Should I Build It Should I Build It
11 Apr 2025
Developer Tools

Simple Form Builder with Magic Links (No Login Needed) frontend

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Run Away

Multiple attempts have failed with clear negative feedback. Continuing down this path would likely waste your time and resources when better opportunities exist elsewhere.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

You're entering a crowded market with your simple form builder idea, as indicated by the 19 similar products we found. This gives us high confidence in understanding the landscape, but also means you'll face significant competition. The engagement level for these similar products is moderate, with an average of 8 comments per product, suggesting there's interest but not widespread enthusiasm. Unfortunately, we don't have enough data to get a feel of the "use" and "buy" signals, so that's a bummer, and a potential blind spot for your idea. The core issue is whether your 'simple form builder with magic links' offers enough differentiation to stand out from the existing solutions, particularly concerning the no-login feature.

Recommendations

  1. Dive deep into the criticism surrounding existing form builders, especially the concern about differentiation from competitors. Many users question the unique value proposition of new form builders compared to established players like Typeform and Tally.so. Consider what specific pain points your magic link, no-login approach alleviates that others don't.
  2. Focus on user experience, and specifically the absence of the need for a password, as your main differentiator. You could conduct user interviews to discover what people dislike about form filling or other similar data entry tasks, and build your product around that.
  3. Since the average number of comments is moderate, try to create a free version that has a ton of value and is easy to share, to boost the number of users quickly. Since you already plan to use magic links, consider adding social media integrations for ease of sharing.
  4. Prioritize integrations with other platforms as Loomer users specifically asked about CRM integration to automatically upload data. Investigate what platforms your target users would like to connect with the forms they are creating, and build an integration roadmap based on this. Given the number of similar products, even a small niche can be a viable start.
  5. As Minform was criticized for asking for email responses instead of offering webhook setup, consider providing both options. Webhooks are essential for connecting to other services and automating workflows, which increases the value proposition for more advanced users.
  6. Ensure the core functionality is rock solid, as Inqform users reported issues with form editing, previewing, and even errors, and session timeouts. Prioritize reliability and a smooth user experience from the start, even for the simplest features.
  7. Clearly define your pricing model. Deftform was praised for its pay-as-you-go model, but also criticized for potentially being costly. Experiment with a transparent pricing structure that scales with usage and offers a generous free tier to attract early adopters.

Questions

  1. Given the existing form builder solutions, what is the TRUE barrier to adoption of online forms? What is the core job-to-be-done that your solution enables, and does the 'magic link' approach truly solve this better than the alternatives?
  2. How will you handle potential abuse or spam submissions with a magic link-based system, and what security measures will you implement to prevent unauthorized access to form data?
  3. How will you measure the success of your 'simple form builder' beyond just user sign-ups and form submissions? What metrics will indicate that you're providing a truly valuable and differentiated solution?

Your are here

You're entering a crowded market with your simple form builder idea, as indicated by the 19 similar products we found. This gives us high confidence in understanding the landscape, but also means you'll face significant competition. The engagement level for these similar products is moderate, with an average of 8 comments per product, suggesting there's interest but not widespread enthusiasm. Unfortunately, we don't have enough data to get a feel of the "use" and "buy" signals, so that's a bummer, and a potential blind spot for your idea. The core issue is whether your 'simple form builder with magic links' offers enough differentiation to stand out from the existing solutions, particularly concerning the no-login feature.

Recommendations

  1. Dive deep into the criticism surrounding existing form builders, especially the concern about differentiation from competitors. Many users question the unique value proposition of new form builders compared to established players like Typeform and Tally.so. Consider what specific pain points your magic link, no-login approach alleviates that others don't.
  2. Focus on user experience, and specifically the absence of the need for a password, as your main differentiator. You could conduct user interviews to discover what people dislike about form filling or other similar data entry tasks, and build your product around that.
  3. Since the average number of comments is moderate, try to create a free version that has a ton of value and is easy to share, to boost the number of users quickly. Since you already plan to use magic links, consider adding social media integrations for ease of sharing.
  4. Prioritize integrations with other platforms as Loomer users specifically asked about CRM integration to automatically upload data. Investigate what platforms your target users would like to connect with the forms they are creating, and build an integration roadmap based on this. Given the number of similar products, even a small niche can be a viable start.
  5. As Minform was criticized for asking for email responses instead of offering webhook setup, consider providing both options. Webhooks are essential for connecting to other services and automating workflows, which increases the value proposition for more advanced users.
  6. Ensure the core functionality is rock solid, as Inqform users reported issues with form editing, previewing, and even errors, and session timeouts. Prioritize reliability and a smooth user experience from the start, even for the simplest features.
  7. Clearly define your pricing model. Deftform was praised for its pay-as-you-go model, but also criticized for potentially being costly. Experiment with a transparent pricing structure that scales with usage and offers a generous free tier to attract early adopters.

Questions

  1. Given the existing form builder solutions, what is the TRUE barrier to adoption of online forms? What is the core job-to-be-done that your solution enables, and does the 'magic link' approach truly solve this better than the alternatives?
  2. How will you handle potential abuse or spam submissions with a magic link-based system, and what security measures will you implement to prevent unauthorized access to form data?
  3. How will you measure the success of your 'simple form builder' beyond just user sign-ups and form submissions? What metrics will indicate that you're providing a truly valuable and differentiated solution?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 19
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 8
  • Net use signal: -1.0%
    • Positive use signal: 7.3%
    • Negative use signal: 8.3%
  • Net buy signal: -1.5%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.4%
    • Negative buy signal: 1.9%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Minform - Free no-code and online form builder

31 Oct 2024 SaaS No-Code Productivity

A form builder that provides you the best form building user experience. Create forms as you type with realtime preview. Add multiple pages, custom thank you pages and use prebuilt form templates to quickly create forms.

