Should I Build It Should I Build It
07 May 2025
Productivity Task Management

a simple miniamlist todo app, just a list of task

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

You're entering a crowded market with your minimalist to-do app. There are already many similar products available (n_matches=28, high confidence), indicating significant competition. The average engagement for similar products is medium (n_comments=6), which means users are somewhat interested, but it may be hard to stand out. Since we don't have any net use or buy signals, it seems like people are neutral about these products in general. The good news is, your challenge isn't convincing people that they need a to-do app, but rather convincing them that your particular take on it is better than the rest. To make your product viable, you'll need to find a way to differentiate it by identifying underserved needs in the existing to-do app landscape or introduce an innovative approach that is missing from other apps.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with thorough market research to identify the shortcomings of existing to-do apps. Focus on user reviews and feedback to pinpoint pain points that your app can uniquely address. For instance, many users criticized existing to-do apps for lacking calendar integration, or for being overly simplistic. Use this intel to guide your app's development.
  2. Define 2-3 key differentiators that will set your app apart. Consider focusing on niche features, enhanced user experience, or a unique design. For example, you could implement advanced workflow capabilities, time-tracking features, or customize the UI.
  3. Target a specific niche market with unique needs. Rather than competing directly with established players, focus on a segment that's underserved. For example, create a to-do app tailored specifically for developers, designers, or students. Based on user reviews, people had success with Todo apps specifically for MacOS or Terminal
  4. Craft a compelling brand and marketing message that clearly communicates your app's unique value proposition. Highlight what makes your app different and why users should choose it over the competition. For instance, emphasize the app's simplicity, focus, or integration with other tools. You can start this by doing a product hunt launch
  5. Prioritize early user engagement and gather feedback continuously. Use beta testing and user interviews to refine your app based on real-world usage. Be prepared to iterate quickly and adapt to user needs. Remember, the goal is to create a loyal group of early adopters who will advocate for your product, and tell others about your app.
  6. Based on the negative feedback from similar products, ensure your app offers clear documentation, responsive customer support, and consistent updates to address user concerns and improve functionality. Given the number of similar products, you need to ensure you are doing everything to retain any users you acquire.

Questions

  1. Given the crowded market, what specific user need or pain point will your minimalist to-do app address that isn't adequately solved by existing solutions?
  2. How will you measure and track user engagement and satisfaction to ensure your app remains differentiated and valuable over time, especially given the medium engagement observed in similar products?
  3. What is your plan to avoid feature creep while still providing enough value to differentiate your app from the many similar options available?

Your are here

You're entering a crowded market with your minimalist to-do app. There are already many similar products available (n_matches=28, high confidence), indicating significant competition. The average engagement for similar products is medium (n_comments=6), which means users are somewhat interested, but it may be hard to stand out. Since we don't have any net use or buy signals, it seems like people are neutral about these products in general. The good news is, your challenge isn't convincing people that they need a to-do app, but rather convincing them that your particular take on it is better than the rest. To make your product viable, you'll need to find a way to differentiate it by identifying underserved needs in the existing to-do app landscape or introduce an innovative approach that is missing from other apps.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with thorough market research to identify the shortcomings of existing to-do apps. Focus on user reviews and feedback to pinpoint pain points that your app can uniquely address. For instance, many users criticized existing to-do apps for lacking calendar integration, or for being overly simplistic. Use this intel to guide your app's development.
  2. Define 2-3 key differentiators that will set your app apart. Consider focusing on niche features, enhanced user experience, or a unique design. For example, you could implement advanced workflow capabilities, time-tracking features, or customize the UI.
  3. Target a specific niche market with unique needs. Rather than competing directly with established players, focus on a segment that's underserved. For example, create a to-do app tailored specifically for developers, designers, or students. Based on user reviews, people had success with Todo apps specifically for MacOS or Terminal
  4. Craft a compelling brand and marketing message that clearly communicates your app's unique value proposition. Highlight what makes your app different and why users should choose it over the competition. For instance, emphasize the app's simplicity, focus, or integration with other tools. You can start this by doing a product hunt launch
  5. Prioritize early user engagement and gather feedback continuously. Use beta testing and user interviews to refine your app based on real-world usage. Be prepared to iterate quickly and adapt to user needs. Remember, the goal is to create a loyal group of early adopters who will advocate for your product, and tell others about your app.
  6. Based on the negative feedback from similar products, ensure your app offers clear documentation, responsive customer support, and consistent updates to address user concerns and improve functionality. Given the number of similar products, you need to ensure you are doing everything to retain any users you acquire.

