Should I Build It Should I Build It
20 Apr 2025
Developer Tools

Like codecrafters which lets you build things like redis or git from ...

...scratch, except you build out a website or implement a new feature on the site using design patterns, framework pardigms and best practices.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Your idea to create a platform similar to CodeCrafters, but focused on building websites and implementing features using design patterns and best practices, falls into the "Competitive Terrain" category. This means there's demonstrated interest in learning and practicing software development, but the market is already populated with similar offerings. With 7 similar products already identified, competition is high. To break through the noise, you'll need to pinpoint exactly how your platform will stand out. While there's no use or buy signal, high engagement (avg 11 comments) suggests a willingness from users to help evolve the product, should it be interesting enough. The key challenge isn't validating demand; it's carving out a unique space for yourself and keeping users engaged through compelling content and innovative features.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with a thorough competitive analysis. Focus on identifying the strengths and weaknesses of existing platforms like CodeCrafters and DaDaBIK. Analyze their content, teaching methodologies, and user engagement strategies. Based on feedback from CodeCrafters, for example, it might be worth identifying a clear target audience, beginners vs. experienced developers, and adjust course difficulty accordingly.
  2. Define a clear and specific niche. Instead of broadly targeting "website development," consider focusing on a specific framework (e.g., React, Vue), a particular type of website (e.g., e-commerce, portfolio sites), or a specific skill set (e.g., front-end architecture, back-end API design). This will help you attract a more targeted audience and differentiate your platform.
  3. Develop a unique learning experience. Think beyond simply recreating existing website features. Can you incorporate elements of gamification, personalized feedback, or collaborative learning to make the experience more engaging? Based on reviews, focus on helping users understand computer science fundamentals, which seems to drive adoption.
  4. Prioritize high-quality content and clear learning paths. Ensure that your tutorials are well-structured, easy to follow, and cover relevant design patterns and best practices. Invest in creating detailed documentation, code examples, and interactive exercises to reinforce learning. As noted from similar platforms, fixing correctness issues promptly will be essential for user satisfaction.
  5. Actively engage with your community. Create a forum or chat where users can ask questions, share their work, and provide feedback. Respond promptly to user inquiries and incorporate their suggestions into your platform. Consider implementing social features to help collaboration, a feature requested from CodeCrafters' audience.
  6. Develop a robust content plan. Plan to regularly add new projects, features, and learning modules to keep users engaged and coming back for more. Based on criticism of similar products, it will be important to keep your projects current. Consider having mechanisms to allow users to suggest new content or flag outdated information.
  7. Focus on marketing that emphasizes your unique value proposition. Highlight what makes your platform different from the competition and how it can help users achieve their specific goals. Showcase successful user projects and testimonials to build trust and credibility.
  8. Since the engagement is high, consider a launch strategy where the initial users are involved in helping you create and curate content - this leverages their expertise as well and will result in higher engagement.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competitive landscape, what specific, unique value proposition will your platform offer to attract and retain users, and how will you effectively communicate this value to your target audience?
  2. Considering the importance of community engagement, what specific strategies will you implement to foster a vibrant and supportive learning environment on your platform, and how will you encourage users to actively participate and contribute?
  3. With the need for continuous content updates and improvements, how will you ensure the long-term sustainability of your platform's content, and what mechanisms will you put in place to gather user feedback and incorporate it into your development process?

