Should I Build It Should I Build It
23 Apr 2025
Finance

tool and dashboard to add my finance and show compounding interest ...

...calculation

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

You're entering a crowded space with your finance tool and dashboard idea, specifically focusing on compounding interest calculations. The data shows 22 similar products already exist, putting you squarely in a highly competitive "Swamp" category where many mediocre solutions struggle to stand out. Engagement, as measured by average comments, is low at 2, suggesting that even existing solutions aren't generating much buzz. Given this landscape, the prevailing advice is: Don't build it. However, the opportunity might exist in a niche where current solutions are not meeting users' needs, or by building on top of existing solutions to provide more tailored and specific calculations that can be more insightful than just compounding interest calculators.

Recommendations

  1. Before diving into development, deeply analyze why existing financial dashboards and compounding interest tools haven't achieved widespread adoption. What are their shortcomings? What user needs are not being met? Research user reviews, identify pain points, and understand the specific gaps in the market. Look at the criticism from similar products to understand usability problems.
  2. If you remain committed to the idea, identify a very specific niche or underserved segment within the personal finance space. Perhaps focus on a particular demographic (e.g., young professionals, retirees) or a specific financial goal (e.g., early retirement, debt payoff). Tailor your dashboard and calculations to their unique needs. For example, create a tool that combines investment performance with debt repayment strategies, something most simple calculators do not do.
  3. Instead of creating a standalone dashboard, consider building tools or integrations for existing personal finance platforms like Mint or Personal Capital. Leverage their existing user base and infrastructure to offer specialized compounding interest calculations or visualizations that complement their core functionality. One user was asking for data import option in a similar tool. Try to think about building something like that on top of existing platform instead of building yet another competing dashboard.
  4. Explore adjacent problems within the personal finance domain that might be more promising or less crowded. For instance, instead of just calculating compounding interest, focus on tools that help users optimize their investment strategies based on risk tolerance, tax implications, or specific financial goals. The metrics show that engagement is low in this category, so you need to find something novel and valuable.
  5. Given the competitive landscape and low engagement in similar products, seriously consider whether this is the best use of your time and resources. There might be other startup ideas or opportunities where you have a greater chance of success. Don't be afraid to pivot or explore alternative ventures. You can still validate your idea with a landing page that explains what problem are you trying to solve.
  6. Focus on UX. A similar tool was criticized for 'over-engineering hindering usability'. Make sure to test your solution and get feedback early and often. Keep it simple and stupid.

Questions

  1. What specific user pain point are you addressing with your dashboard that existing solutions fail to solve, and how will you validate that this pain point is significant enough to drive adoption?
  2. Given the low engagement and 'Swamp' category classification, what unique features or value propositions will differentiate your tool from the numerous existing options and attract a dedicated user base?
  3. How will you approach user acquisition and marketing in a crowded market, and what is your plan to achieve sustainable growth considering the low engagement observed in similar products?

Your are here

You're entering a crowded space with your finance tool and dashboard idea, specifically focusing on compounding interest calculations. The data shows 22 similar products already exist, putting you squarely in a highly competitive "Swamp" category where many mediocre solutions struggle to stand out. Engagement, as measured by average comments, is low at 2, suggesting that even existing solutions aren't generating much buzz. Given this landscape, the prevailing advice is: Don't build it. However, the opportunity might exist in a niche where current solutions are not meeting users' needs, or by building on top of existing solutions to provide more tailored and specific calculations that can be more insightful than just compounding interest calculators.

Recommendations

  1. Before diving into development, deeply analyze why existing financial dashboards and compounding interest tools haven't achieved widespread adoption. What are their shortcomings? What user needs are not being met? Research user reviews, identify pain points, and understand the specific gaps in the market. Look at the criticism from similar products to understand usability problems.
  2. If you remain committed to the idea, identify a very specific niche or underserved segment within the personal finance space. Perhaps focus on a particular demographic (e.g., young professionals, retirees) or a specific financial goal (e.g., early retirement, debt payoff). Tailor your dashboard and calculations to their unique needs. For example, create a tool that combines investment performance with debt repayment strategies, something most simple calculators do not do.
  3. Instead of creating a standalone dashboard, consider building tools or integrations for existing personal finance platforms like Mint or Personal Capital. Leverage their existing user base and infrastructure to offer specialized compounding interest calculations or visualizations that complement their core functionality. One user was asking for data import option in a similar tool. Try to think about building something like that on top of existing platform instead of building yet another competing dashboard.
  4. Explore adjacent problems within the personal finance domain that might be more promising or less crowded. For instance, instead of just calculating compounding interest, focus on tools that help users optimize their investment strategies based on risk tolerance, tax implications, or specific financial goals. The metrics show that engagement is low in this category, so you need to find something novel and valuable.
  5. Given the competitive landscape and low engagement in similar products, seriously consider whether this is the best use of your time and resources. There might be other startup ideas or opportunities where you have a greater chance of success. Don't be afraid to pivot or explore alternative ventures. You can still validate your idea with a landing page that explains what problem are you trying to solve.
  6. Focus on UX. A similar tool was criticized for 'over-engineering hindering usability'. Make sure to test your solution and get feedback early and often. Keep it simple and stupid.

