Should I Build It Should I Build It
16 May 2025
Android Privacy

The mobile app is designed to provide enhanced photo security, ...

...targeting users who need more robust protection than the built-in features of their operating systems. Unlike basic "hide" functions in native galleries, this app offers multi-layered security with features such as biometric authentication, encrypted storage, and decoy photo albums. It also includes emergency functions like remote locking and data wiping in case of unauthorized access. The app aims to deliver a seamless yet highly secure experience, appealing to users who handle sensitive or private images on their mobile devices.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

You're entering a market for photo security apps where users are interested in enhancing their privacy beyond the built-in features of their devices. With 13 similar products already out there, the competition is substantial, so you'll need to carve out a unique position. The engagement around these apps is moderate, with an average of 4 comments per product, suggesting there's some interest but not necessarily overwhelming excitement. Given that your idea falls into the 'Freemium' category, where users often resist paying, it's crucial to identify which features will entice users to upgrade to a paid version. A recurring criticism is the need for differentiation from existing privacy applications, indicating that simply offering another app isn't enough.

Recommendations

  1. Since you're in the 'Freemium' category, start by offering a valuable free version. Focus on core security features that address immediate user needs, like basic encryption and a decoy album. This will help attract a user base and gather feedback before investing heavily in premium features. Consider the criticism around similar apps: differentiate by focusing on ease of use and a seamless experience, which could be a key selling point.
  2. Identify user segments that benefit most from enhanced photo security. Are you targeting professionals handling sensitive data, or individuals with personal privacy concerns? Understanding your audience will help tailor premium features. For example, based on the 'Super App Lock' feedback, users want practical and useful functions, so focus on features beyond basic encryption, such as remote locking and data wiping, that add tangible value.
  3. Develop premium features that cater to the specific needs of your target segments. This could include advanced biometric authentication, secure cloud backup, or priority support. Given the 'Local Lock' criticism, ensure multi-device sync is a priority for paid users. Clearly articulate the value proposition of these premium features to justify the cost and encourage upgrades.
  4. Explore team or family subscription models. This can be a more attractive option than individual subscriptions, especially if you offer features like shared secure storage or family-wide privacy settings. As 'App Lock by Lilucat' showed, users are interested in life organization. Consider features that extend beyond photo security to personal data management and offer a comprehensive privacy solution.
  5. Offer personalized help or consulting services to premium users. This could include assistance with setting up advanced security features or troubleshooting issues. This approach can create a stronger bond with your user base and provide a competitive edge, as it addresses the concerns raised about security complexities and user support.
  6. Test different pricing strategies with small groups of users. Offer various tiers with different features and price points to see what resonates best. Actively solicit feedback on pricing and perceived value, using surveys and in-app prompts. This iterative approach will help you optimize your monetization strategy and maximize revenue.
  7. Prioritize user education and transparency. Clearly explain how your app protects user data, addressing privacy concerns head-on. Publish a detailed privacy policy and provide clear explanations of the permissions your app requires, inspired by the expressed concerns around 'App Lock by Lilucat'. Building trust is essential in the privacy space.
  8. Actively monitor user reviews and comments to identify areas for improvement. Respond to feedback and address concerns promptly. This ongoing engagement will demonstrate your commitment to user satisfaction and help refine your product over time. Leverage feedback to iteratively enhance both free and premium features.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition in photo security apps, what unique angle or technology can you leverage to truly differentiate your app and capture a significant market share, beyond just offering basic encryption?
  2. How will you balance the need for robust security with a seamless and user-friendly experience, ensuring that the app remains accessible and appealing to a broad audience, while implementing features such as remote locking and data wiping?
  3. Considering the 'Freemium' model, what specific premium features will you offer that are compelling enough to convert free users into paying customers, and how will you effectively communicate the value proposition of these features?

Your are here

You're entering a market for photo security apps where users are interested in enhancing their privacy beyond the built-in features of their devices. With 13 similar products already out there, the competition is substantial, so you'll need to carve out a unique position. The engagement around these apps is moderate, with an average of 4 comments per product, suggesting there's some interest but not necessarily overwhelming excitement. Given that your idea falls into the 'Freemium' category, where users often resist paying, it's crucial to identify which features will entice users to upgrade to a paid version. A recurring criticism is the need for differentiation from existing privacy applications, indicating that simply offering another app isn't enough.

