21 Apr 2025
Productivity

FOSS bookmarking, note taking and to-do in one, ofline and selfhosted. ...

...Simple with the possibility of customization and downloading of temples, sharing files and converting them to other formats

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

You're entering a space with a good number of competitors (n_matches = 15), indicating a validated need for bookmarking, note-taking, and to-do list management, especially with offline and self-hosting capabilities. Given the 'Freemium' category designation, it seems many users are interested in these tools but hesitant to pay outright. The fact that we see some good engagement (avg n_comments = 10) suggests that there is an opportunity to engage with your users and perhaps upsell them to a paid tier. The key challenge, as with all freemium models, will be converting free users into paying customers by identifying valuable premium features.

Recommendations

  1. Given the freemium nature of this space, focus on identifying which users derive the MOST value from the free version of your tool. Understanding their specific use cases will inform the development of premium features that directly address their needs.
  2. Develop premium features that enhance the core functionality for your power users. Consider advanced customization options, more robust file sharing capabilities, priority support, or integrations with other productivity tools. Look at the criticism summaries: users are interested in integration with Slack / Teams, so perhaps that's a good candidate to put behind a paywall.
  3. Explore team-based pricing models. If your tool facilitates collaboration and shared knowledge management, charging per team or organization could be more effective than individual subscriptions. The comments in easyy.click indicates a need for shared bookmarks, this is a good upsell opportunity.
  4. Consider offering personalized support, consulting, or training as a premium add-on. This is especially relevant for users who require assistance with customization, template creation, or integrating the tool into their existing workflows.
  5. Experiment with different pricing tiers and approaches, especially with small groups of users. A/B test different feature combinations, pricing points, and subscription models to optimize your conversion rate. Start by offering early access to new features for a discounted price.
  6. Address the common criticisms found in similar products. Users often want features like browser extensions, mobile apps, and public APIs, as we see from the other products. Prioritize these based on user feedback and development resources.
  7. Based on concerns about user's privacy, highlight the open-source and self-hosted nature of your offering to build trust and attract privacy-conscious users. Make it easy for users to understand your security practices.
  8. Pay close attention to how other tools handle link rot and content availability. Implement features to archive or backup saved links, or to notify users when content is no longer available.

Questions

  1. What specific user segments are most likely to convert from free to paid users, and what are their key pain points that a premium feature could solve?
  2. How can you balance the desire for simplicity with the need for advanced customization and feature richness to attract both casual and power users?
  3. Given the existence of established browser-integrated bookmark managers, how will your tool differentiate itself and provide a compelling reason for users to switch?

Your are here

You're entering a space with a good number of competitors (n_matches = 15), indicating a validated need for bookmarking, note-taking, and to-do list management, especially with offline and self-hosting capabilities. Given the 'Freemium' category designation, it seems many users are interested in these tools but hesitant to pay outright. The fact that we see some good engagement (avg n_comments = 10) suggests that there is an opportunity to engage with your users and perhaps upsell them to a paid tier. The key challenge, as with all freemium models, will be converting free users into paying customers by identifying valuable premium features.

Recommendations

  1. Given the freemium nature of this space, focus on identifying which users derive the MOST value from the free version of your tool. Understanding their specific use cases will inform the development of premium features that directly address their needs.
  2. Develop premium features that enhance the core functionality for your power users. Consider advanced customization options, more robust file sharing capabilities, priority support, or integrations with other productivity tools. Look at the criticism summaries: users are interested in integration with Slack / Teams, so perhaps that's a good candidate to put behind a paywall.
  3. Explore team-based pricing models. If your tool facilitates collaboration and shared knowledge management, charging per team or organization could be more effective than individual subscriptions. The comments in easyy.click indicates a need for shared bookmarks, this is a good upsell opportunity.
  4. Consider offering personalized support, consulting, or training as a premium add-on. This is especially relevant for users who require assistance with customization, template creation, or integrating the tool into their existing workflows.
  5. Experiment with different pricing tiers and approaches, especially with small groups of users. A/B test different feature combinations, pricing points, and subscription models to optimize your conversion rate. Start by offering early access to new features for a discounted price.
  6. Address the common criticisms found in similar products. Users often want features like browser extensions, mobile apps, and public APIs, as we see from the other products. Prioritize these based on user feedback and development resources.
  7. Based on concerns about user's privacy, highlight the open-source and self-hosted nature of your offering to build trust and attract privacy-conscious users. Make it easy for users to understand your security practices.
  8. Pay close attention to how other tools handle link rot and content availability. Implement features to archive or backup saved links, or to notify users when content is no longer available.

