Should I Build It Should I Build It
19 Apr 2025
Finance

Finance manager and budget planner where users can import transactions ...

...and categorise them. Bank connection in Australia only

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

You're entering a highly competitive market with your finance manager and budget planner idea. Nineteen similar products already exist, indicating substantial competition but also validated demand. The average engagement for these similar products is moderate, suggesting that users are actively looking for solutions in this space. While it's encouraging that similar products have seen some positive user feedback, standing out will be key. Your focus on the Australian market and bank connections provides a niche, but you'll need a compelling differentiator to capture users' attention in this crowded field. To succeed, you should focus on specific pain points not adequately addressed by existing solutions and tailor your marketing efforts accordingly.

Recommendations

  1. Conduct thorough competitive analysis, paying close attention to the criticisms leveled against existing apps. Users of similar products often cite limited bank integrations, lack of specific features, and concerns about privacy. Focus on excelling in these areas to create a truly superior product. Prioritize which bank integrations are most important for your initial Australian user base.
  2. Define your unique selling proposition (USP) clearly. What makes your app better than the existing options? Is it a specific feature, a superior user experience, or a focus on a particular niche within personal finance? Based on competitor criticisms, consider features like broader bank integration, enhanced privacy features, or AI-driven insights.
  3. Since you're focusing on Australia initially, deeply understand the nuances of the Australian banking system and financial regulations. This localized expertise can be a strong differentiator and attract users seeking tailored solutions. Be sure to address the specific challenges and opportunities in the Australian market.
  4. Develop a robust content marketing strategy to educate potential users about your app's benefits and demonstrate your expertise in personal finance. Create blog posts, guides, and videos that address common financial challenges and highlight how your app can help solve them. Actively engage with online communities and forums to build brand awareness and establish yourself as a trusted resource.
  5. Implement a freemium or subscription-based business model to generate revenue. Consider offering a free tier with basic features and a premium tier with advanced functionality and personalized support. Based on the feedback from similar products, ensure your pricing is competitive and offers compelling value for users.
  6. Prioritize user feedback and iterate quickly. Engage with your early adopters to understand their needs and pain points, and use their feedback to improve your app's features and functionality. Implement a system for collecting and tracking user feedback, and be responsive to their concerns.
  7. Carefully plan your go-to-market strategy. Given the competitive landscape, consider focusing on organic growth through content marketing, social media, and search engine optimization. Explore partnerships with financial institutions and influencers to reach a wider audience.
  8. As several similar products received criticism around difficult initial setup, and especially around unclear instructions how to connect bank accounts, invest heavily in UX and onboarding. This will give you a major advantage versus competitors.

Questions

  1. Given the crowded market, what specific, unmet need will your app address for Australian users that current solutions don't?
  2. How will you leverage your focus on the Australian market to create a competitive advantage and build a loyal user base?
  3. What is your plan to rapidly iterate and improve the product based on user feedback, and how will you balance adding new features with maintaining a user-friendly experience?

Your are here

You're entering a highly competitive market with your finance manager and budget planner idea. Nineteen similar products already exist, indicating substantial competition but also validated demand. The average engagement for these similar products is moderate, suggesting that users are actively looking for solutions in this space. While it's encouraging that similar products have seen some positive user feedback, standing out will be key. Your focus on the Australian market and bank connections provides a niche, but you'll need a compelling differentiator to capture users' attention in this crowded field. To succeed, you should focus on specific pain points not adequately addressed by existing solutions and tailor your marketing efforts accordingly.

Recommendations

  1. Conduct thorough competitive analysis, paying close attention to the criticisms leveled against existing apps. Users of similar products often cite limited bank integrations, lack of specific features, and concerns about privacy. Focus on excelling in these areas to create a truly superior product. Prioritize which bank integrations are most important for your initial Australian user base.
  2. Define your unique selling proposition (USP) clearly. What makes your app better than the existing options? Is it a specific feature, a superior user experience, or a focus on a particular niche within personal finance? Based on competitor criticisms, consider features like broader bank integration, enhanced privacy features, or AI-driven insights.
  3. Since you're focusing on Australia initially, deeply understand the nuances of the Australian banking system and financial regulations. This localized expertise can be a strong differentiator and attract users seeking tailored solutions. Be sure to address the specific challenges and opportunities in the Australian market.
  4. Develop a robust content marketing strategy to educate potential users about your app's benefits and demonstrate your expertise in personal finance. Create blog posts, guides, and videos that address common financial challenges and highlight how your app can help solve them. Actively engage with online communities and forums to build brand awareness and establish yourself as a trusted resource.
  5. Implement a freemium or subscription-based business model to generate revenue. Consider offering a free tier with basic features and a premium tier with advanced functionality and personalized support. Based on the feedback from similar products, ensure your pricing is competitive and offers compelling value for users.
  6. Prioritize user feedback and iterate quickly. Engage with your early adopters to understand their needs and pain points, and use their feedback to improve your app's features and functionality. Implement a system for collecting and tracking user feedback, and be responsive to their concerns.
  7. Carefully plan your go-to-market strategy. Given the competitive landscape, consider focusing on organic growth through content marketing, social media, and search engine optimization. Explore partnerships with financial institutions and influencers to reach a wider audience.
  8. As several similar products received criticism around difficult initial setup, and especially around unclear instructions how to connect bank accounts, invest heavily in UX and onboarding. This will give you a major advantage versus competitors.

