Should I Build It Should I Build It
22 May 2025
Travel

A smartphone application that provides you the perfect trip plan for a ...

...city. It marges data provvided from other peoples like: attraction rating, the importance of the attraction and the time spent to visit it. It provvides you a plan that optimize your trip according to the time you will spend in the city and the way you will move around.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Your idea for a smartphone application providing optimized trip plans for cities places you in a competitive market. There are already many similar apps, as shown by the 22 matching products. This means you'll face a significant challenge in standing out. While the high number of similar products suggests that there is indeed a strong buy signal and that people are willing to pay for this type of service, the key to success will be offering something unique or significantly better than what's already available. Given the existing competition, it's crucial to avoid simply replicating existing features and instead focus on genuine differentiation to capture user attention and loyalty. This will be critical to overcome the existing market saturation.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with thorough market research to identify gaps in existing trip planning apps. Focus on understanding user pain points that competitors aren't adequately addressing. For instance, some competing apps have been criticized for inaccurate data or limited location support. Analyze these weaknesses and consider how your app can overcome these limitations by offering more accurate, comprehensive, or niche-specific travel information.
  2. Develop a unique value proposition that clearly differentiates your app from competitors. This could involve incorporating AI-driven personalization, offline functionality, or focusing on a specific travel niche (e.g., budget travel, adventure travel, cultural immersion). Ensure your value proposition aligns with user needs and is clearly communicated in your marketing efforts.
  3. Consider incorporating user-generated content and community features to enhance the app's value and engagement. This could include allowing users to share their travel experiences, rate attractions, and contribute to trip planning. By leveraging user-generated content, you can create a more dynamic and personalized experience while also building a loyal community around your app.
  4. Given that many users have expressed interest in AI-powered trip planning, explore how you can leverage AI to enhance personalization and efficiency. This could involve using AI to analyze user preferences, optimize itineraries, and provide tailored recommendations based on individual interests and travel styles. Ensure that your AI implementation is transparent and provides users with control over their data and privacy.
  5. Focus on user experience and address common criticisms of competing apps, such as slow performance or broken forms. Prioritize usability testing and gather feedback from early users to identify and fix any issues. Ensure that your app is intuitive, user-friendly, and provides a seamless trip planning experience.
  6. Develop a robust data management strategy to ensure the accuracy and reliability of your travel information. This could involve partnering with reputable data providers, implementing quality control measures, and regularly updating your database. Address concerns about data accuracy and transparency by providing users with clear information about the sources of your data and how it is updated.
  7. Given that many competitors have received criticism for limiting the experience in some way (international support, form issues, incomplete data), start with a very small niche and do it REALLY well, so it can serve as a proof of concept and foundation for scale. This will also help in the marketing messaging (see below).
  8. Craft a compelling brand and marketing message that highlights your app's unique value proposition and resonates with your target audience. Position your app as the go-to solution for a specific travel niche or need. For example, if your app focuses on sustainable travel, emphasize its commitment to eco-friendly practices and responsible tourism.
  9. Implement a feedback loop to actively engage with your users and iterate on your app based on their feedback. Encourage users to provide suggestions, report issues, and share their experiences. Regularly review and incorporate user feedback into your product roadmap to ensure that your app continues to meet their evolving needs.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition, what specific niche or unmet need will your app address to stand out and attract users? How will you ensure that your app offers a truly unique and valuable experience compared to existing trip planning solutions?
  2. How will you ensure the accuracy and reliability of your travel information, and how will you address potential concerns about data privacy and security? What measures will you take to protect user data and maintain transparency about your data management practices?
  3. What is your long-term vision for the app, and how will you adapt to evolving user needs and market trends? How will you sustain user engagement and loyalty over time, and how will you measure the success of your app in terms of user satisfaction and business outcomes?

