Should I Build It Should I Build It
11 Apr 2025
SaaS Climate Tech

Software to help more companies claim and sell emission incentives

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

You're entering a market where companies are increasingly focused on emission incentives, but the 'Freemium' idea category suggests users might be hesitant to pay upfront. There's already a moderate level of competition (n_matches = 12), so differentiation will be key. Given the 'Freemium' categorization, the core challenge lies in identifying which users derive the most value from the free version and then creating premium features that address their specific needs. Many competitors were focused around API solutions, so a freemium API to test and estimate company emissions would be a valuable starting point.

Recommendations

  1. First, deeply analyze the existing landscape of emission incentive programs. Understand the pain points companies face when claiming and selling these incentives. Many of the launches in your competitive set had a need for more detail, so creating a product that is comprehensive, but easy to use is a must.
  2. Offer a free tier that allows companies to calculate potential emission incentives based on limited data inputs. This will help them understand the potential value of your software. Focus on a really great UX here, as the similar product 'Bend Scorecard' got criticized for not having an explainer video.
  3. Develop premium features that automate the entire claim and sales process. This could include integrating with relevant government databases, generating necessary documentation, and connecting companies with potential buyers. The most value will be generated by minimizing friction for the end user.
  4. Consider targeting larger organizations or teams as your primary paying customers. These entities often have more complex emission profiles and stand to gain the most from a comprehensive solution. Also, larger orgs will be less price sensitive than smaller startups.
  5. Explore offering personalized consulting services to help companies navigate the complexities of emission incentive programs. This could be a valuable upsell for premium users who need additional support. You can use the free tier to build up a warm list of customers who would pay extra for the personalized consulting service.
  6. Iterate on your pricing strategy based on user feedback. Conduct A/B tests with small groups to determine the optimal price point for your premium features. Remember that users in this category are sensitive to price.
  7. Given criticisms of similar products lacking examples, create comprehensive documentation and tutorials showcasing the software's capabilities. Focus on demonstrating how it simplifies the process of claiming and selling emission incentives.
  8. Explore partnerships with existing sustainability consulting firms or environmental organizations to expand your reach and credibility. This could give you a leg up in the market because n_matches = 12.

Questions

  1. What specific types of emission incentives will your software support initially, and how will you prioritize adding new ones based on market demand?
  2. How will you ensure the accuracy and reliability of the data used to calculate emission incentives, and how will you address potential discrepancies or errors?
  3. What are the key differentiators that will make your software stand out from existing solutions, and how will you communicate these advantages to potential customers?

Your are here

You're entering a market where companies are increasingly focused on emission incentives, but the 'Freemium' idea category suggests users might be hesitant to pay upfront. There's already a moderate level of competition (n_matches = 12), so differentiation will be key. Given the 'Freemium' categorization, the core challenge lies in identifying which users derive the most value from the free version and then creating premium features that address their specific needs. Many competitors were focused around API solutions, so a freemium API to test and estimate company emissions would be a valuable starting point.

Recommendations

  1. First, deeply analyze the existing landscape of emission incentive programs. Understand the pain points companies face when claiming and selling these incentives. Many of the launches in your competitive set had a need for more detail, so creating a product that is comprehensive, but easy to use is a must.
  2. Offer a free tier that allows companies to calculate potential emission incentives based on limited data inputs. This will help them understand the potential value of your software. Focus on a really great UX here, as the similar product 'Bend Scorecard' got criticized for not having an explainer video.
  3. Develop premium features that automate the entire claim and sales process. This could include integrating with relevant government databases, generating necessary documentation, and connecting companies with potential buyers. The most value will be generated by minimizing friction for the end user.
  4. Consider targeting larger organizations or teams as your primary paying customers. These entities often have more complex emission profiles and stand to gain the most from a comprehensive solution. Also, larger orgs will be less price sensitive than smaller startups.
  5. Explore offering personalized consulting services to help companies navigate the complexities of emission incentive programs. This could be a valuable upsell for premium users who need additional support. You can use the free tier to build up a warm list of customers who would pay extra for the personalized consulting service.
  6. Iterate on your pricing strategy based on user feedback. Conduct A/B tests with small groups to determine the optimal price point for your premium features. Remember that users in this category are sensitive to price.
  7. Given criticisms of similar products lacking examples, create comprehensive documentation and tutorials showcasing the software's capabilities. Focus on demonstrating how it simplifies the process of claiming and selling emission incentives.
  8. Explore partnerships with existing sustainability consulting firms or environmental organizations to expand your reach and credibility. This could give you a leg up in the market because n_matches = 12.