Questions

  1. Given the crowded market, what specific, unmet need will your app address for Australian users that current solutions don't?
  2. How will you leverage your focus on the Australian market to create a competitive advantage and build a loyal user base?
  3. What is your plan to rapidly iterate and improve the product based on user feedback, and how will you balance adding new features with maintaining a user-friendly experience?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 19
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 7
  • Net use signal: 19.1%
    • Positive use signal: 20.8%
    • Negative use signal: 1.7%
  • Net buy signal: 0.2%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.9%
    • Negative buy signal: 1.7%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

FinWise – The modern way to manage your personal finances

30 Oct 2023 Personal Finance Fintech

Hi everyone, I'd like to share FinWise (https://finwiseapp.io) with you, which my wife and I have been building over the last few months.FinWise is an all-in-one personal finance management tool, including budgeting, net-worth tracking, financial planning & forecasting and a couple of other things which we're still busy working on like couples/family budgeting and being able to set and track goals.It's designed to make managing all your personal finances as simple, easy and painless as possible, and we've put a lot of effort into making the website as simple and intuitive, whilst still being powerful and offering a comprehensive set of personal finance tools.A non-exhaustive list of things you can do with FinWise:- Connect your bank & investments accounts with Plaid & Yodlee (Or manual imports). - Currently US, CA and ZA. EU, NZ, AU and others coming soon!- Track and visualize your net-worth.- Budget and save money.- AI transaction categorization (You almost never have to manually categorize your transactions).- Transaction splitting, tags, notes and attachments.- Import transactions with CSV files from Mint/Empower etc.- Export account, transaction and insights data to CSV.- Plan, project and forecast your future finances (In beta).- Spending, saving and net-worth insights and analytics.- Multi-currency support.- Goals and goal-tracking (Coming soon).- Developer API access (Coming soon).- iOS/Android app (Coming soon).- Privacy-focused. No ads, selling data or anything like that.- Just about SOC2 and ISO compliant (No certificates yet, but I've done a few SOC2 certifications in the past.)We made FinWise because we were not able to find a personal finance tool out there which offered all the features we wanted, and which was simple, intuitive and easy to use. There are lots of personal finances apps around, but we felt most were either too basic, over-complicated or too expensive, or limiting in some way.We're now on a mission to build the best personal finance app out there, and to help as many people as possible to better save, grow and manage their money.If you'd like to learn more and try it out, head over to our website: https://finwiseapp.ioIf you have any feedback or questions, please let me know :)Find us on X/Twitter: Me: https://twitter.com/jasrusable Nicol: https://twitter.com/NicolNvojacek FinWise: https://twitter.com/FinwiseappPS: There are some interesting technical aspects of the project that we are particularly proud of which I am planning to do more in-depth posts on soon, namely:- How we implemented our AI transaction categorization system.- How we built the entire website to use optimistic loading, so no loading states.- How we kept the codebases extremely simple and intuitive, allowing us to move quickly.- Going open source once we hit critical mass.

Avatar
9
9
Relevance

Fynyky–Zero-Based Budgeting and Personal Finance Management

22 Jul 2024 Fintech

We are launching our MVP with our zero based budgeting feature, as it defines the structure of the whole app.You can also easily import your transactions with secure bank syncing. We use Plaid to fetch only your latest transaction data.Rest assured, we don't save any sensitive information in our database.We only save the bank account name, which you can edit, or you can simply revoke the connection to Plaid, which only has access to receive the latest transactions.We're working on CSV imports too, coming soon!While we're kicking off with budgeting, we've got big plans ahead. Think leverage , tax filing , and smart projections for you high-earners out there. But first things first – let's get that budget sorted!Our mobile app is in the works, and we will release beta access to early adopters soon.

