Your are here

You're entering a market that seems quite niche right now. There's very little activity around similar ideas, suggesting that the problem might not be widespread or pressing enough for most people. With only one similar product identified, we have low confidence in our assessment, but it seems like there is at least one similar product that achieved low engagement. The lack of strong 'use' or 'buy' signals reinforces this idea. It indicates that you need to carefully validate if there is real demand before investing too much time and resources. Think of yourself as a detective, trying to find solid proof that this is a pain point worth solving for a significant number of soccer enthusiasts.

Recommendations

1. Given the minimal signal, your first step should be intense validation. Don't jump into building the app just yet. Your immediate goal is to confirm that there's a real need for organized soccer field rentals and management.
2. Start by posting in online communities where soccer players and teams gather. These could be Facebook groups, Reddit forums, or dedicated soccer websites. Gauge interest by asking direct questions about their current methods for finding and booking fields, and what problems they face.
3. Offer to manually solve the problem for a small number of potential customers. For example, you could manually call fields and coordinate rentals for a local team for a week or two. This will give you direct insight into the pain points and what features are most valuable.
4. Create a simple explainer video showcasing how your app would work and the benefits it offers. Keep it short, engaging, and focused on solving their specific problems. Track how many people watch the video fully – this is a good indicator of genuine interest.
5. Consider asking for a small, non-refundable deposit to join a waiting list for your app. This is a strong signal of commitment and will help you prioritize your efforts. Make it clear that the deposit goes towards the development of the app and guarantees early access.
6. Set a clear deadline for your validation efforts. If you can't find at least five genuinely interested people within three weeks, it's a strong sign that the demand isn't there, and you should reconsider pursuing this idea or pivot significantly.
7. Analyze the features of 'Soccerbro' and try to contact its creator. See if you can find out what worked, what didn't and what they would do differently. While they only got 1 comment, that single comment ('Excited about real-time leaderboards and stats for local soccer tournaments.') gives a clue: maybe focus on the tournament angle initially, not just field rentals.
8. Based on the Soccerbro comment, explore integrations with existing tournament management platforms. This could provide immediate value and attract users who are already organizing tournaments.

Questions

1. What specific unmet needs of soccer players and field owners are you addressing that aren't currently being met by existing solutions, and how can you prove these needs exist?
2. Given the minimal market activity, what's your riskiest assumption about the demand for this app, and what's the quickest, cheapest way to test that assumption before building anything?
3. If you can only focus on one core feature to attract early adopters, would it be field rentals, tournament management, or something else entirely, and why?