Enable any user to build agentic workflow by natural language in live, ...

...shareable, debuggable automation

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.


Your are here

Your idea to enable users to build agentic workflows with natural language in a live, shareable, and debuggable environment lands squarely in a competitive space. We found 27 similar products, indicating high market activity, but also high competition. The average engagement across these products is high, with an average of 14 comments per product, meaning there is significant interest in the general idea of AI-powered automation. While the use signal is neutral, there is an unusually strong buy signal. This suggests that while users might not be explicitly discussing 'using' similar products, they are expressing a willingness to pay for the functionality you're proposing. Given the high level of competition, your success will depend on how well you differentiate your offering from the existing solutions.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, prioritize identifying a unique selling proposition (USP). What specific problem does your agentic workflow builder solve better than existing solutions like Questflow or AgentHub? Is it the ease of debugging, the shareability, or a specific niche in automation?
  2. Focus on a niche. Instead of trying to be a general-purpose automation tool, consider targeting specific industries or use cases (e.g., marketing automation for e-commerce, or workflow automation for research). This will allow you to tailor your features and marketing efforts effectively.
  3. Develop a compelling content strategy. Many similar products are criticized for lacking demonstration videos or clear explanations of functionality. Create tutorials, demos, and use case examples to showcase the power and ease of use of your platform. Address the need for clearer user guidance, as seen in the AgentCrew feedback.
  4. Pay close attention to user experience (UX). Many users find AI products complex and hard to learn. Make sure your platform is incredibly intuitive, potentially focusing on a drag-and-drop interface similar to AgentHub, which received praise for its UI/UX. But, remember that users also felt overwhelmed, so make the UI clean!
  5. Carefully consider your pricing strategy. The positive buy signal suggests users are willing to pay, but Moveo AI received negative feedback for a complex and unclear pricing plan. Keep it simple, transparent, and value-driven.
  6. Actively engage with your early users. Gather feedback constantly and iterate rapidly. The goal is to build a loyal group of early adopters who will champion your product. Address concerns about privacy protection, as raised in Questflow's feedback, transparently.
  7. Study the criticism of similar products and avoid their pitfalls. For instance, Nekton's landing page was criticized for lacking clarity; ensure your messaging is concise and easily understandable. Be wary of feature creep; focus on core functionality first.
  8. Create real-time collaboration features to improve productivity based on feedback from Questflow's users.
  9. Consider building templates to accelerate user adoption. Take inspiration from AgentCrew and its benefits with tools like Mindpal.

Questions

  1. Given the high competition, what specific, measurable advantage does your platform offer compared to existing solutions, and how will you communicate this advantage clearly to potential users?
  2. How will you balance ease of use for non-technical users with the power and flexibility needed for complex workflow automation scenarios?
  3. Considering the positive 'buy' signal, what value-added features can you offer that would justify a premium pricing tier and entice users to upgrade?

Your are here

Your idea to enable users to build agentic workflows with natural language in a live, shareable, and debuggable environment lands squarely in a competitive space. We found 27 similar products, indicating high market activity, but also high competition. The average engagement across these products is high, with an average of 14 comments per product, meaning there is significant interest in the general idea of AI-powered automation. While the use signal is neutral, there is an unusually strong buy signal. This suggests that while users might not be explicitly discussing 'using' similar products, they are expressing a willingness to pay for the functionality you're proposing. Given the high level of competition, your success will depend on how well you differentiate your offering from the existing solutions.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, prioritize identifying a unique selling proposition (USP). What specific problem does your agentic workflow builder solve better than existing solutions like Questflow or AgentHub? Is it the ease of debugging, the shareability, or a specific niche in automation?
  2. Focus on a niche. Instead of trying to be a general-purpose automation tool, consider targeting specific industries or use cases (e.g., marketing automation for e-commerce, or workflow automation for research). This will allow you to tailor your features and marketing efforts effectively.
  3. Develop a compelling content strategy. Many similar products are criticized for lacking demonstration videos or clear explanations of functionality. Create tutorials, demos, and use case examples to showcase the power and ease of use of your platform. Address the need for clearer user guidance, as seen in the AgentCrew feedback.
  4. Pay close attention to user experience (UX). Many users find AI products complex and hard to learn. Make sure your platform is incredibly intuitive, potentially focusing on a drag-and-drop interface similar to AgentHub, which received praise for its UI/UX. But, remember that users also felt overwhelmed, so make the UI clean!
  5. Carefully consider your pricing strategy. The positive buy signal suggests users are willing to pay, but Moveo AI received negative feedback for a complex and unclear pricing plan. Keep it simple, transparent, and value-driven.
  6. Actively engage with your early users. Gather feedback constantly and iterate rapidly. The goal is to build a loyal group of early adopters who will champion your product. Address concerns about privacy protection, as raised in Questflow's feedback, transparently.
  7. Study the criticism of similar products and avoid their pitfalls. For instance, Nekton's landing page was criticized for lacking clarity; ensure your messaging is concise and easily understandable. Be wary of feature creep; focus on core functionality first.
  8. Create real-time collaboration features to improve productivity based on feedback from Questflow's users.
  9. Consider building templates to accelerate user adoption. Take inspiration from AgentCrew and its benefits with tools like Mindpal.