The product uses a tech stack that includes Next.js, Firebase, Recharts, Tailwind, React, and Redux. Users suggest comparing its features with YNAB and highlighting its advantages. While future offerings are promising, there is currently no compelling reason to choose this product over others.

The main criticisms are that the product's only mentioned advantage is being cheaper, and there is no compelling reason to choose it over YNAB. Additionally, there is a plan to move to Shadcn charts soon, which may indicate current limitations in charting capabilities.

Avatar
1
3
-33.3%
-33.3%
3
1
Relevance

Bank integrations by Rows - 1,000 banks in your spreadsheet

26 Nov 2024 Fintech Productivity Banking

Connect +12,000 accounts from the US/EU banks. Import the list of transactions and to Rows automatically. Use it to categorize and analyze your expenses, get an overview of your balance over time or integrate it directly to a finance tracker in Notion.

Users expressed excitement about the new building possibilities and congratulated the launch of Finance Trackers' new feature, which was described as impressive and a step forward.

Avatar
33
3
33.3%
3
33
33.3%
Relevance

I built an inbox-zero expense tracker with CRDTs and SQLite in browser

30 Nov 2023 Fintech

Hi everyone! I’ve been working on a small personal finance tool called Tender for the better part of a year.I got tired of doing expenses by hand - going through several accounts to figure out refunds, subscription cancellations, getting paid back via venmo, etc. I’d get to the point where I’d have to go through months of transactions at a time if I got lazy and fell behind.The workflow in Tender is centered around getting to inbox-zero. Transactions leave the inbox when they’re categorized and there’s a basic rules engine for automation. You can also do things like add notes, set reminders, and link refunds to their original payment. If you’re a splitwise.com user, there’s an integration to send shared expenses to a group to be split.On the technology side, the data is stored using Automerge (crdt) and indexed using sqlite (wasm) - all running in the browser so the UI stays pretty snappy. For persistence, the data is also backed up server-side using Automerge’s sync protocol. Like everyone else in this space, I’m using plaid to sync in account data.Although Tender isn’t multiplayer, the crdt still gives a lot of out of the box: syncing, file format, change tracking... Since everything is running in the browser, I’ve also hacked up a quick demo environment at https://demo.tender.run that you can play with!I’ve put in a decent amount of effort into the project at this point, and would appreciate any feedback on the product, pricing, feature requests, etc! If you want to give it an extended try, there’s a coupon code (HN2023) that basically prices Tender at-cost for me.

Users have mixed experiences with the product. Some successfully linked their accounts after initial errors, while others faced issues with authorization flows, particularly with Splitwise. One user mentioned using deep links for Venmo payments but noted the lack of API tracking. Another user suggested integrating ElectricSQL. Overall, the project is seen as promising.

Users criticized the product for lacking Venmo API for payment tracking, experiencing issues with the authorization flow being cancelled, and encountering errors in the Splitwise authorization flow.

Avatar
8
5
20.0%
5
8
20.0%
Relevance

Finance Budget Expense Tracker - Track expenses, budget, manage bills, and save money

07 Jun 2024 Android Finance Money

Budget Expense Tracker - money is your ultimate finance manager, built to help you save money, plan for the future, and see all your finances in one place. Easily track expenses, manage budgets, and stay on top of bills.

Users are interested in how the Finance Budget Expenses Tracker differentiates from similar apps and budget trackers. The app is generally considered handy for expense, budget, and bill management, with a good UI/UX. Suggestions include adding analytics and insights for finances, features to solve user problems, and the possibility for multiple family members to record expenses together. Congratulations were offered on the launch.

The feedback suggests incorporating more features to better address existing user problems.

Avatar
123
8
25.0%
8
123
25.0%
Relevance

Pocket - Manage all your finances in one place

03 Feb 2024 Android Fintech Finance

Pocket tracks all your finances in one place, from tracking spending, budgeting, managing loans & checking your bank balances all in one with 100% accuracy and no privacy concerns. (i.e Truebill for India) To access the demo mode use invite code - QWERTYUIOP

Pocket's Product Hunt launch garnered congratulations and excitement, particularly for its potential in personal finance management in India. Users praised the design but requested features like a desktop version, mobile access, and more functionalities. Questions arose regarding differentiation from competitors, expense tracking methods, Indian bank integration, privacy, and security. Several users needed invite codes to try the app, and some reported issues with availability on certain devices. There were also offers to test the product and hopes for its continued improvement.

