30 Apr 2025
Privacy

PIPPA transforms digital interactions by putting users in control of ...

...their data while enabling personalized services. The three-tier agent architecture with end-to-end encryption and tokenization creates a privacy-preserving ecosystem where businesses access only the data they need, when they need it—with explicit user consent. Unlike current models where data is scattered across countless databases, PIPPA creates a user-centric ecosystem that aligns with evolving privacy expectations and regulations. The result? Simplified compliance for businesses, meaningful privacy for users, and a sustainable approach to data-driven innovation in an increasingly privacy-conscious world.

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.


Your are here

PIPPA aims to revolutionize digital interactions by giving users control over their data through a privacy-preserving ecosystem. The idea falls into a crowded space with 19 similar products already launched, indicating significant competition. The IDEA CATEGORY of this product is "Swamp". The average engagement of similar products is low, indicated by the average comment count of 2, indicating it might be difficult to stand out. Since nobody wants to use or buy these products (zero net use, zero net buy) you should really think hard if you want to be yet another mediocre solution in this space. Given the number of competitors and the lack of strong positive signals, proceeding with caution is advised.

Recommendations

  1. Start by deeply researching why existing privacy-focused solutions haven't achieved mainstream success. What are the common pitfalls and unmet needs that PIPPA can uniquely address? Understanding the failures of others is crucial before investing further in development.
  2. Identify a specific niche or user group that is particularly underserved by current privacy solutions. Instead of aiming for broad appeal, focus on solving a critical pain point for a well-defined audience, which can help you stand out in a crowded market. For example, think through the specific needs of privacy for open-source devs, or AI researchers.
  3. Explore the possibility of building tools or services that integrate with existing privacy platforms rather than trying to replace them. This could involve creating add-ons or extensions that enhance the functionality of established solutions, which could be an easier way into the market.
  4. Given the challenges in the core privacy space, consider exploring adjacent problems that might be more promising. For example, could PIPPA's technology be adapted to address data security or compliance issues in specific industries? Broadening your focus might reveal untapped opportunities.
  5. Based on the feedback from similar products, where users requested open-source models and better cookie detection, consider incorporating these features into your product to address those specific criticisms directly. This shows you're listening to the market and actively improving your solution. Think about how this also aligns with privacy.
  6. Before investing significant resources, conduct thorough user testing and gather feedback on your core value proposition. Ensure that users understand the benefits of PIPPA and that it solves a real problem for them. Then create a quick explainer video and post it on youtube and product hunt to see if people actually react.
  7. Carefully evaluate the long-term sustainability of your business model. How will you generate revenue while maintaining user privacy and trust? Explore various options, such as premium features, data anonymization services, or partnerships with privacy-focused organizations, but always prioritize transparency and ethical data practices.
  8. Before launching, make sure you have a compelling narrative and clear messaging that differentiates PIPPA from the competition. Highlight your unique value proposition and explain how you are addressing the shortcomings of existing solutions. If you don't have a solid narrative, then people might not be aware of the unique value and will compare you with existing stuff, where you will be at a competitive disadvantage.
  9. Consider pivoting to a more focused area within the data privacy landscape. Instead of a broad platform, perhaps specialize in AI privacy, consent management, or data redaction. This could make it easier to stand out and attract a dedicated user base.
  10. Given the low engagement observed in similar product launches, prioritize building a strong online presence and community around PIPPA. Engage with potential users on social media, participate in relevant forums, and actively solicit feedback to build awareness and generate interest. Without this initial interest you might never get off the ground.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions in the market, what specific technical innovations or architectural differences does PIPPA offer that truly differentiate it and provide a tangible advantage for users in terms of privacy and control?
  2. Considering the low average engagement of similar products, how will PIPPA proactively generate user interest and build a loyal community around its privacy-focused ecosystem, and what specific marketing strategies will be employed to achieve this?
  3. Many similar products face the challenge of balancing user privacy with the need for data-driven innovation. How will PIPPA strike this balance and ensure that businesses can access the data they need for personalized services while upholding the highest standards of privacy and ethical data practices?

Your are here

PIPPA aims to revolutionize digital interactions by giving users control over their data through a privacy-preserving ecosystem. The idea falls into a crowded space with 19 similar products already launched, indicating significant competition. The IDEA CATEGORY of this product is "Swamp". The average engagement of similar products is low, indicated by the average comment count of 2, indicating it might be difficult to stand out. Since nobody wants to use or buy these products (zero net use, zero net buy) you should really think hard if you want to be yet another mediocre solution in this space. Given the number of competitors and the lack of strong positive signals, proceeding with caution is advised.

