02 Jul 2025
User Experience

feedback colection and commnity builder to build better products and ...

...layal users

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.


Your are here

You're entering a crowded market for feedback collection and community building tools, with 30 similar products already out there. This means you've correctly identified a real need, but also that competition is stiff. The good news is that products in this category see medium engagement, with an average of 10 comments, suggesting people are interested in discussing and shaping these tools. The even better news is that there are many expressing a direct interest in paying for a solution like this, which is really rare and great. However, to succeed, you'll need to differentiate your product significantly. It's not enough to just collect feedback; you need to offer a unique angle or feature set that makes you stand out from the existing solutions. Focus on a specific niche or value proposition to carve out your space in this competitive terrain.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with thorough market research to pinpoint the shortcomings of existing feedback tools. Analyze user reviews and feature sets of competitors like Insighto, Featurebase, and Productlane. Understand what users like, what they complain about, and what features are missing. Use this data to identify your unique selling proposition.
  2. Based on your research, identify 2-3 key areas where you can offer a substantial improvement or unique differentiation. This could be a specific integration (like a Shopify widget mentioned for Insighto), a unique feature (such as AI-powered sentiment analysis requested for EnlightUp), or a focus on a particular niche (e.g., indie developers, e-commerce businesses). Prioritize these differentiators in your development roadmap.
  3. Consider focusing on a niche market segment with specific needs. For example, if you target e-commerce businesses, explore integrations with platforms like Shopify and focus on collecting and analyzing product reviews, as suggested by the Feedback Brief. If you're targeting early-stage startups, consider ReviewLab's approach of incentivizing feedback and trading reviews.
  4. Develop a strong brand and marketing message that clearly communicates your unique value proposition. Highlight what makes you different and why users should choose your product over the competition. Focus on addressing the pain points identified in your market research and demonstrating how your product solves them better than existing solutions.
  5. Engage closely with your early users to gather feedback and iterate quickly. Pay attention to requests for integrations (Slack, Reddit, Discord, Productboard), feature voting, and analytics, as seen in the reviews of Featurebase and Bridge. Implement a system for prioritizing feedback and communicating updates to your users.
  6. Address potential concerns about spam and privacy proactively. Implement robust spam protection measures and provide clear information about data usage and security. Offer options for anonymous feedback, as suggested in the discussion around Bridge.
  7. Explore integrations with AI to offer advanced features like sentiment analysis, user story generation, and feedback prioritization, as seen in Kraftful and EnlightUp. Ensure transparency about the AI's accuracy and provide customization options to align with user needs.
  8. Consider offering a free plan or trial to attract early adopters. Make sure your pricing is competitive and transparent, as pricing was a point of discussion for Insighto and Featurebase. Clearly communicate the value of your paid plans and the benefits they offer over the free plan.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competitive landscape, what specific, underserved niche will your platform target, and how will you tailor your features and messaging to resonate with that niche's unique needs?
  2. With the demand for integrations being so high, what are the top 3 integrations you will prioritize for your initial launch, and how will these integrations create a stickier, more valuable experience for your users?
  3. Considering the criticism around AI accuracy in similar tools, how will you ensure the AI-driven features in your platform provide genuinely insightful and actionable feedback, and what metrics will you use to measure their effectiveness?

