Should I Build It Should I Build It
28 Apr 2025
Artificial Intelligence

BI tool for sales data that is based on MCP and allows conversasional ...

...experience with data - user asks about data in natural language and in response it gets a report with visualizations, generated by AI. It can then follow up and build true analyst-executive conversation experience.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your idea for an AI-powered BI tool that allows users to interact with sales data through natural language and receive AI-generated reports and visualizations falls into a crowded space. We found 20 similar products, indicating high competition. This landscape is categorized as a 'Swamp,' meaning many mediocre solutions exist, and it's difficult to stand out. The average engagement, measured by the number of comments on similar products, is low. However, there's a strong positive buy signal for these types of tools, which is encouraging, suggesting a willingness to pay if the execution is compelling. Therefore, make sure your solution is fundamentally different and addresses unmet needs to avoid blending into the background.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly research existing BI and data analysis solutions. Understand their limitations, user frustrations, and areas where they fall short. Dive deep into why these solutions haven't fully satisfied the market's needs. Use this insight to identify key differentiators for your product. The discussion summaries indicate a need for integrations with platforms like Notion and Shopify, so consider these as potential features.
  2. Focus on a specific niche or underserved group within the sales data analysis space. Instead of building a general-purpose BI tool, target a particular industry or sales team size with tailored features and insights. This targeted approach will help you stand out and attract a loyal customer base. For example, given the comments in the similar products, you could focus on marketing integrations.
  3. Consider building complementary tools or integrations for existing BI providers. Instead of directly competing, you could offer a specialized AI-powered add-on that enhances their capabilities. This strategy allows you to leverage existing customer bases and distribution channels. Make sure that the tool you build is significantly and quantifiably better and more useful than the status quo.
  4. Given the criticisms of similar products, like slow local LLMs or token limit issues with GPT, focus on optimizing the AI's performance and scalability. Ensure that your tool can handle complex queries and large datasets efficiently. Prioritize speed and accuracy to avoid user frustration.
  5. Explore adjacent problems related to sales data analysis that might be more promising. Consider focusing on data quality, predictive analytics, or personalized sales coaching based on data insights. These areas could offer higher growth potential and less direct competition. It's critical to keep in mind the slow speed of GPT-4 and the limits of GPT-3.5-turbo when handling complex SQL queries.
  6. Prioritize privacy and data security in your tool's design. Given the increasing concerns about data privacy, especially with AI, ensure that your solution complies with relevant regulations and protects user data. Emphasize this commitment to privacy in your marketing and communications. Similar products highlight the appreciation for privacy-centered AI approaches.
  7. Develop a clear and compelling value proposition that resonates with your target audience. Clearly communicate the unique benefits of your AI-powered BI tool and how it solves their specific pain points. Avoid jargon and focus on tangible outcomes, such as increased sales, improved efficiency, or better decision-making. From the user discussions, make sure your solution is user-friendly.
  8. Invest in robust customer support and documentation. Provide users with the resources they need to effectively use your tool and troubleshoot any issues. Respond quickly to user inquiries and provide personalized assistance. The existing solutions have low engagement, so customer service can be an area where your product can be significantly better.

Questions

  1. Given the 'Swamp' category and the number of competitors, what specific and defensible technological advantage will your AI algorithms have over existing solutions to ensure superior insights and user experience?
  2. Considering the strong positive 'buy' signal but low overall engagement, what go-to-market strategy will you employ to not only attract paying customers but also ensure their long-term active usage and satisfaction with the tool?
  3. How will you address the potential for 'AI hallucinations' and ensure the accuracy and reliability of the generated reports and visualizations, especially given the reliance on natural language input which can be ambiguous or incomplete?

