Should I Build It Should I Build It
17 Apr 2025
Marketing

A D&D connection platform that allows users to build parties together ...

...by meeting people online with similar ideas or interests for their campaigns

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Run Away

Multiple attempts have failed with clear negative feedback. Continuing down this path would likely waste your time and resources when better opportunities exist elsewhere.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your idea for a D&D connection platform falls into a crowded space where many similar products have emerged. With 10 similar products already identified, competition is significant. The average comment count on these platforms is high, indicating strong engagement within the niche, but the lack of positive signals for use or purchase is concerning, because it suggests it's a crowded space with limited user adoption. Therefore it's best to avoid building such product as this is in the "run away" category where it makes sense to give up, accept failure, learn, and move on.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly analyze the negative feedback from existing D&D platforms, specifically focusing on interface complexity, performance issues, and lack of customization, as these areas consistently receive criticism. Understand why current solutions aren't meeting user needs before proceeding.
  2. Evaluate if your existing skills and resources could be applied to a related, but less saturated, problem within the tabletop gaming community, like AI assisted DMing. Could you pivot to a more specialized service, such as campaign management tools or character creation resources, to differentiate yourself?
  3. If you've already developed any components of your platform, assess whether the underlying technology can be repurposed for a different application, potentially outside of the D&D niche, to leverage your investment.
  4. Reach out to individuals who have used similar D&D connection platforms and conduct in-depth interviews to understand their pain points, unmet needs, and desired features. Focus on identifying gaps in the market that your platform could uniquely address.
  5. Synthesize the insights gathered from competitive analysis and user interviews to develop a revised concept that addresses the shortcomings of existing solutions and offers a compelling value proposition. Ensure your revised idea stands out in a crowded market.

Questions

  1. Given the existing criticisms of similar D&D platforms, how will your platform specifically address issues like complex interfaces, slow performance, and limited customization to provide a superior user experience?
  2. With numerous competitors in the D&D space, what unique features or value propositions will differentiate your platform and attract users away from established solutions?
  3. Considering the concerns about AI's impact on gameplay and narrative coherence, how will your platform strike a balance between leveraging AI for assistance and preserving the human elements of storytelling and player agency?

Your are here

Your idea for a D&D connection platform falls into a crowded space where many similar products have emerged. With 10 similar products already identified, competition is significant. The average comment count on these platforms is high, indicating strong engagement within the niche, but the lack of positive signals for use or purchase is concerning, because it suggests it's a crowded space with limited user adoption. Therefore it's best to avoid building such product as this is in the "run away" category where it makes sense to give up, accept failure, learn, and move on.

Recommendations

  1. Thoroughly analyze the negative feedback from existing D&D platforms, specifically focusing on interface complexity, performance issues, and lack of customization, as these areas consistently receive criticism. Understand why current solutions aren't meeting user needs before proceeding.
  2. Evaluate if your existing skills and resources could be applied to a related, but less saturated, problem within the tabletop gaming community, like AI assisted DMing. Could you pivot to a more specialized service, such as campaign management tools or character creation resources, to differentiate yourself?
  3. If you've already developed any components of your platform, assess whether the underlying technology can be repurposed for a different application, potentially outside of the D&D niche, to leverage your investment.
  4. Reach out to individuals who have used similar D&D connection platforms and conduct in-depth interviews to understand their pain points, unmet needs, and desired features. Focus on identifying gaps in the market that your platform could uniquely address.
  5. Synthesize the insights gathered from competitive analysis and user interviews to develop a revised concept that addresses the shortcomings of existing solutions and offers a compelling value proposition. Ensure your revised idea stands out in a crowded market.

Questions

  1. Given the existing criticisms of similar D&D platforms, how will your platform specifically address issues like complex interfaces, slow performance, and limited customization to provide a superior user experience?
  2. With numerous competitors in the D&D space, what unique features or value propositions will differentiate your platform and attract users away from established solutions?
  3. Considering the concerns about AI's impact on gameplay and narrative coherence, how will your platform strike a balance between leveraging AI for assistance and preserving the human elements of storytelling and player agency?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 10
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 15
  • Net use signal: -0.9%
    • Positive use signal: 8.1%
    • Negative use signal: 9.0%
  • Net buy signal: -4.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.4%
    • Negative buy signal: 4.5%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

I made an AI Dungeon Master to play D&D 5e with

06 Jul 2023 Artificial Intelligence Games

Hey everyone, I built this project because I always wanted to try playing D&D but couldn’t find a group of friends or a DM to play with. It’s still early stages and not meant to be a complete replacement for real DMs or IRL sessions, but it’s a good way to dip your toes into DnD or to play on your phone between your IRL sessions.I tried playing D&D with ChatGPT but the overall experience was lacking, so I built this site & Discord bot that has a character sheet tool, better memory management, support for multiplayer, and automatic tracking for things like spells, HP, and encounters.Try it out at https://www.fables.gg/ and let me know what you think! You can try it for free, but after a while there is a paywall since the GPT API costs aren’t cheap.

