03 Jun 2025
SaaS

The core idea addresses a fundamental problem with AI app ...

...monetization: monthly subscriptions create misaligned incentives where users either waste money on unused services or companies operate at unsustainable losses. As venture capital funding tightens, AI companies will need profitable business models, making usage-based pricing essential. However, implementing per-user usage tracking and connecting it to payment systems is technically complex and time-consuming for developers. The proposed solution is a closed-source SDK that provides out-of-the-box billing and usage dashboards for both users and administrators, making it easy for AI app developers to implement usage-based pricing models without building the infrastructure themselves.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.


Your are here

You're entering a competitive space where multiple solutions already address the need for usage-based pricing in AI applications. The existence of 14 similar products suggests that the problem you're solving is real and recognized, but it also means you'll need a strong differentiator to stand out. While we don't have explicit use/buy signals for similar products, the engagement (avg 5 comments) is medium, implying some level of user interest and validation. Given the crowded landscape and the lack of strong positive signals, success hinges on your ability to offer unique value, superior execution, or a targeted niche strategy. Competitors like Metering.ai and AI Spend already garner positive feedback for clean design and cost tracking, but also face criticisms around analytics and OpenAI costs. You must carefully consider these factors as you move forward.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with comprehensive market research to identify the shortcomings of existing solutions. Focus on understanding the specific pain points of AI developers struggling with usage-based billing. Look at products like Metering.ai and AI Spend to identify where users express dissatisfaction, like the need for better analytics or concerns about OpenAI costs, as identified in the similar product discussions.
  2. Define a clear and compelling value proposition that sets your SDK apart. Is it ease of integration, superior analytics, broader payment gateway support, or perhaps specialized features for a specific type of AI application? For example, the Props AI tool has garnered interest around no/low-code projects, so this might be a potential differentiation angle.
  3. Instead of a broad approach, consider focusing on a niche market segment within the AI space. For instance, you could specialize in billing solutions for AI-powered SaaS applications or tools used in the education sector, tailoring your SDK to their specific needs.
  4. Develop a Minimum Viable Product (MVP) with core billing and usage tracking features. Prioritize a seamless developer experience with clear documentation and excellent support. The discussion surrounding Metering.ai highlights the importance of simplicity and user-friendliness, so emphasize these aspects in your MVP.
  5. Create a freemium or trial version of your SDK to attract early adopters. Offer a limited set of features for free, with paid tiers for advanced functionality and higher usage limits. This approach allows developers to experience the value of your solution before committing to a purchase.
  6. Actively engage with your early users, gathering feedback and iterating quickly based on their needs. A strong, vocal group of early adopters can become powerful advocates for your product. Make sure to thank them for reporting billing errors just like the Metering.ai team did.
  7. Given the competitive landscape, focus on building a strong brand and marketing strategy. Clearly communicate your unique value proposition and target your marketing efforts towards the specific niche you're serving. The InteractWith.AI Marketplace launch suggests that focusing on marketing and sales is crucial for improving results.
  8. Explore strategic partnerships with AI development platforms, cloud providers, or payment gateways. These partnerships can help you reach a wider audience and integrate your SDK into existing workflows.
  9. Continuously monitor the competitive landscape and adapt your product and marketing strategies as needed. The AI space is rapidly evolving, so staying agile and responsive is essential for long-term success.

Questions

  1. What specific metrics will you track to measure the success of your SDK, and how will you use this data to inform your product development and marketing efforts?
  2. How will you ensure the security and privacy of user data, particularly sensitive billing information, given the increasing concerns around data breaches and regulations?
  3. Considering the criticisms of existing solutions, how will you prioritize features and improvements to deliver a truly differentiated and valuable experience for AI developers?

Your are here

You're entering a competitive space where multiple solutions already address the need for usage-based pricing in AI applications. The existence of 14 similar products suggests that the problem you're solving is real and recognized, but it also means you'll need a strong differentiator to stand out. While we don't have explicit use/buy signals for similar products, the engagement (avg 5 comments) is medium, implying some level of user interest and validation. Given the crowded landscape and the lack of strong positive signals, success hinges on your ability to offer unique value, superior execution, or a targeted niche strategy. Competitors like Metering.ai and AI Spend already garner positive feedback for clean design and cost tracking, but also face criticisms around analytics and OpenAI costs. You must carefully consider these factors as you move forward.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with comprehensive market research to identify the shortcomings of existing solutions. Focus on understanding the specific pain points of AI developers struggling with usage-based billing. Look at products like Metering.ai and AI Spend to identify where users express dissatisfaction, like the need for better analytics or concerns about OpenAI costs, as identified in the similar product discussions.
  2. Define a clear and compelling value proposition that sets your SDK apart. Is it ease of integration, superior analytics, broader payment gateway support, or perhaps specialized features for a specific type of AI application? For example, the Props AI tool has garnered interest around no/low-code projects, so this might be a potential differentiation angle.
  3. Instead of a broad approach, consider focusing on a niche market segment within the AI space. For instance, you could specialize in billing solutions for AI-powered SaaS applications or tools used in the education sector, tailoring your SDK to their specific needs.
  4. Develop a Minimum Viable Product (MVP) with core billing and usage tracking features. Prioritize a seamless developer experience with clear documentation and excellent support. The discussion surrounding Metering.ai highlights the importance of simplicity and user-friendliness, so emphasize these aspects in your MVP.
  5. Create a freemium or trial version of your SDK to attract early adopters. Offer a limited set of features for free, with paid tiers for advanced functionality and higher usage limits. This approach allows developers to experience the value of your solution before committing to a purchase.
  6. Actively engage with your early users, gathering feedback and iterating quickly based on their needs. A strong, vocal group of early adopters can become powerful advocates for your product. Make sure to thank them for reporting billing errors just like the Metering.ai team did.
  7. Given the competitive landscape, focus on building a strong brand and marketing strategy. Clearly communicate your unique value proposition and target your marketing efforts towards the specific niche you're serving. The InteractWith.AI Marketplace launch suggests that focusing on marketing and sales is crucial for improving results.
  8. Explore strategic partnerships with AI development platforms, cloud providers, or payment gateways. These partnerships can help you reach a wider audience and integrate your SDK into existing workflows.
  9. Continuously monitor the competitive landscape and adapt your product and marketing strategies as needed. The AI space is rapidly evolving, so staying agile and responsive is essential for long-term success.