Your are here

Your idea to create a platform similar to CodeCrafters, but focused on building websites and implementing features using design patterns and best practices, falls into the "Competitive Terrain" category. This means there's demonstrated interest in learning and practicing software development, but the market is already populated with similar offerings. With 7 similar products already identified, competition is high. To break through the noise, you'll need to pinpoint exactly how your platform will stand out. While there's no use or buy signal, high engagement (avg 11 comments) suggests a willingness from users to help evolve the product, should it be interesting enough. The key challenge isn't validating demand; it's carving out a unique space for yourself and keeping users engaged through compelling content and innovative features.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with a thorough competitive analysis. Focus on identifying the strengths and weaknesses of existing platforms like CodeCrafters and DaDaBIK. Analyze their content, teaching methodologies, and user engagement strategies. Based on feedback from CodeCrafters, for example, it might be worth identifying a clear target audience, beginners vs. experienced developers, and adjust course difficulty accordingly.
  2. Define a clear and specific niche. Instead of broadly targeting "website development," consider focusing on a specific framework (e.g., React, Vue), a particular type of website (e.g., e-commerce, portfolio sites), or a specific skill set (e.g., front-end architecture, back-end API design). This will help you attract a more targeted audience and differentiate your platform.
  3. Develop a unique learning experience. Think beyond simply recreating existing website features. Can you incorporate elements of gamification, personalized feedback, or collaborative learning to make the experience more engaging? Based on reviews, focus on helping users understand computer science fundamentals, which seems to drive adoption.
  4. Prioritize high-quality content and clear learning paths. Ensure that your tutorials are well-structured, easy to follow, and cover relevant design patterns and best practices. Invest in creating detailed documentation, code examples, and interactive exercises to reinforce learning. As noted from similar platforms, fixing correctness issues promptly will be essential for user satisfaction.
  5. Actively engage with your community. Create a forum or chat where users can ask questions, share their work, and provide feedback. Respond promptly to user inquiries and incorporate their suggestions into your platform. Consider implementing social features to help collaboration, a feature requested from CodeCrafters' audience.
  6. Develop a robust content plan. Plan to regularly add new projects, features, and learning modules to keep users engaged and coming back for more. Based on criticism of similar products, it will be important to keep your projects current. Consider having mechanisms to allow users to suggest new content or flag outdated information.
  7. Focus on marketing that emphasizes your unique value proposition. Highlight what makes your platform different from the competition and how it can help users achieve their specific goals. Showcase successful user projects and testimonials to build trust and credibility.
  8. Since the engagement is high, consider a launch strategy where the initial users are involved in helping you create and curate content - this leverages their expertise as well and will result in higher engagement.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competitive landscape, what specific, unique value proposition will your platform offer to attract and retain users, and how will you effectively communicate this value to your target audience?
  2. Considering the importance of community engagement, what specific strategies will you implement to foster a vibrant and supportive learning environment on your platform, and how will you encourage users to actively participate and contribute?
  3. With the need for continuous content updates and improvements, how will you ensure the long-term sustainability of your platform's content, and what mechanisms will you put in place to gather user feedback and incorporate it into your development process?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 7
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 11
  • Net use signal: 31.5%
    • Positive use signal: 31.5%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 6.5%
    • Positive buy signal: 6.5%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

CodeCrafters (YC S22) - Recreate your favorite developer tools from scratch

18 May 2023 Coding Books Software Engineering Developer Tools

CodeCrafters makes interactive courses for software engineers, where you get to recreate popular developer tools from scratch. Build your own Redis, Git, Docker, and SQLite—in Go, Python, Rust, etc.

CodeCrafters is lauded for its hands-on, project-based approach to learning programming, making it a unique and effective tool for developers of various experience levels. Users appreciate the balanced challenges, clean platform, and helpful community. Many highlight its utility in learning new languages by recreating real-world tools and applications. The platform is seen as particularly beneficial for understanding CS fundamentals, developer onboarding, and maintaining coding skills. Several users inquire about course suitability, certifications, tech stack, and future updates. Overall, the reception is overwhelmingly positive, with many congratulating the team on the launch and expressing excitement about the product's potential.

Users find the platform intimidating and geared towards beginners, not experienced developers. There are concerns about keeping projects current, deciding tutorial structure, and reinventing existing solutions. Requests include social features for collaboration, more product-focused challenges instead of infrastructure, and clarity on course creation/prioritization. Users questioned the submission process and suggested improving the initial product image.

Avatar
280
48
31.2%
48
280
31.2%
Relevance

DaDaBIK 12: New UI, build with AI & more - The Low-code/No-code Web App Builder, Self-hosted Since 2001

23 Jul 2024 Database No-Code Developer Tools

Start from an existing DB, Excel file, or from scratch and build internal tools, business apps, admin portals, or personal databases in minutes without coding. Enhance with custom JS and PHP, if needed (low-code). Self-hosted, deploy anywhere with ease.

