05 Jun 2025
Privacy

A SECURE STORAGE APP WHERE PEOPLE CAN STORE TEXT BASED THINGS ONLY ...

...LIKECREDIT CARD NUMBER ETC

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.


Your are here

You're entering a competitive space with your secure text storage app. Seventeen similar products suggest there's a recognized need, but also that you'll need a strong differentiator to stand out. Don't be discouraged, many successful products thrive even in crowded markets. The average engagement (7 comments) on these products suggests there is interest, but your app must address user concerns around security and ease of use to truly resonate. Your focus needs to be on building trust and demonstrating why your solution is superior. Because there are so many other similar apps, you need to think very hard about what makes your product truly special and worth switching to. Do not proceed until you have a clear answer to this question.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with thorough competitive analysis. Examine the features, pricing, and user reviews of existing secure storage apps. Pay close attention to the discussion and criticism summaries. What are users praising and complaining about in competitor products? Understanding these pain points will inform your product development and marketing strategies. Note that in the provided data, many similar apps are criticized due to the login requirement being unclear.
  2. Focus on a specific niche within the broader market of secure storage. For instance, you could target developers needing to store API keys, or journalists protecting sensitive information. Specializing your approach allows you to tailor your features and marketing to a specific user base, making it easier to stand out. In fact, one user made a relevant inquiry about instructions for sending encrypted text using the product.
  3. Prioritize security and transparency. Clearly communicate your encryption methods, data storage practices, and security protocols. Consider undergoing a third-party security audit to build trust with your users. Address security concerns proactively in your marketing materials and app design. As seen in the 'Access' app discussion, transparency is key for user adoption.
  4. Simplify the user experience. Security doesn't have to come at the cost of usability. Design an intuitive interface that makes it easy for users to store and access their data. Offer features like autofill, biometric authentication, and secure sharing to enhance convenience. The Folio Wallet App was praised for its clean design and ease of use.
  5. Develop a strong content strategy centered around security and privacy. Create blog posts, tutorials, and videos that educate users on the importance of data protection and how your app helps them achieve it. Address specific concerns and use cases to demonstrate your app's value. The Encrypt Text Online tool's launch was seen as relevant due to the importance of data security.
  6. Implement a freemium or tiered pricing model. Offer a free plan with limited storage and features to attract new users. Provide paid plans with more storage, advanced features, and priority support. This allows users to try your app before committing to a subscription. But make sure that you offer clear differentiation between the tiers.
  7. Engage with your early adopters. Actively solicit feedback and iterate on your app based on their suggestions. Build a community around your product to foster loyalty and advocacy. By doing so, you can create a loyal, vocal group of early adopters who will advocate for your product. Consider that the Folio Wallet App had some users requesting Dropbox integration, enhanced security options and clarity on encryption methods and data privacy.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions, what specific security vulnerabilities or user pain points will your app uniquely address to attract users from established competitors?
  2. How will you balance robust security measures with a seamless user experience to avoid alienating less tech-savvy users?
  3. What is your plan to build trust with users in a market where security breaches are common, and how will you handle potential security incidents transparently and effectively?

Your are here

You're entering a competitive space with your secure text storage app. Seventeen similar products suggest there's a recognized need, but also that you'll need a strong differentiator to stand out. Don't be discouraged, many successful products thrive even in crowded markets. The average engagement (7 comments) on these products suggests there is interest, but your app must address user concerns around security and ease of use to truly resonate. Your focus needs to be on building trust and demonstrating why your solution is superior. Because there are so many other similar apps, you need to think very hard about what makes your product truly special and worth switching to. Do not proceed until you have a clear answer to this question.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with thorough competitive analysis. Examine the features, pricing, and user reviews of existing secure storage apps. Pay close attention to the discussion and criticism summaries. What are users praising and complaining about in competitor products? Understanding these pain points will inform your product development and marketing strategies. Note that in the provided data, many similar apps are criticized due to the login requirement being unclear.
  2. Focus on a specific niche within the broader market of secure storage. For instance, you could target developers needing to store API keys, or journalists protecting sensitive information. Specializing your approach allows you to tailor your features and marketing to a specific user base, making it easier to stand out. In fact, one user made a relevant inquiry about instructions for sending encrypted text using the product.
  3. Prioritize security and transparency. Clearly communicate your encryption methods, data storage practices, and security protocols. Consider undergoing a third-party security audit to build trust with your users. Address security concerns proactively in your marketing materials and app design. As seen in the 'Access' app discussion, transparency is key for user adoption.
  4. Simplify the user experience. Security doesn't have to come at the cost of usability. Design an intuitive interface that makes it easy for users to store and access their data. Offer features like autofill, biometric authentication, and secure sharing to enhance convenience. The Folio Wallet App was praised for its clean design and ease of use.
  5. Develop a strong content strategy centered around security and privacy. Create blog posts, tutorials, and videos that educate users on the importance of data protection and how your app helps them achieve it. Address specific concerns and use cases to demonstrate your app's value. The Encrypt Text Online tool's launch was seen as relevant due to the importance of data security.
  6. Implement a freemium or tiered pricing model. Offer a free plan with limited storage and features to attract new users. Provide paid plans with more storage, advanced features, and priority support. This allows users to try your app before committing to a subscription. But make sure that you offer clear differentiation between the tiers.
  7. Engage with your early adopters. Actively solicit feedback and iterate on your app based on their suggestions. Build a community around your product to foster loyalty and advocacy. By doing so, you can create a loyal, vocal group of early adopters who will advocate for your product. Consider that the Folio Wallet App had some users requesting Dropbox integration, enhanced security options and clarity on encryption methods and data privacy.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions, what specific security vulnerabilities or user pain points will your app uniquely address to attract users from established competitors?
  2. How will you balance robust security measures with a seamless user experience to avoid alienating less tech-savvy users?
  3. What is your plan to build trust with users in a market where security breaches are common, and how will you handle potential security incidents transparently and effectively?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 17
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 7
  • Net use signal: 30.8%
    • Positive use signal: 31.7%
    • Negative use signal: 0.9%
  • Net buy signal: 0.2%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.6%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.5%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Password-protect your Plain Text with AES in my minimal macOS app

