Should I Build It Should I Build It
17 Mar 2025
iOS

A mobile app that uses image recognition to identify plants and ...

...provide information on their care requirements, helping users become better gardeners, because why not!

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.

Your are here

Your idea for a mobile app using image recognition for plant identification and care is entering a very active market. We found 22 similar products, indicating high confidence that this falls into the 'Freemium' category. This means while users engage with these types of apps (average comments are high at 7), they often resist paying. The lack of strong 'buy' signals in competitor comments, coupled with specific feedback criticizing subscription models as too expensive compared to free alternatives, reinforces this. The sheer number of competitors (22!) makes differentiation absolutely critical. While people are clearly interested in identifying and caring for plants via apps, you need a clear plan to stand out and convince users your solution offers unique value worth potentially paying for, or find a sustainable non-payment model.

Recommendations

  1. Deep Dive into Competition: With 22 similar products identified, your first step is intense competitive analysis. Don't just list features; understand why users choose apps like Pl@ntNet, PictureThis, or others mentioned in competitor feedback (often citing simplicity, cost, or reliability). Identify a specific underserved niche (e.g., specific climates, indoor plant specialists, beginner gardeners needing foolproof guidance, advanced disease diagnostics) or a unique user experience that current apps lack. Generic identification isn't enough.
  2. Validate Your Core Free Value: Embrace the 'Freemium' reality identified. Define the absolute best free plant identification and basic care experience possible. What core problem will your free tier solve better than anyone else? Based on competitor feedback, reliability, ease of use, and speed are key expectations even for free users. Ensure this core offering is strong enough to attract a large user base.
  3. Design Premium Features Strategically: Based on who gets the most value from your free tier, design premium features that offer a significant upgrade. Look at criticisms of competitors: users want more than basic ID, perhaps advanced diagnostics, personalized long-term care plans, integration with weather data, or community features for sharing progress/advice. Crucially, learn from the negative feedback on $7 subscriptions for similar apps – test alternative models like a one-time purchase for premium features, feature bundles, or even a 'pay-per-advanced-ID' option.
  4. Prioritize Accuracy and Trust: Competitor discussions repeatedly raise concerns about identification accuracy, especially for uncommon or poisonous plants. How will your image recognition model be demonstrably better or more reliable? Clearly communicate your approach to accuracy and data sourcing. Consider partnerships or expert validations to build credibility, as trust is paramount when competing against established free tools.
  5. Targeted Go-to-Market: Given the crowded space, broad marketing will be expensive and inefficient. Identify specific online communities, forums (like gardening subreddits), social media groups, or even partnerships with nurseries or garden centers where your target users congregate. Focus initial efforts on demonstrating your unique value proposition to these specific groups.

Questions

  1. Considering the 22 existing competitors and strong free alternatives highlighted in user discussions, what specific, unmet need or significant pain point within plant identification or care does your app address so uniquely that users will actively choose and potentially pay for your solution over established, free options?
  2. User feedback on similar apps shows significant resistance to subscription models. What evidence do you have that a specific user segment will pay for premium features, and what monetization model (beyond standard subscription) are you considering that directly addresses this observed market resistance?
  3. Given the recurring user concerns about identification accuracy in competitor apps, what is your specific strategy to achieve and demonstrate superior accuracy, particularly for challenging cases (e.g., rare species, early disease stages, poisonous look-alikes), to build essential user trust from launch?

Your are here

Your idea for a mobile app using image recognition for plant identification and care is entering a very active market. We found 22 similar products, indicating high confidence that this falls into the 'Freemium' category. This means while users engage with these types of apps (average comments are high at 7), they often resist paying. The lack of strong 'buy' signals in competitor comments, coupled with specific feedback criticizing subscription models as too expensive compared to free alternatives, reinforces this. The sheer number of competitors (22!) makes differentiation absolutely critical. While people are clearly interested in identifying and caring for plants via apps, you need a clear plan to stand out and convince users your solution offers unique value worth potentially paying for, or find a sustainable non-payment model.

