Should I Build It Should I Build It
19 Apr 2025
Marketing

find leads on reddit, its an app that will do automatic find leads on ...

...reddit

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Your idea for an app to automatically find leads on Reddit falls into the 'Competitive Terrain' category. This means there are already several similar products in the market. With 12 similar products already out there, competition is high. While this indicates there's definitely interest in lead generation on Reddit, it also means you'll need a strong differentiator to stand out. The average comment count on these similar products is around 5, indicating medium engagement; people are talking, but not excessively. While we don't have explicit positive or negative signals for 'use' or 'buy' from the comments of similar products, the existence of multiple competitors validates the demand. To succeed, you'll need to carefully analyze the existing solutions, identify their shortcomings, and offer a unique value proposition.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with in-depth market research. Analyze the existing 'find leads on Reddit' apps. Focus on identifying their weaknesses, limitations, and areas where users express dissatisfaction. The 'Similar Products' section in the provided materials offers valuable insights into user feedback on existing solutions. For instance, users of Octolens AI wanted to filter out irrelevant mentions. This could be an opportunity for your product to excel.
  2. Define a clear and unique value proposition. What will your app do better or differently than the competition? This could be a specific niche focus (e.g., lead generation for SaaS companies, as seen with Subreddit Signals), a unique feature (e.g., better filtering of irrelevant mentions, inspired by Octolens AI feedback), or a more intuitive user experience. Avoid being a 'me too' product.
  3. Prioritize a Minimum Viable Product (MVP) with a core set of differentiating features. Don't try to build everything at once. Focus on delivering exceptional value in one or two key areas. Ensure the MVP is user-friendly and addresses a specific pain point better than existing solutions.
  4. Develop a robust content strategy focused on educating your target audience about lead generation on Reddit. Showcase your expertise and build trust. Provide valuable resources, such as blog posts, guides, and case studies, that demonstrate the effectiveness of your approach. Optimize content for relevant keywords to improve search engine visibility and attract potential users actively seeking lead generation solutions on Reddit.
  5. Actively engage with Reddit communities to understand user needs and preferences. Participate in relevant subreddits, answer questions, and provide helpful advice. Avoid blatant self-promotion; focus on building relationships and establishing yourself as a knowledgeable resource. Use this engagement to gather feedback on your product and refine your approach based on user input.
  6. Implement a feedback loop to continuously improve your app based on user input. Encourage users to submit feedback, and actively solicit suggestions for new features and improvements. Prioritize updates and bug fixes based on user feedback to demonstrate your commitment to providing a high-quality product. Respond promptly to user inquiries and provide excellent customer support to foster loyalty and advocacy.
  7. Consider offering a freemium model with a limited set of features or usage limits to attract a wider audience. Provide a clear upgrade path to a paid plan with enhanced functionality and increased usage. The price point should be competitive and reflect the value provided by your app. Highlight the benefits of upgrading to a paid plan, such as access to premium features, priority support, and increased usage limits.

Questions

  1. Given the competitive landscape, what specific niche within Reddit lead generation will your app target, and how will you tailor your features and marketing to address the unique needs of that niche?
  2. Many similar tools face criticism around the quality of leads. How will you ensure your app delivers highly qualified leads that are genuinely interested in your users' products or services, and what metrics will you use to measure lead quality?
  3. Considering the importance of community engagement on Reddit, how will you balance automation with genuine interaction to avoid being perceived as spammy or intrusive, and how will you ensure your app adheres to Reddit's guidelines and policies?