Recommendations

  1. Since you're in the 'Freemium' category, start by offering a valuable free version. Focus on core security features that address immediate user needs, like basic encryption and a decoy album. This will help attract a user base and gather feedback before investing heavily in premium features. Consider the criticism around similar apps: differentiate by focusing on ease of use and a seamless experience, which could be a key selling point.
  2. Identify user segments that benefit most from enhanced photo security. Are you targeting professionals handling sensitive data, or individuals with personal privacy concerns? Understanding your audience will help tailor premium features. For example, based on the 'Super App Lock' feedback, users want practical and useful functions, so focus on features beyond basic encryption, such as remote locking and data wiping, that add tangible value.
  3. Develop premium features that cater to the specific needs of your target segments. This could include advanced biometric authentication, secure cloud backup, or priority support. Given the 'Local Lock' criticism, ensure multi-device sync is a priority for paid users. Clearly articulate the value proposition of these premium features to justify the cost and encourage upgrades.
  4. Explore team or family subscription models. This can be a more attractive option than individual subscriptions, especially if you offer features like shared secure storage or family-wide privacy settings. As 'App Lock by Lilucat' showed, users are interested in life organization. Consider features that extend beyond photo security to personal data management and offer a comprehensive privacy solution.
  5. Offer personalized help or consulting services to premium users. This could include assistance with setting up advanced security features or troubleshooting issues. This approach can create a stronger bond with your user base and provide a competitive edge, as it addresses the concerns raised about security complexities and user support.
  6. Test different pricing strategies with small groups of users. Offer various tiers with different features and price points to see what resonates best. Actively solicit feedback on pricing and perceived value, using surveys and in-app prompts. This iterative approach will help you optimize your monetization strategy and maximize revenue.
  7. Prioritize user education and transparency. Clearly explain how your app protects user data, addressing privacy concerns head-on. Publish a detailed privacy policy and provide clear explanations of the permissions your app requires, inspired by the expressed concerns around 'App Lock by Lilucat'. Building trust is essential in the privacy space.
  8. Actively monitor user reviews and comments to identify areas for improvement. Respond to feedback and address concerns promptly. This ongoing engagement will demonstrate your commitment to user satisfaction and help refine your product over time. Leverage feedback to iteratively enhance both free and premium features.

Questions

  1. Given the existing competition in photo security apps, what unique angle or technology can you leverage to truly differentiate your app and capture a significant market share, beyond just offering basic encryption?
  2. How will you balance the need for robust security with a seamless and user-friendly experience, ensuring that the app remains accessible and appealing to a broad audience, while implementing features such as remote locking and data wiping?
  3. Considering the 'Freemium' model, what specific premium features will you offer that are compelling enough to convert free users into paying customers, and how will you effectively communicate the value proposition of these features?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 13
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 4
  • Net use signal: 18.0%
    • Positive use signal: 18.0%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

App Lock by Lilucat – Hide apps and lock videos and photos

25 Sep 2024 iOS

Hey HN!I’m Kevin, co-founder of Lilucat, a small indie team passionate about building privacy-focused and user-friendly products. Today, I’m excited to share one of our most popular projects: App Lock by Lilucat.What is App Lock? App Lock lets you securely lock and hide apps, photos, and videos on your iOS device. It’s designed to enhance privacy, protect sensitive data, and prevent unauthorized access. Here’s what it can do:Lock any app instantly with your PIN or Face ID (password unlock coming soon). Restrict device configurations, like blocking app installations or removals, preventing in-app purchases, and more. Hide apps completely—hidden apps aren’t just removed from the home screen, they’re invisible in the App Library as well. Why use App Lock? Whether you’re safeguarding financial apps, securing personal data, or controlling what kids can access, App Lock provides an extra layer of privacy. It’s especially helpful for those in regions where using certain apps might put them at risk.While iOS 18 introduced Face ID app locking, App Lock offers a more comprehensive solution—on iOS, hidden apps can still be found in a folder in the App Library, whereas with our app, hidden apps remain completely invisible unless unlocked through App Lock.We’ve built this app with privacy at its core, and we’d love your feedback to keep improving!You can find more info on App Lock by Lilucat here: https://lilucat.com/app-lock/Looking forward to hearing your thoughts and ideas!

