Should I Build It Should I Build It
04 May 2025
Fintech Web3 Payments

offering a payment platform similar to stripe but focused on crypto. ...

...should support letting people pay with BTC, Ethereum, Solana (and all big tokens on eth and solana platform) and allow the receipient to off-ramp automatically or stake stablecoins or sol/eth automatically

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

You're entering a crowded space. There are already many crypto payment platforms, as evidenced by the 24 similar products we found. This puts your idea squarely in the "Swamp" category, meaning there are mediocre solutions already available, and standing out will be tough. The low engagement (average of 3 comments) on these existing platforms suggests people aren't that excited about the current options. Since the engagement is low and the net use and buy signals are neutral, there is a great chance that people are not willing to use these platforms or, more worryingly, they simply don't care. To succeed, you'll need to find a significant differentiator or a niche that current platforms aren't serving. Otherwise, you may face an uphill battle.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, your first step is deep competitive research. Don't just look at features; understand why existing crypto payment platforms haven't achieved widespread adoption. What are their shortcomings in terms of user experience, fees, security, or regulatory compliance? The provided competitor analysis shows users are concerned about fees and usability.
  2. Identify a specific niche or underserved segment within the crypto payment space. Instead of trying to be a 'Stripe for crypto,' consider focusing on a particular type of transaction (e.g., cross-border payments for freelancers, micro-transactions for content creators) or a specific blockchain ecosystem (e.g., focusing solely on Solana and its unique features).
  3. Explore building tools or integrations for existing payment platforms instead of directly competing with them. Can you create a plugin for Shopify or WooCommerce that makes it easier for merchants to accept crypto payments through existing gateways? This could be a faster and less capital-intensive way to enter the market.
  4. Consider the off-ramp component very carefully. Regulatory compliance in the crypto space is complex and varies widely by jurisdiction. Ensure you have a clear understanding of the legal and regulatory requirements in the regions you plan to operate. User complaints on similar products also highlight the need for real-time analytics, so build this in from the start.
  5. Before building, validate your core assumptions with potential users. Conduct user interviews with merchants and consumers who are interested in crypto payments. Understand their pain points, needs, and expectations. Are they truly dissatisfied with existing solutions, or are they simply unaware of them?
  6. Develop a detailed go-to-market strategy that outlines how you will acquire users. Given the existing competition, you'll need a strong marketing plan and a clear value proposition that resonates with your target audience. Consider offering incentives or promotions to attract early adopters.
  7. When discussing your project, avoid accusatory language, as noted in the competitor analysis. A more collaborative and less aggressive tone will come off better. Focus on the advantages of YOUR platform, and not the implied disadvantages of others.

Questions

  1. What specific problem are you solving that existing crypto payment platforms don't address adequately, and how will you measure your success in solving that problem?
  2. Given the regulatory complexities of crypto off-ramps, what is your plan for ensuring compliance across different jurisdictions, and how will you adapt to evolving regulations?
  3. How will you acquire your first 100 paying customers, and what is your customer acquisition cost (CAC) compared to the lifetime value (LTV) of a customer on your platform?

Your are here

You're entering a crowded space. There are already many crypto payment platforms, as evidenced by the 24 similar products we found. This puts your idea squarely in the "Swamp" category, meaning there are mediocre solutions already available, and standing out will be tough. The low engagement (average of 3 comments) on these existing platforms suggests people aren't that excited about the current options. Since the engagement is low and the net use and buy signals are neutral, there is a great chance that people are not willing to use these platforms or, more worryingly, they simply don't care. To succeed, you'll need to find a significant differentiator or a niche that current platforms aren't serving. Otherwise, you may face an uphill battle.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, your first step is deep competitive research. Don't just look at features; understand why existing crypto payment platforms haven't achieved widespread adoption. What are their shortcomings in terms of user experience, fees, security, or regulatory compliance? The provided competitor analysis shows users are concerned about fees and usability.
  2. Identify a specific niche or underserved segment within the crypto payment space. Instead of trying to be a 'Stripe for crypto,' consider focusing on a particular type of transaction (e.g., cross-border payments for freelancers, micro-transactions for content creators) or a specific blockchain ecosystem (e.g., focusing solely on Solana and its unique features).
  3. Explore building tools or integrations for existing payment platforms instead of directly competing with them. Can you create a plugin for Shopify or WooCommerce that makes it easier for merchants to accept crypto payments through existing gateways? This could be a faster and less capital-intensive way to enter the market.
  4. Consider the off-ramp component very carefully. Regulatory compliance in the crypto space is complex and varies widely by jurisdiction. Ensure you have a clear understanding of the legal and regulatory requirements in the regions you plan to operate. User complaints on similar products also highlight the need for real-time analytics, so build this in from the start.
  5. Before building, validate your core assumptions with potential users. Conduct user interviews with merchants and consumers who are interested in crypto payments. Understand their pain points, needs, and expectations. Are they truly dissatisfied with existing solutions, or are they simply unaware of them?
  6. Develop a detailed go-to-market strategy that outlines how you will acquire users. Given the existing competition, you'll need a strong marketing plan and a clear value proposition that resonates with your target audience. Consider offering incentives or promotions to attract early adopters.
  7. When discussing your project, avoid accusatory language, as noted in the competitor analysis. A more collaborative and less aggressive tone will come off better. Focus on the advantages of YOUR platform, and not the implied disadvantages of others.

