We want to be build a no-code or minimum code platform working around ...

...JSON and JS that can be used to create your own SaaS app. Additionally, there will be an app marketplace that you can use to install any app for your account. And build automations/workflows to connect them or use another app/plugin that does the same for you

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Competitive Terrain

While there's clear interest in your idea, the market is saturated with similar offerings. To succeed, your product needs to stand out by offering something unique that competitors aren't providing. The challenge here isn’t whether there’s demand, but how you can capture attention and keep it.

Should You Build It?

Not before thinking deeply about differentiation.


Your are here

Your idea to build a no-code/low-code platform centered around JSON and JS for SaaS app creation, complete with an app marketplace and automation capabilities, enters a crowded space. We found 19 similar products which indicates high competition. This means that standing out is going to be tough. The average engagement for similar products is medium, meaning that to break through the noise, you'll need to offer something truly compelling to get people talking. There's no clear use signal detected, suggesting people aren't explicitly saying they would use such platforms in comments. However, there's surprisingly a strong positive buy signal, which is unusual, indicating a potential willingness to pay if the platform solves a real problem. This shows that while people are hesitant to use the platform directly, they will use an app built on the platform, but only if it's a viable solution to a problem they have.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with a thorough competitive analysis. Given the numerous similar platforms, identify their shortcomings. Focus on understanding where users are most frustrated with existing solutions, paying close attention to criticisms regarding UI polish, feature limitations, and learning curves. Use this understanding to inform your platform's core differentiators.
  2. Concentrate on 2-3 key areas for differentiation. One approach is to hone in on a specific niche within the SaaS ecosystem (e.g., e-commerce, healthcare, education). Another is to focus on a new feature. Could your platform offer superior AI integration, enhanced security features, or a more intuitive automation engine? Prioritize features that solve concrete problems and resonate with your target audience.
  3. Develop a compelling brand and marketing strategy. Given the competitive landscape, your platform's messaging needs to be clear, concise, and resonate with your target users. Instead of broadly targeting all potential SaaS creators, focus on specific personas, tailor your marketing efforts to their unique needs, and highlight the specific advantages of your platform.
  4. Prioritize user experience and onboarding. Many similar platforms face criticism for steep learning curves or a lack of comprehensive tutorials. Invest in creating a smooth, intuitive user interface and provide clear, step-by-step guides that help users quickly build and deploy their first SaaS apps. Consider incorporating interactive tutorials or templates to further simplify the process.
  5. Build an active community around your platform. Engage with your early users, solicit feedback, and iterate rapidly based on their input. Foster a sense of community by creating a forum or Discord server where users can connect with each other, share tips and tricks, and collaborate on projects. This can lead to a loyal user base who act as advocates for your product.
  6. Explore a "no-code first" approach. Focus on empowering users to build functional apps without writing any code. Then, provide a "minimum code" option for advanced users who need more flexibility. This approach can broaden your appeal and lower the barrier to entry for non-technical users.
  7. Carefully curate the app marketplace. Instead of opening it up to everyone, focus on quality over quantity. Vet submissions to ensure they meet certain standards for functionality, security, and user experience. Highlight apps that solve real problems and demonstrate the potential of your platform.

Questions

  1. Given the existing SaaS starter kits and boilerplate solutions, what specific problem does your platform solve that they don't, and how will you measure that?
  2. Considering the positive buy signal, what SaaS app categories are most likely to attract paying customers on your platform, and how can you validate this early on?
  3. How will you ensure the apps in your marketplace are secure, high-quality, and provide a consistently good user experience, especially as the number of apps grows?

Your are here

Your idea to build a no-code/low-code platform centered around JSON and JS for SaaS app creation, complete with an app marketplace and automation capabilities, enters a crowded space. We found 19 similar products which indicates high competition. This means that standing out is going to be tough. The average engagement for similar products is medium, meaning that to break through the noise, you'll need to offer something truly compelling to get people talking. There's no clear use signal detected, suggesting people aren't explicitly saying they would use such platforms in comments. However, there's surprisingly a strong positive buy signal, which is unusual, indicating a potential willingness to pay if the platform solves a real problem. This shows that while people are hesitant to use the platform directly, they will use an app built on the platform, but only if it's a viable solution to a problem they have.

