Should I Build It Should I Build It
18 Jun 2025
Database

A platform where users can input data into a simple database, similar ...

...to Excel or Google Sheets

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

Your idea for a simple database platform, similar to Excel or Google Sheets, falls into the "Freemium" category. This is a space where users appreciate the utility of such tools but often hesitate to pay. Given the high number of similar products (n_matches = 14), the competition is significant. However, there is high engagement (avg n_comments = 12) which means people are interested in this idea space. Your challenge lies in identifying the specific user segments that derive the most value from the free version, then crafting compelling premium features that justify a paid upgrade. Since users are comfortable using free spreadsheet solutions already, you need to offer a substantial value proposition beyond basic functionality to encourage them to switch and pay.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by deeply researching existing free spreadsheet/database solutions like Google Sheets, Airtable, and others. Identify their limitations and pain points that your platform can address more effectively. Look at the discussions and criticisms from similar products like Teable and Visual DB to understand what users are missing and where competitors are falling short. For instance, many users want on-premise/self-hosted options and better security features.
  2. Focus on a specific niche or user segment (e.g., small businesses, educators, researchers) to tailor your platform's features and marketing efforts. This specialization will help you differentiate from generic spreadsheet alternatives. It will be easier to cater to a smaller group of people and you can increase user satisfaction.
  3. Implement a robust analytics system to track how users are interacting with the free version of your platform. Identify which features are most popular and which users are deriving the most value. This data will inform your strategy for developing premium features and targeting potential paying customers. Understand what makes them tick!
  4. Develop premium features that offer significant advantages over the free version, such as advanced automation, integrations with other business tools, enhanced security, or dedicated support. Refer to the comments on products like Openform and SheetDB to understand specific user needs, such as API authentication handling or the ability to turn spreadsheets into mobile-friendly forms. Think about what people are willing to actually pay for.
  5. Explore team-based pricing models, as organizations are often more willing to pay for solutions that enhance collaboration and productivity across multiple users. Offer features like role-based access control, shared workspaces, and team-specific reporting to appeal to this market. Users may want to use your product in a collaborative setting.
  6. Consider offering personalized consulting or onboarding services to help users get the most out of your platform. This can be a valuable upsell, especially for users who are not technically savvy or who need help migrating from existing solutions. Make your product easy to use for non-technical users.
  7. Implement A/B testing on your pricing page and experiment with different price points, feature bundles, and promotional offers. Use the data you collect to optimize your pricing strategy and maximize conversion rates. This ensures that you find a pricing model that works for your business.
  8. Actively engage with your user community and solicit feedback on your platform's features and roadmap. Address user concerns promptly and demonstrate that you are committed to continuously improving the product. This helps foster a sense of loyalty and can lead to valuable word-of-mouth marketing. Communicate and gather feedback often.

Questions

  1. Given the competitive landscape, what unique value proposition will your platform offer that differentiates it from established players like Google Sheets and Excel, as well as other emerging solutions in the freemium database space?
  2. Considering that users in this category are often resistant to paying, what specific user behaviors or use cases will you target to identify and convert into paying customers, and what premium features will be most compelling to them?
  3. How will you balance the value provided in the free version with the features reserved for paying customers to ensure that the free tier is attractive enough to drive adoption while still incentivizing users to upgrade to a paid plan?

Your are here

Your idea for a simple database platform, similar to Excel or Google Sheets, falls into the "Freemium" category. This is a space where users appreciate the utility of such tools but often hesitate to pay. Given the high number of similar products (n_matches = 14), the competition is significant. However, there is high engagement (avg n_comments = 12) which means people are interested in this idea space. Your challenge lies in identifying the specific user segments that derive the most value from the free version, then crafting compelling premium features that justify a paid upgrade. Since users are comfortable using free spreadsheet solutions already, you need to offer a substantial value proposition beyond basic functionality to encourage them to switch and pay.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by deeply researching existing free spreadsheet/database solutions like Google Sheets, Airtable, and others. Identify their limitations and pain points that your platform can address more effectively. Look at the discussions and criticisms from similar products like Teable and Visual DB to understand what users are missing and where competitors are falling short. For instance, many users want on-premise/self-hosted options and better security features.
  2. Focus on a specific niche or user segment (e.g., small businesses, educators, researchers) to tailor your platform's features and marketing efforts. This specialization will help you differentiate from generic spreadsheet alternatives. It will be easier to cater to a smaller group of people and you can increase user satisfaction.
  3. Implement a robust analytics system to track how users are interacting with the free version of your platform. Identify which features are most popular and which users are deriving the most value. This data will inform your strategy for developing premium features and targeting potential paying customers. Understand what makes them tick!
  4. Develop premium features that offer significant advantages over the free version, such as advanced automation, integrations with other business tools, enhanced security, or dedicated support. Refer to the comments on products like Openform and SheetDB to understand specific user needs, such as API authentication handling or the ability to turn spreadsheets into mobile-friendly forms. Think about what people are willing to actually pay for.
  5. Explore team-based pricing models, as organizations are often more willing to pay for solutions that enhance collaboration and productivity across multiple users. Offer features like role-based access control, shared workspaces, and team-specific reporting to appeal to this market. Users may want to use your product in a collaborative setting.
  6. Consider offering personalized consulting or onboarding services to help users get the most out of your platform. This can be a valuable upsell, especially for users who are not technically savvy or who need help migrating from existing solutions. Make your product easy to use for non-technical users.
  7. Implement A/B testing on your pricing page and experiment with different price points, feature bundles, and promotional offers. Use the data you collect to optimize your pricing strategy and maximize conversion rates. This ensures that you find a pricing model that works for your business.
  8. Actively engage with your user community and solicit feedback on your platform's features and roadmap. Address user concerns promptly and demonstrate that you are committed to continuously improving the product. This helps foster a sense of loyalty and can lead to valuable word-of-mouth marketing. Communicate and gather feedback often.