Your are here

You're entering a crowded market for feedback collection and community building tools, with 30 similar products already out there. This means you've correctly identified a real need, but also that competition is stiff. The good news is that products in this category see medium engagement, with an average of 10 comments, suggesting people are interested in discussing and shaping these tools. The even better news is that there are many expressing a direct interest in paying for a solution like this, which is really rare and great. However, to succeed, you'll need to differentiate your product significantly. It's not enough to just collect feedback; you need to offer a unique angle or feature set that makes you stand out from the existing solutions. Focus on a specific niche or value proposition to carve out your space in this competitive terrain.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with thorough market research to pinpoint the shortcomings of existing feedback tools. Analyze user reviews and feature sets of competitors like Insighto, Featurebase, and Productlane. Understand what users like, what they complain about, and what features are missing. Use this data to identify your unique selling proposition.
  2. Based on your research, identify 2-3 key areas where you can offer a substantial improvement or unique differentiation. This could be a specific integration (like a Shopify widget mentioned for Insighto), a unique feature (such as AI-powered sentiment analysis requested for EnlightUp), or a focus on a particular niche (e.g., indie developers, e-commerce businesses). Prioritize these differentiators in your development roadmap.
  3. Consider focusing on a niche market segment with specific needs. For example, if you target e-commerce businesses, explore integrations with platforms like Shopify and focus on collecting and analyzing product reviews, as suggested by the Feedback Brief. If you're targeting early-stage startups, consider ReviewLab's approach of incentivizing feedback and trading reviews.
  4. Develop a strong brand and marketing message that clearly communicates your unique value proposition. Highlight what makes you different and why users should choose your product over the competition. Focus on addressing the pain points identified in your market research and demonstrating how your product solves them better than existing solutions.
  5. Engage closely with your early users to gather feedback and iterate quickly. Pay attention to requests for integrations (Slack, Reddit, Discord, Productboard), feature voting, and analytics, as seen in the reviews of Featurebase and Bridge. Implement a system for prioritizing feedback and communicating updates to your users.
  6. Address potential concerns about spam and privacy proactively. Implement robust spam protection measures and provide clear information about data usage and security. Offer options for anonymous feedback, as suggested in the discussion around Bridge.
  7. Explore integrations with AI to offer advanced features like sentiment analysis, user story generation, and feedback prioritization, as seen in Kraftful and EnlightUp. Ensure transparency about the AI's accuracy and provide customization options to align with user needs.
  8. Consider offering a free plan or trial to attract early adopters. Make sure your pricing is competitive and transparent, as pricing was a point of discussion for Insighto and Featurebase. Clearly communicate the value of your paid plans and the benefits they offer over the free plan.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competitive landscape, what specific, underserved niche will your platform target, and how will you tailor your features and messaging to resonate with that niche's unique needs?
  2. With the demand for integrations being so high, what are the top 3 integrations you will prioritize for your initial launch, and how will these integrations create a stickier, more valuable experience for your users?
  3. Considering the criticism around AI accuracy in similar tools, how will you ensure the AI-driven features in your platform provide genuinely insightful and actionable feedback, and what metrics will you use to measure their effectiveness?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 30
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 10
  • Net use signal: 22.5%
    • Positive use signal: 22.8%
    • Negative use signal: 0.3%
  • Net buy signal: 2.2%
    • Positive buy signal: 2.6%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.3%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Insighto - Ship features users want

Collect feedback from your customers, prioritize features, and build a product users love.

Insighto's Product Hunt launch garnered overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users praising its simplicity, cost-effectiveness, and value for indie developers as a Canny alternative. Users found it helpful for gathering and prioritizing feedback. Congratulatory messages to Marc were frequent. Common suggestions included mobile responsiveness, unique feedback links, custom theming, admin controls, spam protection, and potential integrations like a Notion plugin or Shopify widget. Some users reported bugs, such as seeing other users' comments or issues with Korean language support. There was also discussion about the pricing model and revenue plan.

Users criticized the product for potential spam vulnerabilities and privacy concerns due to mandatory sign-ups for upvoting. Several bugs were reported, including users seeing others' data and issues with feedback posts linking to incorrect boards. The UI's lack of responsiveness on mobile and the product's limitation to English were also points of concern. Users requested more feature control for admins, better integration options (like a Shopify widget and Notion plugin), a roadmap board, and clearer information on pricing and technical implementation. Questions were raised about data filtering and ensuring feedback quality on the free platform.


Avatar
989
118
21.2%
0.8%
118
989
22.0%
1.7%
Relevance

Featurebase - Create your product feedback community

A central place for all your product discussions - capture feedback, feature requests, and bug reports in your fully customizable public feedback forum. Easily find the most impactful product ideas and announce updates through beautiful embeddable widgets.

Featurebase is receiving overwhelmingly positive feedback for its user-friendly interface, comprehensive feature set, and strong focus on user feedback. Users appreciate its sleek design, customizability, and the ability to track the impact of feedback. Several users have switched to Featurebase from alternatives like Canny due to pricing or superior product experience. Integration capabilities and responsive team are also highly valued. Some users are inquiring about specific integrations like Slack, Reddit, Discord, and Productboard. Many express excitement about the free plan and scalable options, with several users already actively using and loving the product.

Users request native integrations to avoid external site visits. There's also interest in analytics and reporting features to measure the impact of changes made within the product. Some users are unsure if the product fits their needs given their current tool stack. A specific request was made for a Slack upvoting feature, similar to what Canny offered.