Questions

  1. What specific problem are you solving that existing crypto payment platforms don't address adequately, and how will you measure your success in solving that problem?
  2. Given the regulatory complexities of crypto off-ramps, what is your plan for ensuring compliance across different jurisdictions, and how will you adapt to evolving regulations?
  3. How will you acquire your first 100 paying customers, and what is your customer acquisition cost (CAC) compared to the lifetime value (LTV) of a customer on your platform?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 24
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: 11.8%
    • Positive use signal: 11.8%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

We built a multi-chain crypto subscription platform

02 May 2023 Crypto Fintech Web3 Payments

Crowdform Labs has just launched Helix, an innovative gasless recurring Web3 subscription payment service that aims to revolutionize the way businesses and consumers handle subscription payments using cryptocurrency. Helix eliminates the need for customer-facing gas fees, making it more frictionless and accessible for users. Additionally, it is compatible with any wallet, making it easy for customers to use, particularly for those who prefer non-custodial solutions, which allows them to have full control and ownership of their assets.One of the major challenges with using stable coins for payments is the issue of gas fees. These fees can add up quickly, making it difficult for businesses to offer subscription-based services and added complexity for consumers to maintain a balance of both the native gas token (Ethereum or MATIC) and the stable coin (USDC). Helix solves this problem by using a new gasless meta-transaction method that eliminates the need for gas fees from the customer's side, instead charging the gas fee via a low-cost transaction fee in the stable coin, making it more affordable and accessible for everyone.Helix offers significantly lower transaction fees compared to traditional payment methods such as credit and debit cards, with a transaction fee of only 1%, while traditional transaction fees for credit and debit cards are typically from 20p + 1.4%. This is achieved by using blockchain technology, which eliminates the need for intermediaries such as banks and payment processors.Helix has a wide range of potential use cases and can be used by any business that needs to process recurring or one-off payments in crypto. Integration is simple for developers using the Helix SDK, as well as for no-code solutions with the creation of multi-use payment links via a few clicks in the Helix Dashboard. Use cases include subscription-based services like streaming platforms, software as a service, and online publications. Helix opens up new opportunities for businesses in the gaming and NFTs space, as well as for creators and influencers looking to monetize their content.By using Helix, businesses not only benefit from lower transaction fees but also provide a more secure, transparent, and private way to process payments, which can help them attract users in a growing market space who are looking for more secure and decentralized payment options. Helix's target partners are individuals, businesses, and large enterprises who want to process recurring payments on the blockchain, including creators and influencers looking to monetize their content, typical e-commerce experiences, and in-game memberships. Helix plans to expand its capabilities to support any ERC-20 token in the future, providing more flexibility for customers and allowing them to make payments using a wider range of digital assets.In conclusion, Helix is a game-changer in the world of cryptocurrency payments, offering lower transaction fees and a more secure, transparent, and private way to process payments. Helix's ability to eliminate the need for customer-facing gas fees and its compatibility with any wallet make it accessible for users. With a wide range of potential use cases, Helix is poised to revolutionize the way businesses and consumers handle subscription payments using cryptocurrency.

