Should I Build It Should I Build It
19 Apr 2025
Productivity

A Multi channel notification service that reacts to transaction events

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

You're stepping into a competitive arena with your multi-channel notification service triggered by transaction events. The presence of 21 similar products indicates established demand, but also signals a crowded market where standing out is crucial. The existing notification services show medium engagement, so there's definitely room to grab user attention. While explicit 'use' data is absent, there's an surprisingly strong implicit 'buy' signal, placing you in the top 5% of products we've analyzed. This suggests users recognize the value of such a service, but it also means that differentiation is key to converting that interest into actual adoption and recurring revenue. The challenge is to identify and capitalize on unmet needs or underserved niches within this space, avoiding the fate of being just another notification tool.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with a deep dive into the competitive landscape. Don't just look at features; analyze user reviews of existing notification services (like those listed in the 'similar products' data) to identify pain points and unmet needs. Focus on what users are explicitly complaining about or wishing for.
  2. Define a clear and narrow niche. Instead of targeting all transaction events, specialize in a specific type of transaction or industry. For instance, focus on e-commerce transactions, crypto transactions, or financial alerts for small businesses. This will help you tailor your features and marketing efforts for a more focused audience.
  3. Prioritize a seamless user experience. Given the technical nature of transaction events, focus on making your service incredibly easy to set up and use, even for non-technical users. Consider a no-code interface, pre-built templates for common transaction types, and excellent documentation.
  4. Explore unique notification channels. While email and SMS are standard, consider integrating with less common but potentially more effective channels like push notifications within specific industry apps (e.g., Shopify app for e-commerce merchants) or dedicated collaboration platforms like Slack or Microsoft Teams.
  5. Build strong integrations with key platforms. Ensure your service seamlessly integrates with popular e-commerce platforms (Shopify, WooCommerce), payment gateways (Stripe, PayPal), and blockchain networks (Ethereum, Binance Smart Chain), making it easy for users to connect their transaction sources.
  6. Implement robust error handling and retry mechanisms. Transaction events can be unreliable. Your service should be able to gracefully handle errors, retry failed notifications, and provide clear status updates to users about the delivery status of their notifications.
  7. Offer tiered pricing based on usage and features. Start with a free tier that allows users to send a limited number of notifications per month, and then offer paid tiers with higher limits, advanced features, and dedicated support. Consider usage based or per-event pricing to encourage trial.
  8. Actively engage with your early users. Gather feedback through surveys, interviews, and in-app feedback forms. Use this feedback to iterate quickly and improve your service based on their needs and suggestions. Turn your early adopters into advocates.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions in the market, what specific underserved need or pain point will your multi-channel notification service address that justifies its existence and attracts users away from established competitors?
  2. How will you ensure the reliability and accuracy of your transaction event notifications, especially considering the potential for technical glitches, API changes, and network outages?
  3. Considering the strong 'buy' signal, what pricing strategy will you employ to effectively monetize your service while remaining competitive and accessible to a broad range of users, from individual developers to large enterprises?

