Should I Build It Should I Build It
21 Mar 2025
Artificial Intelligence Cooking Food & Drink Health & Fitness

An AI-powered tool that generates personalized recipes based on user's ...

...dietary restrictions, ingredient preferences, and available ingredients, helping them to cook healthy and delicious meals at home.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your idea for an AI-powered personalized recipe generator tackles a common desire: making home cooking easier, healthier, and tailored to individual needs. The concept itself clearly resonates, as evidenced by the significant number (29) of similar products already launched. This high number confirms you've hit on a popular problem area, but it also means you're entering a very crowded space, categorized as a 'Swamp'. This market currently features many tools, but none seem to have truly captured widespread user love or strong engagement (indicated by the low average comment volume and lack of clear 'use' or 'buy' signals for similar products). Essentially, many have tried, but few have deeply succeeded. Standing out will require more than just a functional AI recipe generator; it demands a genuinely unique value proposition or a focus on a segment currently ignored by the existing mediocre solutions.

Recommendations

  1. Deeply investigate why the 29+ existing AI recipe tools haven't achieved breakout success. Analyze user reviews and the criticisms summarized (e.g., lack of specific measurements, poor dietary filtering, UI bugs, generic outputs). What core user needs are consistently unmet despite the numerous attempts? Don't just replicate features; understand the failures.
  2. Identify a hyper-specific, underserved niche instead of aiming for broad personalization. Could you excel at recipes for complex medical dietary needs (e.g., renal, low-FODMAP), specific athletic performance goals, or perhaps families managing multiple allergies simultaneously? The criticisms about missing dietary filters (keto, vegan, gluten-free, micronutrients) hint at these unmet needs. Generic personalization is already a crowded field.
  3. Explore pivoting towards building enabling technology rather than a consumer-facing app. Could you develop a superior AI recipe generation engine or ingredient analysis module and license it to established players like grocery delivery apps, meal kit services, or large recipe websites? This avoids direct competition in the 'Swamp'.
  4. Consider tackling adjacent, potentially less crowded problems where your AI expertise could shine. Examples include advanced meal planning with automated grocery list generation and integration, AI-driven food waste reduction tools that excel at using near-expiration items, or tools that intelligently adapt existing beloved recipes to meet new dietary constraints.
  5. Critically assess if this specific idea, in its current form, is the best use of your resources given the high competition and low demonstrated engagement for similar products. Unless you have identified a truly unique angle or technology that addresses the known shortcomings (like providing precise measurements, handling complex dietary interactions flawlessly, or offering a radically better UX), reconsider pursuing this exact path. The 'Swamp' category strongly advises against building without significant differentiation.

Questions

  1. Given that users can already use powerful tools like ChatGPT for basic recipe generation, and face 29+ specialized competitors, what specific, unique value will make users choose your tool and potentially pay for it, especially when similar products show low engagement and no strong buy signals?
  2. Many existing tools face criticism for lacking detailed measurements, specific dietary options (like micronutrients), and seamless integration (e.g., grocery lists). How will your AI fundamentally overcome these specific, known shortcomings where others have failed?
  3. Instead of directly competing, have you mapped out the specific underserved niches (e.g., clinical nutrition needs, extreme budget constraints, ethical sourcing priorities) and validated whether those users have a pain point severe enough that existing solutions don't solve and they'd actively seek out and adopt your specialized tool?

Your are here

Your idea for an AI-powered personalized recipe generator tackles a common desire: making home cooking easier, healthier, and tailored to individual needs. The concept itself clearly resonates, as evidenced by the significant number (29) of similar products already launched. This high number confirms you've hit on a popular problem area, but it also means you're entering a very crowded space, categorized as a 'Swamp'. This market currently features many tools, but none seem to have truly captured widespread user love or strong engagement (indicated by the low average comment volume and lack of clear 'use' or 'buy' signals for similar products). Essentially, many have tried, but few have deeply succeeded. Standing out will require more than just a functional AI recipe generator; it demands a genuinely unique value proposition or a focus on a segment currently ignored by the existing mediocre solutions.

