Should I Build It Should I Build It
10 Apr 2025
Social Media Monetization Marketing

a creator platform where the brands can create and account and the ...

...creators bid their best offer of content to give to them for a contract

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.

Your are here

Your idea for a creator platform connecting brands with creators through a bidding system enters a highly competitive market. The good news is that there are already 14 similar products, which validates the demand for such platforms. The average engagement, as measured by the number of comments, is high, with 15 comments per product launch. This indicates a strong interest in these types of platforms. While we don't have data on use signals, there's a significant positive buy signal, placing your idea in the top 5% of products regarding user willingness to pay. However, this also means that standing out will be crucial, as numerous competitors are vying for the same audience. Given the competitive terrain, your focus needs to be on differentiation and capturing user attention effectively.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by thoroughly researching the existing creator platforms. Focus on identifying their weaknesses and areas where they fall short in meeting the needs of both brands and creators. Read the reviews and discussions of similar products to get an idea about the needs.
  2. Define 2-3 key differentiators that will make your platform stand out. This could be a unique feature, a superior user experience, a more transparent bidding process, or a focus on a specific niche within the creator economy.
  3. Consider specializing in a specific niche. Instead of trying to be a platform for all types of creators and brands, narrow your focus to a particular industry, content format, or creator skill set. This will allow you to tailor your platform to specific needs and attract a more targeted audience.
  4. Develop a compelling brand and marketing strategy that clearly communicates your platform's unique value proposition. Highlight the benefits that brands and creators will receive by using your platform over competitors, focusing on what makes you different and better.
  5. Prioritize building a minimum viable product (MVP) with your core features and get it in the hands of a small group of early adopters. Collect feedback and iterate quickly to refine your platform based on real-world usage and needs. Given that JoinBrands' users were concerned about quality, ensure there is a score for creators and brands. Also, based on July's users experience, the platform's filtering mechanisms for incoming pitches from creators should be designed to prevent overwhelming the system.
  6. Implement robust analytics from day one. Track key metrics such as user engagement, conversion rates, and bidding activity to measure the performance of your platform and identify areas for improvement. According to Spot's users, the analytics are important to measure campaign performance.
  7. Focus on building a strong community around your platform. Encourage interaction and collaboration between brands and creators. This can create a sense of loyalty and make your platform more attractive to new users. Given Barter's users experience, implement a rating system to assess the quality of creators.
  8. Develop a clear monetization strategy. Determine how you will generate revenue from your platform, whether through subscription fees, commission on deals, or other methods. Make sure your pricing is competitive and fair to both brands and creators.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition, what specific pain points for brands and creators will your platform solve that others aren't adequately addressing, and how will you validate these assumptions before launch?
  2. Considering the strong buy signal, how will you structure your pricing model to ensure it's perceived as valuable to both brands and creators, while also generating sustainable revenue for your platform?
  3. How will you prevent exploitation of creators by managers or agencies, and ensure fair matching of brand ethos with creator vibes as suggested by Barter's users?

