Should I Build It Should I Build It
28 Aug 2025
Marketing

Compare businesses against their peers using Google reviews, reddit ...

...mentions etc

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Your idea to compare businesses using Google reviews and Reddit mentions falls into the 'Competitive Terrain' category. This means there's interest in the concept, but the market is pretty crowded. We found about 10 similar products already out there. With so many competitors, differentiation is key. Think about what unique value you can offer that others aren't providing. While we don't have explicit use and buy signals for this specific instance, the average engagement across similar products is medium, with around 8 comments per product. This indicates that people are interested in engaging with these tools, however, this is a double edged sword as it also implies competition. Your challenge isn’t just building something people want, it's about making it stand out.

Recommendations

  1. Start with thorough market research to understand the existing competitive landscape. Delve into the features, pricing, and marketing strategies of your competitors. Tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, and SimilarWeb can help you gather data. Focus on identifying gaps and opportunities where your product can offer a unique value proposition.
  2. Based on the competitive analysis, define your unique selling proposition (USP). What makes your product different and better? Common differentiators include innovative features, superior user experience, better data accuracy, or niche focus. User feedback from similar products mentions issues with data accuracy and competitor identification, which highlights potential areas for improvement.
  3. Consider focusing on a specific niche market. Instead of trying to be everything to everyone, identify a particular segment with underserved needs. For instance, you could focus on comparing SaaS companies, e-commerce businesses, or local restaurants. Specializing allows you to tailor your features and marketing efforts for better resonance.
  4. Given the competition, prioritize building a strong brand and marketing strategy. Develop a clear and compelling message that communicates your USP to your target audience. Use content marketing, social media, and SEO to increase visibility. Explore offering a free trial or freemium version to attract new users, but ensure the free tier provides enough value to convert users into paying customers.
  5. Since you're aggregating data from sources like Google Reviews and Reddit, ensure your data collection process is robust and accurate. Implement data validation techniques to minimize errors and inconsistencies. Regularly update your data to provide users with the most current information. This will address a key criticism in similar products regarding data accuracy and delays.
  6. Engage with early users and gather feedback. Use surveys, interviews, and user testing to understand their needs and pain points. Iterate quickly based on feedback to improve your product. Focus on building a loyal user base that can advocate for your product. Based on the similar product analysis, providing side-by-side comparison options can be valuable.
  7. Explore partnerships with complementary businesses or platforms. Collaborate with industry influencers or bloggers to promote your product. Consider integrating with other tools that your target users already use. This can help you expand your reach and acquire new customers. For example, integrating with popular SEO tools can attract users looking for competitor analysis features.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition, what specific data sources or analysis methods will you use to provide unique and valuable insights that competitors are missing?
  2. How will you address the common criticisms of similar products, such as data accuracy and irrelevant competitor suggestions, to build trust and credibility with your users?
  3. What is your plan to build a strong brand and marketing strategy that differentiates you from the competition and attracts a loyal user base in a crowded market?

Your are here

Your idea to compare businesses using Google reviews and Reddit mentions falls into the 'Competitive Terrain' category. This means there's interest in the concept, but the market is pretty crowded. We found about 10 similar products already out there. With so many competitors, differentiation is key. Think about what unique value you can offer that others aren't providing. While we don't have explicit use and buy signals for this specific instance, the average engagement across similar products is medium, with around 8 comments per product. This indicates that people are interested in engaging with these tools, however, this is a double edged sword as it also implies competition. Your challenge isn’t just building something people want, it's about making it stand out.

Recommendations

  1. Start with thorough market research to understand the existing competitive landscape. Delve into the features, pricing, and marketing strategies of your competitors. Tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, and SimilarWeb can help you gather data. Focus on identifying gaps and opportunities where your product can offer a unique value proposition.
  2. Based on the competitive analysis, define your unique selling proposition (USP). What makes your product different and better? Common differentiators include innovative features, superior user experience, better data accuracy, or niche focus. User feedback from similar products mentions issues with data accuracy and competitor identification, which highlights potential areas for improvement.
  3. Consider focusing on a specific niche market. Instead of trying to be everything to everyone, identify a particular segment with underserved needs. For instance, you could focus on comparing SaaS companies, e-commerce businesses, or local restaurants. Specializing allows you to tailor your features and marketing efforts for better resonance.
  4. Given the competition, prioritize building a strong brand and marketing strategy. Develop a clear and compelling message that communicates your USP to your target audience. Use content marketing, social media, and SEO to increase visibility. Explore offering a free trial or freemium version to attract new users, but ensure the free tier provides enough value to convert users into paying customers.
  5. Since you're aggregating data from sources like Google Reviews and Reddit, ensure your data collection process is robust and accurate. Implement data validation techniques to minimize errors and inconsistencies. Regularly update your data to provide users with the most current information. This will address a key criticism in similar products regarding data accuracy and delays.
  6. Engage with early users and gather feedback. Use surveys, interviews, and user testing to understand their needs and pain points. Iterate quickly based on feedback to improve your product. Focus on building a loyal user base that can advocate for your product. Based on the similar product analysis, providing side-by-side comparison options can be valuable.
  7. Explore partnerships with complementary businesses or platforms. Collaborate with industry influencers or bloggers to promote your product. Consider integrating with other tools that your target users already use. This can help you expand your reach and acquire new customers. For example, integrating with popular SEO tools can attract users looking for competitor analysis features.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition, what specific data sources or analysis methods will you use to provide unique and valuable insights that competitors are missing?
  2. How will you address the common criticisms of similar products, such as data accuracy and irrelevant competitor suggestions, to build trust and credibility with your users?
  3. What is your plan to build a strong brand and marketing strategy that differentiates you from the competition and attracts a loyal user base in a crowded market?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 10
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 8
  • Net use signal: 24.3%
    • Positive use signal: 25.5%
    • Negative use signal: 1.2%
  • Net buy signal: 2.4%
    • Positive buy signal: 3.6%
    • Negative buy signal: 1.2%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