Questions

  1. What specific user pain point are you addressing with your dashboard that existing solutions fail to solve, and how will you validate that this pain point is significant enough to drive adoption?
  2. Given the low engagement and 'Swamp' category classification, what unique features or value propositions will differentiate your tool from the numerous existing options and attract a dedicated user base?
  3. How will you approach user acquisition and marketing in a crowded market, and what is your plan to achieve sustainable growth considering the low engagement observed in similar products?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 22
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 2
  • Net use signal: 17.1%
    • Positive use signal: 17.1%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Compound Interest Calculator

27 Jul 2024 Personal Finance

This side project started from my personal interest in the effects of compound interest.My goal was to create a simple, user-friendly tool that hides all the complexity—something people could use regularly. No registration required, free forever for everyone.

Simple, user-friendly compound interest tool, free forever.

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

Simple and Playful Compound Interest Calculator

15 Feb 2024 Fintech Investing Finance

Hey HN!I made this to encourage people to start investing their money. Usually, when I search for compound interest calculators, they are always too technical or not that "good-looking," which I thought could disinterest some people, so the idea was to create a simple calculator that is more interactive and playful.Let me know your thoughts or if you have any suggestions to improve it!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

savings.lol - Calculator - Effortlessly predict and visualise your future wealth

27 Jul 2024 Personal Finance Investing Money

Forecast future savings and plan your financial future with ease. Compound Interest Calculator is a simple yet powerful tool that allows you to calculate the growth of your investments over time using the power of compound interest.

The Product Hunt launch features an easy-to-use compound interest calculator. Users find it beneficial for financial planning.

Avatar
15
2
50.0%
2
15
50.0%
Relevance

Wait for Wealth - Encourage people to start investing in a playful way

16 Feb 2024 Investing Finance Money

A fun and insightful compound interest calculator designed to motivate you towards investing. Enter basic info and watch as it projects your financial growth and equates it to tangible items you could purchase.

Users appreciate Wait for Wealth's playful and relatable approach to encouraging investing and highlighting the importance of financial planning and compound interest. One user launched the product on Product Hunt, shared it with their team, and voted for it. Another user expressed interest in trying out Wait for Wealth.

The primary criticism revolves around the perception of a quid-pro-quo arrangement, as the product launch seeks support, potentially implying an expectation of reciprocal endorsements from others. This presents an ethical concern in manipulating the review ecosystem.

Avatar
78
4
25.0%
4
78
25.0%
Relevance

Finance Dashboard - A Notion template to monitor your finances

13 Jul 2023 Notion

Our Finance Dashboard tracks everything you need for your finances, such as income, expenses, accounts, savings, debt. We added bonus features such as calculation of net worth, debt payoff calculator & more.

The Notion Finance Dashboard launch received positive feedback, with users praising its effectiveness as a finance tracker for debt management. A suggestion was made to increase visibility by listing the app on AI directories like wikigpt3.com.

Avatar
93
3
3
93
Relevance

I built a collection of personal finance calculators

21 May 2024 Productivity

I am teaching myself to code (JS) and decided to build something practical for my existing website.Let me know what you think and if you want me to add a specific calculator. I already have a list of 10 more, which I'll add within the next month.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Invest first and spend what's left

06 Jun 2024 Investing

I made a tool to help with investing.I always love to save money. I didn’t know how to manage it properly to earn passively and overcome inflation.I found out about index funds, especially the S&P 500. The average return on this financial instrument is about 8–10% a year.I needed to understand how much I would earn over a period of time: 5, 10, 15, and 20 years from now.That’s why I built this product. I researched the formula and integrated it. I made pie charts and line charts for a beautiful illustration.For some geeks, I even represented the data in table form.If you are interested, check it out. Write a comment below.

Reliable investment management tool with great data representation.

Avatar
1
1
100.0%
1
1
100.0%
Relevance

I built my own financial planinng app

16 Sep 2024 Personal Finance Fintech Finance Money

A few years ago, I started managing my finances using Google Sheets. It worked fine for a while, but then I hit some limitations. As my financial planning needs grew more complex, I found myself struggling with tracking assets and forecasting future financial scenarios. Thus, I started to work in my spare time on building FinancialAha: https://www.financialaha.com - a financial planning app designed to do everything my spreadsheets couldn’t.It is completely free and I intend to add some paid features later on as listed on the pricing page, but I want to keep it free for people that need to do basic financial planinng and projections. Currently it works best on desktop screens, and I working on making it available on mobile devices.Key Features: - track all your assets & debt - manage various types of assets including cash, stocks, real estate, digital assets, etc., all in one place. - cash flow insights - visualize and optimize your income and spending habits. Understand where your money is going and plan smarter. - financial projections - use your current data to create realistic projections, plan for future expenses or investments, and keep your finances on track. - privacy and Security - by default, your data remains in your browser, and when stored, it's encrypted end-to-end. The data never gets on our servers unencrypted and all the encrypt/decrypt is done on client. This way, the plain data never gets to FinancialAha.You can try it for free and see how it works. Check it out here: https://www.financialaha.comI'd love to hear your feedback!