Recommendations

  1. Begin with a thorough competitive analysis. Given the numerous similar platforms, identify their shortcomings. Focus on understanding where users are most frustrated with existing solutions, paying close attention to criticisms regarding UI polish, feature limitations, and learning curves. Use this understanding to inform your platform's core differentiators.
  2. Concentrate on 2-3 key areas for differentiation. One approach is to hone in on a specific niche within the SaaS ecosystem (e.g., e-commerce, healthcare, education). Another is to focus on a new feature. Could your platform offer superior AI integration, enhanced security features, or a more intuitive automation engine? Prioritize features that solve concrete problems and resonate with your target audience.
  3. Develop a compelling brand and marketing strategy. Given the competitive landscape, your platform's messaging needs to be clear, concise, and resonate with your target users. Instead of broadly targeting all potential SaaS creators, focus on specific personas, tailor your marketing efforts to their unique needs, and highlight the specific advantages of your platform.
  4. Prioritize user experience and onboarding. Many similar platforms face criticism for steep learning curves or a lack of comprehensive tutorials. Invest in creating a smooth, intuitive user interface and provide clear, step-by-step guides that help users quickly build and deploy their first SaaS apps. Consider incorporating interactive tutorials or templates to further simplify the process.
  5. Build an active community around your platform. Engage with your early users, solicit feedback, and iterate rapidly based on their input. Foster a sense of community by creating a forum or Discord server where users can connect with each other, share tips and tricks, and collaborate on projects. This can lead to a loyal user base who act as advocates for your product.
  6. Explore a "no-code first" approach. Focus on empowering users to build functional apps without writing any code. Then, provide a "minimum code" option for advanced users who need more flexibility. This approach can broaden your appeal and lower the barrier to entry for non-technical users.
  7. Carefully curate the app marketplace. Instead of opening it up to everyone, focus on quality over quantity. Vet submissions to ensure they meet certain standards for functionality, security, and user experience. Highlight apps that solve real problems and demonstrate the potential of your platform.

Questions

  1. Given the existing SaaS starter kits and boilerplate solutions, what specific problem does your platform solve that they don't, and how will you measure that?
  2. Considering the positive buy signal, what SaaS app categories are most likely to attract paying customers on your platform, and how can you validate this early on?
  3. How will you ensure the apps in your marketplace are secure, high-quality, and provide a consistently good user experience, especially as the number of apps grows?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 19
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 9
  • Net use signal: 36.7%
    • Positive use signal: 37.3%
    • Negative use signal: 0.6%
  • Net buy signal: 9.1%
    • Positive buy signal: 9.7%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.6%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Frontly - Build AI powered SaaS apps and internal tools with no code

Generate apps with AI and edit them in a no-code drag-and-drop interface. Quickly launch your own AI apps with modern responsive layouts, trigger advanced actions, sync with automation platforms via webhooks and create your own library of reusable blocks.

Frontly's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback. Users praise its ease of use, powerful no-code platform, and excellent AI features for building web applications and SaaS products. Many appreciate its user-friendly interface, fast development capabilities, and responsive support team. Comparisons to Airtable exist, but Frontly is favored for AI integration and quick deployment. Users highlighted successful experiences, from building internal tools to launching AI-powered applications. The platform's continuous improvement, active community, and integration with tools like Google Sheets and webhooks are also well-received.

Users criticize Frontly for lacking the UI polish and feature set of Airtable. Concerns exist regarding Frontly's ability to handle complex applications and data, along with the initial steep learning curve. The simplicity of current examples and the need for more comprehensive tutorials are also points of concern. Missing SEO and GEO-tracking features are noted limitations. The active Discord community requires significant engagement. While AI-powered features are praised over incumbents, some worry about the impact on traditional development shops.

Well, where should I start? Maybe let's start with the end in mind: If you want to create powerful apps and either don't have the coding skills or you need to spin off quick working prototypes, YOU CAN'T LET THIS OPPORTUNITY PASS. Frontly is here to stay and is already a strong contender against the major no-code apps out there while still under the radar (but not for long!) I will share my personal experience. I have limited Software Engineering skills, but I work in tech as an IT consultant. I have built many apps with my teams of engineers. Frontly allowed me to use all my expertise and bridge the gap in my lack of strong full stack coding skills to deliver a number of solo projects. It takes care of the infrastructure, so I can focus on the data architecture and functionality while meeting my client's requirements. It has been a wild adventure and a quick learning curve, surprisingly. The Frontly Team is made of extremely knowledgeable people; they know what they are doing. They are very close to the community, swift and, oh my god, they have the most fast-paced feature-releasing rhythm I have seen. In my opinion, one of the reasons is that the founder is a genius. While highly talented with his coding skills, he still gets the "people and business requirements" amazingly well. They just get it, and they know how to get things done. Everything is done so neatly as well, and it works from the get-go. It's impressive, as I know that this requires outstanding attention to detail and creativity. Now, talking more about the platform. Its extremely easy to use, both for internal and external tools. I have built and commercialised: a multivendor portal, a public platform for reviewing pricing and products, a "Welcome app" of those for ipads, that you find when you enter an office, a "Task management system", a "marketing funnel and reporting tool" and even a Poker app, to track with my friends the results of the poker games we have every Wednesday. They think Im some kind of genius, and it just took me a couple of hours, but the fun we get with the leaderboards and the analytics will last forever. Great tool!! Thank you, Patrick @patrickjkelly5 and all the Frontly team, for giving people like me such a great tool. There is a massive pleasure in building things and seeing them being used and appreciated. I have been always limited by my full stack coding skills, but the tide is changing! Im excited for all the people like me, that will be able to give life to their wildest ideas!


