Should I Build It Should I Build It
07 May 2025
Artificial Intelligence YouTube

my app will download youtube transcript to feed to AI

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your idea to create an app that downloads YouTube transcripts and feeds them into AI falls into a crowded space. We found 29 similar products, indicating high competition. The overall engagement for these products is low, with an average of only 3 comments per product launch. This suggests that while the concept is appealing, many solutions already exist and it's hard to stand out. Without any use and buy signals, it’s hard to determine if anyone will pay for your product or even use it. Given these factors, proceed with caution and a clear understanding of how you will differentiate your app from the many similar offerings already available. Don't build it.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by thoroughly researching existing solutions for downloading YouTube transcripts and integrating them with AI. Understand their strengths and weaknesses, particularly regarding accuracy, speed, and user experience. The high number of similar products (29) means you need a compelling differentiator.
  2. Focus on a niche within the broader market. Instead of targeting all YouTube content, consider focusing on educational videos, specific industries (e.g., legal or medical), or content creators needing very specific features. Specialization can help you stand out. For example, many users of similar products mentioned issues with accuracy, so this is a great starting point.
  3. Rather than building a standalone app, explore integrating your technology as a feature within existing platforms or tools that content creators or researchers already use. This could provide a more direct route to market and reduce the need to acquire new users from scratch. Consider building tools for the existing providers instead of competing directly.
  4. Given the low engagement with similar products, prioritize user feedback early and often. Launch a minimal viable product (MVP) and gather feedback on its core functionality before investing in additional features. This iterative approach will help you validate your assumptions and refine your product based on user needs.
  5. Explore alternative problems or applications for your AI-powered transcription technology. The core technology might be more valuable in a different context or applied to a different type of data. For example, rather than focusing on YouTube, consider podcasts or webinars where the market may be less saturated.
  6. Address the concerns raised in the criticisms of similar products. Many users reported issues with poor formatting, lack of punctuation, and inaccurate transcriptions, especially with varying accents. Prioritize these areas for improvement to build a superior product.
  7. Consider how you might handle YouTube's API limitations, as some similar products faced issues with scraping and bandwidth due to the lack of an official transcript API. Explore alternative methods for obtaining transcripts or improving the efficiency of your scraping process.
  8. Implement a clear plan for content generation. This includes creating tutorials, blog posts, and case studies that demonstrate the value of your app and how it solves specific problems for your target audience. Show, don't just tell, how your app improves upon existing solutions.

Questions

  1. Considering the existing solutions and the challenges they face (e.g., accuracy, API limitations), what unique technology or approach will your app leverage to provide a significantly better user experience and accurate AI results?
  2. Given the low engagement observed in similar products, how will you build a community around your app and foster meaningful interaction with your users to drive adoption and gather ongoing feedback?
  3. How will you address potential copyright concerns related to downloading and using YouTube transcripts for AI processing, and ensure compliance with YouTube's terms of service?

Your are here

Your idea to create an app that downloads YouTube transcripts and feeds them into AI falls into a crowded space. We found 29 similar products, indicating high competition. The overall engagement for these products is low, with an average of only 3 comments per product launch. This suggests that while the concept is appealing, many solutions already exist and it's hard to stand out. Without any use and buy signals, it’s hard to determine if anyone will pay for your product or even use it. Given these factors, proceed with caution and a clear understanding of how you will differentiate your app from the many similar offerings already available. Don't build it.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by thoroughly researching existing solutions for downloading YouTube transcripts and integrating them with AI. Understand their strengths and weaknesses, particularly regarding accuracy, speed, and user experience. The high number of similar products (29) means you need a compelling differentiator.
  2. Focus on a niche within the broader market. Instead of targeting all YouTube content, consider focusing on educational videos, specific industries (e.g., legal or medical), or content creators needing very specific features. Specialization can help you stand out. For example, many users of similar products mentioned issues with accuracy, so this is a great starting point.
  3. Rather than building a standalone app, explore integrating your technology as a feature within existing platforms or tools that content creators or researchers already use. This could provide a more direct route to market and reduce the need to acquire new users from scratch. Consider building tools for the existing providers instead of competing directly.
  4. Given the low engagement with similar products, prioritize user feedback early and often. Launch a minimal viable product (MVP) and gather feedback on its core functionality before investing in additional features. This iterative approach will help you validate your assumptions and refine your product based on user needs.
  5. Explore alternative problems or applications for your AI-powered transcription technology. The core technology might be more valuable in a different context or applied to a different type of data. For example, rather than focusing on YouTube, consider podcasts or webinars where the market may be less saturated.
  6. Address the concerns raised in the criticisms of similar products. Many users reported issues with poor formatting, lack of punctuation, and inaccurate transcriptions, especially with varying accents. Prioritize these areas for improvement to build a superior product.
  7. Consider how you might handle YouTube's API limitations, as some similar products faced issues with scraping and bandwidth due to the lack of an official transcript API. Explore alternative methods for obtaining transcripts or improving the efficiency of your scraping process.
  8. Implement a clear plan for content generation. This includes creating tutorials, blog posts, and case studies that demonstrate the value of your app and how it solves specific problems for your target audience. Show, don't just tell, how your app improves upon existing solutions.