Questions

  1. Given the competitive landscape, what unique value proposition will your platform offer that differentiates it from established players like Google Sheets and Excel, as well as other emerging solutions in the freemium database space?
  2. Considering that users in this category are often resistant to paying, what specific user behaviors or use cases will you target to identify and convert into paying customers, and what premium features will be most compelling to them?
  3. How will you balance the value provided in the free version with the features reserved for paying customers to ensure that the free tier is attractive enough to drive adoption while still incentivizing users to upgrade to a paid plan?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 14
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 12
  • Net use signal: 12.9%
    • Positive use signal: 16.6%
    • Negative use signal: 3.8%
  • Net buy signal: -1.8%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.9%
    • Negative buy signal: 2.7%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

New Spreadsheet, combine database and excel

27 Nov 2024 Productivity Spreadsheets

I come up with idea - a tool for non-developers and small businesses to manage data easily. Current tools like Airtable or Google Spreadsheet are great but struggle with scalability and handling larger datasets. The idea: Combine the simplicity of spreadsheets with the power of modern databases, capable of managing millions of records. It’s targeted at users with limited resources who need a scalable, easy-to-use solution. Would love your feedback.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Table Apps - Make apps with data table, simply

10 Feb 2023 Web App No-Code

Table apps allow you to organize data in a grid format and create data-driven apps without any coding required.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users congratulated the team and expressed excitement about the product's potential to save time and simplify app development, particularly for API creation and management using a no-code approach. Several users praised the concept, execution, and user-friendliness, with some looking forward to additional micro apps and wishing the team good luck. The landing page design was also noted as well-explained.

Avatar
148
9
44.4%
9
148
44.4%
Relevance

Teable – Open-Source No-Code Database Fusion of Postgres and Airtable

11 Mar 2024 Analytics Spreadsheets

FeaturesSpreadsheet-like interface All you want is here • Cell Editing: Directly click and edit content within cells.• Formula Support: Input mathematical and logical formulas to auto-calculate values.• Data Sorting and Filtering: Sort data based on a column or multiple columns; use filters to view specific rows of data.• Aggregation Function: Automatically summarize statistics for each column, providing instant calculations like sum, average, count, max, and min for streamlined data analysis.• Data Formatting: formatting numbers, dates, etc.• Grouping: Organize rows into collapsible groups based on column values for easier data analysis and navigation.• Import/Export Capabilities: Import and export data from other formats, e.g., .csv, .xlsx.Multiple ViewsVisualize and interact with data in various ways best suited for their specific tasks.• Grid View: The default view of the table, which displays data in a spreadsheet-like format.• Form View: Input data in a form format, which is useful for collecting data.• Coming soon: Kanban View, Calendar View, Gallery View, Gantt View, Timeline View.Super Fast Amazing response speed and data capacity• Millions of data are easily processed, and there is no pressure to filter and sort• Automatic database indexing for maximum speed• Supports batch data operations at one timeFull-featured SQL Support Seamless integration with the software you are familiar with• BI tools like Metabase PowerBi...• No-code tools like Appsmith...• Direct retrieve data with native SQLPrivacy-First• Bring your own database (coming soon)Real-time collaboration • No need to refresh the page, data is updated in real-time

Users are intrigued by the product's launch, comparing it to no-code tools like NocoDB, Baserow, and Airtable, but express concerns about database issues for non-technical users, licensing, and differentiation from competitors. There's interest in user-friendly data modeling, SQL connections, and open-source features. Criticism arises over perceived plagiarism of web assets and a need for unique branding. Some praise the product's potential and request comparisons, while others report bugs like scrolling issues on certain browsers. Questions about pricing, roadmap, and no-code functionalities for external apps are also raised.

