19 Apr 2025
Vacation

airbnb clone for the best services such as rooms and hotels and stuff

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

You're entering a crowded market with your Airbnb clone, as evidenced by the 17 similar products we found. This high number indicates significant competition. However, the medium engagement (average of 6 comments per product) suggests there's room to capture user attention if you can stand out. Because you are in the 'Freemium' idea category, people love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for. Based on the similar products' discussions, users often seek solutions that simplify travel planning, offer unique accommodations, and cut costs. Many express desire for direct booking to avoid fees, but security concerns arise. The lack of strong 'buy' or 'use' signals (both positive and negative are neutral), indicates it will be hard to monetize this product.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by clearly defining your target user. Given the crowded market, niche down to a specific segment (e.g., digital nomads seeking work-friendly accommodations, families looking for unique vacation rentals). This focus will help you tailor your features and marketing efforts effectively.
  2. Since you're in the 'Freemium' category, identify the core value proposition you can offer for free. This could be a basic listing service, advanced search filters, or a user-friendly interface. Make sure this free offering is genuinely useful and attracts a solid user base.
  3. Based on the provided discussions and criticisms from competing products, users are looking for direct connection with the property owners, but they also are concerned about payment security. Build this feature into the product but make sure to handle the payments securely. Offer guarantees in case something goes wrong.
  4. Carefully consider how to differentiate your platform to avoid direct competition with Airbnb. Focus on a novel use case, improve Airbnb experiences (e.g. find listings with good internet as some products do), or create a unique user experience. Based on the discussions and criticisms from the similar products make sure to focus on adding a filtering option for wifi when searching for the best services.
  5. Develop premium features that cater to your target user's specific needs. Examples include enhanced security features, personalized itinerary planning, or priority support. Highlight these features prominently to incentivize users to upgrade.
  6. Explore partnerships with local businesses, tour operators, or transportation providers to offer bundled packages. This can add value for users and create new revenue streams. Charge them a fee based on every booking or the additional traffic that you bring them.
  7. Given the concerns about trust and security expressed in the competitive analysis, invest heavily in building a secure and transparent platform. Implement robust verification processes for both hosts and guests, and offer guarantees to protect users against fraud or misrepresentation.
  8. Test different pricing models for your premium features. Offer free trials, tiered pricing, or usage-based pricing to see what resonates best with your target audience. Collect user feedback and iterate on your pricing strategy.
  9. Prioritize user experience and customer support. Address user feedback promptly, resolve issues efficiently, and create a seamless and enjoyable experience for both hosts and guests.

Questions

  1. Given that the positive and negative signals are neutral, who is your ideal paying customer? And how are you planning on getting them to pay for your service?
  2. With so many similar products already available, what is your unfair advantage that will allow you to outcompete established players and capture market share?
  3. How can you build trust and security into your platform to address user concerns and differentiate yourself from competitors, especially given the skepticism around direct bookings?

Your are here

You're entering a crowded market with your Airbnb clone, as evidenced by the 17 similar products we found. This high number indicates significant competition. However, the medium engagement (average of 6 comments per product) suggests there's room to capture user attention if you can stand out. Because you are in the 'Freemium' idea category, people love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for. Based on the similar products' discussions, users often seek solutions that simplify travel planning, offer unique accommodations, and cut costs. Many express desire for direct booking to avoid fees, but security concerns arise. The lack of strong 'buy' or 'use' signals (both positive and negative are neutral), indicates it will be hard to monetize this product.

Recommendations

  1. Begin by clearly defining your target user. Given the crowded market, niche down to a specific segment (e.g., digital nomads seeking work-friendly accommodations, families looking for unique vacation rentals). This focus will help you tailor your features and marketing efforts effectively.
  2. Since you're in the 'Freemium' category, identify the core value proposition you can offer for free. This could be a basic listing service, advanced search filters, or a user-friendly interface. Make sure this free offering is genuinely useful and attracts a solid user base.
  3. Based on the provided discussions and criticisms from competing products, users are looking for direct connection with the property owners, but they also are concerned about payment security. Build this feature into the product but make sure to handle the payments securely. Offer guarantees in case something goes wrong.
  4. Carefully consider how to differentiate your platform to avoid direct competition with Airbnb. Focus on a novel use case, improve Airbnb experiences (e.g. find listings with good internet as some products do), or create a unique user experience. Based on the discussions and criticisms from the similar products make sure to focus on adding a filtering option for wifi when searching for the best services.
  5. Develop premium features that cater to your target user's specific needs. Examples include enhanced security features, personalized itinerary planning, or priority support. Highlight these features prominently to incentivize users to upgrade.
  6. Explore partnerships with local businesses, tour operators, or transportation providers to offer bundled packages. This can add value for users and create new revenue streams. Charge them a fee based on every booking or the additional traffic that you bring them.
  7. Given the concerns about trust and security expressed in the competitive analysis, invest heavily in building a secure and transparent platform. Implement robust verification processes for both hosts and guests, and offer guarantees to protect users against fraud or misrepresentation.
  8. Test different pricing models for your premium features. Offer free trials, tiered pricing, or usage-based pricing to see what resonates best with your target audience. Collect user feedback and iterate on your pricing strategy.
  9. Prioritize user experience and customer support. Address user feedback promptly, resolve issues efficiently, and create a seamless and enjoyable experience for both hosts and guests.