Questions

  1. Considering the existing solutions and the challenges they face (e.g., accuracy, API limitations), what unique technology or approach will your app leverage to provide a significantly better user experience and accurate AI results?
  2. Given the low engagement observed in similar products, how will you build a community around your app and foster meaningful interaction with your users to drive adoption and gather ongoing feedback?
  3. How will you address potential copyright concerns related to downloading and using YouTube transcripts for AI processing, and ensure compliance with YouTube's terms of service?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 29
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: 4.4%
    • Positive use signal: 9.1%
    • Negative use signal: 4.7%
  • Net buy signal: -2.5%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 2.5%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Transcript Generator - Generate blog content from YouTube transcripts with AI.

21 May 2024 Writing YouTube Marketing

Create blog posts from YouTube videos in seconds. Download, search, and customise the transcript from any YouTube video. Then use the AI features to enhance it and create custom content for your site.

The Product Hunt launch received congratulations from users. A key question raised concerns the accuracy of the AI, especially regarding different accents and dialects. One user reported a positive initial experience, noting that the AI quickly generated a decent article.

Avatar
12
2
50.0%
2
12
50.0%
Relevance

I create a free website for download YouTube transcript, subtitle

18 Feb 2024 YouTube

It use youtube_transcript_api

The product is a script that enhances YouTube transcript formatting, adding punctuation and structure. Users mention its reliance on YouTube's API, which lacks official support for transcripts, leading to inefficient scraping and potential bandwidth issues. There's speculation about YouTube's motives, suggesting they limit competition and keep training data costly. Positive feedback exists alongside technical discussions about tools like yt-dlp, error handling, and content-to-markdown conversion. Questions about copyright, obtaining transcripts, and searching subtitles also arise. The code is open-source with an MIT license.

Users criticized the product for poorly formatted auto-generated subtitles, lack of a clear API endpoint from Google, and YouTube's cultural resistance to exposing a transcript API. Inefficient scraping methods were likened to pseudo-DDOS attacks. The absence of a clear competitor and behavior that limits competition were noted. Complaints about YouTube restricting data access, raw transcripts lacking punctuation, unclear punctuation derivation, and suggestions to use Whisper for retranscription were made. Technical issues with --trim-filenames not working, rg failing with timestamp metadata, and gibberish subtitles were reported. There were also mentions of YouTube blocking IPs and advice to avoid API requests for transcripts.

Avatar
125
26
0.0%
26
125
3.8%
Relevance

A simple app for downloading YouTube transcripts in bulk

08 Jul 2024 Productivity

After hearing several youtubers I follow describe ardiuous manual processes for downloading youtube transcripts, I made a simple app to help anyone download transcripts in bulk.Drag and drop a text file with one url per line, or enter urls manually.hf space demo --> https://huggingface.co/spaces/neonwatty/youtube_shorts_trans...github repo --> https://github.com/neonwatty/youtube_shorts_transcript_downl...

Users suggest using yt-dlp and provide a related Reddit link. They express a desire for a tool to search and download video transcripts, noting that YouTube only allows transcript downloads for one's own uploads. There is also a question about whether the tool only works for YouTube Shorts.

Users prefer no authentication/login, find the transcripts to be of poor quality, and are disappointed that the service only works for short videos.

Avatar
21
4
0.0%
4
21
25.0%
Relevance

Transcriptal - Free AI powered Youtube transcription platform

05 Dec 2023 Artificial Intelligence YouTube Productivity

Transcriptal provides free YouTube transcriptions! With their AI-powered platform, get fast and accurate results for your YouTube content—no signups. Unlock easy and efficient transcription services today.

Transcriptal's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users praising its speed, accuracy, and ease of use, particularly the no sign-up feature for YouTube transcriptions. Some users are considering switching to Transcriptal for blogging purposes. Questions were raised about its unique features, backend models, and speaker recognition capabilities. Users also noted the tool's speed in searching videos, and one user promoted a similar product. Overall, the sentiment towards Transcriptal is enthusiastic, with many calling it a game-changer and awesome tool for content creation.

A user suggested adding custom formatting options.