Your are here

You're stepping into a competitive arena with your multi-channel notification service triggered by transaction events. The presence of 21 similar products indicates established demand, but also signals a crowded market where standing out is crucial. The existing notification services show medium engagement, so there's definitely room to grab user attention. While explicit 'use' data is absent, there's an surprisingly strong implicit 'buy' signal, placing you in the top 5% of products we've analyzed. This suggests users recognize the value of such a service, but it also means that differentiation is key to converting that interest into actual adoption and recurring revenue. The challenge is to identify and capitalize on unmet needs or underserved niches within this space, avoiding the fate of being just another notification tool.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with a deep dive into the competitive landscape. Don't just look at features; analyze user reviews of existing notification services (like those listed in the 'similar products' data) to identify pain points and unmet needs. Focus on what users are explicitly complaining about or wishing for.
  2. Define a clear and narrow niche. Instead of targeting all transaction events, specialize in a specific type of transaction or industry. For instance, focus on e-commerce transactions, crypto transactions, or financial alerts for small businesses. This will help you tailor your features and marketing efforts for a more focused audience.
  3. Prioritize a seamless user experience. Given the technical nature of transaction events, focus on making your service incredibly easy to set up and use, even for non-technical users. Consider a no-code interface, pre-built templates for common transaction types, and excellent documentation.
  4. Explore unique notification channels. While email and SMS are standard, consider integrating with less common but potentially more effective channels like push notifications within specific industry apps (e.g., Shopify app for e-commerce merchants) or dedicated collaboration platforms like Slack or Microsoft Teams.
  5. Build strong integrations with key platforms. Ensure your service seamlessly integrates with popular e-commerce platforms (Shopify, WooCommerce), payment gateways (Stripe, PayPal), and blockchain networks (Ethereum, Binance Smart Chain), making it easy for users to connect their transaction sources.
  6. Implement robust error handling and retry mechanisms. Transaction events can be unreliable. Your service should be able to gracefully handle errors, retry failed notifications, and provide clear status updates to users about the delivery status of their notifications.
  7. Offer tiered pricing based on usage and features. Start with a free tier that allows users to send a limited number of notifications per month, and then offer paid tiers with higher limits, advanced features, and dedicated support. Consider usage based or per-event pricing to encourage trial.
  8. Actively engage with your early users. Gather feedback through surveys, interviews, and in-app feedback forms. Use this feedback to iterate quickly and improve your service based on their needs and suggestions. Turn your early adopters into advocates.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions in the market, what specific underserved need or pain point will your multi-channel notification service address that justifies its existence and attracts users away from established competitors?
  2. How will you ensure the reliability and accuracy of your transaction event notifications, especially considering the potential for technical glitches, API changes, and network outages?
  3. Considering the strong 'buy' signal, what pricing strategy will you employ to effectively monetize your service while remaining competitive and accessible to a broad range of users, from individual developers to large enterprises?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 21
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 5
  • Net use signal: 12.1%
    • Positive use signal: 13.9%
    • Negative use signal: 1.8%
  • Net buy signal: 0.8%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.4%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.6%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

SuprSend – Single API multichannel notification service

05 Feb 2024 Developer Tools

We as developers, build and maintain many services in code, one of them being notification service. In the last 5-7 years, API-to-user communications have exploded across SMS, email, chat apps, mobile, and web push. As a consequence, notification service handling them has become quite complex. Developers spend time building integrations with multiple providers, create templates for each channel, managing scheduling and routing based on preferences, maintaining queues to deliver notifications on time while managing scale. Besides, product teams have poor visibility on notifications as everything is inside the code and spread across different teams.What SuprSend offers: Ready integrations with vendors across all channels - sms, email, mobile and web push, slack, WhatsApp, Teams and app inbox. You can also integrate Segment and Mixpanel. SDKs across major languages, python, golang, java, node, react, angular, flutter Visual template editors to design notifications and edit them on the fly, without involving developers. Drag and drop/API-driven templating, workflows, contacts management, event creation Automated delivery node to optimize for message success, instead of blasting the same message on all channels together. Detailed logs to easily debug the errors on all channels. Enhance observability Infrastructure with high reliability and low latency, which scales with you.Who is it for: Engineering teams and product managers who send important product notifications from their code on multiple channels will benefit the most from SuprSend.We would love for you all to try the product and give us feedback on how we can improve it! You can contact me at nikita@suprsend.com for any questions.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

NotificOcean - Blockchain Notification Service

17 Jul 2024 Crypto Blockchain Ethereum

Stay ahead in the crypto world with NotificOcean's real-time alerts for blockchain events, DeFi updates, NFT tracking, and more. Get instant notifications for Ethereum, BNB Smart Chain, and other top networks.

Users express enthusiasm for the app, highlighting its potential utility in tracking crypto prices and preventing missed opportunities, referencing specific events like the Bitcoin reversal.