Your are here

Your idea for an AI-powered BI tool that allows users to interact with sales data through natural language and receive AI-generated reports and visualizations falls into a crowded space. We found 20 similar products, indicating high competition. This landscape is categorized as a 'Swamp,' meaning many mediocre solutions exist, and it's difficult to stand out. The average engagement, measured by the number of comments on similar products, is low. However, there's a strong positive buy signal for these types of tools, which is encouraging, suggesting a willingness to pay if the execution is compelling. Therefore, make sure your solution is fundamentally different and addresses unmet needs to avoid blending into the background.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly research existing BI and data analysis solutions. Understand their limitations, user frustrations, and areas where they fall short. Dive deep into why these solutions haven't fully satisfied the market's needs. Use this insight to identify key differentiators for your product. The discussion summaries indicate a need for integrations with platforms like Notion and Shopify, so consider these as potential features.
  2. Focus on a specific niche or underserved group within the sales data analysis space. Instead of building a general-purpose BI tool, target a particular industry or sales team size with tailored features and insights. This targeted approach will help you stand out and attract a loyal customer base. For example, given the comments in the similar products, you could focus on marketing integrations.
  3. Consider building complementary tools or integrations for existing BI providers. Instead of directly competing, you could offer a specialized AI-powered add-on that enhances their capabilities. This strategy allows you to leverage existing customer bases and distribution channels. Make sure that the tool you build is significantly and quantifiably better and more useful than the status quo.
  4. Given the criticisms of similar products, like slow local LLMs or token limit issues with GPT, focus on optimizing the AI's performance and scalability. Ensure that your tool can handle complex queries and large datasets efficiently. Prioritize speed and accuracy to avoid user frustration.
  5. Explore adjacent problems related to sales data analysis that might be more promising. Consider focusing on data quality, predictive analytics, or personalized sales coaching based on data insights. These areas could offer higher growth potential and less direct competition. It's critical to keep in mind the slow speed of GPT-4 and the limits of GPT-3.5-turbo when handling complex SQL queries.
  6. Prioritize privacy and data security in your tool's design. Given the increasing concerns about data privacy, especially with AI, ensure that your solution complies with relevant regulations and protects user data. Emphasize this commitment to privacy in your marketing and communications. Similar products highlight the appreciation for privacy-centered AI approaches.
  7. Develop a clear and compelling value proposition that resonates with your target audience. Clearly communicate the unique benefits of your AI-powered BI tool and how it solves their specific pain points. Avoid jargon and focus on tangible outcomes, such as increased sales, improved efficiency, or better decision-making. From the user discussions, make sure your solution is user-friendly.
  8. Invest in robust customer support and documentation. Provide users with the resources they need to effectively use your tool and troubleshoot any issues. Respond quickly to user inquiries and provide personalized assistance. The existing solutions have low engagement, so customer service can be an area where your product can be significantly better.

Questions

  1. Given the 'Swamp' category and the number of competitors, what specific and defensible technological advantage will your AI algorithms have over existing solutions to ensure superior insights and user experience?
  2. Considering the strong positive 'buy' signal but low overall engagement, what go-to-market strategy will you employ to not only attract paying customers but also ensure their long-term active usage and satisfaction with the tool?
  3. How will you address the potential for 'AI hallucinations' and ensure the accuracy and reliability of the generated reports and visualizations, especially given the reliance on natural language input which can be ambiguous or incomplete?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 20
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: 15.3%
    • Positive use signal: 18.1%
    • Negative use signal: 2.8%
  • Net buy signal: 1.6%
    • Positive buy signal: 3.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 1.4%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

AI Data Chat by skills.ai - Ask data anything, charts, KPIs and insights in seconds

26 Jun 2023 Data & Analytics Data Visualization Analytics

Conversational Data Analysis for Business Executives. Chat with your data like speaking with your favorite data analyst, get your charts, KPIs and insights in seconds!

The product launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating the team. One user found the chart generator particularly useful for assignments. A suggestion was made to list the app on AI directories and promote wikigpt3.com to enhance visibility.

Avatar
91
3
33.3%
3
91
33.3%
Relevance

Flowtrail AI - Conversational AI Data Analyst

05 Jun 2024 Data & Analytics Artificial Intelligence Analytics

Simplify your data analytics journey With Flowtrail AI. We introduce a conversational analytics platform to generate reports and dashboards by talking to your data.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with one user congratulating the team and inquiring about similarities to Tableau. Another user found the product useful and expressed interest in exploring its features further.

Avatar
37
2
50.0%
2
37
50.0%
Relevance

DataLine – AI data analysis and visualization through chat-Open source

06 Jul 2024 Data & Analytics Artificial Intelligence Data Visualization Analytics

Introducing DataLine: The simplest, fastest, and most secure way to analyze and visualize your data.From devs to sales, everyone can finally focus on the questions and get instant answers.

Users appreciate the launch and the open-source nature of the product. They seek clarity on local LLMs and praise the privacy-centered AI approach, expressing eagerness to experiment with it.

Local LLMs are slow.

Avatar
6
2
50.0%
2
6
50.0%
Relevance

AI Data Analyst

20 Jun 2024 Artificial Intelligence Analytics

Hey HN, Michael and Alexey from Narrative BI here.BackgroundWe've been working on Natural Language Query tools for quite some time. Back in the pre-LLM era, we launched a natural language to SQL startup called FriendlyData. It was later acquired by Service now where we integrated it into the Now Intelligence platform. Then we started Narrative BI with the thesis that business users like marketers don't always know how to ask data questions, so our goal was to build a product where data insights are generated proactively, before users even ask questions.EvolutionThe general dynamics of Generative AI going mainstream created an interesting opportunity. We still believe that the future of BI lies in proactive analytics and easy data integrations. However, with increased AI awareness, we've seen a lot of interest from our users in natural language capabilities, so we decided to take it to the next level.Why don't just use ChatGPT?The problem with ChatGPT and other chat-based LLM tools that they hallucinate a lot. ChatGPT answers look plausible so most of users don't bother to verify if the answers match the actual data. However our research shows that ChatGPT hallucination rate is 47% for more or less complex data sets, such as Google Search Console data, for example. For business data analysis accuracy is the key as wrong answers can lead to misinformed decisions. Another limitation is data integration. AI data analyst comes with pre-built data integrations, so you can easily connect your data sources such as GA4, Google Ads, Google Search Console, FB Ads, Hubspot and Salesforce. More data sources coming soon and we're also doing custom integrations for enterprise.We're here to answer your questions and look forward to your feedback!