Questions

  1. What specific types of emission incentives will your software support initially, and how will you prioritize adding new ones based on market demand?
  2. How will you ensure the accuracy and reliability of the data used to calculate emission incentives, and how will you address potential discrepancies or errors?
  3. What are the key differentiators that will make your software stand out from existing solutions, and how will you communicate these advantages to potential customers?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 12
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 5
  • Net use signal: 9.4%
    • Positive use signal: 10.3%
    • Negative use signal: 0.9%
  • Net buy signal: -0.9%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.9%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

CarbonScribe - Copilot for industrial carbon accounting

26 Oct 2024 Artificial Intelligence SaaS Climate Tech

CarbonScribe is the first true carbon accounting copilot. AI agents analyse invoices and spreadsheets in minutes instead of days to create assurance-ready emissions inventories. Suppliers are also autonomously engaged to maintain up-to-date data.

The CarbonScribe launch was congratulated, with users noting the significant reduction in emission inventory time achieved through AI. Well wishes were also expressed to the CarbonScribe team.

A user questioned the AI's ability to process invoices with different formatting styles. This concern centers on the system's adaptability and accuracy when faced with diverse invoice layouts.

Avatar
19
2
2
19
Relevance

EasyOffSet - Net Zero for Every Company with EasyOffset

21 Oct 2024 Budgeting Climate Tech Accounting

EasyOffset is a marketplace where companies can connect with certified providers of carbon offset credits. Integrate Your Business Software for Carbon Accounting to Automate Tasks.

Users express enthusiasm for a product focused on environmental impact and carbon offsetting. The product is praised for its comprehensive details and potential to empower businesses. There's interest in learning more about how it works, particularly regarding its certified providers and accounting integration, highlighting a need for more detailed explanations.

The primary criticism is the lack of detailed instructions or guidance on effectively utilizing the new concept or idea presented in the Product Hunt launch. Users are requesting more comprehensive information on how to work with the novel idea.

Avatar
20
6
6
20
Relevance

App and API that makes company emissions data more accessible than ever

06 May 2024 Fintech Investing Climate Tech

Own Your Beliefs makes it simple for everybody to invest in the planet.It’s a web app and API that offers the best way to decarbonize a stock portfolio and makes company emissions data more accessible and transparent than ever before. Understand and act on the carbon emissions of companies and funds you have a stake in with our transparent data and easy-to-use tools.Whether you're a professional or retail investor, with just a few clicks you can analyze your portfolio's equity-financed CO2e emissions to understand opportunities for targeted action and even remove them with permanent CO2 removal. We offer the most direct and effective way to balance your investment performance with minimizing your carbon impact.We lead with transparent company emissions data front and center, making it more accessible than ever before. If you're an activist, academic, developer, concerned employee, or just somebody who is conscious about our planet: explore our data and talk to us about your use case. Join the community that believes sustainably data should be accessible to everybody.We just built this and would appreciate any feedback (or sign-ups)!

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Bend - A modern corporate card built for climate-friendly business

03 May 2023 Fintech Climate Tech Productivity

With Bend any company or organization can automatically track and reduce their greenhouse gas emissions (for free!) as they earn 4% yield on deposits, and carbon removal credits with every purchase.

The Product Hunt launch received generally positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team. Several inquiries focused on carbon offset quantification, emission calculation accuracy, and the mechanics of carbon credit allocation (prepaid vs. given). Users also asked about bank integration (including a BYO option), international availability (U.K., U.S., Nigeria), target company size, and the possibility of offsetting carbon footprints with card rewards. The tech stack and monetization strategy were also topics of interest. Feature requests included virtual cards and carbon footprint estimation.

Users criticize the difficulty in finding an appropriate business category for the product, suggesting that "software" feels inaccurate. Additionally, there's a call for feature parity with competitors like Mercury and Brex, specifically regarding card issuance capabilities, to better serve power users.