Questions

  1. Given that the positive and negative signals are neutral, who is your ideal paying customer? And how are you planning on getting them to pay for your service?
  2. With so many similar products already available, what is your unfair advantage that will allow you to outcompete established players and capture market share?
  3. How can you build trust and security into your platform to address user concerns and differentiate yourself from competitors, especially given the skepticism around direct bookings?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 17
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 6
  • Net use signal: 8.6%
    • Positive use signal: 13.9%
    • Negative use signal: 5.3%
  • Net buy signal: -3.6%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.1%
    • Negative buy signal: 4.7%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Direct Booking for Airbnb Hosts and Hotels

13 Aug 2024 SaaS

I built it using Vike and Express. Do you think there is room for a new Airbnb competitor. Yearly membership for unlimited listing and no Booking Fees. What do you think?


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

SubIt - The Airbnb for Subleasing

04 Nov 2024 Travel Vacation Tech

We are a marketplace that allows users to list and chat with other users seeking to sublease. In the following months we will be adding contracts for landlords and charging for that. Airbnb style!

SubIt is a helpful Airbnb-style marketplace for subleasing with contracts.


Avatar
10
1
100.0%
1
10
100.0%
Relevance

FlyBnB - Flights & Airbnbs in one smart search

Flybnb.io simplifies trip planning by combining flights & Airbnb stays in one search. Smart filters like min reviews count & score show vetted options. Find destinations you’d skip otherwise— high flight costs may be offset by cheap stays on your exact dates.


Avatar
7
7
Relevance

Offsite - Airbnb for team retreats

13 Mar 2024 Remote Work Travel Hotels

Save time, money, and stress when planning team retreats. Access 20%+ discounts on room blocks, meeting spaces, and more at premier offsite venues worldwide. Join hundreds of top startups, VCs, and remote/hybrid teams using Offsite today.

Offsite's launch is being met with widespread excitement and congratulations. Users highlight its value in simplifying retreat planning, especially for remote teams and resource-strapped startups. The intuitive UX, efficient cost-cutting, and quality team retreat solutions are repeatedly praised. Several users express anticipation to try Offsite for future events and appreciate the growing selection of venues. International expansion, particularly into Canada, is a desired feature. The importance of offsites for fostering company culture and successful remote work is also emphasized. Past collaborators share positive experiences working with the Offsite team.

Criticism focuses on the lacking quality of Breather's NYC locations. A user also suggested implementing personalized itinerary building based on team size and preferences to improve user experience.


Avatar
318
27
37.0%
3.7%
27
318
37.0%
3.7%
Relevance

AirCMP - Smart Airbnb comparison & filtering

AirCMP simplifies your Airbnb search by analyzing all reviews and extracting key benefits and drawbacks. Get hidden insights instantly on each listing, so you can make the best choice quickly and confidently. Find your perfect stay with ease!

AirCMP is receiving positive feedback for its ability to streamline Airbnb review analysis. Users are enthusiastic about its speed and the helpful insights it provides for finding ideal Airbnb bookings. The tool is considered valuable for simplifying the comparison and filtering of listings, enhancing the overall user experience for Airbnb users.


Avatar
7
4
50.0%
4
7
50.0%
Relevance

A website for remote workers to find Airbnb's with good Internet

18 Aug 2023 Remote Work

I created this website about a month ago to solve a problem I was facing myself as an aspiring digital nomad. It is very important to find an accommodation with fast and reliable Internet. I also specifically wanted places with Ethernet access to minimize latency as much as possible since I (and many others) use a VPN hosted back at home.The database is in its infancy but covers 11 countries so far. I realize the UX is very basic and a minimum viable product. I intend to have someone help me overhaul the design (with ReactJS perhaps) to make it mobile friendly and more appealing.

Users appreciate the concept, highlighting the need for work-friendly accommodations with good internet and ergonomic setups. Concerns were raised about the site's functionality, with reports of blank pages and caching issues. Some users are interested in collaboration. There's a debate on Airbnb's impact on local economies and housing affordability, with opinions on both sides. The discussion includes the distinction between digital nomads and remote workers, local regulatory solutions, and the political influence of property owners. Suggestions include adding hotels to the service and improving data points for better utility.

Users criticize the lack of internet speed verification, Airbnb's impact on housing affordability and local economies, misrepresentation of remote work, technical issues with cache and API, and insufficient data collection. Concerns include Airbnb evading taxes, worsening the affordability crisis, and harming the residential market. Some comments suggest that not all hosts evade taxes and that other factors like zoning contribute to the crisis. The dedicated workspace feature is considered vague, and there's a call for more comprehensive data beyond Airbnb.