Users criticize the lack of an Android app link on the website, its unavailability on certain devices, and trustworthiness concerns regarding expense tracking. The absence of a desktop version and limited mobile access are also drawbacks. Many users also dislike that the app requires an invite code with unclear instructions on how to get one. Some users are comparing the experience to previous solutions with mixed reviews.

Avatar
185
23
17.4%
-4.3%
23
185
21.7%
Relevance

Budgety - Budgeting, expense tracking, money manager

09 Jul 2024 Personal Finance Android Money

Budgety is a budgeting, expense tracking and money management app. Track your income, expenses, savings and progress towards your financial goals. Analyze your spending patterns, goals, identify areas for improvement and make informed decisions

Users appreciate the shared budget feature for financial tracking and the fast onboarding process. The personalized transaction notes are useful for expense tracking, and the app provides valuable spending insights to identify potential areas for cutbacks.

Avatar
7
4
75.0%
4
7
75.0%
Relevance

Financial - Manager & Tracker - A better way to manage your income, expenses & debts.

30 Jul 2024 iOS Finance Productivity

Discover Financial, the all-in-one app for managing your finances! With Financial, you can manage all your accounts in one place, set up recurring payments with SmartPay, organize contracts and wish lists, and keep track of your liabilities.

App launch congratulations; feedback given, but difficult to provide initially.

Hard to find on ProductHunt; feedback submission not intuitive.

Avatar
63
1
100.0%
1
63
100.0%
Relevance

Finoyou - Budget & expense manager

09 Apr 2023 Personal Finance Fintech Finance

Finoyou is a comprehensive finance management app designed to help individuals take control of their finances. With its user-friendly interface and powerful features, users can easily track their expenses, create budgets, and plan for the future.

Users have mixed feedback. One user noted the app requires a Google account, lacks currency options, and restricts budget features to the Pro version. Another user gave positive feedback and expressed interest in connecting on Twitter.

Users criticized the Product Hunt launch for requiring a Google account for access. Concerns were raised about the budget requiring a Pro subscription. The lack of currency options was also noted as a significant drawback.

Avatar
74
2
-50.0%
2
74
Relevance

Financial Hub: Advanced Finance Tracker - Manage and track your personal & business finances easily

23 Mar 2024 Finance Business Notion

Looking to track your personal and business finances effortlessly? Explore Financial Hub: the ultimate Notion template for unified financial management.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with numerous users congratulating Steffy and praising the comprehensive Financial Hub template. Many highlighted its usefulness for managing personal and business finances effectively, with specific mention of its extensive features and functionalities. Users found the template to be well-designed, user-friendly, and valuable. Some users are excited to try the product and expressed intentions to leave reviews, while others expressed gratitude for its creation and wished Steffy good luck. The launch also reached 150 upvotes.

Avatar
265
38
13.2%
2.6%
38
265
13.2%
2.6%
Relevance

Budgets Planner - Plan smarter, spend better, and live happier

26 Mar 2024 Finance Productivity Freelance

Budgets Planner is a user-friendly SaaS tool offering budget templates and financial insights to help you manage income, track expenses, and achieve financial goals.

The Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, with users congratulating El Mehdi and praising the tool as a much-needed planner. Users found the idea cool and well-built, highlighting its potential to improve productivity and effectively manage finances.

Avatar
67
5
5
67
Relevance

Fina - Your AI financial advisor

26 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence Personal Finance Fintech

Fina's simple interface allows you to connect accounts, categorize transactions, and track custom metrics. Want to know specific things like: "How much money have I actually spent at Starbucks this year??" Just ask! Flexible financial management has arrived🧙

Fina's Product Hunt launch garnered considerable positive feedback. Users praise its intuitive design, ease of onboarding, and AI-driven approach to personal finance management, highlighting its potential to improve financial clarity, track expenses, and identify overspending. The game-changing linked block philosophy, similar to Notion, resonated with many. Security and privacy, particularly the read-only access, were appreciated. Several users requested broader bank integration, specifically for UK, Irish, and European banks, and amount-based rules. Many congratulated the makers on the launch and expressed excitement for Fina's future growth and potential applications for families and small businesses. Others highlighted its usefulness as a simple personal assistant.

The primary criticism revolves around limited geographic support, specifically the lack of integration with European banks, including those in the UK, Ireland (Revolut, AIB), and Portugal. Users also inquired about location-based purchase filtering and the app's role in improving financial literacy. Feature requests include access to shared finances with privacy controls. Some users expressed interest in the product roadmap and future development plans, indicating a desire for broader accessibility and enhanced features.

Avatar
321
51
43.1%
5.9%
51
321
45.1%
5.9%
Top