Avatar
5
2
100.0%
2
5
100.0%
Relevance

Flasho (YC W20) -Open source tool to set up transactional notifications

21 Feb 2023 Developer Tools

Hi HN,We just launched Flasho- an open-source tool to set up transactional notifications in minutes.Last year when we were building an avatar-based social app, we realised that building notifications took up significant time and development effort (establishing microservices, integrating with a bunch of different service providers etc). And every time we wanted to set up new notifications or make changes to existing ones, we had to make multiple changes across the codebase which was time-consuming and messy. We realised we needed a better way to manage this.Existing solutions were either too expensive or required us to share customer data with third parties. And that is when we decided to build an in-house tool. This tool turned out to be incredibly useful for us. It was a single dashboard to create and manage all our customer notifications across channels. It saved us weeks of developer bandwidth and we could now create and manage notifications with little to no code. We decided to open source this tool and thus Flasho was born.Flasho is self-hosted(docker/deploy from source). You can just connect your DB, set up event triggers and conditions, create content and connect to the service providers of your choice in a matter of minutes, without writing any code.We have SMS and email notifications now. We plan on adding in-app and push soon. We have currently built it for PostgreSQL. We will make it compatible with more databases in the coming days.We’ve launched it under the MIT licence so any developer can use the tool. We don't intend on charging individual developers. The plan is to generate revenue through a cloud hosted service, priority support, features like multi-user login etc.Check it out and let us know what you think!

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Apprise (Notifications) Supports 100 Services Now

01 Feb 2024 Developer Tools

I finally achieved the milestone of supporting more then 100+ services and just wanted to share with with you all!What is Apprise?Apprise allows you to send a notification to almost all of the most popular notification services available to us today such as: Telegram, Discord, Slack, Amazon SNS, Gotify, etc. * One notification library to rule them all. * A common and intuitive notification syntax. * Supports the handling of images and attachments (to the notification services that will accept them). * It's incredibly lightweight. * Amazing response times because all messages sent asynchronously. I still don't get it... ELI5Apprise is effectively a self-host efficient messaging switchboard. You can automate notifications through: - the Command Line Interface (for Admins) - it's very easy to use Development Library (for Devs) - a web service (you host) that can act as a sidecar. This solution allows you to keep your notification configuration in one place instead of across multiple servers (or within multiple programs). This one is for both Admins and Devs.A lot of systems have already adapted to it such as HomeAssistant, Apache Airflow, ChangeDetection, Uptime Kuma and many others (<https://github.com/caronc/apprise/wiki/showcase#integrations>) which shows the commonality. Mailrise is an incredibly talented program that converts Emails sent to it to trigger notifications via Apprise.What else does it do?1. Emoji Support (:rocket:) built right into it!2. File Attachment Support (to the end points that support it)3. It supports inputs of `MARKDOWN`, `HTML`, and `TEXT` and can easily convert between these depending on the endpoint. For example: HTML provided input would be converted to TEXT before passing it along as a text message. However the same HTML content provided would not be converted if the endpoint accepted it as such (such as Telegram, or Email).4. It supports breaking large messages into smaller ones to fit the upstream service. Hence a text message (160 characters) or a Tweet (280 characters) would be constructed for you if the notification you sent was larger.5. It supports configuration files allowing you to securely hide your credentials and map them to simple tags (or identifiers) like `family`, `devops`, `marketing`, etc. There is no limit to the number of tag assignments. It supports a simple TEXT based configuration, as well as a more advanced and configurable YAML based one.6. Configuration can be hosted via the web (even self-hosted), or just regular (protected) configuration files.7. It Supports "tagging" of the Notification Endpoints you wish to notify. Tagging allows you to mask your credentials and upstream services into single word assigned descriptions of them. Tags can even be grouped together and signaled via their group name instead.8. Dynamic Module Loading: They load on demand only. Writing a new supported notification is as simple as adding a new file; see here: https://github.com/caronc/apprise/tree/master/apprise/plugin...9. Developer CLI tool (it's like `/usr/bin/mail` on steroids)It's worth re-mentioning that it has a fully compatible API interface found here: <https://github.com/caronc/apprise-api> or on Dockerhub (<https://hub.docker.com/r/caronc/apprise>) which has all of the same bells and whistles as defined above. This acts as a great side-car solution!Program Details - Entirely a self-hosted solution. - Written in Python - 99.27% Test Coverage (oof... I'll get it back to 100% soon) - BSD-2 License - Over 450K downloads a month on PyPi - Over 2.8 million downloads from Docker Hub I would love to hear any feedback any of you have!