Recommendations

  1. Deeply investigate why the 29+ existing AI recipe tools haven't achieved breakout success. Analyze user reviews and the criticisms summarized (e.g., lack of specific measurements, poor dietary filtering, UI bugs, generic outputs). What core user needs are consistently unmet despite the numerous attempts? Don't just replicate features; understand the failures.
  2. Identify a hyper-specific, underserved niche instead of aiming for broad personalization. Could you excel at recipes for complex medical dietary needs (e.g., renal, low-FODMAP), specific athletic performance goals, or perhaps families managing multiple allergies simultaneously? The criticisms about missing dietary filters (keto, vegan, gluten-free, micronutrients) hint at these unmet needs. Generic personalization is already a crowded field.
  3. Explore pivoting towards building enabling technology rather than a consumer-facing app. Could you develop a superior AI recipe generation engine or ingredient analysis module and license it to established players like grocery delivery apps, meal kit services, or large recipe websites? This avoids direct competition in the 'Swamp'.
  4. Consider tackling adjacent, potentially less crowded problems where your AI expertise could shine. Examples include advanced meal planning with automated grocery list generation and integration, AI-driven food waste reduction tools that excel at using near-expiration items, or tools that intelligently adapt existing beloved recipes to meet new dietary constraints.
  5. Critically assess if this specific idea, in its current form, is the best use of your resources given the high competition and low demonstrated engagement for similar products. Unless you have identified a truly unique angle or technology that addresses the known shortcomings (like providing precise measurements, handling complex dietary interactions flawlessly, or offering a radically better UX), reconsider pursuing this exact path. The 'Swamp' category strongly advises against building without significant differentiation.

Questions

  1. Given that users can already use powerful tools like ChatGPT for basic recipe generation, and face 29+ specialized competitors, what specific, unique value will make users choose your tool and potentially pay for it, especially when similar products show low engagement and no strong buy signals?
  2. Many existing tools face criticism for lacking detailed measurements, specific dietary options (like micronutrients), and seamless integration (e.g., grocery lists). How will your AI fundamentally overcome these specific, known shortcomings where others have failed?
  3. Instead of directly competing, have you mapped out the specific underserved niches (e.g., clinical nutrition needs, extreme budget constraints, ethical sourcing priorities) and validated whether those users have a pain point severe enough that existing solutions don't solve and they'd actively seek out and adopt your specialized tool?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 29
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: 31.5%
    • Positive use signal: 33.5%
    • Negative use signal: 2.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Be My Chef - An AI-powered recipe generator, for unlimited recipes

08 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence Cooking Food & Drink

"Be My Chef" is an AI-powered recipe generator that crafts personalised meals based on your dietary needs, preferences, and available ingredients. You can discover endless culinary creations, from allergy-friendly recipes to diet-specific dishes.

Users are largely enthusiastic about the Be My Chef launch, congratulating the creator and praising the idea as fun, awesome, nice, and easy to use for recipe generation. Several users are eager to try it, while one jokingly mentions an AI chef breakup due to recipe evolution. There's interest in whether the platform offers recipes from various global regions, and one user suggests using ChatGPT directly for recipes. One user is also excited about its potential as an Uber Eats alternative.

Avatar
115
14
35.7%
14
115
35.7%
Relevance

Cookup: AI Chef - AI Recipe Generator

19 Jul 2024 Cooking Food & Drink Apple

Cookup: AI Chef – An AI-powered app that generates personalized recipes based on your ingredients and regional cuisine preferences. Get culinary advice and check ingredient prices with ease. Perfect for enhancing your cooking experience!

Avatar
4
4
Relevance

Fridgeraider - Track your ingredients and make new creative meals

07 Aug 2023 Android Cooking Health & Fitness

With the help of AI, users can easily generate new recipes based on their available ingredients, specific preferences such as serving size, flavor, meal type, and cuisine, creating a personalized and convenient cooking experience.