Avatar
52
13
15.4%
13
52
15.4%
Relevance

An app for downloading YouTube videos, transcripts, and thumbnails

05 Aug 2024 YouTube

I found the manual process of downloading various YouTube assets painful so built a simple app to help myself and hopefully others.The app wraps up popular Python libraries (`yt-dlp, scrapetube, youtube-transcript-api`) and makes their functionality easier to use.Python and Docker versions are available.

Avatar
6
6
Relevance

I Built VideoSnack – Repurpose Videos to Text Content with AI

17 Jun 2024 Artificial Intelligence Video Productivity

I'm creating how-to videos for my other SAAS products and I built my own process where I would take the Youtube video transcript and add it to ChatGPT with a couple of optimized prompts to turn it into a tutorial like blog post. I would take the resulted text, add it to Google Docs where I would format it, add images, links and so on, and export it to my WordPress website with DocPress (a tool I built for that pupose).Based on this experience I built VideoSnack, a Google Docs add-on (for now) that does all this with a couple of clicks. Just add the YouTube video, set your options and you get a ready to be published blog post or other types of content like newsletter, summary, tutorial, show notes and more.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

An Open Source "News Feed" for AI-Focused Videos on YouTube

07 Feb 2024 Artificial Intelligence YouTube

Source Code: https://github.com/bingdai/summaryfeedsSummary Feeds (https://www.summaryfeeds.com) is a website that:- Fetches transcripts of AI-focused YouTube videos, using the YouTube Transcript API by pypi.org.- Uses OpenAI's GPT-3.5-turbo-16k to summarize video transcripts.- Presents summaries in an easily readable format.- Organized interface to browse video summaries by date.Tech Stack:- Front End: HTML/CSS. No JavaScript needed yet.- Back End: Python's Flask Framework- Third-Party APIs:--- YouTube Transcript API by pypi.org, for transcript retrieval.--- Google's YouTube Data API, for retrieving information like each video's title and publication date.--- OpenAI API, for summarizing the transcripts.- Deployment: AWS Elastic Beanstalk---------By the way, if you want to summarize any YouTube videos, please try out my other project, Summary Cat (https://www.summarycat.com). It uses a very similar tech stack as Summary Feeds.---------Happy to answer any questions you might have!! Any criticisms, suggestions, and feedbacks would be sincerely appreciated.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

AI Analysis of Bryan Cantrill's Rust Talks [video]

13 Sep 2023 Artificial Intelligence

Hi HN,Matt here, founder of https://flowch.aiI just added the ability to add transcripts of YouTube videos to FlowChai, and was pleased with how well it works.In this demo I show how easy it is to take some YouTube videos on a subject and then easily use the content of those videos for efficient research, content creation and more.Happy to get feedback or answer questions.

Users expressed concerns about the ability to capture metaphors in various contexts. One user suggested replacing Bryan Cantrill with the product or service being discussed.

The main criticisms are the need to replace Bryan Cantrill and the difficulty in capturing metaphors.

Avatar
3
2
2
3
Relevance

Turn YouTube videos into study notes w/ Streaming, GPT, and Whisper

20 Mar 2023 Productivity

Hey HN!I just launched https://magic.jxnl.co/youtube, a small app that streamlines YouTube videos by providing powerful tools to turn video content to structured written content.Key features:Transcription: The app utilizes existing transcripts or our custom, private streaming version of Whisper to generate accurate transcriptions.Markdown Summary: A streaming markdown summary is automatically created for each video, making it easier to digest the content.Timestamps & Chapters: Our app generates timestamped sections with links that you can copy and paste into YouTube comments, which in turn creates your own chapters for seamless navigation.Tips: Click the # to jump to that section of the youtube video, copy chapters and leave it as a comment share / help others. I even set up a little chrome extension in case people find this useful.Give it a try and let me know your thoughts!Note: I'm limit transcription length right now to prevent my system getting overloaded. only the first 60000 characters of transcripts are processed.

A new app was launched to streamline YouTube videos with transcription and summaries. Users praised the tool but encountered issues with the URL input, which only showed the embedded video without providing a summary. Multiple users reported the same problem.

Users criticized the transcription length being limited to 60,000 characters and the lack of summarization features, with only an embedded video being provided. These issues were mentioned multiple times.

Avatar
20
4
-25.0%
-25.0%
4
20
Relevance

How I made AI watch YouTube for me!

26 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence

Hey friends!We built an AI app to make it easy for you to consume long YouTube videos This app converts videos to short blog posts with a Python app powered by Langchain and EvaDB: https://github.com/yulaicui/youtube_video_qaHere's an 3 minute blog post based on an 8-hour video from MindsDB AI Developer Convention 2023: https://medium.com/evadb-blog/ai-generated-summary-of-mindsd...

Users appreciate the innovative Python app for simplifying the consumption of long YouTube videos. They are excited about the use of large language models (LLMs) and commend the app's simplicity.