Users criticized the product for database issues, unclear differentiation from competitors, and concerns about feature limitations behind subscriptions. Criticisms include non-technical user difficulties, AGPL license concerns, lack of open source, and copied content from competitors. Ease of use, UI customization, and schema change processes were questioned. Technical issues like demo downtime, vertical scrolling problems, and lack of support for certain platforms were noted. The product was also compared unfavorably to Airtable and MS Access in terms of functionality.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=ccorcos

I totally agree. I’m very interested in some kind of data modeling representation that’s a lot more user-friendly.The core problem as I understand it is the difference between references and values.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=okcdz

I've deployed this on my server, and I have to say, it's incredible. I've been looking for an open-source alternative to Airtable for a long time, but none of them met my requirements.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=christoff12

I've been waiting on Xata to allow a direct SQL connection to the underlying db to take advantage of the Postgres connector in Plasmic for rapid product development -- that Teable allows this is a killer feature for me.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=bieberChen

Sure we will, this week.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=sigmarule

Are you serious, man? You edited your comment, twice. We both know your comment did not include "(cofounder)", but did include unnecessary jabs at your your competitor ("this makes me lose all faith in our credibility.") when you posted it. I've used Budibase and think it's a great product, and couldn't have anything but respect for the people behind it. You're above this.EDIT - Apologies, you did indeed include "(cofounder)" in your original post, I just missed it (based on bing's cached page.) Regardless, this is not the way to deal with competitors, and frankly your product speaks for itself. And perhaps obscene amounts of torrenting in my teenage years has permanently skewed my moral compass for these things, but I really don't care about table cell background svg theft.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=bieberChen

We have a plan to do it, we have a lot of user feedback, and we find it very useful

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=mistermann

That's not quite as functional as MS Access could do (though, maybe it's possible but you don't have a demo), but it is quite nice.This whole app looks extremely promising, for my purposes it looks very close to something that I could build a huge database on top of, I am going to keep it in mind and try to get some time to play with it, I hope you guys keep moving it forward because it is slick!With adequate features, I could see this being something that consultants could use to go in and write impressive custom database software in a month or so for companies like used to be so common, I think it would be a great way for junior people to get into the IT business, with a few caveats of course.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=zem

can I use this as a collaborative grid component in my own project? that is, I don't want any of the no-code, spreadsheet etc features, I just want part of the frontend of my own app to be a grid that multiple people can edit, persisted in a database table that my own phoenix/rails/whatever process also has access to.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=zem

thanks! i've been hoping for this functionality for years but none of the airtable replacements so far has provided it.

Avatar
279
71
4.2%
-4.2%
71
279
9.9%
Relevance

Turn spreadsheets into CRUD mobile apps(PWA) without coding

08 May 2024 Spreadsheets

Hello HN, I'm Peter, the founder of AppAlloy. Over the last year, we've been working on a tool that converts spreadsheets (Google Sheets, Excel, csv) into fully functional CRUD mobile apps, without the need for coding skills.Our goal is to make mobile app development accessible to anyone who uses spreadsheets for business operations.Our platform uses OpenAI to analyze and infer the structure of spreadsheet data, automatically generating a mobile-friendly app interface. This allows non-technical users to easily manage data directly from their mobile devices with an interface optimized for usability on small screens.Here’s what AppAlloy offers:1. AI-Driven interface creation: Automatically generates a user interface suitable for mobile devices based on the contents of your spreadsheet. 2. Customization with Power Fx: Users can integrate Microsoft Power Fx to add custom logic and calculations that appear directly in the app. 3. Real-time sync: Changes made in the mobile app are synchronized in real-time with the original spreadsheet, maintaining a single source of truth without disrupting existing workflows.We believe that simplifying the app creation process from spreadsheets can significantly empower businesses, especially those relying heavily on mobile workforces.Check out these demos: App creation in 30 seconds https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8sODApB5yCoIn-depth customization https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_h6gG2LCY2QAppAlloy is still in the early stages, and we're keen to gather feedback to improve further. We're particularly interested in your thoughts on usability, AI integration, and any other features you think we could add or improve.Thanks for checking this out, and I look forward to your feedback!

Users praised Peter and his introduction. They commended the great work and requested information about AppAlloy's initial purpose.