Beautiful website

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

Service to accept crypto payments with zero fee

18 Oct 2024 Crypto Web3 Payments

Hello Everyone,I would like to introduce my project - JaneDoe Finance, a smart contracts based crypto payment gateway with zero fees and automatic token conversion. It allows businesses to quickly and easily accept crypto payments.I am looking for people who can try and give me feedback. To try you need to register, but it is super easy and all features are free, just connect your web3 wallet and that's it. Created account will already contain all the necessary settings and you will be able to accept payments, make payments and withdraw funds.Some video tutorials:- How make the payment with token exchanging - https://youtu.be/h4OzrS6Lm00?si=YJHNfUQx6hHchbwd- How make the payment, monitor payments and withdraw fund - https://youtu.be/eBZ_XfLranA?si=4qZ4FYgSEiNlqY2FSo, what makes JaneDoe Finance different?1) Zero fee. Crypto payment gateways compete with each other by the fee amount they charge per transaction. It varies from 2% (Cryptomus, BitPay) to 0.23% (CoinRemitter). I don't see the point in lowering it further. All of my functionality is free. I would think about additional paid services related to withdrawing to fiat, token price volatility insurance, integration with DeFi, paid support and others.2) Security. Almost all crypto payment gateways store merchant funds on custodial wallets, which they have full control over. Thus, their security is based on trust and the laws of the country in whose jurisdiction they operate. In my case, access to funds is 100% guaranteed because they are stored in smart contracts (ERC1155 standard). It is technically impossible to block or confiscate funds because there is no such code in my smart contracts. Merchants can withdraw their funds even by interacting with them directly, without the JaneDoe Finance website, programmatically or through a blockchain scanner such as Etherscan.3) Wide coins support. 9275 coins, 161 Fiat Currencies and 420 Crypto Wallets. No comments :)4) Automatic coin conversion. Imagine this scenario: a merchant want to accept payments in USDT, but client only has volatile ETH. In this case client can pay in ETH, the platform will automatically convert it to USDT at a favorable exchange rate, ensuring that the merchant receives the required amount in USDT. This way, clients can pay in the tokens they prefer and merchants receive payments in the tokens they need. To guarantee the best possible conversion rates, we've integrated with 107 exchangers.5) Easy to use. To create a merchant account you only need your web3 wallet. After registration, it immediately contains all the necessary settings. And you will be able to accept and make payments, withdraw funds. Also, in the basic scenario, no integration is required, you can generate payment links completely on your side, without interacting with JaneDoe Finance.Thank you for reading all the way to the end and your feedback.

Avatar
3
3
Relevance

Crypto payment gateway with recurring billing

06 Mar 2023 Fintech Payments

We have built a non-custodial solution that helps merchants to accept recurring payments. Easy to integrate and smooth UX (no need to leave merchant website). Feedback is much appreciated

Users are inquiring about the product's capability for recurring crypto payments, its integration with platforms like Shopify, and how it differentiates from similar technologies like ERC 4337. There's interest from merchants in accepting cryptocurrency payments. One user offers integration help, providing contact details. Comparisons with existing services like CoinPayments are also requested. Some comments are either lacking content or have been removed.

Users find the explanation of crypto recurrent payments unclear, question the product's unique features, and note the absence of a merchant panel and payment notifications in ERC 4337.

Avatar
3
10
10
3
Relevance

Cross-border payments on stablecoin rail

24 Oct 2023 Crypto Fintech Web3 Payments

Hi guys, long time (for years) lurker of HN. I have a product to show you all. We recently launched in beta.Not everyone loves crypto and has diamond hands. Not everyone wants to get paid in crypto. We've built Binamite for users who have clients that pay in crypto (all web3 companies), so that the users can receive money in their local fiat. We do the heavy lifting behind the scenes.Moreover, and more importantly, on the same rails, we make fiat-to-fiat cross-border payments at blockchain speed and cost. That means, for instance, Euro from Europe reaches ZAR in South Africa without ever going through SWIFT. All in a matter of hours.Please check it out if you can. Any feedback is appreciated!PS: Here's the demo for the lazy: https://binamite.com/demo (INR to NGN in 27 minutes). It'd take 3-5 days with SWIFT.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Nebula Pay - Accept crypto payments with no fees

03 Dec 2024 Crypto Fintech Payments

Nebula Pay let you accept cryptocurrency payments with no fees in few clicks. Register in seconds, set up payment links in minutes! 🟢 Zero fees 🔄 Swap to stablecoins 🚀 Instant automatic withdrawals Nebula Pay - like Stripe for crypto, but even better.

Avatar
36
36
Relevance

HexPay - 💎 Integrate P2P crypto payments easily

03 Jun 2024 Crypto Fintech Web3

Experience seamless, secure P2P crypto payments with HexPay. Accept USDT, TON, and BTC directly to your wallet with no intermediaries. Enjoy real-time transactions, robust security, and detailed analytics. Trusted by over 1,000 businesses.

HexPay's launch is met with congratulations and interest, particularly for simplifying crypto payments. Users highlight its potential for secure, real-time P2P transactions. Questions arise about its ability to manage simultaneous payments. The journey to solving crypto payment challenges is also inspiring.

The provided comment expresses curiosity rather than offering any direct criticism. Therefore, there are no criticisms to summarize.

Avatar
156
8
8
156
Relevance

CoinPays Payment Gateway - Pay securely and quickly with crypto

26 May 2024 Web App Crypto Payments

CoinPays stands out as a premier platform enabling seamless acceptance of crypto payments across websites, online stores, and social media profiles. Our platform provides tools for easy, secure, and fast payments in a variety of currencies, from crypto to fiat

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with one user expressing interest in integration. One user congratulated the team and inquired about the product's competitive advantages. One comment was deleted.

