Should I Build It Should I Build It
08 Apr 2025
Security

GenAI based security operation agents for alert investigation nd ...

...remediation

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

You're entering a competitive space with your GenAI-based security operation agents, as evidenced by the 19 similar products we identified. While this high number of matches indicates that there's definitely interest in solutions like yours, it also means you'll need a strong strategy to differentiate yourself. The engagement with similar products is medium, suggesting users are actively looking for and discussing these tools. You'll face established competitors and emerging startups. A key success factor is going to be whether you can offer something unique, be it a specific feature, better user experience, or innovative business model, to capture attention and keep it.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with an in-depth competitive analysis. Focus on identifying the strengths and weaknesses of existing solutions, paying particular attention to user reviews and feedback (like the Spectate's or Exploit Alarm's implementation challenges). Specifically, focus on the AI agent's efficacy: in at least one case (Generate malicious CloudTrail logs with AI agents) the AI solution performed worse than the manual alternative.
  2. Based on your competitive research, pinpoint at least two key differentiators. These could be specialized features, superior accuracy in threat detection, or a more intuitive user interface. Cyguru users appreciated ease of deployment and AI automation; see how you can offer something similar but better.
  3. Consider focusing on a specific niche within the security operations domain. For example, you could specialize in cloud security, IoT security, or threat intelligence for a particular industry. By focusing on a niche, you can tailor your product and marketing efforts to a specific audience, making it easier to stand out from the crowd.
  4. Develop a compelling brand and marketing strategy that highlights your unique value proposition. Clearly communicate how your GenAI agents solve specific pain points for security teams and what makes your approach superior. Leverage social media and content marketing to build awareness and generate leads.
  5. Prioritize early user feedback and iterate rapidly. Engage closely with your initial users to understand their needs and challenges. Use their feedback to refine your product and ensure it meets their expectations. Create a feedback loop where users feel heard and valued. Offer strong support from day one.
  6. Given concerns about scalability in similar products like Exploit Alarm, proactively address this issue. Invest in robust infrastructure and testing to ensure your agents can handle increasing volumes of data and alerts without performance degradation. Be transparent about your scalability capabilities in your marketing materials.
  7. Explore potential partnerships with complementary security vendors or service providers. Collaborating with others can expand your reach and provide access to new customers. Look for companies that offer products or services that align with your own, such as vulnerability scanners, SIEM systems, or incident response platforms.
  8. Develop a clear and competitive pricing strategy. Consider offering different pricing tiers based on features and usage. You might also want to explore a 'pay as you go' option, as suggested by users of Exploit Alarm. Balance affordability with the need to generate revenue and sustain your business.

Questions

  1. Considering the competitive landscape, what specific security alert investigation and remediation tasks will your GenAI agents handle more effectively or efficiently than existing solutions?
  2. How will you measure and communicate the accuracy and effectiveness of your GenAI agents in detecting and responding to security threats, especially compared to existing AI powered solutions?
  3. Given the feedback that AI generated security logs may be worse than manual analysis, how will you ensure that your GenAI based security operation agents provide tangible value and avoid being perceived as a gimmick?