Fridgeraider is receiving positive feedback for its AI-assisted cooking and recipe generation using ChatGPT. Users appreciate the core functionality and suggest enhancements such as grocery integration, sharing features, nutrition information, and gamification to improve the user experience. Some users inquired about dietary restriction filters.

Users are requesting additional features to enhance the product's functionality. Specifically, users are requesting dietary filters such as vegetarian and gluten-free, plus integrations, options for sharing recipes, detailed nutrition information, and gamification elements to increase user engagement. The ability to add personal notes to generated recipes is also desired.

Avatar
83
4
25.0%
4
83
25.0%
Relevance

MyCookAi - Turn your ingredients into custom recipes with AI magic

29 Oct 2024 Cooking Productivity Health & Fitness

Transform your available ingredients into delicious, personalized recipes with AI. Set dietary preferences, cooking time, and servings to get custom recipes that match your needs. No more food waste. Tell us what you have, and we'll create the perfect recipe.

CookAI is praised as an excellent, original, and practical AI cooking assistant that creates personalized recipes based on dietary needs. Users appreciate its convenience and ability to reduce food waste through custom recipe creation.

Avatar
22
3
33.3%
3
22
33.3%
Relevance

I built an AI-powered recipe assistant

08 Oct 2024 Artificial Intelligence Cooking

Email me at sage.cookinghelp@gmail.com and mention Hacker News! I'll give the first 100 people who do a month free.I built Sage Cooking because my wife and I love to cook, but we're both slightly picky eaters. It's a next-gen recipe manager powered by AI, fine- tuned on techniques from top chefs and food scientists. I wanted something that would let us cook great meals tailored to our preferences and remember recipes we love.Key features:AI recipe generation using culinary expertise Recipe editing for personalization "Cook by photo" - upload a dish pic, get a recipe (surprisingly accurate!) Browse thousands of pre-generated free recipesWe've been using dev versions for a couple months, comparing against ChatGPT/Claude. The recipes and ingredient choices are noticeably better due to the fine-tuning.It's pretty straightforward, but powerful. Perfect for picky eaters or anyone wanting to elevate their home cooking. Curious to hear what HN thinks!

Landing page looks great, interested in design process.

Avatar
10
1
100.0%
1
10
100.0%
Relevance

RecipeGen AI - Create Personalized Recipes and Reduce Food Waste

09 Jul 2024 Artificial Intelligence Cooking Food & Drink

Do you have ingredients in your fridge but don't know what to do with them? RecipeGen AI helps you create personalized recipes based on the ingredients you have, thereby contributing to the reduction of food waste.

RecipeGen AI is lauded for its ability to generate personalized recipes based on user tastes and available ingredients, effectively reducing food waste. Users appreciate the convenience of having a wide range of recipes at their fingertips and find the recipe generation feature akin to having a personal chef. Sharing recipes with friends directly from the app is also a valued feature.

Avatar
5
5
60.0%
5
5
60.0%
Relevance

AI Dinner Recipe Generator - Revolutionize your meal planning

01 Jun 2023 Cooking Cookbooks Health & Fitness

My app is designed to help users create delicious and diverse meals effortlessly. With just a few clicks, you can generate a recipe that matches your preferred ingredients, the number of people you are serving, and the type of cuisine you are interested in.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating the team. A common question was how this product differentiates itself from existing AI recipe generators. Users expressed excitement and appreciated the solution for meal planning, particularly for resolving meal-related disagreements between partners.

Avatar
74
6
16.7%
6
74
16.7%
Relevance

My AI Chef - AI chef sharing coolest recipes

18 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence Cooking Health & Fitness

MyChef.live is an online platform that generates personalized meal recipes based on your dietary preferences and restrictions with AI. MyChef.live uses a combination of advanced algorithms and machine learning to generate custom recipes for users.