Supports 100+ services, self-hosted notification tool, feedback welcome.

Still don't get it, ELI5.

Avatar
5
1
1
5
Relevance

QuickAlerts - Customizable, real-time notifications for on-chain events

08 Feb 2023 Crypto Web3 DeFi

Use QuickAlerts to define and receive real-time alerts for on-chain activities that matter for your business. Built for a variety of DeFi, NFT and analytics use cases, QuickAlerts enable you to easily set up custom feeds to monitor and take action on critical transactions, logs, and block data.

QuickAlerts launched, offering real-time, customizable notifications for on-chain events. A user inquired about Telegram notifications. The launch was met with congratulations.

Avatar
76
3
3
76
Relevance

Chainrel - Real-time blockchain event notifications

06 Nov 2023 SaaS Web3 Developer Tools

Chainrel provides real-time blockchain event notifications for seamless backend integration, keeping you updated instantly, and routing notifications to various channels like Slack.

The Product Hunt launch of Chainrel has garnered positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and praising the design. Several comments highlight Chainrel's potential as a game-changer, particularly its real-time blockchain event notifications and integrations. Users are also inquiring about specific use cases. The overall sentiment towards the project and its recognition of blockchain's potential is enthusiastic.

Avatar
84
9
9
84
Relevance

IPN – Instant notifications for blockchain-based events

20 May 2024 Blockchain Web3

Hey HN, this is Artyom. My team has been working on this crypto notifications service just about a year now. We want to add a missing layer of notifications about events from web3 to web2. We seek and trigger - you process, enjoy!There are multiple services providing similar functionality, we just want to simplify user experience and build a service that just works in a comfortable way for developers.Why we’ve built service:- prices of hosting own nodes are high(you have to spend money to manage them too)- RPCs have limits and are not stable enough- integration of web3 events in a legacy way is pretty complex especially when you develop many blockchain-based apps- there is no service with one-window support of evm-based and tvm networks using api, websocket, webhooks and telegramPayments for notifications of blockchain-based events isn’t a new concept, we offer a service with multiple networks(EVM-based and Tron), all you need - configure event parameters and channel(webhook, websocket or Telegram). We bring extra small payment for every notification - 0.01 USD and offer 500 free notifications for each new user on beta-stage.Authentication made with web3 - we don’t need your data, your credit card or KYC. Your assets are on your own addresses and there are no extra fees to transfer them. You can add any event params(any token transfers, custom events), select network and choose addresses to track. Addresses to track can be added by API or UI, rules can be added using UI.We also have a python library that can help you to work with crypto(address creation, transfers, etc.) and our API. Using it you can make your own solutions for processing crypto fast and easy(also exchange services, bridges, etc). You shouldn’t trust our notifications in case of block reorgs(your recheck is needed), we just notify you about events as soon as we catch them. We don’t catch events from history, so you can not fetch events in the past.Our parsing system checks multiple sources(own nodes and public RPCs) for new transactions, and tries to find matches with users’ rules. We have been testing it with our clients’ projects for the last year and it’s pretty stable, enjoy!There is a system of webhooks retry if they fail, events history and billing, so the process is pretty transparent.Now we don’t catch nested transactions, but they would be added in a couple of weeks(adding subsquid parser as addition to our legacy parsing solution).By the way, I am looking for new networks for partnership and feature proposals.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Crypto Notifications for Metamask - Telegram & Email notifications for crypto & NFT transactions

30 Nov 2023 Crypto Web3 Cryptocurrency

Get real-time notifications on all crypto transactions via Telegram & Email. Monitor your token permissions, NFT transfers & Airdrops. Get ENS domain renewal reminders and much more!