Questions

  1. What specific metrics will you track to measure the success of your SDK, and how will you use this data to inform your product development and marketing efforts?
  2. How will you ensure the security and privacy of user data, particularly sensitive billing information, given the increasing concerns around data breaches and regulations?
  3. Considering the criticisms of existing solutions, how will you prioritize features and improvements to deliver a truly differentiated and valuable experience for AI developers?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 14
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 5
  • Net use signal: 15.7%
    • Positive use signal: 15.7%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 1.2%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.2%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Props AI – A Free Tool for Cost-per-User Visibility for Open AI

Hey HN,I am excited to launch Props AI. A Free tool that provides cost-per-user insights and visibility for you apps built on Open AI's API.For those of us building GenAI apps, There is a disparity between how we pay for LLMs (Tokens) and how we charge for them (Per month). Its hard to know your COGS or Unit Level Economics with a single bill at the end of each month from Open AI, so I build a free lightweight proxy and data pipeline that to utilise the "user" field in the competition requests and track the breakdown in usage per customer.In the future I hope to add integrations to stripe to enable frictionless Usage-based billing.I would love your feedback <3

Users are excited to try the product for addressing Tax Titans issues and find it helpful. There is also interest in no/low-code projects.

Users have expressed the need for support for no-code or low-code projects, indicating that the current offering lacks this feature.


Avatar
4
2
100.0%
2
4
100.0%
Relevance

Track and bill users' AI token usage through an API

Nowadays, everyone's building an AI app, but they're not pricing their apps fairly. Each user should be billed separately based on their GPT token usage, and many developers aren't tracking tokens. Instead, they just give a fixed price for their users, which isn't equitable. This is what I built Tiktokenizer to solve, it allows you to use OpenAI's GPT models and track each user's token usage through a single REST API. You could then use this API to get every user's token usage and bill them accordingly.


Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Metering.ai - Automated metering and billing for usage based pricing

Metering your product usage data manually? Switch to metering.ai & turn millions of rows of usage data into Stripe invoices in just 3 clicks. This means no more billing errors & no more manual grunt work. Launch usage based pricing for your product in days.

The Product Hunt launch of Metering.ai (Togai) garnered overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many congratulating the team (Aravind, Abhishek, Ashish Krishna) on their launch. Users praised the product's clean design, user-friendly interface, simplicity, and its potential as a game-changer for usage-based pricing models in SaaS. Several comments highlighted the importance of metering in SaaS and expressed excitement for the product's innovation and solid use case. Some users inquired about the role of AI, Stripe invoice generation accuracy, non-consumption adoption and installation. Several users specifically thanks the team for fixing billing errors.

The provided content only contains a question about potential errors, which does not constitute a criticism. Therefore, there is no criticism to summarize.


Avatar
368
35
8.6%
2.9%
35
368
8.6%
2.9%
Relevance

Lotus – open-source pricing engine

24 Mar 2023 SaaS

Hey HN!We discovered that no one innovates on pricing because every billing software is inflexible. Excited to share our progress with Lotus entering beta (full MIT license, https://github.com/uselotus/lotus).New features: * backtest and run analysis comparing multiple plans* version pricing plans like you version code* Meter and aggregate usage flexibly with custom SQL* billing for usage-based pricing, hybrid, bespoke contracts* generate invoice pdfs or integrate with Stripe, Braintree, Netsuite, Salesforce* webhooks to send alerts when usage thresholds are high or build robust invoicing integrations* analyze margin and cost per customerAll feedback is appreciated! If the project is especially relevant to you, reach out on our website.Check out our brand new self-serve demo here (https://demo.uselotus.io).Or self-host here (https://github.com/uselotus/lotus) and let us know what you think.

Congratulates launch of new products.


