Your are here

Creating a web app to record trading history places you in a crowded space where many have tried and struggled. The 'Swamp' category suggests existing solutions are mediocre and haven't captured significant user love. With 6 similar products already out there, competition is a factor. Given the generally low engagement (indicated by the average of 0 comments on existing products) the metrics suggest people aren't actively seeking or particularly excited about existing solutions. The lack of use/buy signals means there isn't strong feedback either way, pointing to indifference. This means you should temper your expectations.

Recommendations

1. Thoroughly investigate why current trading history recording apps haven't resonated with traders. Look beyond surface-level features and try to understand the deeper pain points traders experience. Use forums, communities, and direct interviews to gather detailed feedback.
2. If you decide to proceed, identify a niche segment of traders with very specific needs that aren't being met. For example, focus on options traders, crypto day traders, or traders using specific platforms. A highly targeted approach is essential to differentiate yourself.
3. Consider building tools or integrations that enhance existing trading platforms rather than creating a standalone application. Partnering with established brokers or platforms could provide a faster route to market and access to a user base.
4. Explore adjacent problems in the trading workflow that could be more promising. Perhaps focus on risk management tools, automated trade analysis, or educational resources tailored to specific trading styles. Addressing a less saturated problem may yield better results.
5. Given the challenges in this space, consider whether your time and resources might be better spent on a different opportunity. Carefully evaluate your passion for this specific problem and whether you're willing to commit to a potentially long and difficult journey.
6. Since TradesBud had a comment deleted, investigate what kind of feedback, positive or negative, led to this. This deleted comment could provide valuable insight into what traders dislike or find problematic in similar apps.

Questions

1. What unique insights do you have about the needs of traders that existing solutions are missing? How can your app offer a fundamentally different experience that traders will genuinely love?
2. How will you acquire your first 100 paying users, and what specific marketing channels will you use to reach your target audience? (Remember that with high competition, standing out is key.)
3. What is your plan to achieve significant user engagement given that similar products have received very little engagement from users? How can you encourage active participation and make the app a sticky part of traders' daily workflow?