Recommendations

  1. Deep Dive into Competition: With 22 similar products identified, your first step is intense competitive analysis. Don't just list features; understand why users choose apps like Pl@ntNet, PictureThis, or others mentioned in competitor feedback (often citing simplicity, cost, or reliability). Identify a specific underserved niche (e.g., specific climates, indoor plant specialists, beginner gardeners needing foolproof guidance, advanced disease diagnostics) or a unique user experience that current apps lack. Generic identification isn't enough.
  2. Validate Your Core Free Value: Embrace the 'Freemium' reality identified. Define the absolute best free plant identification and basic care experience possible. What core problem will your free tier solve better than anyone else? Based on competitor feedback, reliability, ease of use, and speed are key expectations even for free users. Ensure this core offering is strong enough to attract a large user base.
  3. Design Premium Features Strategically: Based on who gets the most value from your free tier, design premium features that offer a significant upgrade. Look at criticisms of competitors: users want more than basic ID, perhaps advanced diagnostics, personalized long-term care plans, integration with weather data, or community features for sharing progress/advice. Crucially, learn from the negative feedback on $7 subscriptions for similar apps – test alternative models like a one-time purchase for premium features, feature bundles, or even a 'pay-per-advanced-ID' option.
  4. Prioritize Accuracy and Trust: Competitor discussions repeatedly raise concerns about identification accuracy, especially for uncommon or poisonous plants. How will your image recognition model be demonstrably better or more reliable? Clearly communicate your approach to accuracy and data sourcing. Consider partnerships or expert validations to build credibility, as trust is paramount when competing against established free tools.
  5. Targeted Go-to-Market: Given the crowded space, broad marketing will be expensive and inefficient. Identify specific online communities, forums (like gardening subreddits), social media groups, or even partnerships with nurseries or garden centers where your target users congregate. Focus initial efforts on demonstrating your unique value proposition to these specific groups.

Questions

  1. Considering the 22 existing competitors and strong free alternatives highlighted in user discussions, what specific, unmet need or significant pain point within plant identification or care does your app address so uniquely that users will actively choose and potentially pay for your solution over established, free options?
  2. User feedback on similar apps shows significant resistance to subscription models. What evidence do you have that a specific user segment will pay for premium features, and what monetization model (beyond standard subscription) are you considering that directly addresses this observed market resistance?
  3. Given the recurring user concerns about identification accuracy in competitor apps, what is your specific strategy to achieve and demonstrate superior accuracy, particularly for challenging cases (e.g., rare species, early disease stages, poisonous look-alikes), to build essential user trust from launch?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 22
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 7
  • Net use signal: 11.9%
    • Positive use signal: 22.1%
    • Negative use signal: 10.1%
  • Net buy signal: -10.4%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.0%
    • Negative buy signal: 11.4%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

DrPlant - An app to help you care for your plants

16 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Home Productivity

Identify the plant, get care instructions, get diagnosis for sick plants, get remedy for sick plants

Users are looking for a simple and inexpensive plant app. The concept is interesting, with simplicity and affordability being key differentiators in a market with many options.

Users criticize the product's lack of differentiation in a crowded market of plant apps, desiring a simpler and more affordable solution. The need for a clear differentiation strategy and community features to enhance user engagement was also mentioned.

Avatar
10
2
50.0%
-50.0%
2
10
50.0%
Relevance

Plantora- Plant Identify, Care - The Best Plant Identification and Care Companion.

20 Jun 2024 Android Education Nature & Outdoors

Plantora is the best identifier and care app! Identify plants instantly with AI technology, get detailed plant care guides, track watering schedules, and receive tips for best plant growth. Perfect for plant enthusiasts, gardeners and who loves greenery.

Users praise the app as a top-tier plant identification tool, highlighting its reliable results and helpful guides. The app is also lauded as an excellent plant care resource, packed with numerous useful features that enhance the user experience.

Avatar
7
2
50.0%
2
7
50.0%
Relevance

Built a plant ID app after seeing friend waste €23/month

28 Oct 2024 Productivity

My friend was spending €23/month (GPT) to plant ID during her forest walks. After building her a simple solution, she loved it and encouraged me to share it with others - so here it is!This is actually my second HN. Your feedback on my first post was eye-opening (thanks!).I'm bootstrapping this as a student and planning to grow it beyond just plant identification. Working on adding community features and leaderboards - turning it into a cozy corner of the internet for plant parents. Think less "utility app" and more "home for plant enthusiasts".Open for feedback from the HN community - especially from fellow plant lovers! Get 30 free credits to try it out and let me know what you think.For those who ask - this is not just LLM wrapper.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

GrowLab AI – Plant Identification and Diseases

24 Jan 2024 Artificial Intelligence

GrowLab AI is a groundbreaking digital assistant that transforms the gardening experience. Our innovative platform combines advanced automation with user-friendly design, catering to both novice and seasoned gardeners.Our platform also includes integrated to-do lists, helping gardeners stay organized and on top of their gardening tasks. With GrowLab AI, users can track plant growth, set reminders for feeding and watering, and record personal observations, making gardening more efficient and enjoyable.Our mission is to make plant management accessible and fun for everyone. GrowLab AI is ideal for those who love gardening but struggle with the complexities it entails. From balcony gardens to large greenhouses, our app scales to fit your needs.GrowLab AI is more than just an app; it's a community of gardening enthusiasts. We're constantly updating our platform with new features and device compatibility, ensuring that GrowLab AI remains at the forefront of digital gardening innovation.