Avatar
167
25
44.0%
12.0%
25
167
44.0%
12.0%
Relevance

EnlightUp - Enhance your products with customer feedback

05 Dec 2023 SaaS Productivity Tech

Enhance your products with customer feedback. Collect feedback from customers in one place to make better product decisions.

EnlightUp.io's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and praising the product's concept and functionality. The tool is seen as fantastic for aggregating customer feedback, simplifying decisions, and improving product quality. Users appreciate the centralization of feedback, which streamlines business processes, enhances product development, and improves customer service. Some users highlighted the importance of early feedback for startups, implying the product's usefulness in connecting products with customers.

Users are requesting AI integration, specifically for sentiment analysis and to better understand language and regional nuances in feedback. This would improve the tool's ability to process and categorize user opinions more effectively.


Avatar
40
8
8
40
Relevance

Feedback Hunter - Transform your user's feedback into product success

Feedback Hunter helps you collect, organize, and prioritize user feedback to build better products that your customers will love. Integrate it seamlessly into your application and start collecting users' feedback today!

Streak Hunter is praised for connecting SaaS with user feedback, with users expressing love for the product and encouraging its continued development. Feedback Hunter is seen as lightweight, powerful, and born from real needs. Streamlining feedback is considered crucial for product development, with users excited to try it. Thanks were given to Denis, a Streak Hunter user, for helpful advice.


Avatar
17
6
16.7%
6
17
16.7%
Relevance

Feedback Rivers - Make customer feedback visible and actionable

Make customer feedback visible and actionable. Combine all your feedback sources into a system of record. Get closer to your customers and build the habit of listening to them. Analyze and act on feedback to improve your product and customer experience.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating the team on the launch and a well-built project. There's excitement about the potential of the product. Some users are interested in Product Hunt integration and a potential discount for the platform's community. Feedback collection was noted as a great feature.

The main criticism is the request for a discount specifically for Product Hunt users after the trial period.


Avatar
94
3
3
94
Relevance

FeatureFind - Fuel product growth with user feedback

Make smarter decisions with real product feedback. Streamline your roadmap, prioritize features, and build what users need with our customer feedback software.

The product launch was met with congratulations and optimism regarding user experience. Users expressed confidence that the product would be utilized. There is an expectation that feedback will be thoughtfully incorporated for future improvements.

The Product Hunt launch received some feedback regarding the implementation of user suggestions. Some users expressed uncertainty about whether the feedback would be effectively integrated and whether this would guarantee the product's success.


Avatar
17
2
50.0%
2
17
50.0%
Relevance

I made a web app that streamlines collecting your customers' feedback

26 Apr 2024 Marketing

I realized how important and crucial it is to collect feedback in order for your business/product to grow a few months ago, and with that, coupled with my journey to freedom(launching startups) I decided to develop this app!Feedbackr: Your shortcut to invaluable insights. Effortlessly collect feedback from customers with a few clicks, empowering your business to thrive.

The app aims to streamline feedback collection for business growth, but some users find the product's purpose and appearance unclear.

The landing page requires more user feedback to improve its effectiveness.


Avatar
2
2
2
2
Relevance

VoteFeature.com – Build what users want

24 May 2024 SaaS

Hi HN community,I'm excited to share a project I’ve been working on for quite a while: https://www.VoteFeature.com.VoteFeature is a place that aims to help users and builders come together to shape the future of products. It's a simple catalog of products where users can search by features, suggest enhancements and vote features to help prioritize the development.For Users:1. Discover - Search products by specific features (e.g. AI capabilities, system integration etc.).2. Vote - Impact products roadmaps by voting features.3. Suggest - Share your ideas and suggest features to builders.For Builders:1. Prioritize - You can prioritize the backlog based on user votes for specific features.2. Simple Backlog - Very simple way to manage your product backlog.3. Exposure - Get some exposure by adding your product to the platform.Try It:You can try the (very) beta version at https://www.VoteFeature.comFeedback:Any feedback is invaluable and much appreciated!What do you think? Do you find it useful? How can I make it better for both users and builders?Thank you!