Your are here

Your idea for a smartphone application providing optimized trip plans for cities places you in a competitive market. There are already many similar apps, as shown by the 22 matching products. This means you'll face a significant challenge in standing out. While the high number of similar products suggests that there is indeed a strong buy signal and that people are willing to pay for this type of service, the key to success will be offering something unique or significantly better than what's already available. Given the existing competition, it's crucial to avoid simply replicating existing features and instead focus on genuine differentiation to capture user attention and loyalty. This will be critical to overcome the existing market saturation.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with thorough market research to identify gaps in existing trip planning apps. Focus on understanding user pain points that competitors aren't adequately addressing. For instance, some competing apps have been criticized for inaccurate data or limited location support. Analyze these weaknesses and consider how your app can overcome these limitations by offering more accurate, comprehensive, or niche-specific travel information.
  2. Develop a unique value proposition that clearly differentiates your app from competitors. This could involve incorporating AI-driven personalization, offline functionality, or focusing on a specific travel niche (e.g., budget travel, adventure travel, cultural immersion). Ensure your value proposition aligns with user needs and is clearly communicated in your marketing efforts.
  3. Consider incorporating user-generated content and community features to enhance the app's value and engagement. This could include allowing users to share their travel experiences, rate attractions, and contribute to trip planning. By leveraging user-generated content, you can create a more dynamic and personalized experience while also building a loyal community around your app.
  4. Given that many users have expressed interest in AI-powered trip planning, explore how you can leverage AI to enhance personalization and efficiency. This could involve using AI to analyze user preferences, optimize itineraries, and provide tailored recommendations based on individual interests and travel styles. Ensure that your AI implementation is transparent and provides users with control over their data and privacy.
  5. Focus on user experience and address common criticisms of competing apps, such as slow performance or broken forms. Prioritize usability testing and gather feedback from early users to identify and fix any issues. Ensure that your app is intuitive, user-friendly, and provides a seamless trip planning experience.
  6. Develop a robust data management strategy to ensure the accuracy and reliability of your travel information. This could involve partnering with reputable data providers, implementing quality control measures, and regularly updating your database. Address concerns about data accuracy and transparency by providing users with clear information about the sources of your data and how it is updated.
  7. Given that many competitors have received criticism for limiting the experience in some way (international support, form issues, incomplete data), start with a very small niche and do it REALLY well, so it can serve as a proof of concept and foundation for scale. This will also help in the marketing messaging (see below).
  8. Craft a compelling brand and marketing message that highlights your app's unique value proposition and resonates with your target audience. Position your app as the go-to solution for a specific travel niche or need. For example, if your app focuses on sustainable travel, emphasize its commitment to eco-friendly practices and responsible tourism.
  9. Implement a feedback loop to actively engage with your users and iterate on your app based on their feedback. Encourage users to provide suggestions, report issues, and share their experiences. Regularly review and incorporate user feedback into your product roadmap to ensure that your app continues to meet their evolving needs.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition, what specific niche or unmet need will your app address to stand out and attract users? How will you ensure that your app offers a truly unique and valuable experience compared to existing trip planning solutions?
  2. How will you ensure the accuracy and reliability of your travel information, and how will you address potential concerns about data privacy and security? What measures will you take to protect user data and maintain transparency about your data management practices?
  3. What is your long-term vision for the app, and how will you adapt to evolving user needs and market trends? How will you sustain user engagement and loyalty over time, and how will you measure the success of your app in terms of user satisfaction and business outcomes?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 22
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 8
  • Net use signal: 21.7%
    • Positive use signal: 22.2%
    • Negative use signal: 0.5%
  • Net buy signal: 0.6%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.1%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.5%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Tripnotes.ai: Intelligent Travel Planner