Avatar
14
1
1
14
Relevance

Meter/Aggregate your product usage data (no-code, no login, no charge)

27 Apr 2023 SaaS

If you’re using Stripe for your SaaS product and if you have a usage based component in your pricing - this is for you.Aggregating usage data into a digestible format for Stripe is a monthly chore no one likes to do.- The computations are complex and ripe for errors - It’s repeated manual grunt work - having to aggregate and calculate usage for every customer every month - You’re restricted to the pricing models that your billing systems allows you to haveThis is what we solved with metering.ai.With metering.ai as a free add-on to your existing billing system, you can meter your product’s usage without any engineering effort.This is how it works: 1. Upload your usage data as a .csv file 2. Connect to your Stripe account 3. Enter your aggregation formula And voila - aggregated usage data for every customer is sent to Stripe and ready to be invoiced.No more manual work. And no more billing errors.

Can I upload a .csv from mixpanel?


Avatar
10
1
1
10
Relevance

UseCredits – Add credit-based billing to your SaaS in minutes

09 Mar 2024 SaaS

Ready to learn more? Here are the top four things to know:Hassle-free Billing- Effortlessly manage credits for your products with our intuitive UI. - Set credits seamlessly and let our system automatically top up your customer's account upon purchase.Minimal Code Changes- Integrations made simple with just 3 lines of code. - Our SDK ensures automatic top-ups and easy implementation of account debits.Built-in Usage Analytics- Gain insights into customer usage patterns. - Leverage detailed analytics on credit sales and consumption for informed decision-making.Transparency-First- Enjoy detailed account statements for you and your customers. - Enhance trust and transparency with comprehensive transaction records.Thanks for showing interest in UseCredits. This is our product's first release, and we're listening to every feedback. We're excited to hear what you liked or didn't like about UseCredits."


Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Bill like OpenAI with a per token pricing

It works on top of the open-source metering and billing engine Lago [1]that you can easily self-host.You can connect this usage metering and billing system to any payment processor, be it Stripe Payments, Adyen or GoCardLess for instance [2].Usage events can be sent directly to Lago, or you can sent them using our integration with Segment or Hightouch.[1] https://github.com/getlago/lago[2] https://www.getlago.com/integrations


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

I built a SaaS to grow sales with "credits" instead of subs

23 May 2024 SaaS

Hi HN,While developing another app, I realized users really hate our beloved subscriptions. And one-time payments for micro-features? Super inefficient thanks to fixed costs.I thought, why not a 'credits' system instead? So, I created CreditCharge.Me, making it easy for other creators to solve this problems and set up the same model for their users.- No subscriptions - Less fixed fee pain on microtransactions - Free credits for content users actually want, not bulk trial - No user auth - No code - Lower churn rate.I use Stripe API for bulk credit recharges, GCP for cloud magic, and NextJS plus TailwindCSS for the UI.

Created credits-based payment alternative for apps.


Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

InteractWith.AI Marketplace - An open marketplace for AI assistant subscriptions

InteractWith.AI Marketplace allows developers to launch and monetize AI Assistants without spending time on auth, billing, or multi-modal chat interfaces. With an open platform, developers have access to their users and a low platform fee.

The launch introduces an open alternative to the OpenAI GPT store for AI monetization. Users express excitement about the project and congratulate Kevin and Julian on the launch of InteractWith.AI Marketplace. The concept is considered novel and alluring. One user suggests focusing on marketing and sales to improve results.

Criticism focuses on the inadequacy of current marketing and sales strategies to drive successful outcomes.


Avatar
80
6
16.7%
6
80
16.7%
Relevance

AI Spend - Avoid surprises by monitoring OpenAI costs

AI Spend offers user-friendly cost tracking with a dashboard and notifications that passively monitors your usage and costs. The analytics and charts provide insights that help you optimize your OpenAI usage and avoid billing surprises.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many congratulating the team and praising the UI. Users find the tool helpful, particularly for OpenAI API integration and cost tracking. Several users highlighted the need for better analytics and expressed concerns about increased OpenAI costs. Suggestions included integrating with Palm/Bard API and improving usage explanations. AI Spend's notification feature was specifically lauded. There were also offers to include the app in an AI directory.

Users criticized the Product Hunt launch primarily for issues related to OpenAI. Concerns were raised about high and rising OpenAI costs. Additionally, the OpenAI analytics dashboard was found lacking in explanation and difficult to understand, with the tool providing little insight into usage. Finally, feedback mentioned the AI needing better data handling, particularly regarding speech patterns and triggers.


Avatar
215
27
40.7%
27
215
40.7%
Relevance

Dashboard to Get Complete Breakdown of OpenAI Costs

Hello Folks, I am an indie developer, For the last 5 months I was freelancing by building GPT-powered chatbots.One of the challenges I faced was not having visibility into my OpenAI costs.This is why I have built a dashboard to get a complete breakdown of my OpenAI API usage through network calls from OpenAI.Please give it a try & help with feedback on how I can further improve the product,which can really add value and save some money.Note: 1)I found this API through the network logs of the billing screen. 2)The tool stores the OpenAI Key locally on the browser.


Avatar
5
5
Top