Avatar
730
105
38.1%
8.6%
105
730
38.1%
8.6%
Relevance

npx create-saas-app - The only Full-Stack React boilerplate you'll ever need

Create SaaS App makes launching full-stack SaaS products effortless. Built with Vercel, Supabase, Stripe, and Vite, it offers modern functionality, seamless integrations, and out-of-the-box features. Fast to set up, cost-effective, and no vendor lock-in.

Users express excitement and anticipate testing the tool, highlighting its potential usefulness. The tool is praised for saving time with database, Stripe, and React UI integration. A question was raised about multi-tenancy support for B2B SaaS, and another user inquired about the setup time for beginners. Overall, the comments are positive, with users wishing the creator good luck.


Avatar
30
5
60.0%
5
30
60.0%
Relevance

I'm building a new Bubble – for tech and non-tech people

Website: https://codesmash.studio/schemaDemo: https://youtu.be/aBT0qPnl42UOkay guys, I'm building a new No Code platform. The biggest problem with current No Code app builders, from what I can tell, is the lock-in.That's why I'm making sure to build a No Code platform where you will have access to all of your code, which will be saved in Git repos by default. This way there will be no lock-in. The devs will be able to access the code with VS Code, so they can work in sync with non-tech guys, who will be using the UI.You can think of it as NPM for fullstack apps. Users will be able to compose apps from repos. Repos will be provided by the community, so any frontend, backend or infrastructure code can be reused in building new apps.Currently, I'm working on supporting Terraform to create composable AWS infrastructure. Feature requests are welcome and I'll add them to my roadmap!


Avatar
2
2
Relevance

DaDaBIK 12: New UI, build with AI & more - The Low-code/No-code Web App Builder, Self-hosted Since 2001

Start from an existing DB, Excel file, or from scratch and build internal tools, business apps, admin portals, or personal databases in minutes without coding. Enhance with custom JS and PHP, if needed (low-code). Self-hosted, deploy anywhere with ease.

DaDaBIK receives overwhelmingly positive feedback, praised for its ease of use, customizability, and excellent support. Users highlight its intuitive design, simple installation, and flexibility for various applications, including humanitarian work. Many appreciate its mature CRUD solution for MySQL databases, time-saving capabilities, and the developer's responsiveness to user requests. The new UI is lauded as fantastic and user-friendly. Long-time users and new adopters alike recommend DaDaBIK for both personal and business use, emphasizing its ability to streamline database management and allow focus on core client needs.

Users criticized the enterprise license's limited support tickets (5). Additionally, the AI AppifyText tool was noted as needing more robustness to improve its functionality and reliability.


Avatar
32
15
66.7%
40.0%
15
32
66.7%
40.0%
Relevance

SaaSBold - Full-stack SaaS boilerplate and starter kit

Full-Stack SaaS Boilerplate and Starter Kit for Next.js: A production-ready solution crafted for optimal front-end and back-end functionality, developer experience, seamless integrations, quick launch, easy deployment, scalability, and maintenance.

The Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with users praising the resource for its ability to expedite SaaS project launches. Many highlighted its seamless integrations, optimal functionality, and time-saving capabilities. Several users expressed excitement about using it for their next SaaS venture, emphasizing its potential to remove barriers for side hustles. Congratulations were offered repeatedly for the launch. One user suggested exploring Astro/Solid as alternatives to Next.js.

The primary criticism revolves around the suggestion of using Astro or Solid as potentially better alternatives to Next.js for the project's framework.


Avatar
205
12
8.3%
12
205
8.3%
Relevance

I made a Scalable Next.js SaaS starter kit to save you weeks of coding

11 Jun 2024 SaaS Developer Tools

Avatar
9
3
0.0%
-33.3%
3
9
33.3%
Relevance

Codepilot – The Ultimate SaaS Starter Kit

14 Apr 2024 SaaS

I've noticed I kept doing the same things over and over again while building SaaS apps from scratch. So I thought, why not streamline the process? I launched a super flexible SaaS Starter Kit, CODEPILOT, that can be used for all sorts of SaaS building.My goal is to ensure I am are on the right track when it comes to technology, customizability, developer experience, and maintenance. It's built with the latest frameworks to ensure that your application is fast, secure, and scalable.I hope this boilerplate will help you as it helps me!Enis.