23 Mar 2023 Artificial Intelligence Travel

Hey HN,We're excited to announce the public beta preview of Tripnotes, an intelligent travel planner that mixes a custom recommendation engine, our own data, and a bit of GPT to help you find the right places to go while traveling. Our team has been working hard on this project for 6 months, and we're excited to finally share it with the HN community.With Tripnotes, you can keep track of all your notes about travel when planning to visit a city. Paste in article URLs, videos, emails, text messages, any other text, and if you need some help with research, ask our Concierge which will provide useful recommendations and itineraries for the city in question - with a fallback to GPT for things we didn't quite understand.If you're not ready to dive right in, here are a few short highlight videos:https://twitter.com/matthewer/status/1619047755271536640https://twitter.com/matthewer/status/1621172173598756864https://twitter.com/matthewer/status/1623703548545445890https://twitter.com/matthewer/status/1638010661694234625All the places by Tripnotes are from our own database, but we rely upon GPT to understand the intent of the incoming prompts, as well as to help with the prose in our response to ensure the place descriptions fit what's being asked for.Since we tweeted about our preview release on Monday, we've had over 15,000 people come and try at least one prompt, with over 40,000 unique notes generated from prompts about cities all over the world.We'd love for you to give Tripnotes a try and let us know what you think. The "unauthed" version is open to everyone. If you're interested in using the full version, please join our waitlist.The full version maintains a history of your notes and allows you to edit the text and auto-highlights any text you write/paste in on the fly, which can be useful for pasting recommendations from friends (say via SMS or Email) and having them auto-highlighted and mapped. You can also paste in links from articles, websites, blogs, even Tiktok or Youtube. We scrape those urls, gather the list of places that are mentioned, and then show them on the map along side the rest of your note.We'd love to hear your thoughts and feedback, so please feel free to leave a comment or reach out to us directly. Thanks for your support!

The product is praised for its usefulness in travel planning and regular updates. However, users have reported errors in closures and descriptions, and there are concerns about the app siphoning data from phones.

Users raised concerns about the sources and updates of the database, reported errors in closures and descriptions, and expressed worries about the app siphoning all data from their phones.

Avatar
9
3
0.0%
-33.3%
3
9
33.3%
Relevance

TravelTrail-Planifica Tu Viaje - Your interactive AI trip planner

19 Jun 2024 User Experience Travel Productivity

Our app provides a unique platform where you can save and manage lists of your dream destinations, explore details of each city, and customize your travel experience like never before with our Artificial intelligence (AI).

The app is lauded as a great tool for organized trip planning, featuring easy map access and enhancing travel planning with AI personalization and detailed information. Users are particularly interested in how the AI customizes travel plans based on individual preferences and whether recommendations vary among users in the same location. Many consider it useful for travel enthusiasts, congratulating its launch and AI-driven customization.

The user's comment expresses uncertainty about the AI's functionality, specifically questioning whether it links to review platforms for product recommendations.

Avatar
102
6
33.3%
6
102
33.3%
Relevance

I Built an AI That Plans Your Perfect Trip in Seconds

09 Jun 2024 Artificial Intelligence Travel

I’m excited to introduce my new AI-powered SaaS that takes the hassle out of travel planning. With just a few inputs, my AI generates personalized day-to-day itineraries, including the best hotels, restaurants, and activities, all in seconds.Key features:Custom Itineraries: Tailored day-to-day plans based on your preferences. Top Hotels and Restaurants: Recommendations for the best places to stay and dine. Recommended Activities: Discover must-see sights and activities suited to your interests. Instant Results: Save time with quick and accurate travel plans. I built this tool to simplify travel planning and help you make the most of your trips. Give it a try and let me know what you think!

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

theDIYtrip - Plan your dream trip in minutes

27 Feb 2023 Android iOS Productivity

theDIYtrip is a DIY(Do-It-Yourself) trip-planning app that helps travelers who lack the time & information for diligent trip planning. It empowers them with building flexible & personalized trip & provides curated recommendations from travel experts.

The Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback with congratulations and expressions of interest in the trip organizer. Users are curious about its differentiation from competitors and potential for international expansion, including non-US address support. There's also specific interest in its capabilities for booking flights and hotels, with one user planning to test it on their next trip.

The primary criticism is the product's limitation to the USA. Users, particularly travelers, expressed a strong need for international address support to broaden the product's usability beyond the United States.

Avatar
100
5
20.0%
5
100
20.0%
Relevance

theDIYtrip - Plan your dream trip in seconds

03 May 2023 Android Travel Productivity

theDIYtrip is an AI based trip planning app that helps travelers plan & book their trip in seconds!

The app, TheDIYtrip, is well-received for simplifying and expediting travel planning. Users are excited about its instant itineraries, detailed recommendations, and ease of use, which saves them considerable time. Many express enthusiasm to try it out for upcoming vacations and appreciate its unique itinerary suggestions. The launch is considered impressive, and the project and its creator receive strong support and congratulations. The app is also noted for facilitating ticket purchases.

Users criticize the app's slow performance when submitting trips, suggesting a need for UX improvements to address the sluggishness.

Avatar
109
13
69.2%
7.7%
13
109
69.2%
7.7%
Relevance

Discovertsy 2.0 - Get inspired, plan & explore cities with the Discovertsy App

20 Dec 2023 iOS Travel Entertainment

Discovertsy: Your mobile concierge for dream trips. Effortlessly plan and personalise your itinerary, discover top city experiences, and navigate with real-time nearby suggestions. All with the tap of an app—worldwide.

The Discovertsy launch on Product Hunt has been met with positive feedback. Users appreciate the beautifully made travel cards and consider the app a great tool for vacation planning. They're excited about the personalized learning, community features, multilingual support, and offline booking capabilities. Several users congratulated the team on the launch and wished them success.

Avatar
92
10
20.0%
10
92
20.0%
Relevance

I built an AI tool that generates personalized travel plans in seconds

16 May 2024 Artificial Intelligence Travel Productivity

Hey HN,I’m Fran, and I wanted to share a project I’ve been working on. It’s an AI tool that generates personalized travel plans tailored to your preferences in just seconds.I built this app because I love traveling, but I always spend so much time researching and finding nice hotels.I was surprised how well this tool works, finding the best hotels, restaurants, and day-to-day planning in just a few seconds.I’d love to hear your thoughts and feedback!Thanks, Fran

AI tool generates personalized travel plans quickly.

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

80days.me 3.0 Travel - An app that helps plan multi-city eurotrips in a few clicks

12 Dec 2023 Artificial Intelligence Travel

GenAI in TravelToday, we're excited to launch two distinct planning modes: the AI and Math algorithm-based SMART mode for Generated Planning; and our new addition - "AB Magic mode" for Manual Step-by-Step Planning. Promo code PH35OFF for travel with us.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team on the launch and relaunch of the app. Users repeatedly praised the app's innovative use of AI for travel planning, clean UI, ease of use, and potential to save time and money. Several users expressed excitement to use the app for upcoming trips, highlighting specific features like the SMART and AB Magic modes. Suggestions for improvement included feature requests for cost optimization, flexible dates, multi-city planning, and expansion to B2B and other languages.

Users expressed concerns about unclear pricing and upfront paywalls. Some questioned how user feedback influences app development and suggested improvements like recommending cheaper airports reachable by train. There were doubts about relinquishing travel planning and ensuring flight prices align with user preferences. Concerns also arose regarding financially irresponsible unplanned vacation suggestions. One user favored natural attractions over cities. The company was encouraged to advertise on university campuses.

Avatar
700
97
27.8%
1.0%
97
700
27.8%
1.0%
Relevance

TravelAI - Your personal travel assistant powered by AI

18 Apr 2023 Artificial Intelligence Travel Virtual Assistants

Travel effortlessly with our AI-powered travel planning app. Easily create personalized itineraries for your dream destinations. Save time and stress by letting artificial intelligence handle the details. Access our app and start planning your next adventure!