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Kraftful - Copilot for product builders

Kraftful saves product builders hundreds of hours by using AI to analyze user feedback in one place. Identify your highest priority product improvements, write JIRA tickets, and use ChatGPT to uncover deeper insights ✨Try it out onkraftful.com

Kraftful's Product Hunt launch garnered overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users are excited about its potential to streamline product development by centralizing and analyzing user feedback with AI. Many congratulated the team, especially Yana, on the launch and praised the tool's ability to save time and improve product building. Several users inquired about specific features like feedback prioritization, data import methods, integration with analytics platforms, and the types of feedback analyzed. Kraftful is viewed as a game-changer and a valuable co-pilot for product builders, promising to revolutionize user research and boost productivity.

Users expressed concerns about the lack of detail regarding the AI's accuracy in generating user stories and customization options. The absence of features for structuring and prioritizing feedback, especially crucial for early-stage startups, was also noted. Furthermore, questions arose about how well the AI-generated stories align with actual user needs and the extent to which they can be tailored to specific requirements.


Avatar
674
70
18.6%
1.4%
70
674
18.6%
1.4%
Relevance

Bridge - An easy way for your users to give you feedback

19 Apr 2024 User Experience SaaS

User Feedback is the single most important source of truth to get to Product-Market fit, yet talking to users is really hard. We aim to Bridge the communication gap between users and creators with easy to launch beautiful forms inside your website or app.

The Product Hunt launch of Bridge received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users praised its simplicity, ease of use, and ability to streamline user feedback collection, specifically highlighting the easy-to-launch forms. Many see it as a practical solution to communication challenges. Suggestions included feature voting, integration with heatmap tools, different display methods, and anonymous feedback options. Several users inquired about native app integration and Hebrew language support. The AI insights extraction feature and rewards feature were noted as exciting and innovative. Users congratulated Tarek Abillama and wished the product success.

The primary criticism revolves around the efficiency of Bridge in identifying and prioritizing urgent issues following a product release. Users are questioning whether the tool effectively helps in pinpointing the most critical feedback and usage problems that arise post-launch.


Avatar
364
27
18.5%
3.7%
27
364
18.5%
3.7%
Relevance

Productlane - One platform for user feedback and customer support

Productlane combines user feedback management with customer support so you can close the loop on everything and build well-crafted products. Local-first and built on Linear.

Productlane's launch is receiving positive feedback, with users praising its comprehensive feedback component, ease of use, and user-centric approach. Many are excited about the new features, particularly the support widget and integration capabilities. Users highlight Productlane's value in centralizing feedback, prioritizing features, and improving product development, especially for startups. The tool is considered a gamechanger for roadmaps and user feedback collection. Some users are asking about the expansion beyond Linear integrations.

Users are seeking clear differentiation from existing solutions like Featurebase before considering a migration to Productlane. They want to understand Productlane's unique features and advantages to justify the switch.


Avatar
381
25
44.0%
4.0%
25
381
44.0%
4.0%
Relevance

ReviewLab - Feedback exchange platform for digital product makers

Improve your ideas, designs, and early-stage products with constructive feedback from a community of founders, makers, and tech professionals. Help others by reviewing their work to earn points and unlock reviews on your future projects.

ReviewLab is praised as a valuable tool for obtaining objective design evaluations, particularly beneficial for early-stage startups and indie beginners seeking constructive feedback. Users appreciate its ability to provide detailed feedback on copy and designs. The point system for incentivizing reviews and the ability to trade reviews are also well-received. Some users have questions about review requests and anonymity. It is recommended as a landing page service for high-quality results, with one user expressing hope for community growth to support digital product launches.

The primary criticism revolves around the handling of review requests, specifically addressing imbalances and the anonymity of reviewers. These concerns raise questions about fairness and transparency in the review process.


Avatar
60
9
44.4%
9
60
44.4%
Relevance

Feedbacker AI - Automate user feedback, elevate your product

I built Feedbacker AI to seamlessly collect user feedback and provide concise, AI-driven insights in seconds. Improve decisions, boost satisfaction, and drive growth with automated analysis. Easy integration, real-time updates, and quick support.

The comments highlight the value of real-time feedback updates. A question was raised about the product's existing customer base.


Avatar
16
2
2
16
Relevance

Feedback Management Tool

25 Oct 2023 SaaS

Here’s a tool I’ve created for businesses to easily collect feedback from their customers and improve their customer relationships.Feel free to try it out for free and let me know what you think!


Avatar
3
3
Top