Users praised the tech stack and inquired about library versions and their advantages. One user found the demo button hard to find and suggested moving it to the hero section. Another user loved the landing page.

Users have criticized the product for not clearly stating its advantages over competitors like ShipFast. Additionally, the demo button is difficult to locate, which hampers user experience.


Avatar
4
3
33.3%
3
4
33.3%
Relevance

I built a SaaS boilerplate for NextJS and Supabase

21 Dec 2023 SaaS Developer Tools

Hey HN!To build a SaaS, you need to make a lot of components work together: Backend, Frontend, Payments, and more.This year I learned NextJS and Supabase from scratch. These are amazing techs that helped me build five side-projects myself in one year having a full-time job.Now I created a SaaS boilerplate based on NexJS and Supabase, which has everything one needs to create a full-stack web app: Database, Auth, Storage, Stripe payments (one-time and subscriptions), OpenAI AI connection, Design elements, Landing Page template, Email APIs.I hope it can help you launch your next project faster.

Created SaaS boilerplate with NextJS and Supabase.


Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

GSoftApp – Build end-to-end app from a prompt

06 Aug 2024 SaaS Developer Tools

Hi HN, I am Garik, Co-founder of GSoftApp. I have spent the last few years developing a low-code framework for building end-to-end apps. I have always been traditional engineer, and as many of us, would not go close to low-code platforms because of their limitations. After all us engineers want to have control over what we are building. So I decided to build a fully extensible low-code framework, which means now anyone can have their own low-code platform, in your own development environment.Key features- Bootstrap your own self-hosted (or cloud-based) low-code platform in seconds- Build technology-agnostic applications: Works with any database, file storage, you can set up your own security etc.- Create and package modular solutions: these are your reusable building blocks- Deploy in microservices environmentsI made sure in the framework nothing is hard-coded and everything is dynamically generated as metadata. As a sneak peek, here is our recent AI implementation, where you build end-to-end app from a prompt. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qaZ9vgr1oD0Would love to hear your thoughts and see if it would be useful to you. AMA!Thanks!

Asks about the framework used.


Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

Codepilot – The Ultimate SaaS Starter Kit

07 Apr 2024 SaaS

I've noticed I kept doing the same things over and over again while building SaaS apps from scratch. So I thought, why not streamline the process?I launched a super flexible SaaS Starter Kit, CODEPILOT, that can be used for all sorts of SaaS building.My goal is to ensure I am are on the right track when it comes to technology, customizability, developer experience, and maintenance. It's built with the latest frameworks to ensure that your application is fast, secure, and scalable.I hope this boilerplate will help you as it helped me!Enis.

Helpful for freelancing, smooth and fancy design.


Avatar
8
1
100.0%
1
8
100.0%
Relevance

SaaSPack – From Idea to MVP in Record Time

11 Oct 2024 SaaS Developer Tools

Hey HN, I'm Bilal, and I’ve been working on SaaS Pack, a Next.js boilerplate designed to help developers and indie hackers launch micro SaaS products faster. It includes built-in features like authentication, payment processing, waitlist forms, and more. My goal is to simplify building SaaS apps so you can focus on your unique product without reinventing the wheel. Would love feedback and thoughts from the community!


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Build Apps with Automated Workflows

26 Jan 2023 API Developer Tools

Hey HN! We [1] just released a new thing: http://tines.com/product/build-apps.tl;dr – it's a way to build simple-but-slick web apps that are powered by API automation behind the scenes, without writing code.No code? It's because our traditional users are technical-but-not-engineer types like Security Analysts and IT Managers. So this new way of building front-end experiences follows that lead. But as a more technical maker myself, I've been really surprised at how well this works and scales, and we’re seeing teams like Engineering and DevOps increasingly adopt also. I think maybe it's because us software people most intimately understand the long-term/hidden costs of code… maintaining, bug-fixing, deployment, etc.Anyway, If you’d like to check it out…1. there's a usable version of a demo app mid-way down the page above, and then clicking the "How was this built?" button shows you the equivalent of source-code, i.e. the visual automation underpinning everything.2. we have a forever-free tier, which you can sign up for here and play around for real: https://www.tines.com/sign-upI’d love to hear any and all feedback! We love a good dose of HN-style tough love, which we certainly received our fair share of last time we surfaced here :-) [2]- Stephen---[1]: Tines – no code automation [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30249518


Avatar
3
3
Relevance

Next.js SaaS Starter Kit/Boilerplate from RyzeKit

08 Aug 2024 SaaS Developer Tools

Users have raised concerns about the originality of the animation, suggesting it may have been copied from another site. Additionally, there are complaints about the appearance differing from expectations and the code not being visible.

Users criticized the product for including a copied animation and for the appearance differing from expectations, particularly noting that the code is not visible.


Avatar
6
2
2
6
Top