Users have mixed feedback on the site. One user praises the site design, while another user reports an issue with scroll-jacking on the homepage, preventing them from scrolling down.

The homepage has an unusual scroll-jacking behavior that users find problematic.

Avatar
6
2
2
6
Relevance

ChatGPT develops a Dungeons and Dragons multiplayer game

24 Mar 2023 Games

this is the very beginning of hacking a Dungeons & Dragons multiplayer game together with ChatGPT.will add another portion every other day.open to your thoughts, feedback, and contributions(!)

Users are intrigued by the experiment of using GPT-3.5 for a simulated D&D/RPG campaign. They find it great for text adventures and are curious about the development time. One user is starting a D&D multiplayer game with ChatGPT and is seeking feedback.

Users criticized ChatGPT for becoming stubborn when provided with too much context and noted its limitations.

Avatar
6
3
3
6
Relevance

Friends & Fables - AI TTRPG and world building game

29 Oct 2024 Artificial Intelligence RPGs Open World Games

A generative tabletop roleplaying game inspired by D&D 5e. Play through 5e campaigns with an AI game master, either solo or with friends. Build worlds full of custom locations, characters, items, spells, and more.

Users are excited about the AI map generation and character art. There's a call for beginner-friendly tutorials and guides to help users understand the game's mechanics and storytelling aspects. Users congratulated the launch and were curious to know more about the new content and community sharing.

Users criticized the Product Hunt launch for lacking beginner-friendly tutorials and guides, specifically concerning mechanics and storytelling aspects. This absence makes it difficult for new users to understand and effectively utilize the product.

Avatar
96
3
3
96
Relevance

I built a virtual tabletop for playing Dungeons and Dragons

12 Oct 2023 Games

Diceright is a virtual tabletop for playing dungeons and dragons with friends on the web. You can watch a quick overview of how it works here: https://tinyurl.com/diceright. And there’s a list of the main features right on the homepage.It’s a Ruby on Rails site that makes heavy use of action cable for keeping the maps and tokens in sync for all players. On the front end, I’m using HTML canvas for the maps and a js library called fabric.js for interacting with the canvas. Otherwise, just jQuery on the front end. I optimized it all to work on mobile too.I built this as a side project for fun over of the past couple years. It took a lot longer than expected, but it was also a lot of fun. I did all the design / UX for it too which was a struggle at first but was a great learning experience.Let me know what you think and if you have any questions. Thanks!

Users provided feedback on a virtual tabletop (VTT) product, highlighting the need for improved menus, data entry, and user customization. Many are interested in self-hosting and open-source options, with questions about the implications of releasing code on platforms like GitHub. There's a demand for support of various tabletop RPGs beyond D&D, with suggestions to market to niche players. Some users prefer in-person play, while others combine it with VTTs for efficiency. Technical suggestions include better mobile support, faster page loads, and feature enhancements like map creation. Concerns about IP rights and legal challenges from companies like Wizards of the Coast were mentioned. Overall, the project received positive feedback, with encouragement to continue development and consider community-driven models like open-source or donation-based funding.

Users criticized the product for its complex interface with too many menus and a lack of clarity, slow performance, and bugs. They expressed a need for better user experience, self-hosting options, and support for different game systems like Pathfinder 2e. Concerns were raised about the potential legal issues, lack of customization, and the product's monetization strategy. Users also noted the product's limitations in map and scenario building, and the need for better import features. The role of the dungeon master (DM) and the balance between storytelling and technical gameplay were also discussed.

Avatar
395
100
-2.0%
-6.0%
100
395
11.0%
Relevance

Open-Source AI Tool for Crafting Custom D&D Campaigns

30 Jan 2024 Artificial Intelligence

Hey everyone, DNDGenerate is my little adventure into the world of AI and D&D. I wanted to learn more about using ChatGpt to build software and about the openai apis. When I saw how much fun my 9-year-old was having, creating his own D&D worlds. That got me thinking – why not make a tool that uses ChatGPT to help build cool D&D campaigns? It's been a blast mixing my love for tech and D&D. I showed this at our latest dnd game, and my fellow party members seemed to like the results, so I thought I'd share it here as well.