GrowLab AI transforms gardening with automation and user-friendly design.

Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

I made a site to quick identify any plant and learn how to care for it

29 Oct 2024 Productivity

My friend was spending €23/month (GPT) to plant ID during her forest walks. After building her a simple solution, she loved it and encouraged me to share it with others - so here it is!This is actually my second HN. Your feedback on my first post was eye-opening (thanks!).I'm bootstrapping this as a student and planning to grow it beyond just plant identification. Working on adding community features and leaderboards - turning it into a cozy corner of the internet for plant parents. Think less "utility app" and more "home for plant enthusiasts".Open for feedback from the HN community - especially from fellow plant lovers! Get 30 free credits to try it out and let me know what you think.For those who ask - this is not just LLM wrapper.

Over-submitting content on Hacker News.

Over-submitting content.

Avatar
2
1
1
2
Relevance

I built a Plant Identification Tool Powered GPT4 Vision

30 Apr 2024 Artificial Intelligence

Hey everyone!Zach here, as an avid house plant enthusiast I created Photo Synthesis to solve my need of constantly trying to find care instructions for new house plants I was shopping for.It's built using the GPT4 Vision API with no pre-training. I was impressed with how it performs especially considering how simple it was to integrate.Hope you like it!

Users appreciate the name 'Photo Synthesis' for a house plant care instructions service. One comment was flagged for review.

Avatar
4
3
3
4
Relevance

I made a site to quick identify any plant and learn how to care for it

19 Oct 2024 Productivity

I'm still working on it, curious but what feature may be most valuable for you? What do you think about personalised care instructions, and an interactive chat feature for each plant.

Users find the $7 subscription for the plant identification service expensive, preferring a per-use or one-time payment model. Many compare it to free alternatives like Pl@ntNet, PictureThis, and built-in phone apps, suggesting a lower entry price or highlighting unique features. Concerns about accuracy, especially with poisonous plants, and the free trial requiring payment details are noted. Some endorse the idea and suggest community support models, while others question the value over free services and are hesitant without a stable version. The site's downtime post-launch and issues with sign-up also frustrate users.

Users criticize the $7 price point as too high, especially for occasional use, and dislike the subscription model, preferring a pay-per-scan option. They question the app's trustworthiness and accuracy in plant identification, noting free alternatives are more reliable. Criticisms include high transaction fees, the requirement of payment information for a free trial, and the inability to delete accounts. Users also mention misidentification issues, particularly with poisonous plants, and express a need for proof of the app's superior accuracy. The app's value proposition is questioned, as it lacks unique features and is compared unfavorably to free or existing services.

Avatar
110
71
-15.5%
-25.4%
71
110
8.5%
Relevance

PlantIdentify - Plant Detector - Free plant identifier app

16 Jun 2024 Plants Education Photography

🌿 FREE Plant Identifier App 🌿 📷Use your camera or a picture to quickly identify plants with AI🌿 Features: • Instant Plant Identification • Free to Use • Multi-Language Support • Save Identification History

Users are excited about PlantIdentify's launch and its potential as a plant identification tool, especially for families and nature enthusiasts. The app is praised for its accuracy, convenience, and time-saving capabilities. There are inquiries about its differentiation from competitors, revenue model, AI accuracy (particularly for uncommon plants), global plant identification capabilities, and business model. Suggestions include monetization through paid features and offline functionality via an on-device model. Users have tested the app and confirmed it is working and accurate.

Users question the plant identifier's differentiation from existing apps, particularly regarding its AI capabilities and accuracy. Concerns are raised about the AI's ability to accurately identify less common plant species and the browser version's image recognition. Users are also curious about the depth of additional plant information provided.

Avatar
342
36
36.1%
2.8%
36
342
36.1%
2.8%
Relevance

HomeGardenAI - Transforming plant care with AI: your green thumb assistant

02 Aug 2024 Artificial Intelligence Internet of Things Home Automation

HomeGardenAI: Transform your home garden with smart plant care powered by AI. Diagnose plant diseases, receive personalized care recommendations, and maintain a thriving garden with ease.