Your are here

You're entering a competitive space with your GenAI-based security operation agents, as evidenced by the 19 similar products we identified. While this high number of matches indicates that there's definitely interest in solutions like yours, it also means you'll need a strong strategy to differentiate yourself. The engagement with similar products is medium, suggesting users are actively looking for and discussing these tools. You'll face established competitors and emerging startups. A key success factor is going to be whether you can offer something unique, be it a specific feature, better user experience, or innovative business model, to capture attention and keep it.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with an in-depth competitive analysis. Focus on identifying the strengths and weaknesses of existing solutions, paying particular attention to user reviews and feedback (like the Spectate's or Exploit Alarm's implementation challenges). Specifically, focus on the AI agent's efficacy: in at least one case (Generate malicious CloudTrail logs with AI agents) the AI solution performed worse than the manual alternative.
  2. Based on your competitive research, pinpoint at least two key differentiators. These could be specialized features, superior accuracy in threat detection, or a more intuitive user interface. Cyguru users appreciated ease of deployment and AI automation; see how you can offer something similar but better.
  3. Consider focusing on a specific niche within the security operations domain. For example, you could specialize in cloud security, IoT security, or threat intelligence for a particular industry. By focusing on a niche, you can tailor your product and marketing efforts to a specific audience, making it easier to stand out from the crowd.
  4. Develop a compelling brand and marketing strategy that highlights your unique value proposition. Clearly communicate how your GenAI agents solve specific pain points for security teams and what makes your approach superior. Leverage social media and content marketing to build awareness and generate leads.
  5. Prioritize early user feedback and iterate rapidly. Engage closely with your initial users to understand their needs and challenges. Use their feedback to refine your product and ensure it meets their expectations. Create a feedback loop where users feel heard and valued. Offer strong support from day one.
  6. Given concerns about scalability in similar products like Exploit Alarm, proactively address this issue. Invest in robust infrastructure and testing to ensure your agents can handle increasing volumes of data and alerts without performance degradation. Be transparent about your scalability capabilities in your marketing materials.
  7. Explore potential partnerships with complementary security vendors or service providers. Collaborating with others can expand your reach and provide access to new customers. Look for companies that offer products or services that align with your own, such as vulnerability scanners, SIEM systems, or incident response platforms.
  8. Develop a clear and competitive pricing strategy. Consider offering different pricing tiers based on features and usage. You might also want to explore a 'pay as you go' option, as suggested by users of Exploit Alarm. Balance affordability with the need to generate revenue and sustain your business.

Questions

  1. Considering the competitive landscape, what specific security alert investigation and remediation tasks will your GenAI agents handle more effectively or efficiently than existing solutions?
  2. How will you measure and communicate the accuracy and effectiveness of your GenAI agents in detecting and responding to security threats, especially compared to existing AI powered solutions?
  3. Given the feedback that AI generated security logs may be worse than manual analysis, how will you ensure that your GenAI based security operation agents provide tangible value and avoid being perceived as a gimmick?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 19
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 4
  • Net use signal: 21.4%
    • Positive use signal: 21.4%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 1.2%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.2%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Cyguru – Open SOCaaS AI-Based Security on Autopilot

11 Mar 2024 Artificial Intelligence Developer Tools

Hey HN!We're launching Cyguru Beta, a free, automated SOC (Security Operations Center) built for everyone.Traditional SOCs are expensive and complex, leaving smaller businesses vulnerable. Cyguru leverages Wazuh & Opensearch for top-tier security with a built-in AI analyst to automate incident analysis, all without needing a dedicated security team.Key Features:- Automated AI Analyst: Goes beyond basic detection, saving you time and money.- Wazuh Powered: Enterprise-grade security, free from expensive licenses.- Simple Setup: Get your SOC up and running in minutes.- Multi-Use: Protects businesses and personal networks.Cyguru is built with security and scalability in mind. We leverage the proven detection and response capabilities of Wazuh agent authentication protocols, while adding our own integrations to ensure secure open access to the internet. This allows us to handle both horizontal and vertical scaling seamlessly. We use MudBlazor for a smooth and responsive front-end, Springboot for a robust back-end, all orchestrated by the highly scalable power of Kubernetes.Free Beta & Lifetime Offer (Limited Time): Secure up to 10 agents & 2 servers for FREE!We value your feedback immensely – both the good and the constructive! Share your thoughts on our concept, your product experience, and any aspect of your journey with us.

Users are generally impressed with the product, highlighting its features, simplicity, and scalability. The ease of deployment and AI automation are particularly appreciated. The product is seen as a potentially good solution that exceeds expectations, especially for those who have been searching for such a service. Overall, the feedback is positive with congratulations on the launch and interest in the product's potential.

Avatar
15
10
30.0%
10
15
30.0%
Relevance

KubeHA - Streamline Your Alert’s Management using Gen AI

27 Nov 2024 Artificial Intelligence SaaS

Introducing KubeHA – Your Gateway to Effortless Alert Recovery Automation. Revolutionize the way you respond to alerts using the might of KubeHA's SaaS prowess and GenAI. Witness magic as it transforms complex recovery steps into a seamless automated process.

KubeHA's Product Hunt launch is receiving positive feedback. Users are excited about its GenAI-powered automation for alert analysis and remediation. The automated runbooks feature is being recognized as a valuable time-saver. Overall, the launch is being congratulated and the tool is anticipated to be helpful.