Questions

  1. What specific user segments are most likely to convert from free to paid users, and what are their key pain points that a premium feature could solve?
  2. How can you balance the desire for simplicity with the need for advanced customization and feature richness to attract both casual and power users?
  3. Given the existence of established browser-integrated bookmark managers, how will your tool differentiate itself and provide a compelling reason for users to switch?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 15
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 10
  • Net use signal: 3.5%
    • Positive use signal: 10.8%
    • Negative use signal: 7.3%
  • Net buy signal: -1.7%
    • Positive buy signal: 2.4%
    • Negative buy signal: 4.1%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

I made a bookmarks app using Flutter and FastAPI

29 Oct 2023 Productivity

Hey HN!Every time I read any large book, and get back to it after time, I don't seem to remember anything. I used to make bookmarks using dog ears early on, but growing up, I realised that degrades the quality of the page.Since, my phone is always I available with me, I thought why not store the bookmark digitally, and that's when I came up with the idea of Bookmarks IO. You can also add some notes regarding the context so that it is easy to maintain the flow.For all my fellow readers, I hope you find this app useful, as much as I found it to be!


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

easyy.click - Manage frequently used links and notes

26 Sep 2024 Notes Writing GitHub

1 click to open frequently used links, and copy frequently used notes. Everything encrypted, open source, pay once, use forever.

Easyy.click is praised for its practicality, encryption, one-click access, and productivity-boosting capabilities. Users appreciate its simple, secure approach to managing bookmarks and notes, with some noting it as a superior alternative to traditional bookmark managers. The one-time fee for unlimited links and notes is considered a significant advantage. Several users inquired about features like shared bookmarks, encryption key recovery, update speed, and collaboration. Integration with platforms like Slack/Teams was also requested. The open-source nature of the tool is valued.

Users criticize the lack of team collaboration features and request future updates to address this. There are also requests for integrations with platforms like Slack and Teams to facilitate easier note sharing. One user claims that the current bookmarking system is not a simple way to manage links.


Avatar
171
21
42.9%
14.3%
21
171
42.9%
14.3%
Relevance

A simple inbox for all your bookmarks

27 May 2024 Productivity

Hey everyone, I want to share a side project I've been working on for managing bookmarks easily and effectively. I needed a way to manage my links without getting overwhelmed.There are many bookmarking sites, but they often lack good user experience. I wanted a tool where you can treat your links like an inbox—a centralised place to store, search, and share them with friends, colleagues, and clients.I know there are big players in the market, But I find their workflows too complicated. I just wanted a way to save interesting stuff and refer back to it without slowing down browser.Here’s what my project aims to solve:Reducing the number of open browser tabs to avoid losing links. An easy-to-use interface for storing, searching, and sharing links. Easily transfer and download your browser links easily.It took 30 days to build this as a non-tech person, and I hope you find it valuable. I’m looking feedback to improve the experience even more so please go easy on me. Any feedback will help me on.

Users find the messaging fragmented and the purpose unclear. There is a request for live examples and the ability to create pages without signing up. One user is not interested but shares first impressions and offers congratulations.

Users criticized the product for having fragmented messaging and an unclear purpose. They also mentioned that the website lacks clarity and requires sign-up, which is inconvenient. Additionally, the absence of interactive demos was highlighted as a significant drawback.


Avatar
1
3
-66.7%
-66.7%
3
1
Relevance

Zefy – An advanced bookmarking app to organize and collaborate on links

28 Mar 2023 Productivity

We have been working on this for a few weeks - would love to get your feedback.Information is generally spread across various apps and sites, and we wanted an easy way to organize and manage them. We also built sharing and comment features because we realized how crucial they are when collaborating with people on some project. The app is in active development and the idea is to make it super-easy to store, manage and collaborate on information.Here is a quick demo: https://www.loom.com/share/b862b40baebd4b6cba261422a6fc0813


Avatar
2
2
Relevance

I built a better way to bookmark, read news, blog or any internet texts

05 Oct 2023 Writing Productivity

Users prefer browser-integrated bookmark managers over website-based ones. They appreciate the improved storing UI but note that accessing data could be better. There is interest in self-hosting options and a suggestion to turn the service into a Chrome extension. Additionally, users mention the lack of a screenshot on the homepage.