Questions

  1. Given the crowded market, what specific user need or pain point will your minimalist to-do app address that isn't adequately solved by existing solutions?
  2. How will you measure and track user engagement and satisfaction to ensure your app remains differentiated and valuable over time, especially given the medium engagement observed in similar products?
  3. What is your plan to avoid feature creep while still providing enough value to differentiate your app from the many similar options available?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 28
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 6
  • Net use signal: 10.5%
    • Positive use signal: 17.2%
    • Negative use signal: 6.6%
  • Net buy signal: 0.2%
    • Positive buy signal: 2.5%
    • Negative buy signal: 2.3%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Todo Stack - Manage tasks without ever leaving your browser's tab

09 Apr 2023 Writing Productivity Task Management

Our minimalist todo app! With a clean and simple design, this app lets you quickly add, organize, and complete tasks without any unnecessary distractions.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback overall. Users congratulated the team on the launch and encouraged them to keep in touch. The concept was well-received, indicating potential for success.

Avatar
71
3
3
71
Relevance

Simple TODO app that runs in the terminal

16 Mar 2023 GitHub Productivity Developer Tools

Hey there, HN!I wrote a simple TODO app that runs in the terminal. The GIF demo in the repo (https://github.com/mathspp/textual-todo) uses the mouse so that people watching can see where I am clicking, but everything can be done from the comfort of your keyboard.Basic features include data persistence (doh!), sorting items by due date, different styling for items that are late, and collapsing details for a more compact view.Let me know if you find any bugs and/or if you have suggestions for simple features that I could add to keep this app lightweight but useful!

Simple TODO app for terminal with keyboard support.

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

Do this! - Minimalistic and simple to-do list (shopping, tasks, etc.)

15 Feb 2023 Productivity

Use the "Do this!" application to easily create to-do lists (shopping, tasks, etc.). You can create local and cloud to-do lists in the app. Share the link with anyone and monitor task progress in real time. Without registration and personal data.

The Product Hunt launch received congratulations. Users inquired about mobile availability. Feedback included appreciation for the simplistic design, but also raised questions regarding the tagging feature and potential app saturation in the market.

Users feel there are already too many to-do apps available. There are also questions about the tagging functionality.

Avatar
75
2
2
75
Relevance

Let's Focus - Simple and powerful todo list that helps you get more done

12 Oct 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity Task Management

A simple and powerful to-do list designed to help you get more done with ease. Whether you're managing daily tasks or tackling complex projects, it offers the tools you need to stay organized and productive. Optimized for individual who want to thrive.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with one user congratulating Mochamad and expressing interest in GTD integration, specifically suggesting calendar integration. Another user praised the UI but reported an error related to the comments button, indicating a JavaScript issue with 'tQ.map is not a function'.

Users criticized the product launch for lacking calendar integration, which they believe would enhance productivity. Additionally, some users reported encountering a JavaScript error related to the comments button, specifically 'tQ.map is not a function', which needs to be addressed to improve user experience.

Avatar
19
2
2
19
Relevance

Easy Todo - Simple and Efficient Task Management

29 Sep 2024 Artificial Intelligence Productivity Task Management

Easy Todo is a simple, free, and ad-free task management app. Add tasks with one tap or voice input, set priorities, and schedule daily reminders. Urgent tasks get strong desktop alerts, iCloud sync keeps tasks updated across devices.

Easy Todo app praised for voice input and priority tasks.

App not fully tried; initial impressions only.

Avatar
9
1
1
9
Relevance

Hotlist - Manage your daily todos straight from your Mac menu bar

21 Nov 2023 Productivity Menu Bar Apps Task Management

A tiny daily todo list menu bar app for Mac. 1️⃣ Add a short list of things you want to get done today. 2️⃣ Check them off one by one. 3️⃣ Feel good about making progress.

Hotlist's Product Hunt launch received largely positive feedback, with users praising its simplicity, clean design, and plugin functionality. Many users congratulated the creator and expressed interest in future development and customization options. Several users specifically loved the easy and accessible custom plugins. Some users reported issues with the menu bar app, but others confirmed it was working. Suggestions included more sophisticated to-do systems, time tracking features, and integration with server-side apps. The product's simple and effective design was a recurring highlight.

Users criticized the product launch for its overly simplistic to-do system, which lacks advanced workflow capabilities. Several users reported issues with the menu bar app, noting that it either didn't work correctly or had persistent problems. A common request was the addition of a time-tracking feature to enhance productivity management, and some users requested due date support.

Avatar
127
18
33.3%
18
127
33.3%
Relevance

Tududi – A Minimalist, Open-Source Task and Project Management Tool

11 Nov 2024 Productivity Developer Tools Task Management

Users have mixed reactions to the product's name, with some questioning the English proficiency it suggests and others finding humor in it. There's confusion about the pronunciation, leading to a humorous interpretation. The use of the Sinatra framework is questioned, and there's a mix-up between NodeJS and Ruby. A specific user, ThePrimeagen, is noted to be upset.