The product is built with Hugo and VueJS, uses localStorage for data, and is hosted on Netlify. One user appreciates the UX and inquires about a data import option. Another user notes that there is no content available.

The product lacks a data import option.

Avatar
5
3
33.3%
3
5
33.3%
Relevance

My side project is helping me manage my finances

27 Dec 2023 Artificial Intelligence Personal Finance Fintech

For years, I have struggled to understand my cash flow and save for the future. In addition to that, my wife has many credit cards and accounts that complicate matters. I am building a tool that connects all our accounts, helps us create a budget, and tracks and adjusts expenses on the fly. I am also sprinkling some AI magic on it for financial suggestions. I am looking for feedback on the implementation. More importantly, I am looking for more beta testers to improve the product.

The Show HN product, FML, is recognized for simplifying financial planning and review. Users have concerns about the association with a well-known initialism potentially being detrimental. There is curiosity about the AI's functionality and questions regarding integration with financial institutions. The product has received positive remarks on its appearance. Some comments are no longer active.

Users suggest rethinking the use of the initialism 'FML' due to its commonly known negative connotation, which contrasts with the intended message.

Avatar
9
7
7
9
Relevance

Finance Monitor – open-source finance aggregator

29 Apr 2024 Personal Finance Fintech Open Source Finance

This open source web app aggregates accounts, and displays their balances, transactions, and trends in one place. I started building it ~2 months ago after learning Mint.com was shutting down. I used Mint mainly as an aggregator, to view all account values together, and inspect transaction history without logging into each account separately. I realized I could replicate this functionality by using Plaid’s API.Tech stack: - Django backend - Postgres database - HTML + CSS + JS frontend.I may integrate typescript, but am skipping it for now to eschew the build step and associated config.There are other uses people have for Mint, like budgeting, which I don’t use personally. I didn’t put much work into them, but may if I get enough feedback.I’m open to any and all feedback, contributions, and critique. (Here, Github etc) There's also a hosted / fully-working one deployed: https://www.finance-monitor.com/

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

finance_stuff - Track & grow your finances in just 10 minutes a month

27 Sep 2024 Personal Finance Investing Money

Do you track your personal finances using a spreadsheet? Great. You don't? You should start! finance_stuff comes after years of over-engineering my personal finances spreadsheet, it aims to make it simpler but more effective and insightful.

Asks about features stripped away for usability and simplicity balance.

Expresses concern about over-engineering hindering usability.

Avatar
14
1
1
14
Relevance

Finance Monitor – Personal finance aggregator

01 Apr 2024 Personal Finance Fintech

This web app aggregates accounts, and displays their balances, transactions, and trends in one place. I started building this a few weeks ago after learning Mint.com was shutting down. I used Mint mainly as an aggregator, to view all account values together, and inspect transaction history without logging into each account separately. I realized I could replicate this functionality by using Plaid’s API as an aggregator.I noticed after starting that this is a saturated field! I think there’s still a reason to launch: It’s fast (By virtue of not using frameworks or analytics), doesn’t do anything creepy with user data, displays information in a concise format, and doesn’t send marketing email or notifications.Tech stack: Django backend, Postgres database, HTML + CSS + JS frontend. I may integrate typescript, but am skipping it for now to eschew the build step and associated config.There are other uses people have for Mint, like budgeting, which I don’t use personally. I didn’t put much work into them, but may if I get enough feedback.I’m open to any and all feedback and critique, and will add features quickly as I discover shortfalls, and read user feedback.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Corporate Finance OS - Manage all your companies finances in one dashboard

29 Apr 2023 Fintech Finance Notion

This template is a finance system built in Notion. It was specifically designed for solopreneurs, but can be useful for every sort of entrepreneur & business. Track your profits, subscriptions & different accounts - all in one dashboard.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users congratulating the creators and praising the tool's clean, professional design and usefulness for managing finances, tracking profits, and subscriptions. Small business owners and entrepreneurs find it particularly valuable for organization and filling financial knowledge gaps. Several users inquired about specific features like international bank account integration and currency support. The template was repeatedly described as awesome and invaluable, with many expressing eagerness to try it.

The primary criticism revolves around the subtle promotion of another project within a congratulatory message. This was perceived negatively by users on Product Hunt.

Avatar
205
17
35.3%
17
205
35.3%
Relevance

Dividend Calculator I Made

09 May 2023 Investing

Hey,Software engineer and hobby investor here. I've built a Dividend calculator that I hope the community can enjoy. Currently, the portfolio is only saved to the local storage of the machine you are using. Please feel free to share your thoughts and let me know if there are any additional features you would like to see.

Avatar
1
1
Top