Avatar
7
7
Relevance

D&D meets Siri – Interactive voice adventure

23 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence

Hey HN! I've been building tooling for voice-driven apps over the past few months, as part of a hardware project. Someone suggested adapting the DSL to play Dungeons and Dragons. So, here we are!What is it? An AI-powered, voice-controlled D&D adventure set in the world of Dvorak. Talk to characters, explore locations, and shape the story using your words.Use your microphone to interact with the AI dungeon master. Explore freely – interrupt, ask questions, or take unexpected actions. If you make friends at the tavern, you can also just hang out there and chat.Hint: Talk to the bartender to move the story along.This is an early demo, and I'm eager for your thoughts: Is the concept engaging? What works well, and what doesn't? I've added a feedback form to the webpage in case you want to drop a comment without posting on HN.Thanks for trying out the demo!

Users commented on the integration of AI in gaming, highlighting its potential to enhance immersion and creativity, but also expressing concerns about stability, testability, and breaking suspension of disbelief. The AI Dungeon Master (DM) concept received mixed feedback, with some praising its potential in open-world games like Minecraft and Skyrim, while others were skeptical about AI's ability to replicate complex narratives and maintain coherence. There were technical issues mentioned, such as loading problems on iPad Safari. Some users appreciated the project and provided suggestions, while others preferred traditional gameplay and expressed doubts about AI replacing human elements in games.

- AI integration issues causing instability and breaking immersion. - AI's limitations in complex simulations and narrative prediction. - Concerns over AI's impact on game design and player freedom. - Technical problems like server overload and misunderstood commands. - Skepticism about AI replacing human elements in gaming. - Desire for UX improvements and more robust content creation. - Various specific gameplay criticisms, including NPC behavior and scenario design.

Avatar
59
46
0.0%
-6.5%
46
59
15.2%
2.2%
Relevance

RPG game based on ChatGPT leading the game as dungeon master

07 May 2023 Games

Hi guys I've worked on a simple game where players will enjoy playing an RPG based game lead by chatgpt. I've injected audio and image generation as well and my goal is to have people casually jump in and have fun. It's possible to play it with your friends and story should always be weird/funny/interesting. Hope you guys love it (it's still beta and have lots of stuff to be improved, but would like to hear suggestions and collaboration requests as well) :)

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Roleplaying GPT

17 Apr 2023 Artificial Intelligence

Hey HN, I built Roleplaying GPT, a text adventure game powered by GPT4 with inventory, stats, and custom actions. It’s a great way to explore the fun possibilities of GPT4 while playing a roleplaying game. The entire "database" for the game is using GPT4, so I'd expect it to work as long as the conversation token length allows it. I’m looking for feedback on how to make the game even more interesting, so please let me know if you have any ideas. Thanks!

Comment is dead.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

RolePlayHub- AI Roleplay with characters - AI roleplay experiences and digital companionship for free

17 Mar 2024 Artificial Intelligence Games Bots

RolePlayHub is your gateway to a world of immersive AI roleplay. Engage with AI chatbots or create your own, and craft captivating stories in a safe and secure environment. Dive into realistic conversations, explore diverse narratives with RolePlayHub.

Good project: RolePlayHub - AI Roleplay with characters.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

I made a tabletop RPG for remote groups

10 Feb 2023 GitHub

URL: https://triumvene.com/Short version - Dungeons & Dragons with less fighting and more trolley problems. Built as a digital platform.I'm building a non-combat focused tabletop RPG. There's going to be a persistent world with a small dump of lore each month, and larger world events twice a year. Campaigns are between groups of players in a shared world. We're planning an actual play series and a bunch of other interesting things at the moment as well.Happy to give any HN readers a free account to play around with.There's no VTT element and there's no plan to build one; instead it's focused on group storytelling and logging the story, rather than combat and world management.The world and rule set is very much built to be around levelling the playing field so the GM isn't expected to buy everything and be the centre of the world. Instead, players have as much agency as the GM does, and the world lore is free to access.Registration link - https://triumvene.com/#/portal/registerSign up for the free preview and I'll upgrade you to a full account.Contact info - pete at watson-wail dot es. Feedback welcome!

Avatar
3
3
Top