Should I Build It Should I Build It
01 Jul 2025
Artificial Intelligence Developer Tools Games

An browser based html5 JavaScript game engine powered by ai

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

You're entering a "Swamp" category, characterized by numerous mediocre solutions. Six similar products already exist, increasing competition. Engagement is low, with an average of one comment per product, suggesting a lack of significant user interest or strong opinions. Given that there are already a handful of these types of projects and nobody's really engaging with them or using them, you should proceed with extreme caution. You'll need to deliver something truly innovative to stand out. Without that, your time might be better spent elsewhere.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly investigate why existing AI-powered game engines haven't gained traction. Analyze their shortcomings in terms of user experience, functionality, and market fit. Understanding their failures is crucial to avoid repeating the same mistakes and building something truly different.
  2. If you decide to proceed, identify a very specific niche within the gaming market that is underserved by current engines. For example, you could focus on educational games, games for specific age groups, or games with a particular artistic style. Specializing will allow you to tailor your engine to meet specific needs and stand out from the general-purpose options.
  3. Instead of directly competing with existing game engines, explore building AI-powered tools or plugins that enhance them. This could involve AI-assisted asset creation, intelligent level design, or automated testing. Integrating with established platforms can provide a quicker path to market and a lower barrier to entry.
  4. Explore adjacent problems in the game development pipeline that could be more promising. Perhaps tools to aid in narrative design, procedural content generation beyond just game engines, or even AI powered marketing tools to help creators better connect with their target audience.
  5. Based on user feedback from similar projects, provide a gameplay video to demonstrate the capabilities of your engine. Showcasing the engine in action will help potential users understand its mechanics and appeal.
  6. Consider if focusing on the AI aspect more than the game engine would be more beneficial. Many games are starting to incorporate AI characters or AI driven stories, so a tool that is specialized for these cases and pluggable into existing game engines may yield better results.
  7. Carefully assess the target audience and their specific needs. Since similar projects haven't been successful it is especially important to understand why game developers are not using the existing tools. If your engine is successful, how will you deal with the bigger companies in the space incorporating your innovations into their own engines? How will you stay ahead?

Questions

  1. Given the low engagement with existing solutions, what specific, novel features or capabilities will your engine offer to truly differentiate itself and attract users?
  2. What monetization strategies will you employ, and how will you ensure sustainable revenue generation in a market with limited user engagement and potential competition from larger players?
  3. How will you prevent larger, established game engines from simply copying your innovative AI features, and what strategies will you implement to maintain a competitive edge in the long term?

Your are here

You're entering a "Swamp" category, characterized by numerous mediocre solutions. Six similar products already exist, increasing competition. Engagement is low, with an average of one comment per product, suggesting a lack of significant user interest or strong opinions. Given that there are already a handful of these types of projects and nobody's really engaging with them or using them, you should proceed with extreme caution. You'll need to deliver something truly innovative to stand out. Without that, your time might be better spent elsewhere.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly investigate why existing AI-powered game engines haven't gained traction. Analyze their shortcomings in terms of user experience, functionality, and market fit. Understanding their failures is crucial to avoid repeating the same mistakes and building something truly different.
  2. If you decide to proceed, identify a very specific niche within the gaming market that is underserved by current engines. For example, you could focus on educational games, games for specific age groups, or games with a particular artistic style. Specializing will allow you to tailor your engine to meet specific needs and stand out from the general-purpose options.
  3. Instead of directly competing with existing game engines, explore building AI-powered tools or plugins that enhance them. This could involve AI-assisted asset creation, intelligent level design, or automated testing. Integrating with established platforms can provide a quicker path to market and a lower barrier to entry.
  4. Explore adjacent problems in the game development pipeline that could be more promising. Perhaps tools to aid in narrative design, procedural content generation beyond just game engines, or even AI powered marketing tools to help creators better connect with their target audience.
  5. Based on user feedback from similar projects, provide a gameplay video to demonstrate the capabilities of your engine. Showcasing the engine in action will help potential users understand its mechanics and appeal.
  6. Consider if focusing on the AI aspect more than the game engine would be more beneficial. Many games are starting to incorporate AI characters or AI driven stories, so a tool that is specialized for these cases and pluggable into existing game engines may yield better results.
  7. Carefully assess the target audience and their specific needs. Since similar projects haven't been successful it is especially important to understand why game developers are not using the existing tools. If your engine is successful, how will you deal with the bigger companies in the space incorporating your innovations into their own engines? How will you stay ahead?

