process easier and more effective!The Challenge: Creating impactful advertisements often requires a keen eye for design, a deep understanding of your audience, and the ability to incorporate feedback effectively. Yet, many individuals and businesses struggle with this, and obtaining objective, timely feedback can be a significant hurdle.The Solution: Ad Morph AI Ad Morph AI is a user-friendly web platform that simplifies ad creation and provides honest, AI-powered feedback on your ad images. Here's how it works:Upload Your Image: Start by uploading your ad image to our platform.Once your image is uploaded, we leverage Bard, Google's advanced AI, to analyze the image. Bard provides expert insights on various aspects of your ad, including composition, color schemes, text readability, and emotional impact.Receive Honest Feedback: Ad Morph AI provides you with detailed and unbiased feedback based on Bard's analysis. This feedback helps you understand what's working well in your ad and what might need improvement.Generate New Images: Ad Morph AI also offers a feature to generate new ad images using AI, incorporating the feedback provided by Bard. This empowers users to explore alternative creative directions effortlessly.Why Ad Morph AI Matters:Democratizing Ad Creation: Ad Morph AI democratizes the ad creation process, making AI-driven feedback and improvement accessible to everyone, from seasoned marketers to small businesses and startups.Time and Resource Savings: Say goodbye to waiting for subjective feedback or spending hours in trial-and-error. Ad Morph AI accelerates the ad creation process, saving you time and resources.Data-Driven Decision Making: With Ad Morph AI, you can make data-driven decisions. Understand why an ad works or doesn't and optimize your creative process accordingly.Join the Ad Morph AI Community:We invite the Hacker News community to be a part of Ad Morph AI's journey. Try out our platform, share your thoughts, and help us refine and expand our offerings. Together, we can transform ad creation and empower individuals and businesses to create compelling advertisements that stand out in today's competitive landscape.Visit Ad Morph AI today and take the first step toward creating ads that captivate and convert.Thank you for your support and feedback as we embark on this exciting venture!Happy hacking,

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Automate and Generate Facebook Posts

28 May 2024 Social Media Marketing

I have my own software service that I promote to people on Facebook but got tired of manually posting. Created a post scheduler that does it for me. Might be useful to you too. Enjoyhttps://facebookpostscheduler.com/

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

AuditEZ : Facebook Ad Reporting & Audits - Facebook Ads Audit and Reporting tool for eCommerce

03 Nov 2023 Data & Analytics Advertising Social Network

Tired of spending hours on Facebook Ads reporting? Save time and win back billable hours by automating your reporting. ✅ Automated Reporting ✅ KPIs color coding ✅ Scheduled Emails ✅ Live Dashboards ✅ Easy to Use ✅ White Labeling

A user expressed uncertainty about creating Facebook ads and questioned how to identify the target audience. Another user gave positive feedback about the product. One comment was deleted.

A user questioned whether the product's target audience is exclusively ad agencies, which may suggest concerns about the product's broader applicability or market appeal.

Avatar
70
3
3
70
Relevance

Automate your social media workflow

11 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity Marketing

BrandSync AI is a platform that automates your social media workflow. Bring in any documents: (catalogs, code, technical documents, etc.) and let BrandSync AI create platform optimized social media posts for you in seconds.

Users are discussing BrandSync AI for social media content generation. There is a need for a solution that allows crossposting to all platforms. One user mentioned that Facebook makes it harder to crosspost, suggesting that easier crossposting would result in fewer ads.

The main criticism is that Facebook complicates the process, making it more difficult to find a single solution.

Avatar
3
3
3
3
Top