A Tool for Gathering Genuine Product Reviews from Reddit and YouTube

28 Aug 2024 User Experience

I wanted to share a side project I've been working on:http://webpulse.today/review-waitlistA tool that gathers genuine feedback on any product by analyzing discussions from Reddit and YouTube. It provides in-depth analysis results, please check examples below:- Ray-Ban Meta Smart Glasses: http://webpulse.today/review-waitlist?u=Ray-Ban%20Meta%20Sma...- Black Myth: Wukong: http://webpulse.today/review-waitlist?u=Black%20Myth:%20Wuko...- Toyota GR86: http://webpulse.today/review-waitlist?u=Toyota%20GR86&f=y- Llama 3.1: http://webpulse.today/review-waitlist?u=Llama%203.1&f=yIn today's world, it can be tough to find trustworthy reviews. Personally, I find myself relying more on Reddit and YouTube for authentic opinions, especially since search engines like Google are often cluttered with click-driven results and sensational headlines.With that in mind, I built this tool to make it easier to access the kind of feedback I trust the most. It's still in beta, so please bear with me if it’s a bit slow or unstable. I would greatly appreciate any thoughts or feedback you might have—your input will help me improve it.Thanks for taking the time to check it out!

Users generally found the product to work flawlessly and appreciated the sophisticated AI use. A user shared a test video, and another noted that the website review matched their research on the Redmi Note 12 Pro. There was a minor spelling oversight mentioned, and a suggestion for a side-by-side comparison option.

The main criticisms are a minor spelling oversight and the lack of a side-by-side comparison option.

Avatar
5
4
50.0%
4
5
50.0%
Relevance

Competitor Research - The fastest, easiest way to find and research competitors

08 Jul 2024 Sales Business Intelligence Marketing

Meet Competitor Research, the all-in-one tool that helps you discover and research your competitors. Get a comprehensive competitor research report for a one-time fee, with SEO, marketing, pricing, product and many more insights.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising the tool's ease of use, comprehensive insights, and clear reports. Many users found the competitor analysis features valuable, especially for SEO, backlink analysis, and understanding market positioning. Several users requested specific features such as competitor monitoring, report/presentation generation, a live competitor dashboard, and more detailed SEO insights. Some users reported issues with signup and relevance of competitor suggestions. There were also inquiries about pricing, data accuracy, and report update frequency. Overall, users are excited about the product's potential and its usefulness for various business needs.

Users criticized the free tier's lack of competitor overview, hindering user conversion. Data accuracy and delays were noted. Users requested features like report generation, industry specialization, and AI integration to reduce manual analysis. The signup process failed for some due to missing verification emails. Competitor identification was problematic with irrelevant suggestions and inability to manually add competitors. The one-off report format was seen as less appealing than a subscription. Pricing details were insufficient, and the competitor report was perceived as uncompelling.

katrina_t

I’ve been looking for something like this for quite a while! Glad it’s finally on the market! Good work!!

naomigarcia

With new businesses being set up everyday, there are new competitions entering the market everyday. And naturally, any business would want to constantly monitor the competition. If I am understanding correctly, the report is just generated once and you need to purchase the report again when you want to see an updated report. Right? I think I would want something where I can view all my competitor insight at any point of time. A live dashboard of sorts. And of course, would be willing to pay for one such service. One off report is a bit less appealing. And I think you can consider turning it into a subscription service where competitors can be monitored at any given time. All the best! 💪

anastasiia_stepko

Is it possible to set up a monitoring feature? For example, I would like to get weekly updates if some parameters have changed for some competitors.

dzaitzow

@adam_butter interesting product - I just tried it out! For me (might be a distinct user) but I would love to see at least one detailed competitor overview in my free tier. I sign up - I get to see my competitors (which I already know If I am doing any sort of market validation about my product) - there might be some value there on a free plan but the real meat of this (in my opinion) is to show me the insight that I would be getting by paying for the product and if that is worth the price. I think by giving free users (who are already half sold) a little more of "what to expect" might go a long way in actually converting more users or prospective customers. Food for thought - I love the idea and congrats on the launch!