Your are here

Your idea for a creator platform connecting brands with creators through a bidding system enters a highly competitive market. The good news is that there are already 14 similar products, which validates the demand for such platforms. The average engagement, as measured by the number of comments, is high, with 15 comments per product launch. This indicates a strong interest in these types of platforms. While we don't have data on use signals, there's a significant positive buy signal, placing your idea in the top 5% of products regarding user willingness to pay. However, this also means that standing out will be crucial, as numerous competitors are vying for the same audience. Given the competitive terrain, your focus needs to be on differentiation and capturing user attention effectively.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by thoroughly researching the existing creator platforms. Focus on identifying their weaknesses and areas where they fall short in meeting the needs of both brands and creators. Read the reviews and discussions of similar products to get an idea about the needs.
  2. Define 2-3 key differentiators that will make your platform stand out. This could be a unique feature, a superior user experience, a more transparent bidding process, or a focus on a specific niche within the creator economy.
  3. Consider specializing in a specific niche. Instead of trying to be a platform for all types of creators and brands, narrow your focus to a particular industry, content format, or creator skill set. This will allow you to tailor your platform to specific needs and attract a more targeted audience.
  4. Develop a compelling brand and marketing strategy that clearly communicates your platform's unique value proposition. Highlight the benefits that brands and creators will receive by using your platform over competitors, focusing on what makes you different and better.
  5. Prioritize building a minimum viable product (MVP) with your core features and get it in the hands of a small group of early adopters. Collect feedback and iterate quickly to refine your platform based on real-world usage and needs. Given that JoinBrands' users were concerned about quality, ensure there is a score for creators and brands. Also, based on July's users experience, the platform's filtering mechanisms for incoming pitches from creators should be designed to prevent overwhelming the system.
  6. Implement robust analytics from day one. Track key metrics such as user engagement, conversion rates, and bidding activity to measure the performance of your platform and identify areas for improvement. According to Spot's users, the analytics are important to measure campaign performance.
  7. Focus on building a strong community around your platform. Encourage interaction and collaboration between brands and creators. This can create a sense of loyalty and make your platform more attractive to new users. Given Barter's users experience, implement a rating system to assess the quality of creators.
  8. Develop a clear monetization strategy. Determine how you will generate revenue from your platform, whether through subscription fees, commission on deals, or other methods. Make sure your pricing is competitive and fair to both brands and creators.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition, what specific pain points for brands and creators will your platform solve that others aren't adequately addressing, and how will you validate these assumptions before launch?
  2. Considering the strong buy signal, how will you structure your pricing model to ensure it's perceived as valuable to both brands and creators, while also generating sustainable revenue for your platform?
  3. How will you prevent exploitation of creators by managers or agencies, and ensure fair matching of brand ethos with creator vibes as suggested by Barter's users?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 14
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 15
  • Net use signal: 28.5%
    • Positive use signal: 28.5%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.3%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.3%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Barter - The ultimate app for creators

25 Nov 2023 Android Advertising Influencer marketing

Barter makes working together with content creators as easy as ordering pizza. Our automated platform enables companies to collaborate with content creators without an agency or high costs. Creators apply for their offers directly through our app.

Barter's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users loving the concept of empowering creators to monetize skills and expand networks. Many congratulated the team and wished them luck. The streamlining of collaborations was seen as a breath of fresh air. Suggestions included adding a rating system and influencer information. Despite some reported bugs, users expressed a positive experience and wished for continued growth and success.

Users suggest implementing a rating system to assess quality and reliability. There's a need for more detailed information and examples of influencers within the platform. Matching brand ethos with creator vibes to improve collaboration is a crucial suggestion. While users have reported bugs, the overall experience remains positive.

Avatar
122
14
35.7%
14
122
35.7%
Relevance

July - Automate your entire creator business

03 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence SaaS Influencer marketing

July is the only platform that automates brand deals, so creators can focus on what matters: creating great content. Streamline your outreach, negotiations, media kit, and payments all in one place.

The Product Hunt launch of July received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users express excitement for the platform's ability to empower creators, streamline brand deals, and simplify workflows. Many congratulate the team, particularly Wells, on their hard work and the product's potential to revolutionize the creator economy. Users highlight the platform's ease of use, time-saving features, and positive impact on helping creators grow their businesses. Some users shared their success using the platform already. The all-in-one nature of the product is also appreciated. Some inquired about future plans and brand focus.

Criticism centers on potential exploitation of creators by managers or agencies. There are concerns about the platform's filtering mechanisms for incoming pitches from creators, and the potential for the system to be overwhelmed, which may impact the quality of the platform. The structure may cause too much noise.

Avatar
357
85
22.4%
85
357
22.4%
Relevance

JoinBrands: Influencers & UGC Creators - Connect with Influencers, TikTok Affiliates and UGC Creators

12 Nov 2024 Social Media Sales Marketing

Connecting brands with UGC creators, TikTok Affiliates & influencers for impactful content! With JoinBrands, launching products is easy: get viral, drive sales, and boost engagement with seamless creator collaborations. Make waves with us! 🌊 #JoinBrands

JoinBrands is highly praised as a user-friendly platform that easily connects creators with brands for UGC. Users love its ease of use, brand variety, excellent customer support, and on-time payments. It's considered life-changing, perfect for building portfolios, fostering creativity, and securing long-term partnerships. Many appreciate the platform's ability to help new and seasoned creators alike, offering opportunities for growth, monetization, and collaboration. Some users mentioned the need for faster feedback and some isolated and outlier remarks, but overall positive experience on JoinBrands.

Criticism centers around creator quality, particularly on TikTok, suggesting a need for health score filtering. Users want more pricing control, similar to other platforms. Application process issues include difficulty securing high-paying jobs, lack of rejection feedback, and slow task feedback. A serious concern involves the platform potentially facilitating illegal activities like drug dealing.