The product lacks a clear explanation of AppAlloy's initial purpose, leaving users confused about its intended use and benefits.

Avatar
3
2
2
3
Relevance

Visual DB – Web front end for your database

10 Sep 2024 Data & Analytics Database

If you have a cloud-hosted database, read on: Visual DB was designed for you.Visual DB is the fastest way to create data entry forms for your database: Starting with an Excel spreadsheet, you can import your data into the database and create a great-looking form in under 10 minutes. Watch this video: https://youtu.be/6rVD5rmrjN8Visual DB is a comprehensive SaaS frontend for your database. In addition to data entry forms, Visual DB also has a spreadsheet-like interface for inserting and updating data in your database. You can also build interactive reports using Visual DB. Finally, although not intended as a replacement for your database's admin tool, Visual DB can browse schema, create tables, set up relationships, and import and export data.Visual DB began as a drag-and-drop form builder for databases. Forms created with Visual DB are practically indistinguishable from those hand-coded using React. You can add client-side validation, set available values (displayed in dropdowns), define default values, and even add logic to dynamically hide or disable fields—all without writing a single line of code! With Visual DB Forms, you’ll never have to write another CRUD app again.If you have been using Excel to manage data and running into its limits because the volume of data has grown, Visual DB Sheets may be of interest to you. With its spreadsheet-like interface, Visual DB Sheets allows users to interact with data as they would in Excel, while securely storing that data in a robust relational database. Spreadsheet-database hybrids have been around for a while now, but we believe we have one of the best implementations, with features such as advanced grouping, support for foreign keys and lookup tables, query parameters, full-text as-you-type filtering, and so on.The newest feature of Visual DB is interactive reporting. Traditional reporting tools offer limited interactivity. For example, while most reporting tools support time series charts, they do not allow users to zoom or pan along the time axis. In contrast, Visual DB supports this capability thanks to its innovative approach: it downloads the dataset to the client and processes and visualizes data directly in the browser. This allows it to handle user interactions without a server round trip. Visual DB has excellent support for query parameters, which allows you to bring only the subset of data that's of interest (up to 100K rows), to the client.Visual DB supports PostgreSQL (including Neon), MySQL, SQL Server and Oracle. Give it a whirl, and we look forward to getting your feedback: https://visualdb.com

Users have expressed a strong desire for on-premise or self-hosted versions for enhanced security and to avoid SAAS-hostage situations. Criticisms include the lack of granular roles, forms, relational data, user management, and dashboards. The AGPL-3.0 license is seen as restrictive, and there are feature requests pending. The free plan is considered limited, and the paid plan pricing deceptive. Users also suggest adding a privacy section, improving database credential security, and providing clearer information on database connections and the product's purpose.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=albert_e

Thanks this seems very useful. Bookmarked.We are building a couple of small internal applications using React and deployed on AWS.For enabling users with UI for managing the master data tables we want to use a ready to use component - i guess somewhat like nocodb.Could you by any chance point to some examples of how one might integrate this solution into another app within its branding and navigation.If there ate other similar tools that might also allow power users to define the schema of new tables and constraints / pk-fk references on them etc using a similar web UI -- that would be great too.Thanks

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=leansensei

I second this, NocoDB is great!

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=Multrex

Yes please. A self hosted version would be great for companies that have strict security rules about data.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=lucidphreak

I run a online form for public consumption where I catalog old school wardialers and other phreaking related programs that were written (mainly) for 8 and 16 bit computers (atari 800, c64/128, Amiga, etc).. Currently I'm using jqwidgets to grab data from an XML file. This could make both the cataloging as well as the display of the data much easier. Will be looking into this soon. I'm curious though if there is a way to skin the output or am I restricted to the aesthetics that are built into the app?If anyone is interested in the site I mentioned feel free to ask..

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=juan48

Was looking for a nicer web ui for my small self hosted db for my portfolio site. Might just give this a shot, nice!

Avatar
171
42
7.1%
-2.4%
42
171
14.3%
2.4%
Relevance

Interact with your PostgreSQL DB like a spreadsheet

06 Dec 2023 GitHub Developer Tools

A little program I wrote because I'm tired of writing the same Django admin code, maintaining complex SQL queries and JavaScript transformers in Retool, and working around the lack of writability in BI tools.It's an early alpha, so I wouldn't use it in production, but I would appreciate any feedback on it and whether you find it useful.

Users are impressed by the interactivity of htmx and express interest in learning more about it. One user suggests trying the Plato app for an Airtable-like user interface, noting that while Equals is a read-only spreadsheet, Plato functions as a visual database with read-write capabilities.

Avatar
3
3
3
3
Top