Your are here

Your idea for an app to automatically find leads on Reddit falls into the 'Competitive Terrain' category. This means there are already several similar products in the market. With 12 similar products already out there, competition is high. While this indicates there's definitely interest in lead generation on Reddit, it also means you'll need a strong differentiator to stand out. The average comment count on these similar products is around 5, indicating medium engagement; people are talking, but not excessively. While we don't have explicit positive or negative signals for 'use' or 'buy' from the comments of similar products, the existence of multiple competitors validates the demand. To succeed, you'll need to carefully analyze the existing solutions, identify their shortcomings, and offer a unique value proposition.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with in-depth market research. Analyze the existing 'find leads on Reddit' apps. Focus on identifying their weaknesses, limitations, and areas where users express dissatisfaction. The 'Similar Products' section in the provided materials offers valuable insights into user feedback on existing solutions. For instance, users of Octolens AI wanted to filter out irrelevant mentions. This could be an opportunity for your product to excel.
  2. Define a clear and unique value proposition. What will your app do better or differently than the competition? This could be a specific niche focus (e.g., lead generation for SaaS companies, as seen with Subreddit Signals), a unique feature (e.g., better filtering of irrelevant mentions, inspired by Octolens AI feedback), or a more intuitive user experience. Avoid being a 'me too' product.
  3. Prioritize a Minimum Viable Product (MVP) with a core set of differentiating features. Don't try to build everything at once. Focus on delivering exceptional value in one or two key areas. Ensure the MVP is user-friendly and addresses a specific pain point better than existing solutions.
  4. Develop a robust content strategy focused on educating your target audience about lead generation on Reddit. Showcase your expertise and build trust. Provide valuable resources, such as blog posts, guides, and case studies, that demonstrate the effectiveness of your approach. Optimize content for relevant keywords to improve search engine visibility and attract potential users actively seeking lead generation solutions on Reddit.
  5. Actively engage with Reddit communities to understand user needs and preferences. Participate in relevant subreddits, answer questions, and provide helpful advice. Avoid blatant self-promotion; focus on building relationships and establishing yourself as a knowledgeable resource. Use this engagement to gather feedback on your product and refine your approach based on user input.
  6. Implement a feedback loop to continuously improve your app based on user input. Encourage users to submit feedback, and actively solicit suggestions for new features and improvements. Prioritize updates and bug fixes based on user feedback to demonstrate your commitment to providing a high-quality product. Respond promptly to user inquiries and provide excellent customer support to foster loyalty and advocacy.
  7. Consider offering a freemium model with a limited set of features or usage limits to attract a wider audience. Provide a clear upgrade path to a paid plan with enhanced functionality and increased usage. The price point should be competitive and reflect the value provided by your app. Highlight the benefits of upgrading to a paid plan, such as access to premium features, priority support, and increased usage limits.

Questions

  1. Given the competitive landscape, what specific niche within Reddit lead generation will your app target, and how will you tailor your features and marketing to address the unique needs of that niche?
  2. Many similar tools face criticism around the quality of leads. How will you ensure your app delivers highly qualified leads that are genuinely interested in your users' products or services, and what metrics will you use to measure lead quality?
  3. Considering the importance of community engagement on Reddit, how will you balance automation with genuine interaction to avoid being perceived as spammy or intrusive, and how will you ensure your app adheres to Reddit's guidelines and policies?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 12
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 5
  • Net use signal: 21.0%
    • Positive use signal: 22.8%
    • Negative use signal: 1.8%
  • Net buy signal: 2.1%
    • Positive buy signal: 2.1%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Made a PLatform to Solve B2B/B2C Lead Discovery Challenges

01 Nov 2024 Sales Marketing

Hey HN! I'm excited to share LeadBuddy that transforms Reddit into a powerful lead generation engine using AI. What We Do LeadBuddy helps businesses and professionals find high-quality leads by intelligently searching and analyzing Reddit conversations. Key Features Lead DiscoveryKeyword-based search across Reddit posts and comments Real-time results from targeted subreddits Full post and comment context retrievalSmart EngagementAI-generated response suggestions Manual reply composition Direct messaging capabilities Comprehensive response trackingIntelligent AnalyticsTrack leads' most active posting times Monitor engagement rates Understand conversation trendsWhy LeadBuddy?Save hours of manual searching Precision-targeted lead generation AI-assisted communication Comprehensive tracking and analyticsWho's It For?Sales professionals Marketing teams Startup founders Freelancers B2B/B2C service providersAsk away! I'm here to discuss LeadBuddy, get feedback, and learn from the HN community.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Rizz.farm, an AI-assisted lead generation tool for Reddit and beyond