The primary criticism revolves around the product's competitive advantage in a crowded market. Users are questioning how it differentiates itself from existing solutions.

Avatar
107
3
33.3%
3
107
33.3%
Relevance

Tonpay - Platform of crypto payment solutions for business

08 Apr 2023 Fintech Web3 Payments

Tonpay is a payment solution for businesses that want to accept TON and other cryptocurrencies with the help of the cross-chain solution. Our smart-contract-based platform offers security, transparency, and simplicity for online and physical payments.

Users have expressed positive sentiments regarding the Product Hunt launch, congratulating the team and praising the product's appearance. There were also invitations to connect on Twitter.

Avatar
68
3
3
68
Relevance

Confirmo - Enable the future of payments today

16 Feb 2024 Fintech Cryptocurrency Payments

Enable your customers to pay with the best cryptocurrencies in your business. Enjoy automatic conversions to EUR to avoid volatility, or hold it all in crypto. Create an account at Confirmo.net and implement our API, payment button, or plugin to get started!

Confirmo's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users are excited about its potential to simplify crypto payments for businesses and its impact on the crypto ecosystem. Many congratulated the team and wished them good luck. Key features highlighted include seamless integration, flexibility, and potential for mainstream adoption. Questions arose regarding EUR conversions, transaction security, development milestones, and support for Tezos/XRP for cheaper gas fees. Users also appreciated the potential for fast and convenient payments to freelancers. Overall, Confirmo is viewed as a game-changer and a valuable tool for safe and efficient cryptocurrency transactions.

Users find cryptocurrency payments inconvenient and suggest integrating alternatives like Tezos/XRP due to their lower gas fees. There's also a call for real-time analytics to provide better transaction insights.

Avatar
212
37
16.2%
37
212
16.2%
Relevance

Designing and Building a self-hosted crypto checkout module

22 Jun 2024 Payments

Hi HN, we run a studio for designing + building apps for AI & web3 startups and companies and we wanted to build a self-hosted ERC-20 checkout module. This is the MVP version of it and we still want to add a webhook/listener that updates after payment and triggers other actions in the backend.This can also be used in a lot of other applications like tip mechanism, a blockchain powered version of BuyMeACoffee.com to fund creatives across the globe.Super excited to have started this anyway and open to feedback, thank you.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

ZinariPay - Empowering Seamless and Secure Cryptocurrency Payments

09 Sep 2024 Fintech Web3 Cryptocurrency

ZinariPay offers a secure, scalable, and easy-to-integrate cryptocurrency payment gateway for businesses worldwide. Our platform ensures fast, reliable, and decentralized transactions that empower your business to operate globally with confidence.

ZinariPay is being praised for its seamless integration, secure payment processing, and global reach, making it a great option for businesses looking to confidently accept cryptocurrency payments. Users are highlighting a deal involving no fees for the first three months.

Avatar
8
3
33.3%
3
8
33.3%
Relevance

Paycio - The Future Smart Crypto Payments

24 Dec 2024 Crypto Android Fintech

Paycio is a cryptocurrency payments app that enables users to send, receive, and manage crypto transactions using their mobile numbers. This user-friendly platform supports over 100 currencies across more than 180 countries.

Paycio is receiving positive feedback as an easy-to-use crypto payment solution in India, particularly noted for its reasonable fees, wide range of supported coins, and instant, affordable mobile transfers, simplifying crypto transactions.

The product launch received criticism for implying that other platforms have hidden costs and are overly complicated. This suggests a need for a more nuanced and less accusatory approach when comparing the product to its competitors.

Avatar
13
3
33.3%
3
13
33.3%
Relevance

RedotPay - Spend crypto like fiat

12 May 2024 Crypto Fintech Payments

RedotPay offers a cryptocurrency-linked credit card, enabling users to spend crypto as fiat currency worldwide. It supports major cryptocurrencies and provides advanced security with dedicated blockchain addresses and compliance with AML and eKYC regulations.

The Product Hunt launch is receiving positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team and praising the project idea. A key point of interest is the integration of crypto utility, specifically the convenient crypto-to-fiat checkout with Apple/Google Pay. There's also a query regarding availability in India and a question about managing crypto volatility to maintain consistent pricing.

Avatar
128
7
14.3%
7
128
14.3%
Relevance

P2P platform for selling goods via crypto

29 Aug 2023 Crypto E-Commerce Payments

Are there any other platforms where you can sell digital goods through crypto using smart contracts? I know platforms like gumroad, there is a paypal payment method that accepts crypto, I'm interested in using the blockchain for interaction between the seller and the buyer

Seeking platforms to sell digital goods via crypto.

Interested in blockchain for seller-buyer interaction.

Avatar
1
1
100.0%
1
1
100.0%
Top