Questions

  1. Given the high competition, what specific, measurable advantage does your platform offer compared to existing solutions, and how will you communicate this advantage clearly to potential users?
  2. How will you balance ease of use for non-technical users with the power and flexibility needed for complex workflow automation scenarios?
  3. Considering the positive 'buy' signal, what value-added features can you offer that would justify a premium pricing tier and entice users to upgrade?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 27
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 14
  • Net use signal: 19.4%
    • Positive use signal: 19.8%
    • Negative use signal: 0.4%
  • Net buy signal: 0.6%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.8%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.2%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

ControlFlow – open-source AI workflows

Hi HN! I’m excited to share ControlFlow, our new open-source framework for building agentic workflows.ControlFlow is built around a core opinion that LLMs perform really well on small, well-defined tasks and run off the rails otherwise. I know that may seem obvious, but the key insight is that if you compose enough of these small tasks into a structured workflow, you can recover the kind of complex behaviors we associate with autonomous AIs, without sacrificing control or observability at each step. It ends up feeling a lot like writing a traditional software workflow.With ControlFlow you:- define structured tasks for your agents to achieve,- assign one or more specialized agents to each task,- then compose the tasks into a workflow for execution.We've been working toward this for a while, applying insights from our work on Prefect (our workflow engine) and Marvin (our LLM framework). ControlFlow is our effort to bridge the gap between all those impressive AI demos and what we see B2B users actually trying to accomplish in production. More often than not, their goal is to sanely delegate a few steps of a workflow to an AI, not deploy a suite of end-to-end autonomous while loops.This is ControlFlow's initial release and we’d love your feedback. We hope it's a refreshing take on making LLMs feel like software again! You can check out the repo here: https://github.com/prefecthq/controlflow/

Users are generally excited about the product, with one user specifically praising the team. However, there is a request for an actual demonstration video, and another user noted that there is no content available.

The product lacks a demonstration video, making it difficult for users to understand its functionality and benefits.


Avatar
42
3
33.3%
3
42
33.3%
Relevance

Questflow - AI automation workspace

Questflow is the AI-native way to automate tasks across platforms - sending Emails, updating Calendars, organizing Databases, posting on Social Media, etc., all in a text-to-workflow platform.

Questflow's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its AI automation capabilities, intuitive UI/UX, and potential to simplify tasks for non-technical users. Many congratulate the team, especially Alex, on the launch and its progress. Questflow is seen as a game-changer and competitor to Zapier in the automation space. Some users suggest improvements like real-time collaboration and video tutorials. A concern about the confusing name similarity to Microsoft Copilot was raised, as well as a question about privacy protection.

The product is criticized for being in an early stage requiring refinement based on user feedback. Users find AI products require too much effort and have a steep learning curve. The product name is confusing and may present legal issues. There are questions about its privacy protections. Users suggest implementing a real-time collaboration feature to improve productivity.


Avatar
316
20
15.0%
20
316
15.0%
Relevance

Automate your day-to-day tasks with ChatGPT 4 and Nekton.ai

If you are doing the same things over and over every day, you can try automating it with Nekton. Just describe what needs to be done in plain English, step by step. Nekton will then convert your steps into executable code using GPT 4, and run them in the cloud.Here is a sample workflow that shows service features - https://nekton.ai/start/162-Xcz3PZOkB8OhIeFlOeBTVAYou can automate many different things. Here are some things you can try:* Find top Reddit posts about AI and send them to my Discord channel.* Get Reddit posts that mention my project and create a tweet for them.* Assign my latest GitHub pull request to a person with the fewest open PRs in the project.* Automate technical support - https://nekton.ai/start/143-HpJtyXEzfRv7UKvqOHySkwFeatures:* Create reusable automated workflows.* Share workflows with other people - you can send them a link that will start a workflow.* Collect input with forms before running the automation.* Run your automation on a schedule. Workflows run in the cloud - no need to keep your browser open.* Use other services from your workflow. Nekton can securely store access tokens and other credentials needed to access outside services and apps.* Mix together manual and automated steps in a single workflow.Since the last post, we made multiple improvements to make it easier to automate things and connect to external services.I work on this project, and curious to know your thoughts!