08 Jan 2024 Marketing

Hey folks, I have just launched https://rizz.farm/ - an AI-assisted lead generation tool built for Reddit. Thought it might be useful for some HNers.I'm pretty excited about this product, as it was born out of my own needs of doing lead generation in a different way. I wrote a blog post about my rational here: https://persumi.com/u/fredwu/tech/e/blog/p/introducing-rizz-...In short (TL;DR):Challenge:- Keyword bidding and targeted ads are expensive- Cold outreach are rarely answered- Search Engine Optimisation is a lost causeSolution:- Warm leads over cold leads- Personalised and public- Infinite scale at a fixed costIt's still early days (MVP), with more things to build, especially in terms of eliminating potential misuse (for spams, etc).I would love to hear your feedback. Does the landing page resonate with you? Is the message clear? And if you have trialled the product (thank you!!), I would love to hear your thoughts. What worked, what didn't work, etc. Thank you!P.S.Tech stack for both Persumi and Rizz.farm: Elixir, Phoenix LiveView, Postgres, deployed on Fly.In terms of the AI stuff:Google Gemini (and before that, Google PaLM), Google TTS, Azure TTS are used in Persumi.Anthropic Claude via AWS and ChatGPT via Azure are used in Rizz.farm.

Link to a YouTube video.

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

I made a tool to find purchase-ready leads from LinkedIn, X, and Reddit

12 Sep 2024 Sales Marketing

Hey everyone,I’ve just rebuilt my SaaS, Replyhub[1], a tool to find high-potential leads from Reddit, X, and LinkedIn. The tool scans relevant posts related to your business, analyzes them, and identifies potential leads. It then alerts you so you can either reach out to them or engage with the posts directly.Here’s the backstory: When I first launched Replyhub three months ago, it was designed to monitor relevant discussions on Reddit and automatically reply to them. The goal was to streamline engagement and surface potential leads. However, several issues quickly arose. The AI-generated auto-replies started disrupting discussions, making them less natural and less helpful. Additionally, some users exploited the tool by creating new Reddit accounts to spam discussions with automatic replies. To address these problems and maintain community standards, Reddit began shadow-banning these new accounts.Faced with these challenges, I decided to rethink the approach. I removed the auto-reply feature entirely, shifting to a model where users can manually engage with discussions. This adjustment fosters more meaningful and respectful interactions, allowing users to contribute value to conversations and introduce their services only when it’s truly relevant.In the latest update, I’ve expanded Replyhub to include X/Twitter and LinkedIn. It now monitors real-time discussions across all three platforms, helping you find potential leads who are ready to purchase a solution to their problem.Any feedback or advice is welcome, and I look forward to hearing your thoughts.[1] https://replyhub.co

Avatar
10
10
Relevance

Subreddit Signals - Effortless lead generation & authentic engagement on reddit

29 Oct 2024 Growth Hacks Social media marketing Social Impact

a powerful tool that helps you find and engage with potential leads on Reddit. By analyzing relevant subreddits and suggesting authentic, non-promotional comments, it enables you to connect meaningfully with communities while growing your brand.

The tool is perceived as useful for creating connections and engagement on Reddit, especially for SaaS founders. Users are excited about the launch and express positive wishes for its success. The lead generation aspect looks promising, and John's work is praised. There's a question regarding the Reddit connection, indicating a need for clarity on that aspect.

Avatar
58
7
42.9%
7
58
42.9%
Relevance

Reddit Pulse .live - Find Potential Customers with AI Power & Automation

23 Aug 2024 SaaS Social Media Marketing

Discover how our powerful AI-driven tool can help you effortlessly find potential customers on Reddit, generate high-converting replies, and stay on top of trends.

The tool is designed to track trends and top posts. A user inquired about potential multi-platform support for the tool.