Avatar
93
63
60.3%
63
93
60.3%
Relevance

sociove - UGC Creator Network

17 Dec 2024 Social Media Marketing

The ultimate UGC marketplace 🚀 Connect creators with brands effortlessly. Showcase portfolios, manage orders, and collaboration. For creators: earn with your skills. For brands: find the perfect talent for custom content. Elevate your UGC game today!

Avatar
6
6
Relevance

I made an AI platform to find sponsors and brand deals for youtubers

23 Apr 2024 Artificial Intelligence Influencer marketing

Finally after 20 years in software, and 4 years on youtube, I am launching my first ever indie product, Sponsorstream.It uses AI to sift through youtube to find sponsors relevant to creators' video ideas, to help them make more money and become full-time Youtubers faster, through sponsorships and brand deals.I initially made this for a french AI youtuber (Top 5 in France) who raised the difficulty in finding relevant sponsors.Maybe you'll find it useful too?Took a while to get myself to post. Might not be perfect, but got to start somewhere.Appreciate any feedback.

Questions AI's advantage over traditional sponsor search.

Questions AI's added value.

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

Creator Square - Centralising creator deals across social media

20 May 2023 E-Commerce Social Media Marketing

We gather deals & discounts sourced directly from content uploaded by influencers & creators, making them easily searchable through an extension, increasing the visibility of brands and creators while enabling consumers to save on their purchase.

Users are expressing interest in Creator Square, with one user calling it a potential game changer. There are questions about the business model and requests for a simplified explanation of the platform. One user inquired about the tool's ability to search YouTube channels for coupon deals within videos.

Avatar
88
4
4
88
Relevance

Spot - Bridging creators, businesses, and future audiences

16 Oct 2023 Social media marketing Affiliate marketing Social Media

Craft your Link-in-bio, connect with 100+ brands, and flaunt your portfolio. Soon, unlock business collaborations effortlessly with our AI-driven platform. Your bridge from creation to collaboration, leading to endless opportunities.

Spot's Product Hunt launch received positive feedback, emphasizing its potential for creators to showcase talents, connect with like-minded individuals, businesses, and audiences, and collaborate effectively. Users highlighted the platform's personalization and monetization potential. The team was also recognized. Several users congratulated the launch and expressed interest in using it for portfolio and scheduling calls.

The primary criticism is the need for more robust analytics to effectively measure campaign performance. Users are looking for deeper insights into how their campaigns are performing to optimize their strategies. Without these analytics, it's difficult to assess the product's value proposition for campaign management.

Avatar
129
11
27.3%
11
129
27.3%
Relevance

Contnt - Subscription-based platform for the creator economy

22 Feb 2024 Social Media Influencer marketing Marketing

Experience empowerment, autonomy, fair rewards, essential tools, equal exposure, and true ownership, unlocking boundless potential for creators.

The platform is designed by creators, focusing on empowering them through NFT minting and fair monetization. Users are excited about the launch, calling it 'amazing' and 'fantastic'. The product is seen as a boost to the creator economy, supporting creatives in finding new ways to get paid. There are also congratulations on the beta launch of the product.

Avatar
67
7
7
67
Relevance

CreatePay - Secure instant payments for the creator economy

07 Apr 2023 Fintech Social Media Marketing

CreatePay is your way to ensure you get paid by brands for your posts as soon as they go live. Brands too have a safe and secure way to manage their campaigns with influencers all in one place.

The Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, particularly regarding its potential benefits for creators and brands. Users inquired about brand cooperation, commission structures, and its applicability to B2B influencer programs. A brand representative highlighted the tool's ability to simplify influencer management. Several users congratulated the team and expressed interest in connecting.

Avatar
85
5
60.0%
20.0%
5
85
60.0%
20.0%
Relevance

Creatorland - The First Professional Network for Creators

02 May 2024 Social Networking Influencer marketing Career

Introducing Creatorland: the free platform revolutionizing the creator economy. Tailored for modern creative professionals, it’s your hub for showcasing portfolios, connecting with peers, and discovering new opportunities.

Creatorland's Product Hunt launch has garnered positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and expressing excitement about the platform. It's perceived as a valuable networking tool for creators, often compared to LinkedIn for the creative economy. Users appreciate its timing and usefulness for both creators and influencers. Many are eager to be a part of the platform and anticipate its success.

Avatar
40
8
50.0%
8
40
50.0%
Top