DaDaBIK receives overwhelmingly positive feedback, praised for its ease of use, customizability, and excellent support. Users highlight its intuitive design, simple installation, and flexibility for various applications, including humanitarian work. Many appreciate its mature CRUD solution for MySQL databases, time-saving capabilities, and the developer's responsiveness to user requests. The new UI is lauded as fantastic and user-friendly. Long-time users and new adopters alike recommend DaDaBIK for both personal and business use, emphasizing its ability to streamline database management and allow focus on core client needs.

Users criticized the enterprise license's limited support tickets (5). Additionally, the AI AppifyText tool was noted as needing more robustness to improve its functionality and reliability.

Avatar
32
15
66.7%
40.0%
15
32
66.7%
40.0%
Relevance

Build Apps with Automated Workflows

26 Jan 2023 API Developer Tools

Hey HN! We [1] just released a new thing: http://tines.com/product/build-apps.tl;dr – it's a way to build simple-but-slick web apps that are powered by API automation behind the scenes, without writing code.No code? It's because our traditional users are technical-but-not-engineer types like Security Analysts and IT Managers. So this new way of building front-end experiences follows that lead. But as a more technical maker myself, I've been really surprised at how well this works and scales, and we’re seeing teams like Engineering and DevOps increasingly adopt also. I think maybe it's because us software people most intimately understand the long-term/hidden costs of code… maintaining, bug-fixing, deployment, etc.Anyway, If you’d like to check it out…1. there's a usable version of a demo app mid-way down the page above, and then clicking the "How was this built?" button shows you the equivalent of source-code, i.e. the visual automation underpinning everything.2. we have a forever-free tier, which you can sign up for here and play around for real: https://www.tines.com/sign-upI’d love to hear any and all feedback! We love a good dose of HN-style tough love, which we certainly received our fair share of last time we surfaced here :-) [2]- Stephen---[1]: Tines – no code automation [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30249518

Avatar
3
3
Relevance

I'm building a new Bubble – for tech and non-tech people

15 Feb 2023 Open Source No-Code Developer Tools

Website: https://codesmash.studio/schemaDemo: https://youtu.be/aBT0qPnl42UOkay guys, I'm building a new No Code platform. The biggest problem with current No Code app builders, from what I can tell, is the lock-in.That's why I'm making sure to build a No Code platform where you will have access to all of your code, which will be saved in Git repos by default. This way there will be no lock-in. The devs will be able to access the code with VS Code, so they can work in sync with non-tech guys, who will be using the UI.You can think of it as NPM for fullstack apps. Users will be able to compose apps from repos. Repos will be provided by the community, so any frontend, backend or infrastructure code can be reused in building new apps.Currently, I'm working on supporting Terraform to create composable AWS infrastructure. Feature requests are welcome and I'll add them to my roadmap!

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

a Rust intro for experienced programmers

10 Nov 2023 Software Engineering Developer Tools

Hey everybody, it's Sarup and Paul, co-founders of CodeCrafters (YC S22).Today, we're excited to launch the CodeCrafters Rust Primer.https://app.codecrafters.io/collections/rust-primerIt's a free intro to Rust designed with experienced engineers in mind.What problem does it solve?As an experienced engineer learning a new language, you don't need yet another coding 101. You simply want to find out what's unique in the new language, and get to the actual work.So we built a Rust intro that:— jumps right into what's important— reveals one idea at a time, with code examples— can be interactively used on your phone, with "taps"Why we built this?Our core product CodeCrafters, is a set of interactive challenges for experienced software engineers. e.g Build your own BitTorrent, Git, Docker, or SQLite. The challenges can be done in any language, but Rust is our most popular.Our customers often tend to dive right into our challenges, believing they can pick up a new language along the way.They're usually right too. Except with Rust — especially with Rust — most developers realize soon enough that they could have used some introductory help.When we began going through available intro resources, we saw that they were either too dense — or in trying to be beginner-friendly, they focused on motivation too much.Today, we're launching our solution, a mobile-friendly, no fluff intro to Rust that respects your prior programming knowledge.We're starting with 6 modules and will be releasing new modules based on feedback.https://app.codecrafters.io/collections/rust-primerWe'd love for you to try it out and give us feedback. What other modules would you like to see? How can we make your mobile journey smoother? What can we explain better?

Users reported that Module 2 had a question with no correct answer. The issue was acknowledged and subsequently fixed.

The question contains an unnecessary apostrophe on the last item.

Avatar
8
2
2
8
Top