Intuitive form builder with generous free tier, email response question.

Asks for email form responses instead of webhook setup.

Avatar
15
1
100.0%
1
15
100.0%
Relevance

Formlick - Your Cost-Effective Typeform Alternative

20 May 2024 Data Developer Tools Customer Success

Formlick is a simple, powerful form builder that helps you create forms, collect submissions, and manage your data. It is an alternative to Typeform

Form creation and management are excellent and easy to use. Users describe Formlick as a smooth, user-friendly, and cost-effective alternative to Typeform. They praised its dynamic and engaging form experiences and easy form submission handling. Many congratulated the launch and complimented the slick animation. Some users inquired about the details of its AI feature.

The feedback provided contained no actual criticism of the Product Hunt launch. The user simply requested details without offering any negative comments or pointing out any flaws.

Avatar
30
11
18.2%
11
30
18.2%
Relevance

I Made a Cost-Effective Typeform Alternative

20 May 2024 Productivity

Hi Everyone,I am excited to introduce [Formlick.com](https://formlick.com), a new alternative to Typeform that offers a cost-effective solution for creating dynamic and engaging forms. Recognizing the high costs associated with Typeform, several independent developers, including myself, have been working to provide a more affordable option. With the MVP now complete, I am pleased to announce that Formlick is ready for public launch.Formlick boasts several features designed to enhance user experience and functionality: - Multilingual Forms: Create forms in multiple languages to cater to a diverse audience. - AI-Generated Forms: Utilize AI to generate form content when you need inspiration. - Customizable Appearance: Modify the look and feel of your forms to align with your brand identity. - Partial Form Collection: Capture data as soon as users begin filling out the form, even if they do not complete it. - Logo Upload: Personalize your forms by uploading your logo. - Submission Notifications: Receive notifications for each form submission via webhook and email. - Submission Export: Easily export all form submissions for your records.Your feedback is invaluable as I continue to develop and improve Formlick. Please feel free to share your thoughts and suggestions.URL: https://formlick.com

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Deftform Form Builder - Create shareable and embeddable forms that just work

22 Apr 2024 SaaS Productivity Marketing

Deftform lets you create forms that are quick, easy to spin up and simply work. Collect unlimited responses, use a custom domain and more, all without starting another subscription.

Users appreciate the product's design, creativity, and pricing. The pay-as-you-go model is well-received. Many users congratulate the creators on the launch and consider the product awesome with neat design and indicate plans to use it in the future.

The main criticism is that the pay-as-you-go model could be perceived as costly for users.

Avatar
94
4
25.0%
4
94
25.0%
Relevance

DummyForms - Create Beautiful Forms in Minutes

31 Dec 2024 No-Code Operations Marketing

The easiest way to build and share online forms. No coding required. Start creating professional forms with our intuitive drag-and-drop builder. DummyForms won #3 on the Christmas Hackathon by Lovable.

Users generally appreciate DummyForms' sleek, lightweight design and user-friendliness, particularly the no-code form setup. The name is also well-received. A potential issue is the lack of email notifications upon form submission, which might be a paid feature. There is also an inquiry regarding how it compares with Tally.so. A suggestion was also given that the website have more colors.

Users criticized the lack of email notifications after form submissions, reporting uncertainty if it was a bug. Suggestions included adding more color options to the website. A key concern raised was the need to differentiate the product from competitors like Tally.so, highlighting potential feature overlap. There was also a request for future implementation of SMS notifications for urgent responses.

Avatar
204
6
16.7%
6
204
16.7%
Relevance

I made a simple web app to create forms

21 Jan 2024 Developer Tools

Hi guys,I used to ship many products a year back, but I cannot build even a simple side project due to a full-time job. Now I decided to build simple side projects and ship them without thinking about colors, logos, or other cosmetic things.PS: I wanted to move away from react/next.js and try something new so I built this side project with golang + templ + htmx.Let me know your feedback. I will keep on adding more features to it and keep it as simple as possible.URL: https://tinyform.emailBest, Arvind

Users raised questions about server processing and caching. Additionally, a small typo was noted in the 'Receive Submissions' section.

There is a typo in 'Receive Submissions'.

Avatar
2
2
2
2
Relevance

Loomer - Build and embed forms in minutes

14 Aug 2024 SaaS CRM Customer Communication

Loomer simplifies lead management with an intuitive drag-and-drop form builder, multi-platform embeds, and efficient data handling. Build and embed forms in minutes!

Loomer's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising its lead management capabilities, intuitive drag-and-drop builder, and GDPR compliance. Many see it as a game-changer for lead generation and conversion improvement, especially for non-technical users. Users congratulated on the launch. Questions were raised about CRM integration, lead analytics insights, form templates, user data privacy, and Loomer's analytics dashboard compared to competitors. Some users expressed curiosity about Loomer's unique value proposition compared to other form builders.

The primary criticism revolves around whether the form builder offers sufficient differentiation from existing market solutions. Users question its unique value proposition and the novelty it brings to the competitive landscape.

Avatar
145
21
19.0%
21
145
19.0%
Relevance

I just made my profitable online form builder open-sourced

01 Apr 2024 Productivity

Users criticized FramaForms for being clunky, lacking auto-update features, and requiring paid plugins for complexity. Concerns were raised about the definition of 'club', manual dues collection, and the risks of anonymous polls. Trust issues with major providers, confusing open sourcing, and reliance on non-open source dependencies were noted. Criticisms of NestJS included overengineering, dependency issues, and poor documentation. Licensing concerns focused on GPL interpretation, the need for AGPL, and risks to derivative works. Some users questioned the rationale behind the project and its market impact.

Avatar
389
118
-11.0%
-2.5%
118
389
7.6%
0.8%
Top