The feedback questions about multi-platform support and how often data is updated.

Avatar
10
2
2
10
Relevance

Notikey - Get notified when your keywords are mentioned on Reddit

03 Mar 2024 Growth Hacks reddit Marketing

Get alerted instantly when your keywords are mentioned on the subreddits you choose - providing you the opportunity to become a part of the conversation when and where it matters. Start generating qualified leads today by engaging with your audience early.

The product launch received generally positive feedback, with users praising the product and congratulating the team. Several users expressed interest in the product and suggested expanding to Pinterest. One user inquired about the pros and cons compared to Google Alerts for keyword monitoring. A suggestion was made for analytics features and API documentation, specifically for a Reddit conversation tool. The commenter also mentioned they like the kitty slide and praised the price of the product.

The feedback suggests improvements such as adding analytics features and exploring Reddit API integration to enhance the product's capabilities.

Avatar
95
11
9.1%
11
95
9.1%
Relevance

Octolens AI - Find warm leads on X, LinkedIn, Reddit & more

08 Jul 2024 Artificial Intelligence Social Media Business Intelligence

Octolens monitors the web for keyword mentions, assesses posts with AI, and notifies you so you can jump into a conversation. Designed for B2B SaaS Founders and Growth teams to find social posts related to their pain point, product features, or competitors.

Octolens is praised as a great and helpful tool for monitoring relevant online conversations, tracking customer/competitor activity, and connecting influencers with their reach. Users appreciate its simple setup, AI-powered filtering, and ability to uncover missed posts, saving time and effort. The daily snapshot emails are also helpful. Several users congratulate the author on the Product Hunt launch.

The primary criticism revolves around the desire for improved mention tracking capabilities. Users want the ability to specifically track *processed* mentions, implying a need to differentiate between handled and unhandled items. Furthermore, a key feature request is the ability to skip or filter out irrelevant mentions, suggesting that users are currently encountering a high volume of noise or low-value data that they must manually sift through.

Avatar
56
12
33.3%
8.3%
12
56
33.3%
8.3%
Relevance

LeadsOnTrees - Databases & Tools - AI Reddit Marketing Generator

29 Sep 2024 SaaS Database reddit

Reddit is a goldmine for posting. But it's time consuming to find & analyze subreddits for content suggestion. LeadsOnTrees presents - AI Reddit Agent which studies your website and suggests subreddits to post to!

The AI Reddit Agent launch received positive feedback, with users like Tadas expressing support. The tool is considered a game-changer for content promotion and helps users save time by efficiently identifying relevant Reddit subsections for product promotion, streamlining the process.

Avatar
17
3
66.7%
3
17
66.7%
Relevance

CalendarHunter - Find calendly links and fast track your sales process

19 Apr 2024 Social Media Sales Growth Hacking

CalendarHunter instantly reveals hidden meeting scheduler links, delivering lightning-fast outreach results and unsaturated, high-quality leads. Find leads on Twitter, Linkedin & Reddit.

CalendarHunter is a tool for scheduling sales meetings and lead generation, particularly through LinkedIn. User feedback is mixed, with some praising it as innovative, useful, and a potential game-changer that has boosted sales. Others express skepticism about the quality of leads and the scalability of using meetings for growth hacking. Concerns were raised about scheduling meetings without notice. Users reported positive experiences with the trial account and various use cases. There are questions about lead accuracy, relevance, and cal.com support, along with bug reports, and excitement about the product's future milestones.

Users expressed concerns about the product's early stage, emphasizing the need to prioritize quality over quantity. Skepticism arose regarding the product's ability to deliver high-quality leads and prevent cold pitches. Concerns were raised about scalability due to time commitments for meetings. Specific issues included LinkedIn's potential reaction, filtering irrelevant links, a typo on the pricing page ("Auto metting scheduler"), and a technical error ('b.expiresAt.toDate is not a function').

Avatar
295
30
33.3%
3.3%
30
295
40.0%
3.3%
Top