26 Feb 2023 Privacy

Hi HN~~So, I just created NoteLock, a new app that allows you to send secret messages super easily using end-to-end encryption, on an open channel (so they remain encrypted in transit and at rest). This is my second MacOS app ever, so I'm pretty stoked. Just wanted to put something super simple and free on the app store. I noticed that there weren't any apps out there that made this process as effortless as it should be, so I created LockNote to give people a secure and simple way to share confidential information.All you need to do is enter your message and a password, and NoteLock generates a base64 text that you can post anywhere. All operations happen offline, on your device, and no data is ever sent to any server anywhere. Plus, I was able to use industry-standard AES-GCM encryption, which I'm pretty stoked about. Thanks to CryptoKit and Chat GPT, I was able to create something that's not only secure but also easy to use (and was easy to make). Plus I had a bunch of fun making the app preview video for this^0 Man I really love Muzak. Especially royalty free Muzak~~I didn't know there was so much of it!I've always been fascinated by encryption, and creating LockNote was a chance for me to play around with it in a very straightforward way. Aside from that: I really wanted to check the box on the App Store that says: "Does your app use non-exempt encryption" But then I realized that AES in CryptoKit was exempt anyway! If you're like me and you like encryption, or just want to easily send encrypted text in the open, NoteLock is definitely worth checking out.^0: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RS4nSseOH74

The NoteLock app was created for easy and secure message encryption. There was a question raised about the necessity of an App Store login requirement.

The login requirement is unclear.


Avatar
2
2
2
2
Relevance

Wallet - Store your Cards with Privacy

22 Nov 2024 GitHub Credit card

Wallet is a project designed to store card information locally on the device, ensuring that the data is secure and cannot be stolen, as the app does not have internet access. Optimized for efficiency, allowing users to quickly copy details for transactions.


Avatar
6
6
Relevance

Encrypt Text Online - Free text encryption tool

21 Dec 2024 Security

Free online tool to encrypt text messages. Secure password protection for your sensitive messages. Easy to use text encryption and decryption.

The launch is seen as relevant due to the importance of data security. One user inquired about instructions for sending encrypted text using the product.


Avatar
12
2
2
12
Relevance

Folio Wallet App - Organize your cards and documents

12 Aug 2024 Android iOS Security

Set up a digital wallet in seconds. Store documents and cards in one place. Experience automatic text extraction, end-to-end encryption, and secure sharing. Perfect for backup, organization, travel, and managing personal, family, or team documents.

Folio Wallet's Product Hunt launch garnered overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its clean design, ease of use, security features, and the convenience of digital document storage. Many consider it a game-changer, especially for auto text extraction and document organization. Users expressed excitement about features like expiry alerts and secure sharing. Common requests include a web interface, Dropbox integration, enhanced security options (2FA, passkeys), and clarity on encryption methods and data privacy. Several users congratulated the team, particularly Daria, on solving the burden of physical document management.

Users expressed concerns regarding security, particularly the lack of passkey authentication, 2FA, and cloud storage of private information. Trust and the safety of stored documents were major issues, especially given one user's experience with password recovery leading to data loss. The absence of a desktop or web application and limited document support were also points of criticism. Some questioned the international validity of digital licenses, the differentiation from competitors, and the monetization strategy behind the free service. The use of the term 'wallet' raised concerns about association with the crypto community.