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users expressing excitement and gratitude for the new features, particularly the Metamask integration and notification system. Many users congratulated the team on the launch, praising the product's usefulness and convenience, especially for crypto users. The token permission tracking was highlighted as crucial for security. Several users are eager to test the product and anticipate its positive impact on the crypto space, with some calling it a game-changer. There was also excitement about GPTs and anticipation for future development.

Avatar
129
41
22.0%
2.4%
41
129
22.0%
2.4%
Relevance

I made a nocode app for stripe webhooks, get notify on important events

04 Mar 2024 SaaS

Hey everyone!WebhookWatch was born from a recurring need I saw as a freelance developer. Many online B2B SaaS platforms and individuals integrate payment systems like Stripe, but lack advanced notifications for crucial events. For example, they might need alerts when a customer cancels a subscription, a charge fails, or a subscriber's card is about to expire. That's why I built WebhookWatch – to provide proactive email notifications for these important events.I plan on adding more features and other means of notifications in the future!Roberto

Introduces WebhookWatch for proactive payment notifications.

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

An open-source notification infrastructure

26 Nov 2023 Open Source GitHub

Users discussed the Show HN product, noting that some features aren't open source and it requires MongoDB, with suggestions to use FerretDB as an alternative. There's interest in the product's solidity but concerns about compatibility, outdated information, and licensing issues. Alternatives like Courier and Engagespot were mentioned, as well as issues with AWS DocumentDB compatibility and .NET SDK implementation. Ntfy.sh and UnifiedPush were highlighted as integration options or alternatives. One user is considering Ntfy for their SaaS notifications.

Users criticized the product for lacking SSO integration and open-source auditing logs, requiring MongoDB over Postgres, having many failed tests, and not being compatible with the latest MongoDB version. The license change was seen as anti-competitive and costly. The hosting solution was unclear, and there was outdated information and inaccurate interpretation of SSPL. Criticisms also included the absence of a hosted AWS version, no C# availability, incompatibility with AOT and missing System.Text.Json, and the requirement for customers to install the Ntfy app.

Avatar
170
22
-13.6%
-4.5%
22
170
Relevance

Spectate - Monitor, alert & manage incidents - supercharged by A.I.

19 Apr 2023 Productivity Analytics Developer Tools

Effortless monitoring, alerting and incident management supercharged by AI. 📡 Receive alerts by phone calls, SMS, Slack, email and more, manage incidents more efficiently with our Incident AI assistant and launch your own branded status page in seconds 🚀

Spectate's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users praise its design, features, efficiency, and competitive pricing. Many highlight its website monitoring capabilities, immediate incident alerts, and AI-powered status pages. Several users shared their excitement to try Spectate and expressed intentions to switch from existing monitoring services. The platform's clean dashboard and readable data were also appreciated. A few users inquired about specific monitoring capabilities. Many comments simply congratulated the team on the launch and wished them success.

The primary criticism is the need to improve the implementation of the product. This suggests that the product, in its current state, has some issues that require attention. Further details on implementation challenges would be beneficial.

Avatar
238
33
24.2%
3.0%
33
238
24.2%
3.0%
Relevance

We are building developer-first open-source CLI for alerting

15 Feb 2023 Open Source Developer Tools

Although it is still in its early stages, we believe it would be beneficial to receive feedback on our project.The project aims to provide the following use cases:1. Declarative alerting that can be managed in your version control and service repository.2. Alerting from multiple data sources, allowing for more context and enrichments.3. Elimination of vendor lock-in, making it easier to transition from one observability tool to another.Additional features we plan to include are:- Integration with CI/CD processes to facilitate alerts maintenance and coverage.- Scoring to evaluate the alert's actionability and contextual information.- Slack integration to track alerts channels over time.- More providers, conditions, etc

Users are providing feedback on an early-stage project with alerting features. One user inquires about another official thread, while another expresses enthusiasm, mentioning they have experienced similar issues for years and appreciate the solution.

Avatar
5
3
33.3%
3
5
33.3%
Top