The Product Hunt launch received congratulations and excitement from users, with one frequent traveler expressing particular interest. However, multiple users reported that the form is broken, preventing them from fully interacting with the product. Addressing the form issue should be a priority.

A user reported that the form on the Product Hunt launch page appears to be broken, specifically mentioning an inability to select options. This suggests a potential usability issue or bug that needs immediate attention.

Avatar
85
5
5
85
Relevance

Guide.com - AI powered trip planner

15 Feb 2024 Artificial Intelligence Travel

Harness the power of AI to effortlessly design your perfect itinerary in seconds. Collaborate with friends, customize every detail, and embark on extraordinary adventures. Ready to experience the future of travel planning?

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team. Several users expressed excitement about the trip planning capabilities and user-friendly interface. Questions arose regarding location availability, specifically Malaysia. Users highlighted the tool's usefulness for spontaneous trip planning and its potential for travel enthusiasts. Suggestions were made to improve recommendation types and search capabilities. Some users encountered redirection issues, while others forwarded the product for further testing.

Users criticized the product for limited availability, with one noting their location was unsupported. Suggestions included adding more specific recommendation types tailored to individual interests and ensuring the service provides the best and latest information, especially for travel destinations. The service was also dinged for lacking comprehensive coverage, specifically mentioning the absence of Borneo in Malaysia as an option, signalling a need for improvement in supported regions.

Avatar
144
18
33.3%
18
144
33.3%
Relevance

GoTrip - Travel Planner App - Plan, Share, Travel: Your All-in-One Adventure Companion

25 Aug 2024 Travel

Your all-in-one travel planner. Create itineraries, collaborate with friends, and manage budgets. Share trips, split expenses, and store documents. Integrate with Google Maps, convert currencies, and prioritize privacy. Plan smarter, travel better.

Akashdeep is congratulated on the GoTrip launch. Users are excited about its offline functionality.

Avatar
10
2
50.0%
2
10
50.0%
Relevance

PlanMyTrip - Let your personality be your guide

25 Apr 2023 Artificial Intelligence Travel Vacation

PlanMyTrip generates itineraries based on your destination, dates, and budget. It includes recommendations for activities, attractions, accommodations, and transportation. A convenient option to save time and hassle in planning your trip.

PlanMyTrip's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its time-saving capabilities, interesting features, and personalized itinerary recommendations. Many expressed excitement to use it for upcoming travel, particularly in Europe. The app's interface and overall experience were well-received, with one user highlighting its ability to facilitate travel to 'unimaginable places'. Several users congratulated the team on the launch and thought the product was well-thought-out. One user reported a problem with the search functionality.

Users suggest improvements for travel day input and loading feedback mechanisms. A key criticism revolves around the search function's inadequacy. Users desire a more robust search capability and the ability to create itineraries involving multiple destinations.

Avatar
136
19
47.4%
5.3%
19
136
47.4%
5.3%
Relevance

InstaTrip - Travel Itinerary Planner

16 Aug 2024 Travel YouTube

We noticed a gap in how travel is planned. There's plenty of tools for booking flights and hotels, but what about truly experiencing a destination? Our app aims to fill this void by customizing travel plans into an easy-to-navigate interface.

Avatar
3
3
Relevance

Simplifying Travel Planning for travelers's lovers

04 Dec 2024 Travel

Born out of the frustration of planning our honeymoon, Begintrips is a web app designed to simplify the logistics of organizing trips of any kind. Unlike existing solutions, Begintrips combines budgeting, itinerary management, and journey customization into one seamless experience. With features like a guided onboarding process, expense tracking by day and category, and a journey recap page to visualize your plans, it adapts to everything from solo adventures to family vacations. Crafted with real user feedback, Begintrips transforms trip planning from overwhelming to effortless. Try it out and take control of your next adventure!

Avatar
3
3
Top