Recommendations

  1. Start by deeply researching why existing privacy-focused solutions haven't achieved mainstream success. What are the common pitfalls and unmet needs that PIPPA can uniquely address? Understanding the failures of others is crucial before investing further in development.
  2. Identify a specific niche or user group that is particularly underserved by current privacy solutions. Instead of aiming for broad appeal, focus on solving a critical pain point for a well-defined audience, which can help you stand out in a crowded market. For example, think through the specific needs of privacy for open-source devs, or AI researchers.
  3. Explore the possibility of building tools or services that integrate with existing privacy platforms rather than trying to replace them. This could involve creating add-ons or extensions that enhance the functionality of established solutions, which could be an easier way into the market.
  4. Given the challenges in the core privacy space, consider exploring adjacent problems that might be more promising. For example, could PIPPA's technology be adapted to address data security or compliance issues in specific industries? Broadening your focus might reveal untapped opportunities.
  5. Based on the feedback from similar products, where users requested open-source models and better cookie detection, consider incorporating these features into your product to address those specific criticisms directly. This shows you're listening to the market and actively improving your solution. Think about how this also aligns with privacy.
  6. Before investing significant resources, conduct thorough user testing and gather feedback on your core value proposition. Ensure that users understand the benefits of PIPPA and that it solves a real problem for them. Then create a quick explainer video and post it on youtube and product hunt to see if people actually react.
  7. Carefully evaluate the long-term sustainability of your business model. How will you generate revenue while maintaining user privacy and trust? Explore various options, such as premium features, data anonymization services, or partnerships with privacy-focused organizations, but always prioritize transparency and ethical data practices.
  8. Before launching, make sure you have a compelling narrative and clear messaging that differentiates PIPPA from the competition. Highlight your unique value proposition and explain how you are addressing the shortcomings of existing solutions. If you don't have a solid narrative, then people might not be aware of the unique value and will compare you with existing stuff, where you will be at a competitive disadvantage.
  9. Consider pivoting to a more focused area within the data privacy landscape. Instead of a broad platform, perhaps specialize in AI privacy, consent management, or data redaction. This could make it easier to stand out and attract a dedicated user base.
  10. Given the low engagement observed in similar product launches, prioritize building a strong online presence and community around PIPPA. Engage with potential users on social media, participate in relevant forums, and actively solicit feedback to build awareness and generate interest. Without this initial interest you might never get off the ground.

Questions

  1. Given the existing solutions in the market, what specific technical innovations or architectural differences does PIPPA offer that truly differentiate it and provide a tangible advantage for users in terms of privacy and control?
  2. Considering the low average engagement of similar products, how will PIPPA proactively generate user interest and build a loyal community around its privacy-focused ecosystem, and what specific marketing strategies will be employed to achieve this?
  3. Many similar products face the challenge of balancing user privacy with the need for data-driven innovation. How will PIPPA strike this balance and ensure that businesses can access the data they need for personalized services while upholding the highest standards of privacy and ethical data practices?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 19
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 2
  • Net use signal: 18.5%
    • Positive use signal: 20.7%
    • Negative use signal: 2.2%
  • Net buy signal: 0.0%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

User Targeting Without Data Collection: New SDK / Privacy Architecture

09 May 2024 Developer Tools

Hi HN!I’ve built a mobile SDK with new user targeting architecture that improves user privacy, while also giving developers more precision and criteria to target users. I know that sounds super unintuitive, but by inverting standard user targeting architecture becomes possible. The SDK is live on Github, and we have full docs to try it out (links below).Here’s the high level idea of how it works (more detail in in blog post linked below):Zero data collection: the data flow is unidirectional from server to client. The client never needs to send information to the server for targetingPowerful on-device logic engine: you can write targeting logic with conditional strings using powerful but familiar syntax. It supports logical operators, functions, arithmetic, set operations, dates, random number generation, database queries, and more! This runs completely locally on each user’s device.Rich build-in targeting properties: 100 properties you can query, covering device information, user context, sensors, location, permissions, connectivity, peripherals, locale, app info, and much more.Local event database: each client builds a rich database of user engagement history (app launches, session times, terminations, and user actions, custom events, etc). You can query this and target users, without streaming interaction data to any server.Local database for property history: allows you to see if the current state is exceptional or the norm for this user.Logic isn’t hardcoded: you can still update your logic over the air anytime, without app updates. You simply push new logic to clients instead of updating server-side logic.Since everything is local and data never leaves device, we can offer more precise targeting criteria, without the additional scaling complexity, privacy concerns, costs, or legal concerns that come with server-side data collection of contextual data. We can do all this without IDFA or device fingerprinting.SDK docs: https://docs.criticalmoments.io/quick-startMore details on the architecture: https://criticalmoments.io/blog/how_to_target_users_without_...Github: https://github.com/CriticalMoments/CriticalMoments

Mobile SDK improves user privacy and targeting precision.