Avatar
17
2
2
17
Relevance

Turn any YouTube video into a summary, quiz, & flashcards

14 Oct 2024 Artificial Intelligence Education YouTube

YouTube is the greatest learning resource in the world. Yet it doesn't provide any tools to help you learn from videos.I built a simple app that turns YouTube videos into structured learning material using AI. It generates a summary, quiz and flashcards from video content, meaning you can learn from anything (well, at least any YouTube video).Try it out. Would be happy to keep building features based on feedback!

Users are discussing a product or service related to YouTube video handling, expressing concerns about variability in video quality and style, and the compensation for video creators. There is a desire for the service to support all media targets that yt-dlp supports, and a wish not to be overwhelmed by the service. One user is impressed by the payment computation feature.

Users have criticized the product for its inability to adapt to various content styles and its lack of clear benefits for video creators. Additionally, there is dissatisfaction with the limited support for yt-dlp media targets and the incomplete coverage of all sites by yt-dlp.

Avatar
5
6
16.7%
6
5
16.7%
Relevance

YouTube Transcript Cleaner and Reader Tool

18 Jul 2023 Artificial Intelligence YouTube

I made this little self-hosted tool to scratch an itch I had-- I often want to check out long YouTube videos, but they are very slow and I can read much faster than I can listen to something. But I couldn't find a good way to do this without a lot of effort and waiting.I know there are various tools that use OpenAI's Whisper to generate transcripts for YouTube videos, but they take forever to run and the output isn't very nice to read. YouTube already has quite good automatic transcripts for most videos, but the problem is that they are also not really formatted to read easily.I discovered that there is a good free Chrome extension to extract the official YouTube transcript as text to your clipboard (link to the extension is in the readme in my repo), but that just gets you plain text with awkward line breaks.So this little html file can be saved to your local computer and opened in Chrome. Then you just go to the video you want, get the entire transcript in your clipboard using that Chrome extension, and paste it into my tool and click the button to clean it. It takes a couple seconds to run (since it's using a heavy library to determine the optimal line breaks) but then you can view it in a nice little reader mode that makes it quite pleasant. Hopefully people will find it useful.Oh, and the most interesting part of all this from my perspective is that ChatGPT wrote basically all of it from scratch in around an hour or so-- I only had to glue together some code and give feedback. I shared a link to the ChatGPT conversation in the readme file so you can see how I was able to do this step by step.

Request for bug reports and questions on code.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

Read any YouTube video with punctuations added using AI in the browser

24 Oct 2023 Artificial Intelligence

Most YouTube transcripts lack punctuations. So this app adds them back using a deep learning model based on DistilBert converted to ONNX for inference in your browser.

Users appreciate the app's ability to add punctuation to YouTube transcripts using DistilBert and its in-browser functionality. There's interest in future features like handling chapters or paragraphs, and questions about the potential for open-source availability. Users are also curious about the app's use of YouTube captions or ASR and suggest adding a summarization feature.

Users have criticized the product for lacking chapters or separate paragraphs, and for YouTube transcripts missing punctuation. Additionally, there is a mention that other apps already include the feature presented.

Avatar
7
7
28.6%
7
7
28.6%
Relevance

Free web app to read YouTube transcripts and highlight them

05 May 2024 YouTube

Quick hack: just replace youtube.com with appblit.com to see the transcript of any YouTube video.Example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0AaNT7XO41I https://www.appblit.com/watch?v=0AaNT7XO41I

Users commented on a Show HN product discussing the paragraph segmentation challenge in whisper.cpp, appreciating clickable text links to audio, suggesting replacing youtube.com with appblit.com for video transcripts, expressing confusion about highlighted text usage, unclear instructions during loading spinner, and confirming successful downloads.

Users have reported issues with paragraph segmentation, a non-functioning video feature, inoperative export buttons, and unclear instructions.

Avatar
15
6
-16.7%
-16.7%
6
15
Relevance

I made an app that turns YouTube videos and articles into a course

22 Jul 2024 Artificial Intelligence Education Online Learning

Hey everyone! I'm a solo developer and I made this app during my free time after graduating high school.studymap.ai uses AI to create structured courses from start to finish, with lessons, project ideas, and links to useful internet resources. You can either describe what you want to learn or just give it the link to any YouTube video or article and it will create organized chapters.I had this idea after struggling to learn new skills online, like Linux, new programming languages, etc. I found myself browsing for hours just to find the perfect resources to get started with actually learning. Once I realized I could use the power of GPT-4 and web-searching APIs to create a course for me, I had to make it into an app.If you visit my website there are some free courses I generated for you to try out. Let me know what you think!

Avatar
2
2
Top