Avatar
64
2
50.0%
2
64
50.0%
Relevance

AI-powered cyber threat intelligence analysis tool

18 Jun 2024 Artificial Intelligence SaaS Security

Hi HN,I am Ted. I've been on both sides of the security fence – working security operations for clients and building enterprise security tools for vendors. One thing I've learned from years of hands-on experience is that fast and accurate information is king for good threat analysis. The problem is, it can be a real drag. You often have to juggle 5-7 different tools and webpages just to investigate a single threat case. This whole manual process of gathering info, piecing it together, and figuring out what it all means doesn't pay off like other security tasks.Then came along these cool new GenAI models. They are amazing at planning tasks, finding information, and putting it all together. It hit me – this could be a game-changer for threat analysis.Over the past year, I've seen big names like Microsoft, Crowdstrike, and Palo Alto have integrated AI capabilities into their threat analysis offerings. But these tools are expensive and often lock you into their own little data worlds. That's why I built SecAI. Think of it as your open, easy-to-use, and totally affordable AI assistant for security analysis.SecAI is aiming to empowers security analysts to achieve greater efficiency and productivity. Here's what SecAI brings to the table:1.Threat intelligence analysis and attribution with precise verdicts and comprehensive context. 2.Analyzing threat behavior from logs and scripts, providing insights. 3.Tracking threat actors/CVEs across the entire internet and generating detailed reports.Please check it out and let me know what you think. I would be grateful for your feedbacks.https://secai.ai/chat

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Spectate - Monitor, alert & manage incidents - supercharged by A.I.

19 Apr 2023 Productivity Analytics Developer Tools

Effortless monitoring, alerting and incident management supercharged by AI. 📡 Receive alerts by phone calls, SMS, Slack, email and more, manage incidents more efficiently with our Incident AI assistant and launch your own branded status page in seconds 🚀

Spectate's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users praise its design, features, efficiency, and competitive pricing. Many highlight its website monitoring capabilities, immediate incident alerts, and AI-powered status pages. Several users shared their excitement to try Spectate and expressed intentions to switch from existing monitoring services. The platform's clean dashboard and readable data were also appreciated. A few users inquired about specific monitoring capabilities. Many comments simply congratulated the team on the launch and wished them success.

The primary criticism is the need to improve the implementation of the product. This suggests that the product, in its current state, has some issues that require attention. Further details on implementation challenges would be beneficial.

Avatar
238
33
24.2%
3.0%
33
238
24.2%
3.0%
Relevance

TARS – Open-source tool for automating pentesting with AI agents

25 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence

Hi everyone,With the rise of AI agents and recent advancements in agentic research, my co-founder and I wanted to explore whether we could develop a tool to automate parts of penetration testing. This led to the creation of TARS a few months ago.TARS is our attempt to automate parts of cybersecurity penetration testing using AI agents. Currently, we leverage CrewAI as our agentic framework and GPT-4 as our primary model. We've integrated tools that allow TARS to utilize Nettacker, RustScan, ZAP, Nmap, and web browsing via the Brave API & Selenium.Recently, we decided to make TARS accessible to everyone without any restrictions, so we open-sourced TARS under the MIT license. We see the value in TARS's ability to generate general reports from surface-level scans and its potential to perform unique attacks based on the model you're using.Since TARS is in early development and still experimental, we'd greatly appreciate your feedback.You can check out TARS here: https://github.com/osgil-defense/TARSAnd view some demos of TARS here:- Short Demo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sjw_gkSz6Lw- Long Demo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JSBVHl7PWekThank you for reading!

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

NightHawk - Go undercover with your investigative AI partner

28 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity Tech

✖️ AI built on forensic methodologies and investigative best practices ✖️ Pattern analysis to uncover links in complex investigations ✖️ AI insights and questions that adapt to case developments ✖️ Visualize case timeline and location mapping

Users find AI tools beneficial for investigations, particularly for uncovering crucial details. The insights engine is specifically highlighted as helpful for investigators.