Avatar
6
6
Relevance

Super App Lock - Lock & hide apps, protect privacy, screen time control

19 Apr 2024 iOS iPad Apple

Super App Lock is a powerful app management tool dedicated to protecting user privacy and managing app usage. You can easily Lock and Hide apps, create different plans to control app usage time, enhancing focus and eliminating concerns about privacy leaks.

Super App Lock is praised as a useful privacy and time management tool with an intuitive design. Users appreciate its ability to lock apps, enhance privacy, control usage, and improve efficiency. The app is seen as a smart lock solution for hiding private applications, balancing privacy and usability. Some users inquire about password recovery and future development plans. Overall, the sentiment is positive, with users expressing excitement, gratitude, and a desire for more features.

Users question the app's security, wondering if it can be easily bypassed. They also inquire about its differentiation from existing similar apps in the market. Furthermore, there are requests for the addition of more practical and useful functions to enhance the product's overall value and appeal.

Avatar
192
21
38.1%
21
192
38.1%
Relevance

Encrypted Photo Filtering App - Encrypted image filtering using homomorphic encryption

24 Feb 2023 Artificial Intelligence Crypto Security

Today we're happy to release a real-life use case of Fully Homomorphic Encryption (FHE): an encrypted image filtering app using FHE. You can check it out here: https://huggingface.co/spaces/zama-fhe/encrypted_image_filtering

Users are excited about Zama's work and the app's focus on user privacy. The application of Fully Homomorphic Encryption (FHE) is impressive and unexpected, with many looking forward to future FHE-based app developments. The innovation level is also a highlight, and the app is considered good news for privacy-conscious individuals.

Avatar
75
7
7
75
Relevance

App Lock by Lilucat - Hide apps and lock videos & photos

25 Sep 2024 iOS Privacy Security

App Lock is a privacy app designed to help keep your sensitive apps hidden and secure. With App Lock, you can easily lock and hide any app or media file you want, ensuring that you remain private and out of sight from prying eyes.

The Product Hunt launch of App Lock by Lilucat has garnered positive feedback, with users highlighting its privacy and security features, including media hiding and app blocking. Users appreciate the enhanced control over privacy and its potential for organizing life goals and daily tasks. Suggestions include adding goal milestone reminders. Questions were raised about update handling and the app's differentiation strategy. Some users plan to use it humorously, while others are excited to organize their lives and impressed by the life planner feature.

Users expressed concerns about the app's permissions and their potential impact on privacy. There's interest in features like password unlock and future updates to enhance functionality. A key question raised is how App Lock distinguishes itself from existing privacy applications in the market.

Avatar
143
19
21.1%
19
143
21.1%
Relevance

Automatically hide any sensitive information in an image

09 Aug 2024 Privacy

So I've been building and launching new tools every week for more than a month. The reason for my quick turn-around time is that I built a framework for handling all the headaches: frontend, auth, stripe billing. And abstracted it to the point that I'm writing just business logic and copy.I'm using the Google Sensitive Data Protection API, which is pretty "enterprise grade", the images are base64 encoded not uploaded to a bucket or stored on a filesystem and used in-memory for just the lifetime of the request.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

A location-based, privacy-sensitive photo app for on-site reports etc.

06 Nov 2024 Photography Productivity

This little tool allows you to take multiple photos, load photos from a folder on your device, or save them to a folder on your device.If you turn on geo-location, your filename includes the location, and you can see this location by clicking on the red pin.Everything runs client-side in the browser, and none of your picture info is sent to any server.This might come in handy if you need to go to a wharf, and take multiple pictures with a smartphone for example, and would like to easily see them & browse them, together with the location.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Local Lock – secure, all-offline open source password saving app

07 Mar 2024 Privacy Productivity Security

I would love to get some feedback regarding this project I madeIssues that it targets to solve -- Frequently changing less important passwords- For people who do not need multi device sync, a completely offline app where data leakage is not someone else's responsibility- biometric lock but without continuously running in background and taking up memory and battery

Feedback on offline password manager project with biometric lock.

No multi-device sync.

Avatar
3
1
1
3
Relevance

Image Anonymization API - Anonymize images in seconds for privacy and compliance

13 Feb 2024 Artificial Intelligence API Security

Cloud-based Image Anonymization API efficiently detects and blurs faces and license plates in photos, providing robust privacy protection by ensuring sensitive data remains unrecognizable and secure.

The comments express congratulations and wish the product launch good luck. One comment also requests support for their own launch.

Avatar
14
2
2
14
Top