Avatar
203
27
22.2%
27
203
22.2%
Relevance

Bend 2.0 API for transaction enrichment/CO2e estimates

11 Jan 2024 Climate Tech

Heyy HN. We’re celebrating 2 years of Bend’s existence as a company and we’ve launched a new API to help you understand the climate impact of business activity, and/or embed climate data in your application.For most companies, 80% of your emissions are from the goods and services that you buy. Unless you’re running a power plant or an airline, odds are you’re not directly combusting lots of fossil fuels. But literally everything we buy has some upstream climate impact, whether it’s the flights and Ubers that we purchase, or our AWS bills (that run on grids powered by natural gas), all the way through to the computer / phone that you’re reading this on, in an office that is heated and cooled with some amount of coal, etc. And according to the Greenhouse Gas Protocol, all these indirect emissions count towards your company’s inventory (‘scope 3’ emissions).The problem is that figuring out how to estimate the emissions from all the thousands of things a company purchases is a hard data science problem. The best methodology may be different for any given item, and the relevant data is scattered all over the place.We’ve unified it under our v2 API. Here’s how it works: Transactions: For any financial transaction, we match the transaction vendor across our database of tens-of-thousands of vendors and return an emissions estimate based on the specific company’s climate profile, as well as any public decarbonization commitments or targets they’ve set. (There’s a big difference between $100 spent at Chevron vs $100 spent at Apple, for instance) Buildings: For your office (if you still have an office!) we use data gathered by the government and specific grid-intensity info, along with your square footage, to estimate the climate impact there. Flights: For flight route information we’ve wrapped a calculator created by the International Air Transport Association in a simple API.With the SEC set to announce new climate disclosure requirements in April, and more large companies requiring their vendors to report Greenhouse Gas inventories, Bend is on a mission to make it easy for any company to understand their climate impact.We hope you find it useful — we’d love your feedback! The Estimate APIs are 100% free and always will be; the Enrichment API is a paid service but includes a generous free tier of 100 API calls / month. And of course, our dream is that you’ll be inspired to plug this data into your stack, surfacing sustainability insights to your customers.You can get a trial key at https://bend.green/trial-keyThanks! - Ted & Thomas

Users suggest that bosses should invest in tracking information. Additionally, a user from YC S22 invites questions and feedback.

Users criticized the lack of investment in tracking information by bosses, indicating a need for better tracking systems to improve transparency and efficiency.

Avatar
8
2
2
8
Relevance

CarbonSutra - API for estimating carbon emissions of organizations

05 Jan 2023 Climate Tech Accounting API

CarbonSutra API estimates the greenhouse gas emissions for your organization. Free for non-profit and small companies, it calculates carbon footprints for air travel, hotel stays, electricity, fuel, commuting, vehicles usage, freight and ecommerce shipments.

The Product Hunt launch is being congratulated for its potential to help organizations reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Users highlight the API's value for carbon emission footprint estimation and its usefulness for developers integrating it into their solutions. The API is described as transparent, flexible, and helpful, particularly when embedded in ESG software. There's general enthusiasm for the ClimateTech platform launch and appreciation for the team's support.

The main criticism is that the product lacks sufficient examples. Users are looking for more concrete demonstrations of how the product works and its potential applications.

Avatar
69
6
33.3%
6
69
33.3%
Relevance

Carbomine - Calculate, Track, and Manage Mining Operation's Emissions

15 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence SaaS Data & Analytics

Our dashboard automates accounting and generates reports, enabling precise carbon footprint management. Carbomine integrates with Mining Operation Manager (MOM) software via Restful API for effortless data collection and accurate emission calculations.

CarboMine automates accounting and carbon management, which is useful for mining companies and their sustainability efforts. Users wished them good luck with the launch.

Avatar
12
3
3
12
Relevance

Bend Scorecard - Estimate company emissions in 2min

19 Sep 2023 Fintech Climate Tech Analytics

Answer three simple questions, and we'll estimate your company's emissions, leveraging a leading economic climate model with 4m+ data points. See how you stack up against your industry peers.

Bend's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users praising its ability to track company sustainability goals and help businesses reduce emissions. Several users congratulated the team on the launch and expressed excitement about the product's potential, particularly for climate action and emissions measurement against industry peers. There were also inquiries about data accuracy, viral sharing mechanisms, future features, and API availability. One user expressed a preference for traditional fuels, and a comment was deleted.

Users question the accuracy of the data collected due to the limited number of questions. Additionally, a user suggests incorporating an explainer video to enhance user engagement and make the experience more enjoyable.

Avatar
185
18
5.6%
-5.6%
18
185
11.1%
Relevance

Sustainable climate compensation plans for individuals and companies

07 May 2024 Climate Tech

Hello everyone!I would like to share an environmental project I am working on.It’s a web application for sustainable climate compensation plans, which are based on ecosystem restoration projects, and also includes impact tracking and anti-greenwashing measures.The idea came up while browsing reddit, where one redditor shared their environmental impact tracking spreadsheet, but wasn’t sure how to properly include the compensation from recently bought trees. The organization from which they bought those trees didn’t provide reliable information on their impact and how it is spread in time, so I started researching this topic more and found out, that there are many services which either overestimate their impact or even use creative carbon accounting.I know that everything now is a subscription, and in most cases it isn’t good for customers, but it is easier to stick with a subscription to gradually build towards tangible environmental impact, as it requires proper scale, therefore time and/or resources. The upside of planting trees is, that their impact doesn’t disappear after canceling a subscription, so you don’t lose it.We plan to restore temperate broadleaf woodland and forest ecosystems, mainly on agriculturally degraded and unproductive land. As soon as we confirm the details with our potential regional partners, we will add more information how it works to our website, including where, how, and with whom we’ll do the fieldworks.The app wouldn’t be possible without immense help from a programmer and support from an incubation program. We have many ideas how we can improve it, but will appreciate your feedback!

Avatar
1
1
Top