Users appreciate Nekton's ability to automate tasks using plain English steps. Suggestions include adding workflows to the landing page for better clarity. Some users are interested in tweeting from ChatGPT, but there are issues with signing in to Twitter. One user expressed gratitude for a solution that worked.

Users criticized the product for having a landing page that lacks clarity, making it difficult to understand the service. Additionally, there is confusion about how to tweet from ChatGPT, and some users reported issues with signing in on Twitter.


Avatar
7
5
-20.0%
5
7
Relevance

Nekton – Automate your workflows with AI

Show HN: Nekton - Automate your workflows with AIHi HN,I'm Alex, founder of Nekton. You can use this service to automate your workflows. First, you can describe your workflow as text steps, and then Nekton AI will convert them to code and run it in the cloud.The code can make network calls and integrate with different external APIs and services.Nekton is in early access, but you already can create step-by-step checklists, mix together manual and automated tasks in a single workflow, collect user input with forms, and share the workflow with your teammates.We have a sample workflow that you can play around with after signup.Let me know what you think!

Users are inquiring about the code generation language used and reporting issues with importing npm packages.

The main criticism is that users are encountering errors while using the product or service.


Avatar
6
2
2
6
Relevance

Trudo AI: AI-Powered Workflow Automation - Python-based workflow tool for automating complex data tasks

Trudo.ai lets users build workflows with Python-powered nodes. An AI copilot generates nodes from plain English descriptions, viewable and editable in both Code and UI formats. Users can modify nodes easily while keeping full control over adjustments.

AI-driven Python nodes transform workflow development with code and visual tools.


Avatar
20
1
1
20
Relevance

Manaflow - Automate repetitive office work in tables

Manaflow is the simplest way to automate repetitive office work in tables using natural language. With one click, you can execute millions of tasks involving data transformation, gluing APIs, and taking actions with AI agents.

Manaflow's Product Hunt launch is generating excitement, particularly for its potential to automate workflows and enhance productivity for SMBs using natural language AI agents. Users are impressed with its game-changing capabilities and express enthusiasm for its growth. Questions revolve around handling complex workflows, learning curve for non-technical users, task limits, integrations with other tools, customization options, and use cases beyond the provided templates. The tool is seen as beneficial for office productivity, automating repetitive tasks, and reducing the need for coding.

Users expressed concerns regarding the product's ability to handle complex workflows beyond basic data transformation. There were also questions about AI agent customization, adaptation, and integrations. Additionally, concerns were raised regarding the dependency graph and limitations in task automation. Many users feel that there are too many repetitive tasks that require outsourcing and that there should be less coding solutions.


Avatar
215
29
41.4%
29
215
41.4%
Relevance

Open-source framework to build, manage and run Autonomous Agents

Users are curious about the trade-offs of using the langchain framework and question the purpose of configurable workflows. Some have tried agent frameworks and found them not useful. There is interest in the supported models and the future roadmap of the product. Additionally, users are asking about the differences between this product and autoGPT or baby agi.

The main criticisms are that the agent frameworks are not useful, the purpose of the product is unclear, and there is a lack of differentiation from existing tools like autoGPT or baby agi.


Avatar
6
5
5
6
Relevance

Built a Tool to Automate Tedious Tasks with AI, Without Coding

Hey, Lorenzo here,Started to work on this side-project for a week or so, I’m curious what y’all think! Coflow connects AI to your current platforms and automates any repetitive/manual task without coding. How it works:- Specify the trigger/input the AI should expect- Tell the AI what to do- Specify where to send/store the output- Deploy and let it runWould love your feedback :)Early access: https://www.joincoflow.com/

The product is praised for its utility in recruiting engineers and automating subjective tasks, with responsive support noted. It's recommended for use with web scraping, particularly for social media analysis, and is appreciated for eliminating tedious manual processes. Users are excited about potential tool integrations and are eager to try the product.

Users have criticized the product for lacking web scraping capabilities for social media analysis.