HomeGarden AI is praised for simplifying plant care with its intuitive design, plant identification, and customized advice on watering and growth conditions. Users find the app helpful for both beginners and enthusiasts, appreciating features like the 'next watering' notification. The app's speed is noted as fantastic. Some users inquire about accuracy, handling uncommon plants, and integration with smart home systems. Overall, the launch is met with excitement and congratulations, with many believing garden enthusiasts will find the product valuable for improving plant health.

Users suggest feature enhancements like growth tracking and content sharing, and propose a progressive web app for direct image uploads. Concerns were raised about the app's accuracy, particularly for uncommon plants, with questions about data sources and testing. One experienced gardener found the plant identifications uninformative, possibly indicating a need to improve the app's database and identification capabilities to surpass existing solutions.

Avatar
161
19
52.6%
19
161
52.6%
Relevance

AIGardenPlanner – AI-driven personalized planting recommendations

22 May 2023 Artificial Intelligence

Hello HN community, I'm excited to share a project that's been a labor of love for meAs an enthusiast in both tech and gardening, I often found it difficult to get the right guidance that would cater to my specific gardening conditions and personal preferences. Furthermore, living in a small country, localized gardening advice was hard to come by.That's when I thought - why not use technology to solve this? Thus, AIGardenPlanner was born - an online tool leveraging AI to provide tailored gardening advice. It simplifies gardening decisions about what to plant, when, and where, regardless of your geographical location. Whether you're a beginner or an experienced gardener, it's designed to guide you towards a flourishing garden.All you have to do is fill in a brief form about your gardening ambitions, preferences, and available space. The tool then generates a personalized plan suitable for your specific situation.We've launched a free version that you can try out. However, for those interested in more detailed reports, we have a Pro version as well.I believe this tool could be a great help for all gardening enthusiasts, and I'm eager to hear what the HN community thinks about it. Your feedback and suggestions will be invaluable in improving and growing this project.

Avatar
2
2
Relevance

The garden journal app that every plant owner needs

19 Aug 2024 Productivity

Introducing: GrowNotes: Garden Journal Free on the App Store (coming soon to Android)https://www.grow-notes.comA simple way to track plants in your garden. Each plant gets its own dedicated journal and is easy to reference later to help make informed decisions that will lead to healthier, happier plants.As a backyard gardener, I built this app to make it easier for me to take garden notes and find them later. I hope others can find it useful too. Anyone who has a plant, whether it’s an indoor potted plant, a front yard shrub, or a flourishing garden might find this app useful.GrowNotes is in the MVP stage so it’s rather barebones and you may encounter bugs. I highly appreciate any feedback, features requests or bug reports.I'm planning to monetize with planned premium features should there be enough interest in the app. Anyone who's interested in joining as a co-founder with experience in sales/marketing, promotion, social media, etc to help grow the app please reach out. Equity 50-50.Try out GrowNotes today!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

GrowNotes - A Garden Journal to take notes & photos to track your plants

19 Aug 2024 iOS Plants Nature & Outdoors

Gardening is all about learning and what better way to learn than to take notes? GrowNotes makes it super easy to log plant entries with notes and photos and to quickly find them later. This app is for you even if you just have a few plants around the house!

The GrowNotes app launch aims to resolve organizational challenges for gardeners, according to initial user feedback on Product Hunt. A comment was deleted.

No criticisms were found.

Avatar
11
2
50.0%
2
11
50.0%
Relevance

Garden+ - A gardening journal that you can take with you anywhere

31 May 2023 iOS Plants Nature

Garden+ helps you easily track and schedule your daily garden activities and succeed in all your sowing and planting. It's a gardening journal that you can take with you anywhere. — Available on the App Store. In English, French and Spanish. 100% free.

Users express excitement and congratulate the creator on the launch of the gardening app, praising its user-friendliness, helpfulness, and design. Several users plan to use it, including those starting balcony gardens. The app is seen as a time-saving alternative to traditional methods and a potential Father's Day gift. An Android version was requested. The hard work and effort put into the product are recognized and good luck is wished for the future.

The main criticisms are the lack of an Android version and the perception that block notes are not engaging for garden activity tracking. The absence of an Android app limits accessibility, while users find the note-taking method uninspiring.

Avatar
97
11
45.5%
9.1%
11
97
45.5%
9.1%
Top