Questions

  1. Given the low engagement with existing solutions, what specific, novel features or capabilities will your engine offer to truly differentiate itself and attract users?
  2. What monetization strategies will you employ, and how will you ensure sustainable revenue generation in a market with limited user engagement and potential competition from larger players?
  3. How will you prevent larger, established game engines from simply copying your innovative AI features, and what strategies will you implement to maintain a competitive edge in the long term?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 6
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 1
  • Net use signal: 0.0%
    • Positive use signal: 0.0%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

I Built a Free AI Platform to Instantly Create Games with Your Voice

14 Aug 2024 Games

Hey HN,I'm Damiano Rodriguez, and I've been working solo on a project called Caisual Games. It's a free platform where anyone can create web games just by describing them with their voice.Here's how it works: You simply describe your game idea ("Make a cookie clicker game with 5 upgrades"), and the platform generates a playable web game in seconds using HTML and JavaScript.There's no coding required and no downloads needed—you can create and play directly in your browser.What's more, anyone can improve a published game, fostering a collaborative environment for game creation.The ultimate goal is to make game creation accessible to everyone by removing the coding barrier. Currently, it's possible to create only simple games, but soon maybe we might be able to create increasingly complex games.To my knowledge, this is a novel approach to game creation. Your feedback will be extremely valuable in refining and enhancing the platform, especially in this initial phase.Thank you.P.S.: You can create multiplayer games too :-)P.P.S: One of the early users made a game about a water drop floating in the air trying to avoid dust particles and trying to merge with other water molecules. I'm very proud of it: https://caisual.com/g/buo4vwbjveg926vt

Users find the product interesting and somewhat unsettling. There is curiosity about its capability to handle complex games. Overall, the feedback is positive.

Avatar
5
2
2
5
Relevance

PlayCodeAI – A tool I created to let my kid create their own videogames

22 Sep 2024 Artificial Intelligence Developer Tools

Hi hn,Its been a while since my kid has been dreaming to make videogames, as you know, the entry bar is high, too many technical details are involved.A few months ago, we started making games, we have tried many different ways, from dragging blocks to write code with a high-level library to make it simple, it is still too much work.Getting into the AI boat, I decided to give it a try for making games, turns out that it works super nicely, still, you still have many technical concepts involved, what language should the game be written in? where do you store the file/assets? how do you run it?I decided creating a simple playground where most of the tech details are already defined, html/javascript due to the portability they provide, we can get the code and see the result right away, same way, we can easily export it and upload it to a server.So far, the results are amazing, my kid has managed to create 10 simple games in a few hours with no help at all (the landing page includes screenshots from these).I strongly believe that this can help many other people to bring their ideas to life.As of now, the tool is simple, it runs on the client side, requiring an OpenAI API Key to interact with the models, it has the problem that only paid users can access this and I hope to remove that barrier soon but this was the simplest/fastest way to get things done.A big limitation relates to image loading, many images have CORS limitations that chatgpt can't detect, games without images aren't fun and I hope to solve this soon (suggestions accepted).I'd also love making it simple to share the results with others.Anyway, if your kid is willing to make a videogame, I encourage you to try this out, any feedback should help me to polish this to be usable for others.Thanks.

Avatar
7
7
Relevance

I made a web browser game with AI integrated NPC's

04 Nov 2024 Artificial Intelligence Games

As of today the game's demo is officially live and playable at https://www.letsmaketv.comIt's a web browser game, no sign in or downloads required!The game uses fine-tuned OpenAI models to simulate the personalities of six different NPC's, each with their own unique training data and personalities.You can chat with the AI's about anything, become friends or enemies with them and find out their secrets. The dialogue is surprisingly funny sometimes but it's still just very much a proof of concept.There are also a few minigames you can play with the AI too.I'll leave it there an let the game speak for itself. I would love it if you played and shared your feedback! I plan to keep working on this game and evolve it into something much broader but for the time being I wanted to share this big milestone!Let me know what you think!

Users are getting nostalgic MSX2 vibes from the product and are requesting a gameplay video.

Users criticized the lack of a gameplay video, which makes it difficult to understand the game's mechanics and appeal.

Avatar
2
2
2
2
Top