Avatar
17
1
1
17
Relevance

Monoid – Open-Source Privacy Automation (YC S21)

27 Jan 2023 Open Source Privacy

Hi everyone — I wanted to share what we’ve been working on for the past few months. Monoid is a self-hosted, open-source first platform for automating data privacy requirements.A (very simplified) primer for people who aren’t as familiar with data privacy law: one common stipulation in a number of data privacy regulations (e.g. GDPR, CPRA, etc.) is the requirement for businesses to create a map of user data across places where the data is stored & fulfill requests (Data Subject Requests, or DSR’s) for export and/or deletion of this data.Lots of proprietary solutions exist to help businesses meet these guidelines (OneTrust, DataGrail, etc.) by integrating with the data silos that businesses use to aid them in mapping personal data and fulfilling the user privacy requests.I think that an open-source offering contributes to this category meaningfully, though, for a few reasons:1. It seems antithetical to not give companies the option to host software that integrates with sensitive data silos (especially with the intent of keeping it private) locally.2. The number of potential data silos means that virtually all existing solutions have coverage gaps for any given customer. We thought that Airbyte’s approach to solving this for ETL (by offering an easy way for people to build & contribute their own connectors) could be a smart way to solve this problem, so we used that inspiration to design Monoid. At Monoid’s core are open-source privacy connectors with DB’s, warehouses, SaaS tools, and more. These connectors let organizations automate user data export/deletion (for DSARs) and scan for/map PII.3. Open-source lowers the activation energy required for companies to comply with privacy law (two-line deploy)4. This isn’t a virtue of the open-source approach per-se, but we designed Monoid with full automation in mind; mapping, scanning, and request fulfillment are all automated because the privacy connectors are made to read/write/forward privacy requests to the data silos. Most software solutions in this space are missing this component, or have it only nominally.You can play around with a read-only demo account at https://demo.monoid.co, and sign up for our cloud offering at https://app.monoid.co.We’re adding code-scanning, consent management, and more in the coming weeks — hope to share them here as well. Feedback would be much appreciated!

Monoid: open-source platform for automating data privacy requirements.

Existing solutions have coverage gaps.


Avatar
9
1
1
9
Relevance

Private AI Assistant - True anonymity preventing queries from being 'fingerprinted'

Introducing Private AI Assistant: ensuring true anonymity by preventing fingerprinting and data collection. It mixes all AI requests, doesn't see web pages or addresses, and uses no user data. Experience ultimate privacy with Aloha's innovative solution.

ALOHA's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, praising its online presence product, presentation, and fast, accurate query responses. Users are particularly excited about the AI assistant's privacy focus and user control, deeming it perfect for work needs. There are repeated questions about the functionality of the 'red button'. Some users requested the option to use open-source models for enhanced data privacy. Overall, the launch is considered excellent and a cool update, with congratulations extended to the team.

Users expressed a desire for the option to use on-device and Aloha server open-source models. There was also a request for clarification on a specific aspect of the product.


Avatar
155
13
38.5%
13
155
38.5%
Relevance

SecureNest - Swiss-Based privacy solutions for your digital life

SecureNest offers Swiss-based privacy solutions for your digital life. Experience unparalleled security with our AI chat, password manager, cloud storage, and VPN services. All-in-one centralized in a single dashboard

Users on Discord found the product launch interesting, noting its solid concept. One user experienced a smooth interaction and anticipates future use. Initial impressions are positive, emphasizing the product's potential and ease of use.


Avatar
14
3
33.3%
3
14
33.3%
Relevance

Redact PII for OpenAI with a simple proxy

Hi all!Founder of Evervault[0] here.We're excited to launch our AI Privacy use case today, making it easy for developers to easily redact PII in unstructured data (like prompts) using a simple proxy.This means you can collect data from your users and have it redacted at the edge before it touches your infrastructure, or redact it before sending it to third-party LLM providers like OpenAI — solving a lot of the compliance and privacy pains facing developers today.I wrote more about our proxy approach on the Evervault Blog[1].Looking forward to hearing your feedback![0]: https://evervault.com[1]: https://evervault.com/blog/introducing-ai-privacy-relay-reda...

Launching AI Privacy use case for PII redaction.


Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

The First Industry Standard for B2B Trust

Let me ask you this, would you share sensitive data with a company without knowing if they can protect it?No, right?Because trust is missing. In order to trust them, you must assess their privacy and security postures.The problem is, that the current assessments process broken - it’s manual, repetitive and resource intensive.Annually, small and medium businesses spend an avg. 2.1 million euros on evaluating third parties, and companies being evaluated spend an avg. 1.9 million on completing those assessments. You can imagine that for enterprises, those numbers are much higher.As European regulations require vendor assessments and new global privacy laws are being aligned to the EU, this process will become even more challenging.hoggo is here to solve that with an AI powered solution that automates privacy and security assessments for both sides: Sellers can improve and showcase compliance and buyers can evaluate, manage and monitor them.Our platform is live and if you are facing compliance bottlenecks as sellers or having difficulties in assessing and monitoring your third-parties, we would LOVE your feedback and are open to pilot customers.

Comment flagged for review.


Avatar
1
1
1
1
Top