Avatar
10
3
33.3%
3
10
33.3%
Relevance

Exploit Alarm - Vulnerability intelligence for real-time threat analysis

19 Sep 2024 SaaS Security Business Intelligence

Our platform offers comprehensive data, advanced search, team collaboration tools, and seamless integration. Streamline compliance, reduce response times to cyber-threats, and enhance your security posture effortlessly.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising the platform for streamlining vulnerability management and its value in informing cybersecurity strategy. Several users inquired about real-time data updates, specific integrations, data sources, and vulnerability prioritization, particularly for small businesses. There were suggestions for a 'Pay as you go' option and integration with ConverForm.com for user engagement. Concerns were raised about execution and scaling challenges, especially with traffic spikes. The importance of reducing response time was highlighted, prompting questions about future features.

The primary criticism revolves around uncertainty regarding the product's ability to handle traffic spikes and maintain performance under increased load. Users expressed concerns about scaling and the product's robustness in demanding conditions.

Avatar
158
16
18.8%
16
158
18.8%
Relevance

LotusEye - AI Anomaly Detector

28 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Internet of Things Analytics

Freemium AI Anomaly detection product for sensor data. The AI model automatically learns normal behavior from diverse sensor data. When signs of anomalies are detected, it immediately raises an alert.

Users praise the product for its easy setup, requiring no AI expertise, and highlight it as a great anomaly detection solution. The ease of AI model creation and management, along with the availability of a free tier, are also appreciated features.

Avatar
6
2
100.0%
2
6
100.0%
Relevance

Generate malicious CloudTrail logs with AI agents

23 Feb 2024 Developer Tools

Hi HN,I used AI agents to simulate malicious and normal CloudTrail logs. Was playing around with automated Cloud pentesting tools (stratus-red-team) to generate attacker behavior, but there wasn't a good way to generate "noise" AKA false positives. I needed both good and bad CloudTrail logs to fine-tune my AWS anomaly detection model.Decided to throw together a few AI agents to generate it for me. You can play around with the attack builder here: https://simulation.tracecat.comAnybody here try using LLM agents to generate synthetic data for security analysis?If there's interest, happy to open source the prompts and code.

Results worse than manual AWS lab; prompt engineering helps.

Results worse than manual AWS lab.

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

Impulse XDR, real-time threat detection and integrity monitoring

27 Mar 2024 Security

Hello HN!Deploying the next-generation of security telemetry technologies to production is hard, so I’m building Impulse, a fully automated XDR platform that leverages tools like Osquery and eBPF to provide real-time threat detection & integrity monitoring for servers and workstations.It detects malware from behavioural patterns rather than signatures and enables deeper visibility than legacy tools. Impulse agents can be deployed on any device or VM running Linux such as cloud VMs in VPC networks, VPS servers or personal workstations and IoTs.In terms architecture, it is organised around a self-hosted, manager-sensor model that provides traditional SIEM capabilities like centralized log storage, indexing and normalization, but also automated log-correlation and real-time threat detection via 2 open-source EDR sensors (one called “light” for host intrusion detection, and “heavy” sensor with network IDS capabilities).It’s designed to be fast and easy to use, so it installs in 5 mins on as little as 1.5 gb RAM, 1-core VM.Repository: https://github.com/bgenev/impulse-xdrWeb: https://impulse-xdr.com/You can use Impulse to immediately start monitoring a server, personal Desktop, or local VM (to test it out).Main features include:- Security Analytics: Ingests telemetry data from its fleet of monitoring sensors and provides security analytics & insights.- Integrity monitoring for every aspect of your environment - files, processes, connections, ports, users, authentications, installed packages, kernel modules, etc. every variable that could be an indicator of compromise is tracked and stored in “IOCs History” table.- Network Visibility & IDS: Monitors network flows, detects intrusion attempts and automatically blocks offenders with active response.- Security Policies: Monitors system configuration settings to ensure compliance with preset core security policies and provides CIS-benchmark reports.- Active Response: Blocks suspicious IPs, stops processes, closes ports and quarantines files.- Fleet Firewall: nftables-based fleet firewall blocks offenders across the fleet.- Threat Intel: Integrates with high-quality threat intelligence providers to enrich your context data.- Vulnerability Scanning: Discovers installed packages and associated CVEs.- Self-Hosted & Open-Core: Data never leaves you servers.Please feel free to share any requests for further development, this will be a community-driven project.Roadmap: the next major iteration will have custom secure configuration packs, so that users can create checks specific to their infrastructure.

Avatar
5
5
Top