Avatar
651
102
46.1%
1.0%
102
651
46.1%
1.0%
Relevance

Access - Secure storage for your personal data

25 Jan 2024 Privacy Productivity Apple

Access provides secure storage for your personal information. It is a native app which pairs great with Passwords on Apple platforms.

Users praise the app's design and express interest in the product, with one user mentioning they are trying the Access team's product. Questions were raised regarding the project's open-source nature and about competitors.

A user expressed interest contingent on the project being auditable and self-run, indicating a need for transparency and user control.


Avatar
83
3
66.7%
3
83
66.7%
Relevance

1LimX – Offline file encryption and information, password manager

07 Nov 2023 Privacy Productivity

I made a text, file encryption/decryption tool and an encrypted information, password management tool in one offline and cross-platform application for pc, mobile using ChaCha20Poly1305 cipher.Because everything is happening entirely offline on your device, no signup required to use the app.You can enjoy unlimited items, unlimited item custom fields, unlimited file, image attachments in items and more for free.I would love to hear all the feedback/suggestions. Thanks!

Comparison with other file encryption tools.

No unique features mentioned.


Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

Local Lock – secure, all-offline open source password saving app

I would love to get some feedback regarding this project I madeIssues that it targets to solve -- Frequently changing less important passwords- For people who do not need multi device sync, a completely offline app where data leakage is not someone else's responsibility- biometric lock but without continuously running in background and taking up memory and battery

Feedback on offline password manager project with biometric lock.

No multi-device sync.


Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

We built an end-to-end encrypted alternative to Notion

09 May 2023 Productivity

Hello HN, Over the last year we've been building snote.app, a Privacy focused, End-to-End Encrypted alternative to Notion. You can write, plan, collaborate and get organized - it allows you to take notes, store files, add tasks, manage projects & more. Whether you're working solo or in a team.We are hoping to use this post as an opportunity to collect feedback from fellow hackers.If there's anything we can do better, please let us know

Users commented on a product with mixed feedback. Concerns were raised about video quality, specifically mentioning pixelation and a 7-second wait time for videos. The use of dramatic effects was also noted. Positive feedback included the product's open-source nature, self-hosting capability, and simple note synchronization with encryption. Users suggested improvements in explaining the use of cryptography and advised against storing RSA keys server-side. Technical details such as the use of PBKDF2-SHA512 for private keys and the posting of the secure enclave's source code on GitHub were also discussed.

Users criticized the product for its unnecessary pixelation effect, poor video quality, and the complexity and trust concerns due to its closed-source nature. There were also security concerns, specifically regarding the storage of RSA private keys server-side and the security being inferior to that of Argon2.


Avatar
7
7
-28.6%
-14.3%
7
7
Relevance

Patara APP - Password management with the power of blockchain technology

A secure password manager app. With its encrypted storage on the polygon, your passwords are protected from prying eyes.

Users express interest in Patara App's password storage capabilities, particularly its blockchain-based security features. Some acknowledge the inherent vulnerabilities of passwords even with blockchain implementation. There is excitement about the platform's potential and questions about reaching crypto-specific audiences.

Users expressed concerns regarding password security vulnerabilities, particularly against brute-force and phishing attacks. Specifics on the security measures implemented to mitigate these risks were requested but not provided.


Avatar
31
6
16.7%
6
31
16.7%
Relevance

Gated Encrypted Key Value Store

28 Oct 2023 Privacy

NIST FF3-1 Compliance: Octomim adheres to the NIST FF3-1 (Format-Preserving Encryption) standard. This compliance ensures that our encryption methods meet industry-recognized standards for data security and integrity.Secured Secret Database: Octomim employs a secure secret database to store your sensitive information. Rest assured, your data is protected with robust encryption techniques, ensuring only authorized access.Random Temporary Token Generation: As an added layer of security, Octomim generates random temporary tokens. These tokens provide secure access to your data for a limited time, adding an extra level of protection against unauthorized access.Encrypted In-Memory Key Value Store: With our latest feature, Octomim offers an encrypted in-memory key-value store. This feature allows you to securely store and access key-value pairs in real-time, providing efficient and protected data retrieval.Steganographic Token: Hide your tokens in images secured with your key.Gatekeeper: Authenticate with multiple users. Create a gate with authorized users and set threshold of required number of users to open the gate.Gated Key Value Store: KV access is controlled via a gate. KV is attached to a gate that is administered by the Gatekeeper. If gate is open KV can be accessed, otherwise access is denied.Stateless. Decrypted data are not cached and they are securely deleted.Implemented in C for a blazing-fast performance.


Avatar
1
1
Top