kehui_guo

Competitor keyword analysis and competitor action items seem very useful! Is there a way to generate a summary of the competitor analysis in an report or presentation for stakeholder presentations?

zenda1122

Amazing! Search Traffic, Keyword Analysis, and Backlink Analysis are all what I need!

manan_gupta19

This looks fantastic! 🎉 Having all these insights in one place can be a game-changer. Can't wait to try it out and see the impact on our strategy. Are there any specific industries you specialize in or is it suitable for all sectors?

tonyhanded

It's a pretty cool tool someone can use to get a nice all in one competitor analysis, esp for SEO purpose. You get to see what other competitors are focusing on and tap into details like CPC. Congrats on the launch @adam_butter !

zubair_collier

As a marketer focused on digital advertising, insights into competitor ad campaigns and strategies could inform my own advertising tactics.

chandula

This is cool! Love the pricing as well. Will give it a go soon! Congrats!

jerrywjeong

I've been waiting for tools like this! I watched the demo video on your website, and your tool is really comprehensive. I've got a question—does your tool help come up with optimal keywords for SEO based on competitors' keywords?

andreas_sohns

I'm genuinely impressed with the depth of insights provided. The backlink analysis feature is a standout for me. Its already helping us identify valuable link building opportunities.

ericcheng26

Congrats on the launch! Will give it a try! Always looking for a tool like this!

shivay_at_pieces

This is such a powerful tool, finding absolutely accurate competitors - very relevant suggestions given, tried it out on a few products. This is an excellent tool.

ruhika_karuri

Is it possible to set up a monitoring feature? For example, I would like to get weekly updates if some parameters have changed for some competitors.

dessignnet

Congrats.. very cool and useful tool ? Will give it a try 🔥🔥

Avatar
752
59
28.8%
1.7%
59
752
28.8%
3.4%
Relevance

I made a tool that automates competitor research for startups/hackers

06 Jul 2024 Marketing

Hi HN! After months of coding in my free time, I wanted to share Competitor Research [https://competitoresearch.com], a tool that helps you find and research your competitors.Problem: Most competitor analysis tools are 1. Time consuming: These tools get you the data, but you still have to do the work of knowing what to look for 2. Expensive: Most tools like Ahrefs, SEMRush cost $99+/month. Other more niche tools can cost $1000+/month. For enterprise software it can be $100K+, for consultants, it can be ~$2K+ 3. Requires you to know who your competitors are 4. Not comprehensive: Mostly provides only SEO related info/social media information 5. No actionable insightsSolution: We tried our best to help startups/solopreneurs/makers get the best possible experience when researching their competitors. Here’s what we ended up making:1. We help you find your competitors by combining several different sources and ranking the ones most relevant to your business.2. We use multiple data sources and provide a comprehensive overview of your company: 1. SEO Keywords - what keywords do your competitors rank for 2. Backlinks - who’s linking to your competitors 3. Pricing - what your competitor’s pricing model is 4. Traffic - where they get traffic from 5. Website performance - how does your competitor’s website perform 6. Target audience and messaging3. We provide you with actionable insights, things you can do to improve your business (get more customers, improve pricing, improve copy)4. It’s a one time fee of $79, which is a steal compared to other toolsThanks a lot for reading through this :) We'd love to hear any feedback/comments you might have!Adam

Users find the tool useful for identifying competitors, with specific mention of Mood2Movie simplifying competitor research. There are inquiries about whether the product is free or paid, and a wish for good luck alongside a question regarding competitor listing.

Users criticized the product for taking six months to provide a clear view of competition, questioned the accuracy of the competitor listing, and expressed concern over the product being exclusively paid.

Avatar
7
6
16.7%
6
7
16.7%
Relevance

Commentify.io - Monitor brand, reviews, competitors in social networks

13 Jun 2024 Social Media Instagram Marketing

Monitor your brand, reviews, and competitors on social networks and review sites. Track mentions, reviews about your product or brand on platforms like TrustPilot, TripAdvisor, GoogleMaps, YouTube, Instagram, others. Enhance your reputation and boost sales.

Excited user shares product discovery for brand monitoring and sales boost.

Avatar
2
1
100.0%
100.0%
1
2
100.0%
100.0%
Relevance

Know when, where, and what Redditors say about your Business

13 Oct 2023 Marketing

Waitlist, not usable, shouldn't be Show HN

Waitlist, not usable

Avatar
2
1
-100.0%
1
2
Relevance

I collected 3M reviews for a hotel and restaurant benchmark

20 Feb 2024 Marketing

I created a rating benchmark for restaurants and hotels in each state of the US scanning over 3 million reviews from Google. You can see 2 geo charts with the states with the best food and the best accommodation

Users complimented the product and expressed interest in the review scanning duration and the technology used. The team is planning to conduct more customer review benchmarks and is seeking suggestions. Overall, users found the product very useful.

Avatar
6
3
3
6
Top