Avatar
25
50
-12.0%
-14.0%
50
25
4.0%
Relevance

I built an extension to contact Airbnb hosts direcly

29 Nov 2024 Travel Vacation

Hey HN,Over the years, I’ve found myself frustrated with the extra fees Airbnb. While they provide a lot of convenience, the service fees often stack up to a point where they overshadow any potential savings. I started wondering if there was a way to connect directly with property hosts and skip the middleman entirely.That curiosity led me to build getaway.direct, a free Chrome extension that helps travelers save money. It works like this:1. You browse listings on Airbnb. 2. The extension scans for direct booking links, host websites, or social media profiles where you can reach out to the host directly. 3. It shows those results instantly, so you can compare prices, avoid service fees, and book smarter.The main idea is to provide transparency. A lot of hosts already have their own websites but rely on platforms like Airbnb for visibility. This tool helps surface those direct options, which can often save you 10-20% per booking.I’d love to hear your thoughts:Would something like this be helpful to you? Also, I’m curious to get feedback on ways to improve the tool—whether it’s adding more integrations, improving usability, or something else entirely.Thanks for reading! Let me know what you think.

Users expressed dissatisfaction with Airbnb's issue resolution, leading to account deletions. They expect Airbnb to ensure good practices and standards. There are concerns about the accuracy of the extension's direct link finding, and a suggestion for hosts to register directly.

Users criticize Airbnb for not taking responsibility for issues and demanding unrealistic proofs. They also question the accuracy of direct link findings and express frustration over the lack of a direct registration option for hosts.


Avatar
10
4
-50.0%
-50.0%
4
10
Relevance

Alertbnb - Real time alerts for Airbnb listings

Alertbnb is an accommodation availability alert service that currently targets Airbnb. It offers real-time notifications of new accommodation listings to provide users with the best value for money and flexibility when travelling or finding somewhere to live.

Alertbnb's launch on Product Hunt received positive feedback, with users praising its convenience and potential value, particularly for those planning travel across multiple cities. One user expressed interest in trying the service. A common question revolved around how Alertbnb differentiates itself from existing solutions. A specific feature request was made to include VRBO searching. The launch was also met with general congratulations and well wishes to the founder, Luke.

Users question Alertbnb's differentiation from existing services. There's also specific inquiry regarding the methodology used to identify underpriced listings.


Avatar
96
7
28.6%
7
96
28.6%
Relevance

Nomadbnb - Alerts for Airbnb

Tired of checking Airbnb for your upcoming weekend trip, bachelor party or month-long stay as a nomad? We got you! Just browse Airbnb as you normally would. Then copy your URL into Nomadbnb and you'll be notified daily with new listings

Users suggest adding filtering options for wifi and city quarter. One user congratulates the launch and asks about potential Airbnb integration of similar features. Overall, Nomadbnb is recognized for simplifying travel planning by delivering daily notifications of new listings.


Avatar
114
3
66.7%
3
114
66.7%
Relevance

Getaway.direct - Say goodbye to Airbnb fees and book with direct links

Skip Airbnb’s fees and save up to 20% per night! Finds direct booking links, helping you connect with hosts and avoid fees. Book smarter, save more.

Users generally reacted positively to the Product Hunt launch, congratulating the team and calling the product a potential game-changer, especially for travelers. The ability to save on fees and connect directly with owners was well-received. A digital nomad suggested marketing to nomad communities given their affinity for Airbnb. Some users provided feedback, such as increasing the font size on the pricing page and a suggestion to offer bulk owner search. There were also inquiries regarding browser add-ons and the security of payment handling through the extension.

Users criticized the pricing page's unclear 'year' font size, which could cause confusion. A request was made for a bulk search feature that is currently unavailable. There were also security concerns expressed about traveling without a middleman, and skepticism regarding trust in payment extensions.


Avatar
157
7
28.6%
14.3%
7
157
28.6%
14.3%
Relevance

Botvisor - Airbnb AI assistant + website builder

11 Jan 2024 SaaS Travel Vacation

With our software, individuals managing short-term rental properties can create their own customized assistant within just three hours. This not only enhances the overall experience for guests but also significantly improves the lives of hosts.

Botvisor is lauded as an impressive, time-saving AI assistant, particularly useful for Airbnb and short-term rental management by offering timely self-service answers to guest questions. Users appreciate the efficiency and reduction of host time. However, concerns are raised regarding security, accuracy, and the potential negative impact of bot errors on guest experience. One user inquired about the inspiration behind creating an AI assistant for rentals, and the customized assistants can be created relatively fast.

Users expressed concerns regarding the software's security and accuracy, requesting more detailed information. Adoption and potential profit margins were also questioned, with a call for feedback from genuine users. A significant criticism centered on the host losing control and the potential for bot hallucinations leading to negative reviews.


Avatar
95
9
22.2%
9
95
22.2%
Top