Users express interest in the AI Chef app, highlighting its ability to generate personalized recipes based on individual needs and restrictions. The app is praised for its ease of use and speed in creating recipes. Several users congratulate the team on the launch. A suggestion was made to list the product on saasbaba.com. A user noted a need to include quantities and cup sizes in the recipes.

Users criticize the product for lacking micronutrient options, specifically magnesium-rich food suggestions. Recipes need more detailed information, including quantities and specific measurements like cup sizes, to improve usability.

Avatar
88
8
50.0%
8
88
50.0%
Relevance

Recipes By AI - Generate recipes from a list of ingredients, powered by AI

29 Jan 2023 Artificial Intelligence Cooking Food & Drink

If you're left unsure of what to cook for dinner tonight and only have a few ingredients in your kitchen then plug them into our recipe generator and let your personal AI chef come up with the perfect recipe

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and expressing excitement. Users find the app helpful for meal planning, especially for busy individuals and indecisive cooks. Questions were raised about recipe types, website features, and potential integrations like Dall-e for images. Some users found it similar to existing platforms, while others shared success stories and suggestions for future versions, including automated cooking. The app's ability to generate recipes based on available ingredients and inspire culinary experimentation was praised. Overall, the launch was well-received, with users offering support and design assistance.

Users criticized the product for lacking search bar auto-completion, which hinders user experience. Additionally, a bug was reported where recipe generation failed when users typed in ingredients. Addressing these issues could improve usability and functionality.

Avatar
182
19
36.8%
19
182
36.8%
Relevance

MealsAI - Create and share amazing recipes with AI

25 Jan 2023 Artificial Intelligence Cooking Health & Fitness

Create, share, and discover delicious recipes. Leverage the limitless power of AI to turn simple ideas into full meals. Generate unique recipes with any restriction or ingredient, share recipes with friends or your favorite shopping apps, and browse recipes created by others all over the world.

A user expressed satisfaction and gratitude for a Thai-Italian fusion recipe. Another user congratulated the team on the launch. A user expressed excitement to experiment with dishes and mentioned it would be featured in an AI newsletter.

Avatar
19
3
33.3%
3
19
33.3%
Relevance

Recipe Lens - AI-Powered Recipe Identification and Creation

28 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Cooking

Recipe Lens: AI-powered app that identifies dishes from photos and creates personalized recipes from images of ingredients. Revolutionize your cooking experience.

The app is reported to function effectively, demonstrated by successful testing with milk and eggs. Users express positive feedback, indicating excitement and appreciation for the app's functionality and the work put into its development.

Avatar
4
2
50.0%
2
4
50.0%
Relevance

MoodFood – AI Chef Assistant for Personalized Meals and Mood Dining

06 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence Cooking

Users commented on a Nutri-Matic machine that produces a beverage resembling tea. Some users have posted similar content and suggested sharing insights. There are issues with registration, as it requires a Google account, and a feedback button error was reported. The computer voice used by the machine is reminiscent of a 'design is very human' personality. There are mixed feelings about the automated culinary appropriation, with some users upset about sharing food culture. Additionally, there are concerns about the potential for food poisoning from the machine's recipes.

Users criticized the product for producing a tea-like liquid instead of the expected beverage, requiring a Google account for use, and having a faulty feedback button. There were also concerns about cultural insensitivity regarding automated culinary appropriation and unease about sharing food culture. Additionally, there were worries about the safety of the food produced.

Avatar
17
7
-28.6%
7
17
Relevance

Recipe AI - Experience AI inspired cooking and recipe guide

05 Jul 2023 Artificial Intelligence Cooking Food & Drink

FoodGenius: Unleash your culinary creativity with AI-powered recipes. Discover mouthwatering dishes, personalized recommendations, and step-by-step instructions for a delightful cooking experience.

Recipe AI is praised as an amazing tool for personalized recipe suggestions based on user preferences. A user suggested the integration of a fridge photo app for ingredient tracking to enhance the experience.

Avatar
89
2
100.0%
2
89
100.0%
Top