Avatar
26
7
57.1%
7
26
57.1%
Relevance

AgentHub - Automate any workflow with AI

AgentHub is a no-code platform for building powerful AI automations. Our drag-and-drop visual builder lets users create reliable and cost-effective AI-powered automations. Fully automate tasks end-to-end without writing a line of code.

AgentHub's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising its ease of use, powerful automation capabilities, and impressive UI/UX. Many highlighted its potential for time-saving, workflow automation, and increased productivity, especially for non-technical users. The drag-and-drop visual builder and ability to rapidly prototype AI automations were also commended. Several users congratulated the team on the launch and expressed excitement about the platform's roadmap and potential applications across various industries. Suggestions for improvement included a community template gallery and browser automation features.

Users expressed concerns about the visual workflow builder becoming unmanageable for complex automations. Several users inquired about customization options, integrations with other platforms, and seamless integration with specific tools. Some users found the UI took time to get used to, and there was uncertainty about the product's success in the volatile market.


Avatar
267
52
40.4%
52
267
40.4%
Relevance

A New Paradigm for Building Agentic AI Pipelines, Atomically

Atomic Agents is a Python framework that brings software engineering principles to AI agent development. Key features: - Focus on practical business applications rather than fancy autonomous clickbait demos - Modular design inspired by Atomic Design, breaking AI systems into reusable components - Structured input/output using Pydantic schemas for predictable behavior - Separation of concerns (prompts, tools, memory) for fine-grained control - Easy chaining of agents and tools to build complex workflowsIt enables building AI systems that are modular, controllable and aligned with real-world requirements. Think of it as "LEGO blocks for AI agents".


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Agentflow – Run Complex LLM Workflows from Simple JSON

So, it feels like this should exist. But I couldn't find it. So I tried to build it.Agentflow lets you run complex LLM workflows from a simple JSON file. This can be as little as a list of tasks. Tasks can include variables, so you can reuse workflows for different outputs by providing different variable values. They can also include custom functions, so you can go beyond text generation to do anything you want to write a function for.Someone might say: "Why not just use ChatGPT?" Among other reasons, I'd say that you can't template a workflow with ChatGPT, trigger it with different variable values, easily add in custom functions, or force the use of custom functions for steps in the workflow.Someone might also say: "Then why not use Auto-GPT or BabyAGI?" Among other reasons, I'd say you can't if you want consistency because these tools operate autonomously, creating and executing their own tasks. Agentflow, on the other and, lets you define a step-by-step workflow to give you more control.I'd like to do more with this, including adding more custom functions, and more examples, and more ways to trigger workflows (such as in response to events). But first, I want to make sure I'm not wasting my time! For starters, if something like this already exists, please tell me.

Users suggest collaborations with Magic Loop and API discussion, and recommend using cached AI results for consistency. There's interest in workflow automation tools like api2ai and FlowFlow.AI, as well as open-source alternatives to Step Functions. The tool receives praise for its functionality, with requests for workflow configuration details, examples, and comparisons to LangChain. Curiosity about function calls and image generation is noted. Users express interest in trying the tool, and there are inquiries about support for local LLMs and potential use of LocalAI or FastChat for OpenAI API emulation. The need for a standard LLM API and appreciation for lightweight alternatives to LangChain are also mentioned.

Users criticized the product for lacking AI for user input, requiring Python, needing more examples and a LangChain comparison, unclear statements about 'no code with LangChain', no support for local LLMs, uncertainty about function calling support, lack of a standard for LLM APIs, and the JSON basis being moot without a provided library.


Avatar
51
13
15.4%
13
51
15.4%
Relevance

Lemon Agent – Plan and Solve agent for workflow automation

I built this Plan and Solve (PS) agent because I struggled to build stable sequential tasks with LangChain and GPT3.5 turbo. After many failed attempts with LangChain's PS agent, I decided to build my own.I built the agent in a way that it acts as a workflow automation co-pilot rather than trying to play AGI. For example, the user has to tell the Lemon Agent which task needs to be solved and whether the suggested workflow automation is the right one for the task. I decided to go with a PS architecture since I consider the separation of responsibility a great way to increase the accuracy of agents, which is one of the main reasons why I built this agent. I am actively thinking about adding a workflow automation-specific third agent that helps with input validation (so kind of a ‘PVS’ agent) to make the input parameter provision in each workflow step more accurate.I’d love to hear your thoughts and get some initial feedback!

Will this compete with Zapier or similar platforms?


Avatar
7
1
1
7
Top