Smart focus on marketing integrations, odd customer count discrepancy.

Customer count discrepancy between mobile and desktop.

Avatar
14
1
1
14
Relevance

Typper BI - Create charts and reports with AI easily

12 Mar 2024 Artificial Intelligence Business Intelligence Tech

Introducing Typper BI, a tool that democratizes data for startups. Generate customized answers without experts, ask questions in natural language, and share results through Dashboards. Simplify data-driven decision-making!

The product launch is receiving positive attention. Users are interested in future integrations, particularly with Notion, and desire data visualization features. The initial reception is encouraging, with congratulations extended to the team.

Avatar
112
2
50.0%
2
112
50.0%
Relevance

AI Data Analyst - Easily connect your data, ask questions, and get insights

28 Jun 2024 Data & Analytics Artificial Intelligence Analytics

Narrative BI’s AI Data Analyst transforms how you interact with your data. 1. Connect your data sources effortlessly or upload spreadsheets. 2. Ask questions in natural language. 3. Gain actionable insights.

Users show interest in the product's AI features, data source compatibility, and potential integrations (database, Google Analytics alternatives). One user is a happy, long-term customer particularly praising the AI for conversion analysis. Another uses the product for candidate screening and describes the product as slick. Questions revolve around target audience, specific use cases, and functionality without Google Analytics.

Avatar
75
7
28.6%
14.3%
7
75
28.6%
14.3%
Relevance

I built a tool to talk to Stripe data

05 Jun 2024 Analytics

Hey HN!I am a developer working on a startup doing lots of payment integration stuff with payment providers like Stripe.I built a tool to talk to Stripe data, just so that I can answer questions from our team. I turned that into analytics tool (sort of) to answer questions about MRR, churn, revenue etc. (https://www.dataraccoon.io/).There is a two minute demo video on the page if you want to see how it works, or you can use free trial without needing a credit card.I was wondering if you would use such a tool directly in Slack or prefer receiving messages about your metrics directly?If you could have this chat interface for any of the SaaS tools, which tool would you want?

Avatar
7
7
Relevance

nbi.ai – Generative Business Intelligence

17 Nov 2023 Artificial Intelligence Business Intelligence

Hi HN, Yury and Michael are here to answer your questions.2 years ago, we launched Narrative BI to make data analytics available for everyone. Since then we helped 2,500+ teams get insights from their marketing data.Our backstory is here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33627953We started as a freemium product and built a unique business data set. We used this dataset to launch NBI.AI - a Generative BI platform that can be connected to virtually any structured data source (unlike our previous version designed for specific data connectors).

Users discussed the generative BI platform NBI.AI, with comments ranging from critiques on data-driven decisions to suggestions for improvements like dimensional analysis. Interest in AI's role in understanding data for customer service was noted, alongside concerns about AI hallucinations and data usage for training. Some mistook the site for parody, while others saw potential use cases in ad management. Requests for examples, workflow automation tools, and Shopify integration were made. Comments also touched on data processing, ad tracking, and home-rolled AI solutions like OCR and Tesseract.

Users criticized the Show HN product for its perceived lack of value over rule-based NLG in BI, missing features like dimensional analysis and global event correlation, and fluff corporatespeak. Concerns were raised about AI hallucination, potential misuse of past data, and surveillance to harvest data. The site's design was mocked, and the lack of basic workflow automation tools was noted. Some users questioned the necessity of AI in the product.

Avatar
98
18
-5.6%
0.0%
18
98
5.6%
5.6%
Relevance

AI Data Chat by skills.ai – ask your data anything

26 Jun 2023 Artificial Intelligence

If you're a data analyst or engineer fielding repeated questions from business partners, or a business executive with tons of questions about your data, this tool is designed for you.With AI Data Chat, ask your data questions directly, on your own terms.

Working on similar project, open to chat and share learnings.

Hard to unravel business context from data alone.

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

I made a chat bot for spreadsheets

22 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence

OP here. I made this app for quick data analysis on your spreadsheets and Google Sheets. You can ask questions like: 1. Run linear regression to predict Y variable given X inputs 2. Tell me the top 5 movies that had the highest ratio of revenue to votesYou can also do Data Analysis in BI mode by doing specific tasks such as filtering, cleaning, merging, and visualizing. You can even write SQL code that runs directly on the spreadsheets.Each step in BI mode can use results from a previous step, so you can have a repeatable workflow for your data analysis. You can then generate a report that you can share.This uses the Open AI API. We can install a custom LLM backend for you, and install this app on your servers if you have security concerns.Looking forward to having people try it out :)

App for quick data analysis on spreadsheets and Google Sheets.

Avatar
1
1
100.0%
1
1
100.0%
Top