Users criticized the product's name for being unfortunate, with one user noting it sounds like 'too doody.' There's also confusion about the relevance of Sinatra and a misleading association suggested by the name.

Avatar
14
7
7
14
Relevance

Sublime Todo - Minimalist, text editor-based task management for macOS

27 Dec 2024 Mac Productivity Task Management

A keyboard-driven, distraction-free todo app for macOS. Inspired by Sublime Text's efficiency, featuring project tags, smart organization, and fast native macOS build.

Sublime To Do is praised for its simplicity, efficiency, and keyboard-driven approach, making it a productive tool for managing tasks. Users appreciate its clean, minimalistic, and straightforward design, with some likening it to qBasic. A suggestion was made to avoid adding new tasks at the bottom of the list to prevent user confusion, while others are interested in a terminal implementation.

Users criticize the task list's UX, suggesting new tasks should appear at the top. They also find the project tag display insufficient, requesting autocomplete functionality. Additionally, the app's behavior of opening two views of the same content, one smaller, is considered a usability flaw.

Avatar
265
7
71.4%
7
265
71.4%
Relevance

Cubicdone - Free opinionated todo-list

17 Jul 2024 Productivity Task Management

Todo List with preconfigured productivity system, that will keep your tasks and mind in shape

The Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users praising the todo app's clean and simple design. One user inquired about the availability of support for recurring tasks, suggesting a potential area for improvement or further development.

Users are requesting recurring task support, specifically reminders for weekly tasks. This feature seems to be a key area for improvement based on user feedback.

Avatar
16
2
50.0%
2
16
50.0%
Relevance

NowDo – MacOS todo app for procrastinators

17 Dec 2023 Productivity

Users generally appreciate the simplicity and functionality of the NowDo app, with positive feedback on its minimal features and always-on-top design. However, there are requests for improvements such as customizable shortcuts, UI enhancements, cloud sync, and additional features like infinite nesting and task priority management. Concerns about proprietary cloud services and preferences for web apps over Mac installations are noted. The developer's responsiveness and plans for cross-platform support are well-received. Some users suggest alternative apps and features, while others express hesitation about installing non-open source software.

Users criticize the product for its subscription model, task management issues like visibility and multiple selection, and shortcut conflicts. Concerns about over-customization, proprietary cloud services, and the lack of critical features such as infinite nesting are also noted. The UI is seen as distracting and taking up too much space, with specific issues in task switching. Installation discomfort, especially for Mac apps, and the CI/CD system's complexity for small projects are mentioned. Some users perceive the product as unnecessary in a saturated market and question its OS compatibility and lack of clear documentation.

Avatar
103
114
7.0%
0.0%
114
103
18.4%
3.5%
Relevance

A simple app that makes it easier to complete a task

15 May 2024 Productivity Task Management

This is how it works: often, how easy it is for us to complete a task depends on the wording. For example, instead of writing “start reading a book tomorrow,” you should write, “reserve time from 11:00 to 11:30 to read a book.” Another approach is to break the task into the simplest steps, which are easy to complete and make it easier to accomplish the entire task. For example, instead of setting a task on your calendar for tomorrow to “go to the gym,” you should set a task for tonight to “pack a sports bag and leave it by the door.”This small web app helps you set and complete simple steps until the task is done.PS. I submitted it here a week ago, but it turned out that when I deployed it from my local machine to a remote server, it stopped working properly, making it impossible to try. It is still far from perfect, but I have fixed the bugs.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

I Built a Todo Task Management Web App

09 Nov 2024 Task Management

Users are skeptical about the 50k+ active users claim, inquiring about previous versions and the app in use. Positive feedback highlights the good UX, similar to Zendo.cc, and the appealing UI, particularly cursor movement. Criticisms include a non-functional 'Get Started Now' button leading to a 404 error, UX issues with zooming causing the delete button to go off-screen, and text colors that render content unreadable.

Users expressed skepticism about the claimed user count, noted the unavailability of a previous version, reported a non-functional 'Get Started Now' button, and highlighted a user interface issue where zooming in causes the delete button to go off-screen. Additionally, there was criticism about poor readability due to the use of dark gray text on a black background.

Avatar
5
9
0.0%
-11.1%
9
5
11.1%
Relevance

Todo sort - Sort your todo list now

03 Mar 2024 Android Productivity Task Management

Ever thought of sorting your todo list based upon how much time you have ? Todo sort helps you do that by allowing you to create tasks of 5 min, 20 mins and 60 mins duration. Now, whenever you got 5 mins break, just look into the 5 min list and start the task.

Avatar
6
6
Top