The product lacks browser integration and the ability to define keyboard shortcuts. Users question how it differentiates from existing products and note the absence of a screenshot on the homepage.


Avatar
11
5
-20.0%
5
11
Relevance

Link Book – Quickly save links from around the web to GitHub

12 Feb 2023 Productivity

Save and sync your web bookmarks using Link Book and GitHub while retaining full control of your data

Users are questioning the value of the tool compared to manual saving and existing browser features, with concerns about copyright issues and the legality of saving content. There's interest in features like saving as PDFs and markdown, and reducing permissions required. Suggestions include using public repos to demonstrate the tool, fine-grained access tokens, and creating a GitHub user for contributions. Users are also interested in open-source availability, self-hosting, and extensions for browsers and iPhones. Feedback on app flow, security, and permissions, especially in IoT, is mixed, with some confusion and requests for fewer permissions.

Users expressed concerns about the product's added value, likening it to manual saving and existing browser features. They highlighted potential legal issues, such as copyright infringement and link-rot, making saved links less useful. Criticisms also focused on the app's permissions being too broad and risky, unclear functionality, and lack of self-hosting options. There were also mentions of security concerns, particularly with IoT, and the absence of a browser extension or iPhone app. Some users questioned the necessity of the app and its approach to user contributions and testing details.


Avatar
84
31
-12.9%
-6.5%
31
84
3.2%
Relevance

Free Plain-Text Bookmarking

22 Mar 2024 Productivity

Users discussed various bookmarking tools and services, with a focus on features like public bookmarks, tag autocompletion, self-hosting, and archival support. Concerns about development stagnation, support responsiveness, and GDPR compliance were raised. Some users expressed a preference for low-tech or text-based solutions, while others were interested in AI organization or full-text search capabilities. There were also inquiries about import capabilities, hardware requirements, and pricing willingness. The community offered alternative recommendations, including self-hosted options and open-source projects.

Users have reported technical issues such as homepage loading errors, sign-up problems, and service discontinuation. There's a demand for features like product demos, public bookmarks, and tag suggestions. Criticisms also focus on the choice of MongoDB over SQLite, lack of GDPR compliance, and difficulties in account deletion. The product's description is unclear, and there's a desire for a social component and better search functionality. Some users are skeptical about syncing to third parties and prefer outsourcing server maintenance.


Avatar
172
75
2.7%
-4.0%
75
172
13.3%
2.7%
Relevance

Bookmark in Public – Curate and Share Collections of Links Easily

03 Oct 2023 Productivity

Users compared the product to StumbleUpon, del.icio.us, are.na, and HunterGather, with some noting features from the new Chromium Opera. There's interest in Firefox support, a public API, and non-Chrome bookmark options. Users are generally excited, with one praising its role in holding the internet fabric together. Concerns include longevity, auto backup, and the use of 'blazing fast' in marketing. One user questions its suitability for Show HN, and another comment had no content.

Users criticized the product for unreliable social bookmarks and lack of support for non-Chrome browsers, particularly Firefox. The closure of a feature and the negative impact of platforms like Facebook were also mentioned. Marketing was seen as overreliant on the phrase 'blazing fast,' and some users felt the product was not appropriate for Show HN.


Avatar
34
13
23.1%
13
34
30.8%
Relevance

readl8r - a simple self-hosted FOSS read later service

05 Sep 2024 GitHub Developer Tools

I started working on a selfhosted FOSS read later service called readl8r (suggestions for the name are more than welcome haha).These are the ideas/values I have going into it:- It’s built with sveltekit simply because it’s what im used to.- RSS/Atom/JSON Feed feeds are generated at request-time at all the common routes (/rss, /feed.xml, etc).- simple optional auth (bearer token atm).- clean but functional ui with a newspaper-esque design with light customization eventually (id like to add a reading view for each article in addition to an option to open the article at the original site).- run with docker and a smallish image (currently around 100mb but id like to get it smaller if possible).- right now articles are stored in an sqlite db but im thinking about changing to a markdown database.- id like to make the frontend installable as a pwa.- after auth is settled i plan on adding functionality to add/update/delete articles from the frontend.- i learned about websub and would like to eventually figure out how to implement it for instant notifications.- i wanted the service to be easy to setup and straightforward to use and i think its accomplished that so far?I've had a lot of fun building the core functionality and designing the frontend but id love some feedback on any/all aspects of it!Thanks!

Developing selfhosted FOSS read later service, seeking feedback.

Name suggestions welcome.


Avatar
6
1
1
6
Top